Winners and nominees
1984–1989
| Year | Photo | Winner Movie |
Nominees Movies |
| 1984 |  |
Sharon Mitchell Sexcapades |
|
| 1985 | Pamela Mann X Factor |
||
| 1986 | Sheri St. Claire (m) Corporate Assets |
||
 |
Ginger Lynn (v) Project Ginger |
||
| 1987 | Colleen Brennan (m) Getting Personal |
||
 |
Nina Hartley (v) Debbie Duz Dishes |
||
| 1988 | Krista Lane (m) Deep Throat II |
||
.jpg) |
Shanna McCullough (v) Hands Off |
||
| 1989 | .jpg) |
Ona Zee (m) Portrait of an Affair |
|
| Barbara Dare (v) Naked Stranger |
1990–1994
| Year | Photo | Winner Movie |
Nominees Movies | |
| 1990 | Sharon Kane Bodies in Heat—The Sequel |
|||
| 1991 | Hyapatia Lee (m) The Masseuse |
|||
| Lauren Brice (v) Married Women |
||||
| 1992 | .jpg) |
Jeanna Fine (m) Hothouse Rose |
||
|
Ona Zee (v) The Starlet |
|||
| 1993 |  |
Ashlyn Gere Chameleons (m) Two Women (v) |
||
| 1994 | Britney Loara (m) Mud Shark in the Water!" |
|||
| Britney Loara (v) Friday Night Delights |
1995–1999
| Year | Photo | Winner Movie |
Nominees Movies |
| 1995 |  |
Ashlyn Gere The Masseuse (m) Body & Soul (v) |
|
| 1996 | |
Jeanna Fine (m) Skin Hunger |
|
 |
Jenna Jameson (v) Wicked One |
||
| 1997 |  |
Melissa Hill (m) Penetrator 2: Grudge Day |
|
|
Jeanna Fine (v) My Surrender |
||
| 1998 |  |
Dyanna Lauren (m) Bad Wives |
|
 |
Stephanie Swift (v) Miscreants |
||
| 1999 |  |
Shanna McCullough (m) Looker |
|
|
Jeanna Fine (v) Café Flesh 2 |
2000–2004
| Year | Photo | Winner Movie |
Nominees Movies |
| 2000 |  |
Chloe (m) Chloe |
Asia Carrera Search for the Snow Leopard |
| Allysin Chaynes Stray Cat | |||
| Racquel Darrian Original Sin | |||
| Raylene The Trophy | |||
| Nikki Sinn Things Change 3 | |||
| Gwen Summers Nothing to Hide 3 & 4 | |||
| Inari Vachs The Awakening | |||
 |
Serenity (v) Double Feature! | ||
| Chloe Taboo 19 | |||
| Kylie Ireland Timeless | |||
| Katja Kean Millennium | |||
| Ginger Lynn Torn | |||
| Missy Desperate Measures | |||
| Raylene Manic Behavior | |||
| Stephanie Swift Crossroads | |||
| 2001 |  |
Taylor Hayes (m) Jekyll and Hyde Raylene (m) Artemesia (tie) |
Nina Hartley A Midsummer Night's Cream |
| Jenna Jameson Dream Quest | |||
| Julie Meadows Watchers | |||
| Sydnee Steele Facade | |||
 |
Gwen Summers Looker 2: Femme Fatale | ||
| Syren Les Vampyres | |||
| Inari Vachs Facade | |||
| Ava Vincent Les Vampyres | |||
 |
Serenity (v) M Caught in the Act | ||
| Juli Ashton Bliss | |||
| Asia Carrera Goddaughter 5 | |||
| Jewel De'Nyle Dark Angels | |||
| Kylie Ireland Raw | |||
| Devinn Lane Spellbound | |||
| Ginger Lynn White Lightning | |||
| Tera Patrick Sex Island | |||
| Sydnee Steele Dark Angels | |||
| Gwen Summers Virgin Whore | |||
| Inari Vachs West Side | |||
| Ava Vincent Perfectly Flawless | |||
| 2002 |  |
Ginger Lynn (m) Taken |
Alexa Shrink Wrapped |
| Taylor Hayes Fade to Black | |||
| Lola Free Sex on Earth | |||
| Raylene Bad Wives 2 | |||
| Nicole Sheridan Taboo 2001 | |||
