Cumbria Shield

Cumbria Shield
SportRugby Union
Instituted1888; 138 years ago (1888) (Cumberland Challenge Shield)
1974; 52 years ago (1974) (Cumbria Shield)
Country England
HoldersWigton II (10th title) (2017–18)
Most titlesWorkington (18 titles)
WebsiteCumbria Rugby Union

The Cumbria Shield is an annual rugby union knock-out club competition organized by the Cumbria Rugby Union. It was introduced during the 1888–89 season, when it was known as the Cumberland Challenge Shield, and the inaugural winners were Millom. Initially it was open only to junior club sides in Cumberland (senior sides played in the Challenge Cup) but in 1974, as a result of the Local Government Act 1972, Cumberland, Westmorland and Furness merged to form what we now know as Cumbria, and the competition would ultimately be renamed as the Cumbria Shield. It is the third most important cup competition in Cumbria, behind the Cumbria Cup and Cumbria League Cup.

Originally the Shield was a knock-out cup played by the 1st teams of junior clubs, along with the 2nd teams of senior clubs, before becoming mostly a 2nd team competition. In later years the format switched back and forth between a knock-out cup and league cup-hybrid, but has most recently switched to being awarded to the winners of the Cumbria Shield League – a regional league for 2nd and 3rd teams in Cumbria. A secondary competition known as the Cumbria Vase was introduced in 2007 initially for sides knocked out of the early rounds of the Shield competition, although in recent years it seems to have become a stand-alone cup competition for 2nd teams in the region.

