Bremsstrahlung

Bremsstrahlung produced by a high-energy electron deflected in the electric field of an atomic nucleus

In particle physics, bremsstrahlung (/ˈbrɛmʃtrɑːləŋ/; German: [ˈbʁɛms.ʃtʁaːlʊŋ] ⓘ; from German bremsen 'to brake' and Strahlung 'radiation') is electromagnetic radiation produced by the deceleration of a charged particle when deflected by another charged particle, typically an electron by an atomic nucleus. The moving particle loses kinetic energy, which is converted into radiation (i.e., photons), thus satisfying the law of conservation of energy. The term is also used to refer to the process of producing the radiation. Bremsstrahlung has a continuous spectrum, which becomes more intense and whose peak intensity shifts toward higher frequencies as the change of the energy of the decelerated particles increases.

Broadly speaking, bremsstrahlung or braking radiation is any radiation produced due to the acceleration (positive or negative) of a charged particle. This includes synchrotron radiation (i.e., photon emission by a relativistic particle), cyclotron radiation (i.e., photon emission by a non-relativistic particle), and the emission of electrons and positrons during beta decay. Bremsstrahlung also contributes to phenomena underlying some terrestrial gamma-ray flashes. However, the term is frequently used in the more narrow sense of radiation produced when electrons (of any origin) decelerate in matter.

Bremsstrahlung emitted from plasma is sometimes referred to as free–free radiation – that is, created by electrons that are free (i.e., not in an atomic or molecular bound state) before, and remain free after, the emission of a photon. In the same parlance, bound–bound radiation refers to discrete spectral lines (an electron "jumps" between two bound states), while free–bound radiation refers to the radiative combination process, in which a free electron recombines with an ion.

This article uses SI units, along with the scaled single-particle charge q¯≡q/(4πϵ0)1/2.

Classical description

Field lines and modulus of the electric field generated by a (negative) charge first moving at a constant speed and then stopping quickly to show the generated bremsstrahlung radiation.

If quantum effects are negligible, an accelerating charged particle radiates power as described by the Larmor formula and its relativistic generalization.

Total radiated power

The total radiated power is P=2q¯2γ43c(β˙2+(𝜷⋅𝜷˙)21−β2), where 𝜷=𝐯c (the velocity of the particle divided by the speed of light), γ=1/1−β2 is the Lorentz factor, ε0 is the vacuum permittivity, 𝜷˙ signifies a time derivative of 𝜷, and q is the charge of the particle. In the case where velocity is parallel to acceleration (i.e., linear motion), the expression reduces to Pa∥v=2q¯2a2γ63c3, where a≡v˙=β˙c is the acceleration. For the case of acceleration perpendicular to the velocity (𝜷⋅𝜷˙=0), for example in synchrotrons, the total power is Pa⊥v=2q¯2a2γ43c3.

Power radiated in the two limiting cases is proportional to γ4 (a⊥v) or γ6 (a∥v). Because E=γmc2, particles with the same energy E the total radiated power goes as m−4 or m−6, which accounts for why electrons lose energy to bremsstrahlung radiation much more rapidly than heavier charged particles (e.g., muons, protons, alpha particles). This is the reason a TeV energy electron-positron collider (such as the proposed International Linear Collider) cannot use a circular tunnel (requiring constant acceleration), while a proton-proton collider (such as the Large Hadron Collider) can utilize a circular tunnel. The electrons lose energy due to bremsstrahlung at a rate (mp/me)4≈1013 times higher than protons do.

Angular distribution

The most general formula for radiated power as a function of angle is: dPdΩ=q¯24πc|𝐧̂×((𝐧̂−𝜷)×𝜷˙)|2(1−𝐧̂⋅𝜷)5 where 𝐧̂ is a unit vector pointing from the particle towards the observer, and dΩ is an infinitesimal solid angle.

In the case where velocity is parallel to acceleration (for example, linear motion), this simplifies to dPa∥vdΩ=q¯2a24πc3sin2θ(1−βcos⁡θ)5 where θ is the angle between 𝜷 and the direction of observation 𝐧̂.