| Sydnee Steele Mafioso | |||
| Syren Taboo 2001 | |||
| Ava Vincent Underworld | |||
 |
Sydnee Steele (v) Euphoria |
Allysin Chaynes Wonderland | |
| Chloe Unreal | |||
| Jewel De'Nyle Forbidden Flesh | |||
| Lola Destiny Calling | |||
| Gina Ryder Nice Neighbors | |||
| Serenity XXX Training | |||
| Inari Vachs Beauty and the Bitch | |||
| 2003 |  |
Taylor St. Claire (m) Fashionistas |
Julia Ann Paradise Lost |
| Sondra Hall Poison Angel | |||
| Taylor Hayes If You Only Knew | |||
| Raylene Love Games | |||
| Sydnee Steele Falling From Grace | |||
| Nici Sterling Wifetaker | |||
| Syren Les Vampyres 2 | |||
 |
Devinn Lane (v) Breathless |
Aria Naked Eye | |
| Kate Frost Virgin Canvas | |||
| Ashlyn Gere Crime and Passion | |||
| Hannah Harper Role Models 2 | |||
| Kylie Ireland One Sleepless Night | |||
| Julie Meadows Sex World 2002 | |||
| Alexa Rae Karma | |||
| Raylene Betrayed by Beauty | |||
| Sydnee Steele Heroin | |||
| Gwen Summers Double Vision | |||
| Ava Vincent Heartbreaker | |||
| 2004 |  |
Savanna Samson (m) Looking In |
Cassidey Sordid |
| Dasha Heaven's Revenge | |||
| Maya Divine Virtual Love | |||
| Ashley Long Compulsion | |||
 |
Julia Ann (v) Beautiful |
Ashley Blue Girlvert 4 | |
| Chloe Barbara Broadcast Too! | |||
| Stormy Daniels Not A Romance | |||
| Chloe Dior Riptide | |||
| Devinn Lane Improper Conduct | |||
| Kaylani Lei Angel X | |||
| Carmen Luvana Rawhide | |||
| Ginger Lynn Sunset Stripped | |||
| Ann Marie Rios Babes Illustrated 13 | |||
| Savanna Samson Good Time Girl | |||
| Alexandra Silk Stud Hunters | |||
| Sydnee Steele Lost & Found | |||
| Sunset Thomas Truck Stop Trixie |
2005–2009
2010–2014
| Year | Photo | Winner Movie |
Nominees Movies |
| 2010 |  |
Kimberly Kane The Sex Files: A Dark XXX Parody |
Asa Akira Pure |
| Julia Ann Identity | |||
| Lisa Ann Who's Nailin' Paylin? | |||
| Alektra Blue Educating Alli | |||
| Roxy DeVille Whack Job | |||
| Jessica Drake Hush | |||
| Sasha Grey Throat: A Cautionary Tale | |||
| Audrey Hollander Everybody Loves Lucy | |||
| Kayden Kross The 8th Day | |||
| Kelli McCarty Faithless | |||
| Melissa Monet My Daughter's Boyfriend | |||
| Bree Olson One Last Ride | |||
| Hillary Scott Heaven | |||
| India Summer Drill Baby Drill | |||
| 2011 |  |
Andy San Dimas This Ain't Glee XXX India Summer An Open Invitation: A Real Swinger's Party in San Francisco (tie) |
Nyomi Banxxx Fatally Obsessed |
| Tori Black Whatever It Takes | |||
| Ashlynn Brooke WKRP in Cincinnati: A XXX Parody | |||
| Stormy Daniels Partly Stormy | |||
| Jessica Drake 3 Days in June | |||
| Penny Flame Real Wife Stories 6 | |||
| Roxanne Hall Scorned | |||
| Nikki Jayne The Condemned | |||
| Kimberly Kane The Sex Files 2: A Dark XXX Parody | |||
 |
Kayden Kross The Perfect Secretary: Training Day | ||
| Sunny Lane Alice | |||
| Sunny Leone Gia: Portrait of a Porn Star | |||
| Lia The Rush | |||
| Natasha Marley Bonny & Clide | |||
