Dynamic positioning

Offshore support vessel Toisa Perseus with, in the background, the fifth-generation deepwater drillship Discoverer Enterprise, over the Thunder Horse Oil Field. Both are equipped with DP systems.

Dynamic positioning (DP) is a computer-controlled system which automatically maintains a vessel's position and heading by using its own propellers and thrusters. Position references sensors, combined with wind sensors, motion sensors, and gyrocompasses, provides the computer with information about the vessel's position and the magnitude and direction of the environmental forces affecting it. Examples of vessel types that employ DP include ships and semi-submersible mobile offshore drilling units (MODU), oceanographic research vessels, cable layer ships, and cruise ships.

The computer program contains a mathematical model of the vessel, including information such as its current drag and thrusters' locations. This knowledge, combined with sensor data (e.g. wind), allows the computer to calculate the required steering angle and the output for each thruster to support operations at sea where mooring or anchoring is not feasible due to deep water, seabed congestion (pipelines, templates), or other constraints.

Dynamic positioning may be either absolute, in that the position is locked to a fixed point on the bottom, or relative to a moving object, such as another ship or an underwater vehicle. One may also position the ship at a favourable angle to the wind, waves, and current, a practice called Weathervaning.

Dynamic positioning is used by much of the offshore oil industry, for example, in the North Sea, Persian Gulf, Gulf of Mexico, West Africa, and off the coast of Brazil.

History

Dynamic positioning began in the 1960s for offshore drilling. With drilling moving into ever deeper waters, jack-up barges could not be used anymore, and anchoring in deep water was not economical.

As part of Project Mohole, in 1961, the drillship CUSS 1 was fitted with four steerable propellers. The Mohole project aimed to drill to the Moho, which required a solution for deep-water drilling. It was possible to keep the ship in position above a well off La Jolla, California, at a depth of 948 meters.

After this, off the coast of Guadalupe, Mexico, five holes were drilled, the deepest at 183 m (600 ft) below the sea floor in 3,500 m (11,500 ft) of water, while maintaining a position within a radius of 180 metres (590 ft). The ship's position was determined by radar ranging to buoys and sonar ranging from subsea beacons.

Whereas the CUSS 1 was kept in position manually, Shell later in the same year launched the drilling ship Eureka, which had an analog control system interfaced with a taut wire, making it the first true DP ship.

While the first DP ships had analog controllers and lacked redundancy, vast improvements have been made since then. DP is now used not only in the oil industry but also on various other types of ships. In addition, DP is no longer limited to maintaining a fixed position. One use case is sailing an exact track, which is useful for cablelay, pipelay, survey, and other tasks.

Comparison between position-keeping options

Other methods of position-keeping include using an anchor spread and a jack-up barge. All have their own advantages and disadvantages.

Comparison of position-keeping options
Jack-up barge Anchoring Dynamic positioning
Advantages
  • No complex systems with thrusters, extra generators, and controllers.
  • No chance of running off position due to system failures or blackouts.
  • No underwater hazards from thrusters.
  • No complex systems with thrusters, extra generators, and controllers.
  • No chance of running off position due to system failures or blackouts.
  • No underwater hazards from thrusters.
  • Maneuverability is excellent; it is easy to change position.
  • No anchor handling tugs are required.
  • Not dependent on water depth.
  • Quick setup.
  • Not limited by an obstructed seabed.
Disadvantages
  • No maneuverability once positioned.
  • Limited to water depths of 175 meters.
  • Limited maneuverability once anchored.
  • Anchor handling tugs are required.
  • Less suitable in deep water.
  • Time to anchor out varies from several hours to several days.
  • Limited by obstructed seabed (pipelines, seabed).
  • Complex systems with thrusters, extra generators, and controllers.
  • High initial costs of installation.
  • High fuel costs.
  • Chance of running off position in case of strong currents or winds, or due to system failures or blackouts.
  • Underwater hazards from thrusters for divers and ROVs.
  • Higher maintenance of the mechanical systems.

Although all methods have their own advantages, dynamic positioning has enabled many operations that were previously infeasible.

The costs are falling due to newer, cheaper technologies, and the advantages are becoming more compelling as offshore work moves into ever-deeper water and the underwater environment (coral) is given greater respect. In container operations, crowded ports can be made more efficient through faster, more accurate berthing techniques. Cruise ship operations benefit from faster berthing and non-anchored "moorings" off beaches or inaccessible ports.

