Ever After The Musical

Ever After
MusicZina Goldrich
LyricsMarcy Heisler
BookMarcy Heisler
BasisEver After
by Andy Tennant
PremiereMay 21, 2015
Productions2015 Paper Mill Playhouse
2019 Alliance Theatre
2026 The Phoenix Theatre Company

Ever After is a 2015 musical, with book and lyrics by Marcy Heisler and music by Zina Goldrich, based on the 1998 film of the same name written by Susannah Grant, Andy Tennant, and Rick Parks, whose source material is the fairy tale Cinderella. The musical premiered at the Paper Mill Playhouse in May 2015.

Background

A report in 2012 indicated that a musical theatre production was in the works, with the book and lyrics by Marcy Heisler and music by Zina Goldrich. There was a reading of the musical in 2007 in New York City, starring Elena Shaddow as Danielle and Max von Essen as Prince Henry and directed by Doug Hughes. The musical's subtitle at that time was A Cinderella Story. The musical was originally scheduled for its world premiere in April 2009 at the Curran Theatre in San Francisco, but the pre-Broadway run was postponed. In May 2012, the project was back on track with Kathleen Marshall directing a Broadway run.

A workshop of the musical was held from April 25, 2013 to May 15, 2013 with Sierra Boggess as Danielle, Jeremy Jordan as Prince Henry, and Ashley Spencer as Marguerite. The musical made its world premiere at the Paper Mill Playhouse from May 21, 2015 – June 21, 2015. Christine Ebersole played the role of Baroness Rodmilla de Ghent. Alongside Ebersole, Margo Seibert starred as Danielle, James Snyder as Henry, Charles Shaughnessy as King Francis, and Tony Sheldon as Da Vinci. Another production of the musical began playing at Atlanta's Alliance Theatre beginning January 2019. In August 2025, a new workshop of the musical was held in New York with McKenzie Kurtz as Danielle, Derek Klena as Prince Henry, Lisa Howard as Rodmilla, David Garrison as Leonardo Da Vinci / Auguste, David Beach as King Francis, Ann Sanders as Queen Marie / Grande Dame, Lizzy Tucker as Marguerite, Andrea Macasaet as Jacqueline, Nathan Salstone as Gustave, and Dan Rosales as Laurent.

In May 2026, a new production premiered at The Phoenix Theatre Company. The production runs from May 6 - June 14, 2026. This fully staged production stars Bailee Endebrock as Danielle, Jason Gotay as Prince Henry, David Garrison as Leonardo DaVinci, Lisa Howard as Rodmilla de Ghent, and Andrea Mascasaet as Jacqueline.

Productions

Paper Mill Playhouse (2015)

The musical premiered at the Paper Mill Playhouse on May 21, 2015, for a limited engagement until June 21, 2015. The production was directed and choreographed by Kathleen Marshall. The production's design team included scenery by Derek McLane, costumes by Jess Goldstein, lighting by Peter Kaczorowski, sound by Nevin Steinberg, and projections by Olivia Sebesky and Derek McLane. John Kenrick reviews this production: "It is a joy to report that Ever After has been deftly adapted into a musical that boasts delightful music, unusually witty lyrics, and enough human magic to make for a wonderful evening's entertainment."

Alliance Theatre (2019)

The musical premiered at the Alliance Theatre in Atlanta, Georgia, on January 15, 2019, for a limited engagement until February 17, 2019. The production was directed by Susan V. Booth and choreographed by JoAnn M. Hunter. The design team included scenery by Anna Louizos, costumes by Linda Cho, lighting by Robert Wierzel, and projections by Sven Ortel.

Ordway Theatre (2019)

The musical was expected to run at the Ordway Center for the Performing Arts in Saint Paul, Minnesota from December 3 to 29, 2019. However, following this announcement the musical was replaced on the schedule by SIX the Musical, which played at the Ordway for a limited engagement from November 29 to December 22, 2019 before its Broadway debut.

Ordway Concert Hall (2023)

The musical was performed at the Ordway Center for the Performing Arts in a concert staging starring Erika Henningsen, Heidi Blickenstaff, David Garrison and Jason Gotay. The production was directed by Marlo Hunter.

The Phoenix Theatre Company (2026)

The musical is currently performing at The Phoenix Theatre Company from May 5 - June 14, 2026. This fully staged production stars Bailee Endebrock, Jason Gotay, David Garrison, and Lisa Howard. This production is directed by Marlo Hunter.

Characters and original cast

Character Industry Reading
(2007)
Industry Reading
(2013)
Paper Mill Playhouse
(2015)
Alliance Theatre
(2019)
The Phoenix Theatre Company

(2026)

Danielle de Barbarac Elena Shaddow Sierra Boggess Margo Seibert Sierra Boggess Bailee Endebrock
Prince Henry Max von Essen Jeremy Jordan James Snyder Tim Rogan Jason Gotay
Baroness Rodmilla de Ghent Jan Maxwell Christine Ebersole Rachel York Lisa Howard
King Francis of France Ron Holgate Terrence Mann Charles Shaughnessy Chris Kayser D. Scott Withers
Queen Marie of France Mary Beth Peil Kate Burton Julie Halston Terry Burrell Kate Cook
Marguerite de Ghent Brynn O'Malley Ashley Spencer Mara Davi Jenny Ashman Grace Rogers
Jacqueline de Ghent Emily Walton Gwen Hollander Annie Funke Rachel Flynn Andrea Macasaet
Leonardo da Vinci Tim Jerome Tony Sheldon David Garrison
Auguste de Barbarac / Spanish King - Byron Jennings Fred Inkley Corey James Wright Jesse Sharp
Captain Laurent Jonathan Root Jose Llana Charl Brown Todd Buonopane Teddy Ladley
Pierre Malette - John Hillner Jeff McCarthy -
Gustave Jonathan Rayson F. Michael Haynie Andrew Keenan-Bolger Justin Keyes Luke Kolbe Mannikus
Maurice - Nick Corley Jimmy Kieffer -
Louise - Liz McCartney Rhyn Saver -
Young Danielle / Little Girl - Sadie Sink Isabella Burke Bella Yantis Parker Pitt / Audra South
Paulette / Spanish Princess - Jill Abramovitz - Sonia Roman
Flanek - Sean Martin Hingston -
Cargo Master - Will Mann -
Marquis / Spanish Lover - Jonathan Shew -
Spanish Queen - Aléna Watters -
Sophie - Wendi Bergamini -
Le Pieu Stephen Bogardus -
Grand Dame - Jane Bunting
Dimitri - Michael Kuhn
Wilhelm Grimm - Alexander Mendoza
Jacob Grimm - Alexandro Partida

Musical numbers

Paper Mill Playhouse

Alliance Theatre

The Phoenix Theatre Company