| Samantha Ryan Awakening to Love | |||
| Riley Steele Love Fool | |||
| Misty Stone A Love Triangle | |||
| Stoya Stoya: Perfect Picture | |||
| 2012 |  |
Jessie Andrews Portrait of a Call Girl |
Capri Anderson Runaway |
| Tori Black Killer Bodies | |||
| Jessica Drake Horizon | |||
| Allie Haze Lost and Found | |||
| Helly Mae Hellfire This Ain't Lady Gaga XXX | |||
| Kagney Linn Karter Official The Silence of the Lambs Parody | |||
| Kayden Kross Love & Marriage | |||
| Lily LaBeau The Incredible Hulk XXX: A Porn Parody | |||
| Natasha Nice Dear Abby | |||
| Savanna Samson Savanna Samson Is the Masseuse | |||
| Andy San Dimas Rezervoir Doggs: An Exquisite Movies Parody | |||
| Hillary Scott The Flintstones: A XXX Parody | |||
| Bobbi Starr A Little Part of Me | |||
| Misty Stone Hustler's Untrue Hollywood Stories: Oprah | |||
| 2013 |  |
Lily Carter Wasteland |
Nyomi Banxxx Training Day: A Pleasure Dynasty Parody |
| Alektra Blue Next Friday Night | |||
| Gracie Glam Happy Endings | |||
| Presley Hart Diary of Love | |||
| Allie Haze Star Wars XXX: A Porn Parody | |||
| Lily LaBeau Wasteland | |||
| Remy LaCroix Torn | |||
| Brooklyn Lee Voracious: The First Season | |||
| Kaylani Lei Snatched | |||
| Natasha Nice Love is a Dangerous Game | |||
| Chanel Preston Romeo & Juliet: A DreamZone Parody | |||
| Andy San Dimas Café Amore | |||
| Bobbi Starr The Truth About O | |||
| India Summer The Graduate XXX: A Paul Thomas Parody | |||
| 2014 |  |
Remy LaCroix The Temptation of Eve |
Anikka Albrite OMG… It’s the Leaving Las Vegas XXX Parody |
| Lexi Belle Meant to Be | |||
| Alektra Blue Getting Schooled | |||
| Jessica Drake Sexpionage: The Drake Chronicles | |||
| Tara Lynn Foxx This Ain't Homeland XXX | |||
| Allie Haze Clerks XXX: A Porn Parody | |||
| Jesse Jane Code of Honor | |||
| Sunny Lane The Stripper 2 | |||
| Brooklyn Lee The New Behind the Green Door | |||
| Adrianna Luna The Lone Ranger XXX: An Extreme Comixxx Parody | |||
| Maddy O'Reilly Not The Wizard of Oz XXX | |||
| Penny Pax The Submission of Emma Marx | |||
| Raven Rockette Gia: Lesbian Supermodel | |||
| Jennifer White The Stripper |
2015–2019
| Year | Photo | Winner Movie |
Nominees Movies |
| 2015 |  |
Carter Cruise Second Chances |
Asa Akira Holly...Would |
| Anikka Albrite Untamed Heart | |||
| Alex Chance This Ain't Girls XXX | |||
| Brooklyn Chase Odd Jobs | |||
| Jessica Drake Aftermath | |||
| Ash Hollywood No Way Out | |||
| Kimberly Kane The Pornographer | |||
| Maddy O'Reilly The Sexual Liberation of Anna Lee | |||
| Penny Pax Wetwork | |||
| Romi Rain The Laws of Love | |||
| Bonnie Rotten Cape Fear XXX | |||
| Samantha Saint Cinderella XXX: An Axel Braun Parody | |||
| Stevie Shae Apocalypse X | |||
| Jodi West Call Me Mother | |||
| 2016 |  |
Penny Pax The Submission of Emma Marx: Boundaries |
Asa Akira Starmaker |
| Adriana Chechik The Turning | |||
| Carter Cruise Waiting on Love | |||