Cumbria Shield winners

Cumbria Shield Finals
Season Winner Score Runners–up Venue
1888-89Millom II6-4CleatorEgremont
1889-90Egremont II5-1Aspatria IIColliery Recreation Ground, Whitehaven
1890-91Millom II4-0Dearham JuniorsEgremont
1891-92Millom II15-0Whitehaven RecreationCleator
1892-93Whitehaven Recreation10-0Carlisle IIMaryport
1893-94Maryport II13-3Cowan SheldoniansCarlisle
1894-95Millom II3-0Wath BrowEgremont
1895-96Wath Brow3-0Maryport Red RoseLonsdale Park, Workington
1896-97Workington II3-0Highmoor RoversMaryport
1897-98Workington II5-3Whitehaven RecreationWhitehaven
1898-99Highmoor Rover3-0Aspatria HornetsWhitehaven
1900-06No competition
1906-07Aspatria II3-0Cockermouth IIAspatria Agriculture College
1907-08Wigton5-0Aspatria IICockermouth
1908-09Workington Trades6-0Silloth IINoble Croft, Aspatria
1909-10Cockermouth II6-3Wigton IIPark Ground, Silloth
1910-11Wigton II5-3Workington IINoble Croft, Aspatria
1911-12Whitehaven II10-3Cockermouth IINoble Croft, Aspatria
1912-13Blennerhasset II6-3Silloth IIBrindle Field, Wigton
1913-14Workington II6-3Cockermouth IIWhitehaven
1914-18No competition due to World War I
1919-20Workington II5-0Silloth IINoble Croft, Aspatria
1920-21Great Clifton II5-3Aspatria IICockermouth
1921-22Aspatria II9-0Egremont IIWhitehaven
1922-23Silloth II3-0Aspatria IICarlisle
1923-24Aspatria II8-6Blennerhasset IIPark Ground, Silloth
1924-25Aspatria II17-3Silloth IICarlisle
1925-26Workington II16-3Silloth IINoble Croft, Aspatria
1926-27Cockermouth II3-0St Bees IIEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1927-28Wigton Hornets11-5Workington IICockermouth
1928-29Aspatria II17-3Moresby IIEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1929-30Aspatria II6-0Cockermouth IIEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1930-31Workington II6-3Aspatria IICockermouth
1931-32Whitehaven II12-3Egremont IISt Bees
1932-33Aspatria II3-3
8-0
BothelEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1933-34Cockermouth II6-3Egremont IIEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1934-35Workington II23-4Cockermouth IIBleach Green, Egremont
1935-36Workington II14-5Whitehaven IIBleach Green, Egremont
1936-37Moresby II11-3Workington IIBleach Green, Egremont
1937-38Aspatria II3-0Workington IISilloth
1938-39Egremont II4-0Cockermouth IIEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1940-45No competition due to World War II
1946-47Silloth 2nds3-0Cockermouth 2ndsEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1947-48Cockermouth 2nds6-0Silloth 2ndsWigton
1948-49Workington II3-3
8-3
Keswick IICockermouth
1949-50Workington 2nds24-9Carlisle IIWigton
1950-51Workington II14-9Whitehaven IIBleach Green, Egremont
1951-52Egremont 2nds11-9Aspatria 2ndsEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1952-53Egremont 2nds15-0Aspatria 2ndsEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1953-54Workington 2nds6-3Egremont 2ndsWhitehaven
1954-55Egremont 2nds5-3Whitehaven 2ndsCockermouth
1955-56Workington 2nds9-3Egremont 2ndsWhitehaven
1956-57Millom 2nds6-5Egremont 2ndsEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1957-58Workington 2nds12-6Millom 2ndsBleach Green, Egremont
1958-59Border Regiment9-3Workington 2ndsWigton
1959-60Workington II3-0British SteelsCockermouth
1960-61British Steels6-0Netherhall Old BoysEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1961-62Cumberland & Westmorland Police9-8Netherhall Old BoysEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1962-63Whitehaven II15-3Netherhall Old BoysEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1963-64Netherhall Old Boys6-3British SteelsCockermouth
1964-65Netherhall Old Boys6-3Whitehaven IIEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1965-66Netherhall Old Boys15-9Whitehaven IIEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1966-67Netherhall Old Boys6-3Whitehaven IIEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1967-68Whitehaven II12-6Netherhall Old BoysEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1968-69Netherhall Old Boys18-9Whitehaven IIBleach Green, Egremont
1969-70Netherhall Old Boys13-0Workington IILaithwaite Ground, Cockermouth
1970-71Wigton II9-6Whitehaven IIEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1971-72Workington II7-3Wigton IICockermouth
1972-73Wigton II16-9Whitehaven IIEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1973-74Wigton II18-7Smith BrosEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1974-75Cockermouth II15-9Smith BrosWhitehaven
1975-76Wigton II10-10
9-6
Smith BrosBower Park, Aspatria
1976-77Millom II23-22British SteelsWhitehaven
1977-78Netherhall Old Boys3-0Workington IIBower Park, Aspatria
1978-79Netherhall Old Boys16-3SillothLowmoor Road, Wigton
1979-80Wigton II10-7Egremont IIEllis Sports Ground, Workington
1980-81Aspatria II9-6Netherhall IILowmoor Road, Wigton
1981-82Aspatria II15-12Wigton IIWhitehaven
1982-83Aspatria II12-6Egremont IIWhitehaven
1983-84St Benedict's9-4Egremont AWalkmill Park, Moresby
1984-85St Benedict's12-6Workington IIWhitehaven
1985-86Aspatria II18-3British SteelsNetherhall
1986-87St Benedict's9-6Smith BrosWhitehaven
1987-88St Benedict's9-3Wigton IINetherhall
1988-89Carlisle 'A'
1989-90St Benedict's
1990-91Silloth
1991-92Silloth
1992-93Aspatria II
1993-94Aspatria II
1994-95Netherhall II
1995-96Kendal II
1996-97Wigton II
1997-98Wigton II15-8Workington IINetherhall
1998-99Aspatria Eagles13-8St Benedict’sSilloth
1999-00Workington II
2000-01Kirkby Lonsdale II32-9Workington IICarlisle
2001-02Aspatria II29-8Carlisle IISilloth
2002-03Workington IIPenrith II
2003-04Penrith II
2004-05Penrith II
2005-06Aspatria II34-25Carlisle IISycamore Lane, Creighton
2006-07Penrith II15-3Wigton IISycamore Lane, Creighton
2007-08Silloth16-16Penrith IIILowmoor Road, Wigton
2008-09Silloth27-20St Benedict's IISt Benedict’s
2009-10St Benedict's II
2010-11St Benedict's II
2011-12Moresby12-10CockermouthNetherhall Road, Maryport
2012-13Moresby14-5CreightonGrassmoor Sports Centre, Cockermouth
2013-14Penrith III
2014-15Penrith III30-12St Benedict's IIDavidson Park, Keswick
2015-16St Benedict's IINo final as league competition
2016-17Aspatria Eagles
2017-18Wigton IINo final as league competition
2018-19Whitehaven
2020-2021No Winner Due To COVID 19
2021-22Penrith IINo final as league competition
2022-23Keswick II
2023-24No competition held
2024-25Keswick II28-27Penrith IILowmoor Road, Wigton
2025-26St Benedict’s24-10Keswick IILowmoor Road, Wigton

