The dividend puzzle, as originally framed by Fischer Black,
relates to two interrelated questions in corporate finance and financial economics:
why do corporations pay dividends; and why do investors "pay attention" to dividends?
Behavioral economics posits that for investors, outcomes received with certainty are overweighed relative to uncertain outcomes; see Prospect theory. Thus here, respectively, investors will prefer (and pay for) certain cash dividends, as opposed to reinvestment in the firm with possible consequent price appreciation.
Under Agency theory, dividend policy is seen as a way to mitigate the principal–agent problem: by paying out a portion of free cash flow as dividends, shareholders (principals) can limit the actions available to managers (agents, who might otherwise engage, e.g., in "empire building").