| Kausi |
Maalivahti |
Puolustajat |
Keskikenttäpelaajat |
Hyökkääjät |
| 1996 |
Mark Dodd (Dallas) |
Leonel Álvarez (Dallas)
John Doyle (San Jose)
Robin Fraser (Los Angeles) |
Mauricio Cienfuegos (Los Angeles)
Roberto Donadoni (MetroStars)
Marco Etcheverry (D.C. United)
Preki (Kansas City)
Carlos Valderrama (Tampa Bay) |
Eduardo Hurtado (Los Angeles)
Roy Lassiter (Tampa Bay) |
| 1997 |
Brad Friedel (Columbus) |
Jeff Agoos (D.C. United)
Thomas Dooley (Columbus)
Richard Gough (Kansas City)
Eddie Pope (D.C. United) |
Mark Chung (Kansas City)
Marco Etcheverry (D.C. United)
Preki (Kansas City)
Carlos Valderrama (Tampa Bay) |
Ronald Cerritos (San Jose)
Jaime Moreno (D.C. United) |
| 1998 |
Zach Thornton (Chicago) |
Thomas Dooley (Columbus)
Robin Fraser (Los Angeles)
Luboš Kubík (Chicago)
Eddie Pope (D.C. United) |
Chris Armas (Chicago)
Mauricio Cienfuegos (Los Angeles)
Marco Etcheverry (D.C. United)
Piotr Nowak (Chicago) |
Stern John (Columbus)
Cobi Jones (Los Angeles) |
| 1999 |
Kevin Hartman (Los Angeles) |
Jeff Agoos (D.C. United)
Robin Fraser (Los Angeles)
Luboš Kubík (Chicago) |
Chris Armas (Chicago)
Mauricio Cienfuegos (Los Angeles)
Marco Etcheverry (D.C. United)
Eddie Lewis (San Jose)
Steve Ralston (Tampa Bay) |
Jason Kreis (Dallas)
Jaime Moreno (D.C. United) |
| 2000 |
Tony Meola (Kansas City) |
Robin Fraser (Los Angeles)
Greg Vanney (Los Angeles)
Peter Vermes (Kansas City) |
Chris Armas (Chicago)
Piotr Nowak (Chicago)
Steve Ralston (Tampa Bay)
Hristo Stoitškov (Chicago)
Carlos Valderrama (Tampa Bay) |
Mamadou Diallo (Tampa Bay)
Clint Mathis (MetroStars) |
| 2001 |
Tim Howard (MetroStars) |
Jeff Agoos (San Jose)
Carlos Llamosa (Miami)
Pablo Mastroeni (Miami)
Greg Vanney (Los Angeles) |
Chris Armas (Chicago)
Piotr Nowak (Chicago)
Preki (Miami)
John Spencer (Colorado) |
Alex Pineda Chacón (Miami)
Diego Serna (Miami) |
| 2002 |
Tim Howard (MetroStars) |
Wade Barrett (San Jose)
Carlos Bocanegra (Chicago)
Alexi Lalas (Los Angeles) |
Mark Chung (Colorado)
Jeff Cunningham (Columbus)
Ronnie Ekelund (San Jose)
Óscar Pareja (Dallas)
Steve Ralston (New England) |
Carlos Ruiz (Los Angeles)
Taylor Twellman (New England) |
| 2003 |
Pat Onstad (San Jose) |
Carlos Bocanegra (Chicago)
Ryan Nelsen (D.C. United)
Eddie Pope (MetroStars) |
Chris Armas (Chicago)
DaMarcus Beasley (Chicago)
Mark Chung (Colorado)
Landon Donovan (San Jose)
Preki (Kansas City) |
John Spencer (Colorado)
Ante Razov (Chicago) |
| 2004 |
Joe Cannon (Colorado) |
Jimmy Conrad (Kansas City)
Robin Fraser (Columbus)
Ryan Nelsen (D.C. United)
Eddie Pope (MetroStars) |
Eddie Gaven (MetroStars)
Amado Guevara (MetroStars)
Ronnie O'Brien (Dallas)
Kerry Zavagnin (Kansas City) |
Brian Ching (San Jose)
Jaime Moreno (D.C. United) |
| 2005 |
Pat Onstad (San Jose) |
Chris Albright (Los Angeles)
Danny Califf (San Jose)
Jimmy Conrad (Kansas City) |
Dwayne De Rosario (San Jose)
Clint Dempsey (New England)
Christian Gómez (D.C. United)
Shalrie Joseph (New England)
Ronnie O'Brien (Dallas) |
Jaime Moreno (D.C. United)
Taylor Twellman (New England) |
| 2006 |
Troy Perkins (D.C. United) |
Bobby Boswell (D.C. United)
José Burciaga Jr. (Kansas City)
Jimmy Conrad (Kansas City) |
Ricardo Clark (Houston)
Dwayne De Rosario (Houston)
Clint Dempsey (New England)
Christian Gómez (D.C. United)
Justin Mapp (Chicago) |
Jeff Cunningham (Salt Lake)
Jaime Moreno (D.C. United) |
| 2007 |
Brad Guzan (Chivas USA) |
Jonathan Bornstein (Chivas USA)
Michael Parkhurst (New England)
Eddie Robinson (Houston) |
Guillermo Barros Schelotto (Columbus)
Dwayne De Rosario (Houston)
Christian Gómez (D.C. United)
Shalrie Joseph (New England)
Ben Olsen (D.C. United) |
Juan Pablo Ángel (New York)
Luciano Emílio (D.C. United) |
| 2008 |
Jon Busch (Chicago) |
Jimmy Conrad (Kansas City)
Chad Marshall (Columbus)
Bakary Soumare (Chicago) |
Guillermo Barros Schelotto (Columbus)
Cuauhtémoc Blanco (Chicago)
Shalrie Joseph (New England)
Sacha Kljestan (Chivas USA)
Robbie Rogers (Columbus) |
Kenny Cooper (Dallas)
Landon Donovan (Los Angeles) |
| 2009 |
Zach Thornton (Chivas USA) |
Geoff Cameron (Houston)
Wilman Conde (Chicago)
Chad Marshall (Columbus) |
Dwayne De Rosario (Toronto)
Landon Donovan (Los Angeles)
Stuart Holden (Houston)
Shalrie Joseph (New England)
Fredrik Ljungberg (Seattle) |
Conor Casey (Colorado)
Jeff Cunningham (Dallas) |
| 2010 |
Donovan Ricketts (Los Angeles) |
Nat Borchers (Salt Lake)
Omar Gonzalez (Los Angeles)
Jámison Olave (Salt Lake) |
Dwayne De Rosario (Toronto)
Landon Donovan (Los Angeles)
David Ferreira (Dallas)
Sébastien Le Toux (Philadelphia)
Javier Morales (Salt Lake) |
Edson Buddle (Los Angeles)
Chris Wondolowski (San Jose) |