Simplified quantum-mechanical description

The full quantum-mechanical treatment of bremsstrahlung is very involved. The "vacuum case" of the interaction of one electron, one ion, and one photon, using the pure Coulomb potential, has an exact solution that was probably first published by Arnold Sommerfeld in 1931. This analytical solution involves complicated mathematics, and several numerical calculations have been published, such as by Karzas and Latter. Other approximate formulas have been presented, such as in recent work by Weinberg and Pradler and Semmelrock.

This section gives a quantum-mechanical analog of the prior section, but with some simplifications to illustrate the important physics. This is a non-relativistic treatment of the special case of an electron of mass me, charge −e, and initial speed v decelerating in the Coulomb field of a gas of heavy ions of charge Ze and number density ni. The emitted radiation is a photon of frequency ν=c/λ and energy hν. The goal is to find the emissivity j(v,ν) which is the power emitted per (solid angle in photon velocity space * photon frequency), summed over both transverse photon polarizations. It is expressed as an approximate classical result times the free−free emission Gaunt factor gff accounting for quantum and other corrections: j(v,ν)=8π33Z2e¯6nic3me2vgff(v,ν) j(ν,v)=0 if hν>mv2/2, that is, the electron does not have enough kinetic energy to emit the photon. A general, quantum-mechanical formula for gff exists but is very complicated, and usually is found by numerical calculations. The following additional assumptions may be used to present approximate results:

With these assumptions, two unitless parameters characterize the process: ηZ≡Ze¯2/ℏv, which measures the strength of the electron-ion Coulomb interaction, and ην≡hν/2mev2, which measures the photon "softness" and which is assumedly always small (the choice of the factor 2 is for later convenience). In the limit ηZ≪1, the quantum-mechanical Born approximation gives: gff,Born=3πln⁡1ην

In the opposite limit ηZ≫1, the full quantum-mechanical result reduces to the purely classical result gff,class=3π[ln⁡(1ηZην)−γ] where γ≈0.577 is the Euler–Mascheroni constant. Note that 1/ηZην=mev3/πZe¯2ν which is a purely classical expression without the Planck constant h.

A semi-classical, heuristic way to understand the Gaunt factor is to write it as gff≈ln⁡(bmax/bmin) where bmax and bmin are maximum and minimum "impact parameters" for the electron-ion collision, in the presence of the photon electric field. With our assumptions, bmax=v/ν: for larger impact parameters, the sinusoidal oscillation of the photon field provides "phase mixing" that strongly reduces the interaction. bmin is the larger of the quantum-mechanical de Broglie wavelength ≈h/mev and the classical distance of closest approach ≈e¯2/mev2 where the electron-ion Coulomb potential energy is comparable to the electron's initial kinetic energy.

The above approximations generally apply as long as the argument of the logarithm is large, and break down when it is less than unity. Namely, these forms for the Gaunt factor become negative, which is unphysical. A rough approximation to the full calculations, with the appropriate Born and classical limits, is gff≈max⁡[1,3πln⁡[1ηνmax⁡(1,eγηZ)]]

Thermal bremsstrahlung in a medium: emission and absorption

This section discusses bremsstrahlung emission and the inverse absorption process (called inverse bremsstrahlung) in a macroscopic medium. The equation of radiative transfer, which applies to general processes and not just bremsstrahlung is: 1c∂tIν+𝐧̂⋅∇Iν=jν−kνIν

Iν(t,𝐱) is the radiation spectral intensity, or power per (area × solid angle in photon velocity space × photon frequency) summed over both polarizations. jν is the emissivity, analogous to j(v,ν)defined above, and kν is the absorptivity. jν and kν are properties of the matter, not the radiation, and account for all the particles in the medium – not just a pair of one electron and one ion as in the prior section. If Iν is uniform in space and time, then the left-hand side of the transfer equation is zero, and thus: Iν=jνkν

If the matter and radiation are also in thermal equilibrium at some temperature, then Iν must be the blackbody spectrum: Bν(ν,Te)=2hν3c21ehν/kBTe−1 Since jν and kν are independent of Iν, this means that jν/kν must be the blackbody spectrum whenever the matter is in equilibrium at some temperature – regardless of the state of the radiation. This allows us to immediately know both jν and kν once one is known – for matter in equilibrium.

