Drucker–Prager yield criterion

Figure 1: View of Drucker–Prager yield surface in 3D space of principal stresses for c=2,ϕ=−20∘

The Drucker–Prager yield criterion is a pressure-dependent model for determining whether a material has failed or undergone plastic yielding. The criterion was introduced to deal with the plastic deformation of soils. It and its many variants have been applied to rock, concrete, polymers, foams, and other pressure-dependent materials.

The Drucker–Prager yield criterion has the form

J2=A+B I1

where I1 is the first invariant of the Cauchy stress and J2 is the second invariant of the deviatoric part of the Cauchy stress. The constants A,B are determined from experiments.

In terms of the equivalent stress (or von Mises stress) and the hydrostatic (or mean) stress, the Drucker–Prager criterion can be expressed as

σe=a+b σm

where σe is the equivalent stress, σm is the hydrostatic stress, and a,b are material constants. The Drucker–Prager yield criterion expressed in Haigh–Westergaard coordinates is

12ρ−3 Bξ=A

The Drucker–Prager yield surface is a smooth version of the Mohr–Coulomb yield surface.

Expressions for A and B

The Drucker–Prager model can be written in terms of the principal stresses as

16[(σ1−σ2)2+(σ2−σ3)2+(σ3−σ1)2]=A+B (σ1+σ2+σ3) .

If σt is the yield stress in uniaxial tension, the Drucker–Prager criterion implies

13 σt=A+B σt .

If σc is the yield stress in uniaxial compression, the Drucker–Prager criterion implies

13 σc=A−B σc .

Solving these two equations gives

A=23 (σc σtσc+σt) ;  B=13 (σt−σcσc+σt) .

Uniaxial asymmetry ratio

Different uniaxial yield stresses in tension and in compression are predicted by the Drucker–Prager model. The uniaxial asymmetry ratio for the Drucker–Prager model is

β=σcσt=1−3 B1+3 B .

Expressions in terms of cohesion and friction angle

Since the Drucker–Prager yield surface is a smooth version of the Mohr–Coulomb yield surface, it is often expressed in terms of the cohesion (c) and the angle of internal friction (ϕ) that are used to describe the Mohr–Coulomb yield surface. If we assume that the Drucker–Prager yield surface circumscribes the Mohr–Coulomb yield surface then the expressions for A and B are

A=6 c cos⁡ϕ3(3−sin⁡ϕ) ;  B=2 sin⁡ϕ3(3−sin⁡ϕ)

If the Drucker–Prager yield surface middle circumscribes the Mohr–Coulomb yield surface then

A=6 c cos⁡ϕ3(3+sin⁡ϕ) ;  B=2 sin⁡ϕ3(3+sin⁡ϕ)

If the Drucker–Prager yield surface inscribes the Mohr–Coulomb yield surface then

A=3 c cos⁡ϕ9+3 sin2ϕ ;  B=sin⁡ϕ9+3 sin2ϕ
Figure 2: Drucker–Prager yield surface in the π-plane for c=2,ϕ=20∘
Figure 3: Trace of the Drucker–Prager and Mohr–Coulomb yield surfaces in the σ1−σ2-plane for c=2,ϕ=20∘. Yellow = Mohr–Coulomb, Cyan = Drucker–Prager.

Drucker–Prager model for polymers

The Drucker–Prager model has been used to model polymers such as polyoxymethylene and polypropylene[citation needed]. For polyoxymethylene the yield stress is a linear function of the pressure. However, polypropylene shows a quadratic pressure-dependence of the yield stress.

Drucker–Prager model for foams

For foams, the GAZT model uses

A=±σy3 ;  B=∓13 (ρ5 ρs)

where σy is a critical stress for failure in tension or compression, ρ is the density of the foam, and ρs is the density of the base material.

Extensions of the isotropic Drucker–Prager model

The Drucker–Prager criterion can also be expressed in the alternative form

J2=(A+B I1)2=a+b I1+c I12 .

Deshpande–Fleck yield criterion or isotropic foam yield criterion

The Deshpande–Fleck yield criterion for foams has the form given in above equation. The parameters a,b,c for the Deshpande–Fleck criterion are

a=(1+β2) σy2 ,  b=0 ,  c=−β23

where β is a parameter that determines the shape of the yield surface, and σy is the yield stress in tension or compression.