Applications

SBX underway

Important applications include:

Scope

A ship's motion can be described in terms of six degrees of freedom, consisting of translation and rotation along three perpendicular axes.

The three translational motions are:

The three rotational motions are:

Dynamic positioning is primarily concerned with controlling a vessel in the horizontal plane, namely translation along the two horizontal axes (surge and sway) and rotation about the vertical axis (yaw).

Requirements

For a vessel to operate using dynamic positioning (DP), several essential components are required:

When designing a DP vessel, careful consideration must be given to both the position reference systems and the available thrust. In particular, maintaining position and heading in adverse weather requires sufficient thrust capacity in all three controlled degrees of freedom: surge, sway, and yaw.

Maintaining a fixed position is especially challenging in polar conditions, where ice forces can change rapidly. Current ship-borne ice detection and mitigation technologies are not yet advanced enough to predict these forces reliably, though they may offer advantages over sensors deployed by helicopter.

Positioning systems

There are several methods for determining a ship's position at sea. Most traditional methods of ship navigation are not accurate enough to meet some modern requirements. For that reason, several positioning systems have been developed during the past decades. Producers of DP systems are: Marine Technologies LLC, Kongsberg Maritime, Navis Engineering Oy, GE, SIREHNA, Wärtsilä (ex L-3), Edison Chouest Offshore, Rolls-Royce plc, Praxis Automation Technology, Brunvoll AS. The term digital anchor has been used to describe such dynamic positioning systems. The applications and availability depends on the type of work and water depth. The most common position reference systems (PRS) and position measuring systems (PME) are:

GPS satellite in orbit

Heading systems

More advanced methods are:

Other sensors

Besides position and heading, other variables are fed into the DP system through sensors:

Control systems

Block diagram of control system

In the beginning, PID controllers were used and are still used in simpler DP systems today. But modern controllers use a mathematical model of the ship that is based on a hydrodynamic and aerodynamic description concerning some of the ship's characteristics, such as mass and drag. Of course, this model is not entirely correct. The ship's position and heading are fed into the system and compared with the model's prediction. This difference is used to update the model by using the Kalman filtering technique. For this reason, the model also has input from the wind sensors and feedback from the thrusters. This method even allows not having input from any PRS for some time, depending on the quality of the model and the weather. This process is known as dead reckoning.

The accuracy and precision of the different PRSs is not the same. While a DGPS has a high accuracy and precision, a USBL can have a much lower precision. For this reason, the PRS's are weighted. Based on variance, a PRS receives a weight between 0 and 1.

Power and propulsion systems

North Sea Giant

To maintain position azimuth thrusters (electric, L-drive or Z-drive) bow thrusters, stern thrusters, water jets, rudders, and propellers are used. DP ships are usually at least partially diesel-electric, as this allows a more flexible setup and better handles the large changes in power demand typical of DP operations. These fluctuations may be suitable for hybrid operation. An LNG-powered platform supply vessel started operation in 2016 with a 653 kWh/1600 kW battery acting as spinning reserve during DP2, saving 15-30% fuel. The 154-meter North Sea Giant has combined 3 powerpacks, switchboards and 2 MWh batteries to operate in DP3 using only one engine, keeping the engine load between 60% and 80%.

The setup depends on the ship's DP class. A Class 1 can be relatively simple, whereas the system of a Class 3 ship is quite complex. On Class 2 and 3 ships, all computers and reference systems should be powered through an UPS.

International Maritime Organization class requirements

Based on IMO (International Maritime Organization) publication 64,5 the Classification Societies have issued rules for Dynamic Positioned Ships described as Class 1, Class 2, and Class 3.

Classification Societies have their own Class notations:

DescriptionIMO
Equipment Class
LR
Equipment Class
DNV
Equipment Class
GL
Equipment Class
ABS
Equipment Class
NK
Equipment Class
BV
Equipment Class
Manual position control and automatic heading control under specified maximum environmental conditions.-DP(CM)DYNPOS-AUTS-DPS-0-
Automatic and manual position and heading control under specified maximum environmental conditions.Class 1DP(AM)DYNPOS-AUT & DPS1DP 1DPS-1DPS ADYNAPOS AM/AT
Automatic and manual position and heading control under specified maximum environmental conditions, during and following any single fault, excluding loss of a compartment. (Two independent computer systems).Class 2DP(AA)DYNPOS-AUTR & DPS2DP 2DPS-2DPS BDYNAPOS AM/AT R
Automatic and manual position and heading control under specified maximum environmental conditions, during and following any single fault, including loss of a compartment due to fire or flood. (At least two independent computer systems with a separate backup system separated by an A60 class division).Class 3DP(AAA)DYNPOS-AUTRO & DPS3DP 3DPS-3DPS CDYNAPOS AM/AT RS

DNV rules 2011, Pt 6, Ch 7, introduced the "DPS" classification series to compete with ABS's "DPS" series.