In plasma: approximate classical results

NOTE: this section currently gives formulas that apply in the Rayleigh–Jeans limit ℏω≪kBTe, and does not use a quantized (Planck) treatment of radiation. Thus a usual factor like exp⁡(−ℏω/kBTe) does not appear. The appearance of ℏω/kBTe in y below is due to the quantum-mechanical treatment of collisions.

Bekefi's classical result for the bremsstrahlung emission power spectrum from a Maxwellian electron distribution. It rapidly decreases for large ω, and is also suppressed near ω=ωp. This plot is for the quantum case Te>Z2Eh, and ℏωp/Te=0.1. The blue curve is the full formula with E1(y), the red curve is the approximate logarithmic form for y≪1.

In a plasma, the free electrons continually collide with the ions, producing bremsstrahlung. A complete analysis requires accounting for both binary Coulomb collisions as well as collective (dielectric) behavior. A detailed treatment is given by Bekefi, while a simplified one is given by Ichimaru. These calculations follow Bekefi's dielectric treatment, with collisions included approximately via the cutoff wavenumber, kmax.

Consider a uniform plasma, with thermal electrons distributed according to the Maxwell–Boltzmann distribution with the temperature Te. Following Bekefi, the power spectral density (power per angular frequency interval per volume, integrated over the whole 4π sr of solid angle and summed over the polarizations) of the bremsstrahlung radiated, is calculated to be dPBrdω=823πe¯6(mec2)3/2[1−ωp2ω2]1/2Zi2nine(kBTe)1/2E1(y), where ωp≡(nee2/ε0me)1/2 is the electron plasma frequency, ω is the photon frequency, ne,ni is the number density of electrons and ions, and other symbols are physical constants. The second bracketed factor is the index of refraction of a light wave in a plasma, and shows that emission is greatly suppressed for ω<ωp (this is the cutoff condition for a light wave in a plasma; in this case the light wave is evanescent). This formula thus only applies for ω>ωp. This formula should be summed over ion species in a multi-species plasma.

The function E1 is the exponential integral, and the unitless quantity y is y=12ω2mekmax2kBTe

kmax is a maximum or cutoff wavenumber, arising due to binary collisions, and can vary with ion species. Roughly, kmax=1/λB when kBTe>Zi2Eh (typical in plasmas that are not too cold), where Eh≈27.2 eV is the Hartree energy, and λB=ℏ/(mekBTe)1/2[clarification needed] is the electron thermal de Broglie wavelength. Otherwise, kmax∝1/lC where lC is the classical Coulomb distance of closest approach.

For the usual case km=1/λB, y=12[ℏωkBTe]2.

The formula for dPBr/dω is approximate, in that it neglects enhanced emission occurring for ω slightly above ωp.

In the limit y≪1, E1 can be approximated as E1(y)≈−ln⁡[yeγ]+O(y) where γ≈0.577 is the Euler–Mascheroni constant. The leading, logarithmic term is frequently used, and resembles the Coulomb logarithm that occurs in other collisional plasma calculations. For y>e−γ the log term is negative, and the approximation is clearly inadequate. Bekefi gives corrected expressions for the logarithmic term that match detailed binary-collision calculations.

The total emission power density, integrated over all frequencies, is PBr=∫ωp∞dPBrdωdω=163e¯6me2c3Zi2ninekmaxG(yp)G(yp)=12π∫yp∞[1−ypy]1/2E1(y)dyy1/2yp=y(ω=ωp) G(yp=0)=1 and decreases with yp; it is always positive. For kmax=1/λB, PBr=163e¯6(mec2)32ℏZi2nine(kBTe)12G(yp)

Note the appearance of ℏ due to the quantum nature of λB. In practical units, a commonly used version of this formula for G=1 is PBr[W/m3]=Zi2nine[7.69×1018m−3]2Te[eV]12.

This formula is 1.59 times the one given above, with the difference due to details of binary collisions. Such ambiguity is often expressed by introducing Gaunt factor gB, e.g. in one finds εff=1.4×10−27T12neniZ2gB, where everything is expressed in the CGS units.

Relativistic corrections

Relativistic corrections to the emission of a 30 keV photon by an electron impacting on a proton.

For very high temperatures there are relativistic corrections to this formula, that is, additional terms of the order of kBTe/mec2.

