Contagious shooting

A contagious shooting, also known as sympathetic fire, is a sociological phenomenon observed in police personnel, in which one person firing on a target can induce others to begin shooting without knowing why they are firing. The term may have been coined, but certainly rose to prominence in public discourse in the aftermath of the killing of Amadou Diallo by the NYPD in 1999. DeCarlo, Dlugolenski, and Myers (2024) conducted a randomized trial with 169 officers across four states and 11 agencies. Officers were randomly assigned to test or control conditions. Each officer experienced the exact same scenario. In test conditions, two peer (role player) officers fired their weapons. In the control condition they withheld their fire. The odds of officers firing in the presence of peer fire was 11.57 times greater, and they fired 72% more rounds on average than the control condition. The large effect size and causal design demonstrated that behavioral interdependence is a key concern in multi-officer-involved shootings

Examples

Usage

More views

Besides the above examples, the phenomenon has been observed in other contexts. A former CIA employee and FBI firearms instructor observed it in training. "Consistently, in every class, officers would shoot at their target upon hearing others shoot, even when their particular target board did not contain the called target." He suggests that one reason it occurs is because of muscle memory: "[T]he targets turn, or the whistle blows, and all the officers shoot together until a cease-fire signal is given."

Law professor Eugene O'Donnell was once quoted describing the notion as "debatable" although in the same interview he agreed with its existence, saying that in classic cases involving contagious shooting, "a gun was shot before any officers fired", and thus "the officers involved began shooting because of fear or because of the sound of a colleague firing".

See also