Anisotropic Drucker–Prager yield criterion

An anisotropic form of the Drucker–Prager yield criterion is the Liu–Huang–Stout yield criterion. This yield criterion is an extension of the generalized Hill yield criterion and has the form

f:=F(σ22−σ33)2+G(σ33−σ11)2+H(σ11−σ22)2+2Lσ232+2Mσ312+2Nσ122+Iσ11+Jσ22+Kσ33−1≤0

The coefficients F,G,H,L,M,N,I,J,K are

F=12[Σ22+Σ32−Σ12] ;  G=12[Σ32+Σ12−Σ22] ;  H=12[Σ12+Σ22−Σ32]L=12(σ23y)2 ;  M=12(σ31y)2 ;  N=12(σ12y)2I=σ1c−σ1t2σ1cσ1t ;  J=σ2c−σ2t2σ2cσ2t ;  K=σ3c−σ3t2σ3cσ3t

where

Σ1:=σ1c+σ1t2σ1cσ1t ;  Σ2:=σ2c+σ2t2σ2cσ2t ;  Σ3:=σ3c+σ3t2σ3cσ3t

and σic,i=1,2,3 are the uniaxial yield stresses in compression in the three principal directions of anisotropy, σit,i=1,2,3 are the uniaxial yield stresses in tension, and σ23y,σ31y,σ12y are the yield stresses in pure shear. It has been assumed in the above that the quantities σ1c,σ2c,σ3c are positive and σ1t,σ2t,σ3t are negative.

The Drucker yield criterion

The Drucker–Prager criterion should not be confused with the earlier Drucker criterion which is independent of the pressure (I1). The Drucker yield criterion has the form

f:=J23−α J32−k2≤0

where J2 is the second invariant of the deviatoric stress, J3 is the third invariant of the deviatoric stress, α is a constant that lies between -27/8 and 9/4 (for the yield surface to be convex), k is a constant that varies with the value of α. For α=0, k2=σy627 where σy is the yield stress in uniaxial tension.

Anisotropic Drucker Criterion

An anisotropic version of the Drucker yield criterion is the Cazacu–Barlat (CZ) yield criterion which has the form

f:=(J20)3−α (J30)2−k2≤0

where J20,J30 are generalized forms of the deviatoric stress and are defined as

J20:=16[a1(σ22−σ33)2+a2(σ33−σ11)2+a3(σ11−σ22)2]+a4σ232+a5σ312+a6σ122J30:=127[(b1+b2)σ113+(b3+b4)σ223+{2(b1+b4)−(b2+b3)}σ333]−19[(b1σ22+b2σ33)σ112+(b3σ33+b4σ11)σ222+{(b1−b2+b4)σ11+(b1−b3+b4)σ22}σ332]+29(b1+b4)σ11σ22σ33+2b11σ12σ23σ31−13[{2b9σ22−b8σ33−(2b9−b8)σ11}σ312+{2b10σ33−b5σ22−(2b10−b5)σ11}σ122{(b6+b7)σ11−b6σ22−b7σ33}σ232]

Cazacu–Barlat yield criterion for plane stress

For thin sheet metals, the state of stress can be approximated as plane stress. In that case the Cazacu–Barlat yield criterion reduces to its two-dimensional version with

J20=16[(a2+a3)σ112+(a1+a3)σ222−2a3σ1σ2]+a6σ122J30=127[(b1+b2)σ113+(b3+b4)σ223]−19[b1σ11+b4σ22]σ11σ22+13[b5σ22+(2b10−b5)σ11]σ122

For thin sheets of metals and alloys, the parameters of the Cazacu–Barlat yield criterion are

Table 1. Cazacu–Barlat yield criterion parameters for sheet metals and alloys
Materiala1a2a3a6b1b2b3b4b5b10α
6016-T4 Aluminum Alloy 0.8150.8150.3340.420.04-1.205-0.9580.3060.153-0.021.4
2090-T3 Aluminum Alloy 1.050.8230.5860.961.440.061-1.302-0.281-0.3750.4451.285

See also