Bremsstrahlung cooling

If the plasma is optically thin, the bremsstrahlung radiation leaves the plasma, carrying part of the internal plasma energy. This effect is known as the bremsstrahlung cooling. It is a type of radiative cooling. The energy carried away by bremsstrahlung is called bremsstrahlung losses and represents a type of radiative losses. One generally uses the term bremsstrahlung losses in the context when the plasma cooling is undesired, as e.g. in fusion plasmas.

Polarizational bremsstrahlung

Polarizational bremsstrahlung (sometimes referred to as "atomic bremsstrahlung") is the radiation emitted by the target's atomic electrons as the target atom is polarized by the Coulomb field of the incident charged particle. Polarizational bremsstrahlung contributions to the total bremsstrahlung spectrum have been observed in experiments involving relatively massive incident particles, resonance processes, and free atoms. However, there is still some debate as to whether or not there are significant polarizational bremsstrahlung contributions in experiments involving fast electrons incident on solid targets.

It is worth noting that the term "polarizational" is not meant to imply that the emitted bremsstrahlung is polarized. Also, the angular distribution of polarizational bremsstrahlung is theoretically quite different than ordinary bremsstrahlung.

Quantum mechanical description

The complete quantum mechanical description was first performed by Bethe and Heitler. They assumed plane waves for electrons which scatter at the nucleus of an atom, and derived a cross section which relates the complete geometry of that process to the frequency of the emitted photon. The quadruply differential cross section, which shows a quantum mechanical symmetry to pair production, is: d4σ=Z2αfine3ℏ2(2π)2|𝐩f||𝐩i|dωωdΩidΩfdΦ|𝐪|4×[𝐩f2sin2Θf(Ef−c|𝐩f|cos⁡Θf)2(4Ei2−c2𝐪2)+𝐩i2sin2Θi(Ei−c|𝐩i|cos⁡Θi)2(4Ef2−c2𝐪2)+2ℏ2ω2𝐩i2sin2Θi+𝐩f2sin2Θf(Ef−c|𝐩f|cos⁡Θf)(Ei−c|𝐩i|cos⁡Θi)−2|𝐩i||𝐩f|sin⁡Θisin⁡Θfcos⁡Φ(Ef−c|𝐩f|cos⁡Θf)(Ei−c|𝐩i|cos⁡Θi)(2Ei2+2Ef2−c2𝐪2)], where Z is the atomic number, αfine≈1/137 the fine-structure constant, ℏ the reduced Planck constant and c the speed of light. The kinetic energy Ekin,i/f of the electron in the initial and final state is connected to its total energy Ei,f or its momenta 𝐩i,f via Ei,f=Ekin,i/f+mec2=me2c4+𝐩i,f2c2, where me is the mass of an electron. Conservation of energy gives Ef=Ei−ℏω, where ℏω is the photon energy. The directions of the emitted photon and the scattered electron are given by Θi=∢(𝐩i,𝐤),Θf=∢(𝐩f,𝐤),Φ=Angle between the planes (𝐩i,𝐤) and (𝐩f,𝐤), where 𝐤 is the momentum of the photon.

The differentials are given as dΩi=sin⁡Θi dΘi,dΩf=sin⁡Θf dΘf.

The absolute value of the virtual photon between the nucleus and electron is −𝐪2=−|𝐩i|2−|𝐩f|2−(ℏcω)2+2|𝐩i|ℏcωcos⁡Θi−2|𝐩f|ℏcωcos⁡Θf+2|𝐩i||𝐩f|(cos⁡Θfcos⁡Θi+sin⁡Θfsin⁡Θicos⁡Φ).

The range of validity is given by the Born approximation v≫Zc137 where this relation has to be fulfilled for the velocity v of the electron in the initial and final state.