Norwegian Maritime Authority Guidelines

Where IMO leaves the decision of which class applies to what kind of operation to the operator of the DP ship and its client, the Norwegian Maritime Authority (NMA) has specified what Class should be used regarding the risk of an operation. In the NMA Guidelines and Notes No. 28, enclosure A, four classes are defined:

Based on this, the type of ship is specified for each operation:

Failure

Loss of position, also known as runoff, can threaten safe operations and the environment, including possible loss of life, injury, damage to property or the environment, and loss of reputation and time. Incident records indicate that even vessels with redundant dynamic positioning systems experience occasional loss of position, which may result from human error, procedural failures, dynamic positioning system failures, or poor design.

Dynamic positioning failure results in an inability to maintain position or heading control and can cause a drift-off due to insufficient thrust or a drive-off due to inappropriate thrust.

Dynamic positioning alarm and runout response for bell divers

The basic response with a closed bell is similar to that with a wet bell, but after stowing the umbilicals, the hatch will be sealed to retain internal pressure. The bell will be recovered as rapidly as possible in a red alert, and may be recovered if there is doubt that a yellow alert will be downgraded.

Redundancy

Redundancy is the ability to withstand, while in DP mode, the loss of equipment that is online, without losing position or heading. A single failure can be, amongst others:

For certain operations, redundancy is not required. For instance, if a survey ship loses its DP capability, there is normally no risk of damage or injury. These operations will normally be done in Class 1.

For other operations, such as diving and heavy lifting, there is a risk of damage or injury. Depending on the risk, the operation is done in Class 2 or 3. This means at least three Position reference systems should be selected. This allows the voting logic to be applied, enabling the failing PRS to be found. For this reason, there are also three DP control computers, three gyrocompasses, three MRU's, and three wind sensors on Class 3 ships. If a single fault occurs that jeopardizes the redundancy, i.e., the failure of a thruster, generator, or PRS, and this cannot be resolved immediately, the operation should be abandoned as quickly as possible.

To have sufficient redundancy, enough generators and thrusters should be online so that the failure of one does not result in a loss of position. This is left to the judgment of the DP operator. For Classes 2 and 3, a Consequence Analysis should be incorporated into the system to assist the DPO in this process.

The redundancy of a DP ship should be judged by a failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA) study and proved by FMEA trials. Besides that, annual trials are done. Normally, DP function tests are completed before each project.

DP operator

The DP operator (DPO) assesses whether sufficient redundancy is available at any given moment during the operation. IMO issued MSC/Circ.738 (Guidelines for dynamic positioning system (DP) operator training) on 24-06-1996. This refers to IMCA (International Marine Contractors Association) M 117 as an acceptable standard.

To qualify as a DP operator, the following path should be followed:

  1. a DP Induction course + Online Examination
  2. a minimum of 60 days seagoing DP familiarisation
  3. a DP Advanced course + Online Examination
  4. a minimum of 60 days watchkeeping on a DP ship
  5. a statement of suitability by the master of a DP ship

When the watchkeeping is done on a Class 1 DP ship, a limited certificate will be issued; otherwise, a full certificate will be issued.

The DP training and certification scheme is operated by The Nautical Institute (NI). The NI issues logbooks to trainees, accredits training centers, and controls certification issuance.

With ever more DP ships and rising workforce demands, the DPO role is gaining prominence. This shifting landscape led to the creation of The International Dynamic Positioning Operators Association (IDPOA) in 2009.

IDPOA membership comprises certified DPOs who qualify for fellowship (fDPO), while members (mDPO) are those with DP experience or who may already be working within the DP certification scheme.

International Marine Contractors Association

The International Marine Contractors Association was formed in April 1995 from the amalgamation of the Dynamic Positioning Vessel Owners Association, founded in 1990, and the International Association of Offshore Diving Contractors, founded in 1972.

While it started with the collection and analysis of DP Incidents, since then, it has produced publications on different subjects to improve standards for DP systems. It also works with IMO and other regulatory bodies.