Cumbria Vase winners

Cumbria Vase Finals
Season Winner Score Runners–up Venue
2007-08Kendal 'A'
2008-09Kendal 'A'
2009-10Carlisle 'A'
2010-11Carlisle 'A'
2011-12Kendal 'A'
2012-13No final
2013-14Creighton
2014-15Penrith IIIAmblesideKendal
2015-16St Benedicts II14-11Cockermouth
2018-19Windermere34-5Aspatria EaglesKeswick
2024-25Hawcoat Park37-3CreightonWindermere

Number of wins

Notes

  1. ↑ Workington have won 19 Challenge Shield titles including the 1909 win by Workington Trades RUFC - the side that would merge with Workington RUFC in 1910 to form the current club. Figure also includes titles won by the 1st XV.
  2. ↑ Includes both 1st and 2nd team titles.
  3. ↑ Includes 8 titles won by Netherhall Old Boys.
  4. ↑ No relation to the better known Clifton RFC who are based in Bristol.
  5. ↑ Maryport were Challenge Shield winners during the 1890s before they switched over to Rugby League in 1898-99.
  6. ↑ Whitehaven Recreation won a Challenge Shield during the 1890s before switching to Rugby league in 1898. Despite being based in the same town they do not seem to have any connection with Whitehaven R.L.F.C., who were formed much later in 1948.
  7. ↑ It is not clear if Wigton Hornets were in any way related to Wigton RUFC - they could possibly have been the name for the Wigton 2nd team or even a separate club.

See also

References

  1. ↑ "History". Angelfire. Retrieved 10 July 2017.
  2. ↑ "Cumbria Shield second team tournament set for revival". News & Star. 29 May 2004.
  3. ↑ "Club reputation enhanced after one of finest ever seasons". Cumberland & Westmorland Herald. 21 June 2003.
  4. ↑ "Aspatria fight back to win Shield". News & Star. 27 April 2006.
  5. ↑ "Seconds AIM for Shield SUCCESS". Cumberland & Westmorland Herald. 27 April 2007.
  6. ↑ "Vags in final countdown". Cumberland & Westmorland Herald. 25 April 2008.
  7. ↑ "Moresby rise from the ashes to lift Cumbria Shield". News & Star. 8 May 2012.[permanent dead link]
  8. ↑ "Moresby rally to the Rowell revival bid". News & Star. 2 April 2013.
  9. ↑ "Vags celebrate shield win". Cumberland & Westmorland Herald. 1 May 2015.
  10. 1 2 "Cumbria Rugby Union Newsletter Issue 54 (June 2016)" (PDF). Cumbria RU. Retrieved 20 July 2017.
  11. ↑ "Cumbria Vase - Previous Winners (Word Doc)". Cumbria RU. Retrieved 18 July 2017.
  12. ↑ "History". Workington RFC (Pitchero). Retrieved 10 July 2017.
  13. ↑ "History 3". Maryport ARLFC (Pitchero). Retrieved 10 July 2017.
  14. ↑ "Foundation". Whitehaven Rugby League Football Club. Retrieved 10 July 2017.
  15. ↑ "Calling RL historians". Total Rugby League Fans Forum. 8 March 2016.