| Dani Daniels Sisterhood | |||
| Stormy Daniels Wanted | |||
| Dana DeArmond Mother's Little Helper | |||
| Daisy Haze Bad Romance | |||
| Kimberly Kane Family Secrets | |||
| Remy LaCroix Stockholm Syndrome | |||
| Keira Nicole Peter Pan XXX: An Axel Braun Parody | |||
| Bonnie Rotten Sisters of Anarchy | |||
| Riley Steele Barbarella XXX: An Axel Braun Parody | |||
| India Summer Marriage 2.0 | |||
| Sarah Vandella Love, Sex & TV News | |||
| 2017 |  |
Kleio Valentien Suicide Squad XXX: An Axel Braun Parody |
Asa Akira The J.O.B. |
| Aria Alexander Sex Machina: A XXX Parody | |||
| Samantha Bentley Hard in Love | |||
| Carter Cruise Suicide Squad XXX: An Axel Braun Parody | |||
| Cherie DeVille Project Pandora: A Psychosexual Lesbian Thriller | |||
| Jessica Drake DNA | |||
| Karlee Grey Student Bodies 5 | |||
| Veruca James Deception: A XXX Thriller | |||
| Cassidy Klein Little Red: A Lesbian Fairy Tale | |||
| Sara Luvv Babysitting the Baumgartners | |||
| Abigail Mac True Detective: A XXX Parody | |||
| Penny Pax The Submission of Emma Marx: Exposed | |||
| Dana Vespoli Lefty | |||
| Kasey Warner Color Blind | |||
| 2018 | Sara Luvv The Faces of Alice | ||
| Asa Akira The Blonde Dahlia | |||
| Chloe Amour Love for Sale 2 | |||
| Abella Danger The Obsession | |||
| Jessica Drake An Inconvenient Mistress | |||
| Alexis Fawx Fantasy Factory | |||
| Alexa Grace Crash | |||
| Janice Griffith Ingenue | |||
| Jill Kassidy Half His Age: A Teenage Tragedy | |||
| Cassidy Klein Conflicted | |||
| Melissa Moore The Voyeur | |||
| Katie Morgan Bad Babes Inc. | |||
| Ella Nova Snapshot | |||
| Romi Rain Justice League XXX: An Axel Braun Parody | |||
| Angela White The Altar of Aphrodite | |||
| 2019 | Eliza Jane Anne: A Taboo Parody | ||
| Britney Amber Naked | |||
| Mercedes Carrera Second First Date | |||
| Adriana Chechik Star Wars: The Last Temptation - A Digital Playground XXX Parody | |||
| Jessica Drake Fallen II: Angels & Demons | |||
| Kimmy Granger Poon Raider: A DP XXX Parody | |||
| Aaliyah Love Too Little Too Late | |||
| Avi Love The Possession of Mrs. Hyde | |||
| Abigail Mac Fantasy Factory: Wastelands | |||
| Gia Paige Love in the Digital Age | |||
| Kenzie Reeves A Trailer Park Taboo | |||
| Kristen Scott Camgirl | |||
| India Summer Flawless | |||
| Mona Wales Insomnia | |||
| Whitney Wright Cursed |
2020–
| Year | Photo | Winner Movie |
Nominees Movies |
| 2020 |  |
Angela White Perspective |
Aiden Ashley Insomniac |
| Christiana Cinn Arcane | |||
| Jessica Drake Lost Love | |||
| Lacy Lennon The Gentleman | |||
| Kristen Scott Teenage Lesbian | |||
| Magdalene St. Michaels Confessions of A Sinful Nun 2: The Rise of Sister Mona | |||
| Kenzie Taylor Captain Marvel XXX: An Axel Braun Parody | |||
| Whitney Wright What We Do for Money | |||
| Ariel X Girls of Wrestling | |||
| 2021 |  |
Maitland Ward Muse |
|
| 2022 |  |
Kenna James Under the Veil |
|
| 2023 | |
Maitland Ward Drift |