For practical applications (e.g. in Monte Carlo codes) it can be interesting to focus on the relation between the frequency ω of the emitted photon and the angle between this photon and the incident electron. Köhn and Ebert integrated the quadruply differential cross section by Bethe and Heitler over Φ and Θf and obtained: d2σ(Ei,ω,Θi)dωdΩi=∑j=16Ij with I1=2πAΔ22+4pi2pf2sin2Θiln⁡(Δ22+4pi2pf2sin2Θi−Δ22+4pi2pf2sin2Θi(Δ1+Δ2)+Δ1Δ2−Δ22−4pi2pf2sin2Θi−Δ22+4pi2pf2sin2Θi(Δ1−Δ2)+Δ1Δ2)×[1+cΔ2pf(Ei−cpicos⁡Θi)−pi2c2sin2Θi(Ei−cpicos⁡Θi)2−2ℏ2ω2pfΔ2c(Ei−cpicos⁡Θi)(Δ22+4pi2pf2sin2Θi)],I2=−2πAcpf(Ei−cpicos⁡Θi)ln⁡(Ef+pfcEf−pfc),I3=2πA(Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc)4+4m2c4pi2pf2sin2Θi×ln⁡[([Ef+pfc][4pi2pf2sin2Θi(Ef−pfc)+(Δ1+Δ2)([Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc]−[Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc]2+4m2c4pi2pf2sin2Θi)])[(Ef−pfc)(4pi2pf2sin2Θi[−Ef−pfc]+(Δ1−Δ2)([Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc]−(Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc)2+4m2c4pi2pf2sin2Θi])]−1×[−(Δ22+4pi2pf2sin2Θi)(Ef3+Efpf2c2)+pfc(2[Δ12−4pi2pf2sin2Θi]Efpfc+Δ1Δ2[3Ef2+pf2c2])(Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc)2+4m2c4pi2pf2sin2Θi−c(Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc)pf(Ei−cpicos⁡Θi)−4Ei2pf2(2[Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc]2−4m2c4pi2pf2sin2Θi)(Δ1Ef+Δ2pfc)([Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc]2+4m2c4pi2pf2sin2Θi)2+8pi2pf2m2c4sin2Θi(Ei2+Ef2)−2ℏ2ω2pi2sin2Θipfc(Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc)+2ℏ2ω2pfm2c3(Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc)(Ei−cpicos⁡Θi)([Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc]2+4m2c4pi2pf2sin2Θi)],I4=−4πApfc(Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc)(Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc)2+4m2c4pi2pf2sin2Θi−16πEi2pf2A(Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc)2([Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc]2+4m2c4pi2pf2sin2Θi)2,I5=4πA(−Δ22+Δ12−4pi2pf2sin2Θi)([Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc]2+4m2c4pi2pf2sin2Θi)×[ℏ2ω2pf2Ei−cpicos⁡Θi×Ef(2Δ22[Δ22−Δ12]+8pi2pf2sin2Θi[Δ22+Δ12])+pfc(2Δ1Δ2[Δ22−Δ12]+16Δ1Δ2pi2pf2sin2Θi)Δ22+4pi2pf2sin2Θi+2ℏ2ω2pi2sin2Θi(2Δ1Δ2pfc+2Δ22Ef+8pi2pf2sin2ΘiEf)Ei−cpicos⁡Θi+2Ei2pf2(2[Δ22−Δ12][Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc]2+8pi2pf2sin2Θi[(Δ12+Δ22)(Ef2+pf2c2)+4Δ1Δ2Efpfc])(Δ2Ef+Δ1pfc)2+4m2c4pi2pf2sin2Θi+8pi2pf2sin2Θi(Ei2+Ef2)(Δ2pfc+Δ1Ef)Ei−cpicos⁡Θi],I6=16πEf2pi2sin2ΘiA(Ei−cpicos⁡Θi)2(−Δ22+Δ12−4pi2pf2sin2Θi), and A=Z2αfine3(2π)2|𝐩f||𝐩i|ℏ2ωΔ1=−𝐩i2−𝐩f2−(ℏcω)2+2ℏcω|𝐩i|cos⁡Θi,Δ2=−2ℏcω|𝐩f|+2|𝐩i||𝐩f|cos⁡Θi.

However, a much simpler expression for the same integral can be found in (Eq. 2BN) and in (Eq. 4.1).

An analysis of the doubly differential cross section above shows that electrons whose kinetic energy is larger than the rest energy (511 keV) emit photons in forward direction while electrons with a small energy emit photons isotropically.

Electron–electron bremsstrahlung

One mechanism, considered important for small atomic numbers Z, is the scattering of a free electron at the shell electrons of an atom or molecule. Since electron–electron bremsstrahlung is a function of Z and the usual electron-nucleus bremsstrahlung is a function of Z2, electron–electron bremsstrahlung is negligible for metals. For air, however, it plays an important role in the production of terrestrial gamma-ray flashes.

See also