Federation Council (Iraq)

Supporting arguments

Proponents of the Federation Council (FC) have argued that:

• According to some proponents of the FC, Iraq's legislative system is "disjointed" and there's "internal competition or rivalry between the legislative institutions", with the Council of Representatives occasionally forcing contested laws into effect. Currently, even the president cannot block a bill from being passed regardless of whether he/she signs it.

• The FC can balance the proportional representation-based Council of Representatives by allowing for regions and governorates to be directly represented in legislative affairs.

• Some Sunni and Shia parties, and the Kurds are already starting to support the implementation.

• Despite the fact that 78.59% of voters chose to implement the current constitution of Iraq, some of its articles are yet to be implemented. This could have prevented the 2017 Kurdish independence referendum and consequently, the 2017 Iraqi–Kurdish conflict.

• The Council of Representatives has been criticised before for passing laws that further added tension between the federal government and the Kurdistan Region and between Iraq's three main components.

• The FC can function as a guarantor of decentralisation by ensuring that the Council of Representatives does not consolidate disproportionate power.

• Implementation of the FC can improve internal security of Iraq's governorates by passing legislation that allows for the devolution of internal security administration –such as law enforcement– to provincial authorities.

• Federalism in Iraq can only function properly when democratic institutions function as a bastion against a dictatorship of the majority.

• The FC can ensure the representation of Iraq's minorities in parliament.

Opposing arguments

Critics additionally also argued that:

• The FC may not be able to actually handle solving problems within Iraq as those who lead parties have a better say in Parliament rather than elected representatives.

• The FC might additionally be too expensive for the country's budget with little to no actual effect, explaining on why not many Iraqis are bothered with implementing the FC or even know about its existence.