Marine Technology Society Dynamic Positioning Committee

The Marine Technology Society Dynamic Positioning (DP) Committee's mission is to facilitate incident-free DP operations. This committee of volunteers contributes to the DP community of vessel owners, operators, Marine Class Societies, engineers, and regulators through an annual DP Conference, topical workshops, and an extensive set of Guidance Documents covering DP Design Philosophy, DP Operations, and Professional Development of DP Personnel. In addition, a growing set of unique documents, collectively called TECHOP, addresses specific topics of significant interest and impact. Conference papers are available for public download, providing a source of DP industry technical papers.

The DP Guidance documents published by the MTS DP Committee are designed to share knowledge, methods, and unique tools to help the DP community achieve incident-free DP operations.

See also

References

  1. ↑ "What is dynamic positioning?". The Nautical Institute. Archived from the original on 2013-01-25. Retrieved 2013-01-24.
  2. 1 2 Introduction to Dynamic Positioning Archived 2010-06-26 at the Wayback Machine
  3. ↑ Wolden, Grete (February 2017). "Forskning: Dynamisk Posisjonering for Arktis: Systemet skal muliggjøre kompliserte operasjoner i is og ekstremvær". Teknisk Ukeblad. Retrieved 2 February 2017.
  4. ↑ "Advertisement from Mercury Marine" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2015-05-22. Retrieved 2015-05-22.
  5. ↑ "IMCA M 141, Guidelines on the Use of DGPS as a Position Reference in DP Control Systems". London: International Marine Contractors Association. October 1997.
  6. ↑ "Veripos DP system can be installed with several Augmentation systems as well as GLONASS support, they can disable any satellite or service via Ultra corrections received via Spotbeam or Inmarsat links".{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: deprecated archival service (link)
  7. ↑ "IMCA M 151, The Basic Principles and Use of Hydroacoustic Position Reference Systems in the Offshore Environment". London: International Marine Contractors Association.
  8. ↑ "IMCA M 174, A Review of the Artemis Mk V Positioning System". London: International Marine Contractors Association.
  9. ↑ "RADius relative positioning system". Konsberg Gruppen. 15 August 2011.
  10. ↑ Stensvold, Tore (2016-10-11). "Første i verden: Her skal batterier erstatte motor i kritiske situasjoner". Teknisk Ukeblad. Teknisk Ukeblad Media AS. Retrieved 11 October 2016.
  11. ↑ Stensvold, Tore (14 March 2018). "Et av verdens mest avanserte skip er bygget om: Sparer 30 prosent drivstoff med batteri". Tu.no (in Norwegian). Teknisk Ukeblad. Retrieved 31 March 2019.
  12. ↑ "The Motorship | Giant battery boost for North Sea Shipping". www.motorship.com. Retrieved 31 March 2019.
  13. ↑ Førde, Thomas (31 May 2019). "Dette fartøyet sparer penger og kutter CO2 med avansert batterisystem". Tu.no (in Norwegian). Teknisk Ukeblad.
  14. ↑ "IMO MSC/Circ.645, Guidelines for vessels with dynamic positioning systems" (PDF). 6 June 1994. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2007-06-10.
  15. 1 2 3 Castro, Alexander (13–14 October 2015). DP Emergency Drills (PDF). Dynamic Positioning Conference. Houston: Marine Technology Society.
  16. ↑ CADC Admin (31 October 2012). "Dynamically Positioned Vessel Run-off / Severance of Bell Diver's Umbilical". Canadian Association of Diving Contractors. Retrieved 29 November 2018.
  17. 1 2 Guidance for diving supervisors IMCA D 022, chpt. 11 Surface supplied air diving, sect. 8 Emergency and contingency plans
  18. ↑ Guidance for diving supervisors IMCA D 022, chpt. 13 Closed bell diving, sect. 10 Emergency and contingency plans
  19. ↑ "IMCA M 166, Guidelines on Failure Modes & Effects Analyses (FMEAs)". London: International Marine Contractors Association.
  20. ↑ "IMCA M 117, The training and experience of key DP personnel". London: International Marine Contractors Association.
  21. ↑ "Dynamiv positioning - A brief IMCA History" (PDF). London: International Marine Contractors Association. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2006-03-11.
  22. ↑ "IMCA M 181, Analysis of Station Keeping Incident Data 1994-2003". London: International Marine Contractors Association.
  23. ↑ "Home - Dynamic Positioning".

Sources