Griffiths inequality

In statistical mechanics, the Griffiths inequality, sometimes also called Griffiths–Kelly–Sherman inequality or GKS inequality, named after Robert B. Griffiths, is a correlation inequality for ferromagnetic spin systems. Informally, it says that in ferromagnetic spin systems, if the 'a-priori distribution' of the spin is invariant under spin flipping, the correlation of any monomial of the spins is non-negative; and the two point correlation of two monomial of the spins is non-negative.

The inequality was proved by Griffiths for Ising ferromagnets with two-body interactions, then generalised by Kelly and Sherman to interactions involving an arbitrary number of spins, and then by Griffiths to systems with arbitrary spins. A more general formulation was given by Ginibre, and is now called the Ginibre inequality.

Definitions

Let $σ = {σ_{j}}_{j \in Λ}$ be a configuration of (continuous or discrete) spins on a lattice $Λ$ . If $A \subset Λ$ is a list of lattice sites, possibly with duplicates, let $σ_{A} = \prod_{j \in A} σ_{j}$ be the product of the spins in $A$ .

Assign an a-priori measure $d μ (σ)$ on the spins; let $H$ be an energy functional of the form

H (σ) = - \sum_{A} J_{A} σ_{A},

where the sum is over lists of sites $A$ , and let

Z = \int d μ (σ) e^{- H (σ)}

be the partition function. As usual,

⟨ f ⟩ = \frac{1}{Z} \int d μ (σ) f (σ) e^{- H (σ)}

stands for the ensemble average.

The system is called ferromagnetic if, for any list of sites $A$ , $J_{A} \geq 0$ . The system is called invariant under spin flipping if, for any $j$ in $Λ$ , the measure $μ$ is preserved under the sign flipping map $σ \to τ$ , where

τ_{k} = {\begin{matrix} σ_{k}, & k \neq j, \\ - σ_{k}, & k = j . \end{matrix}

Statement of inequalities

First Griffiths inequality

In a ferromagnetic spin system which is invariant under spin flipping,

⟨ σ_{A} ⟩ \geq 0

for any list of spins A.

Second Griffiths inequality

In a ferromagnetic spin system which is invariant under spin flipping,

⟨ σ_{A} σ_{B} ⟩ \geq ⟨ σ_{A} ⟩ ⟨ σ_{B} ⟩

for any lists of spins A and B.

The first inequality is a special case of the second one, corresponding to B = $\emptyset$ .

Proof

Observe that the partition function is non-negative by definition.

Proof of first inequality: Expand

e^{- H (σ)} = \prod_{B} \sum_{k \geq 0} \frac{J_{B}^{k} σ_{B}^{k}}{k!} = \sum_{{k_{C}}_{C}} \prod_{B} \frac{J_{B}^{k_{B}} σ_{B}^{k_{B}}}{k_{B}!},

then

\begin{matrix} Z ⟨ σ_{A} ⟩ & = \int d μ (σ) σ_{A} e^{- H (σ)} = \sum_{{k_{C}}_{C}} \prod_{B} \frac{J_{B}^{k_{B}}}{k_{B}!} \int d μ (σ) σ_{A} σ_{B}^{k_{B}} \\ = \sum_{{k_{C}}_{C}} \prod_{B} \frac{J_{B}^{k_{B}}}{k_{B}!} \int d μ (σ) \prod_{j \in Λ} σ_{j}^{n_{A} (j) + k_{B} n_{B} (j)}, \end{matrix}

where n_A(j) stands for the number of times that j appears in A. Now, by invariance under spin flipping,

\int d μ (σ) \prod_{j} σ_{j}^{n (j)} = 0

if at least one n(j) is odd, and the same expression is obviously non-negative for even values of n. Therefore, $Z ⟨ σ_{A} ⟩ \geq 0$ , hence also $⟨ σ_{A} ⟩ \geq 0$ .

Proof of second inequality. For the second Griffiths inequality, double the random variable, i.e. consider a second copy of the spin, $σ^{'}$ , with the same distribution of $σ$ . Then

⟨ σ_{A} σ_{B} ⟩ - ⟨ σ_{A} ⟩ ⟨ σ_{B} ⟩ = ⟨ ⟨ σ_{A} (σ_{B} - σ'_{B}) ⟩ ⟩ .

Introduce the new variables

σ_{j} = τ_{j} + {τ_{j}}^{'}, σ'_{j} = τ_{j} - {τ_{j}}^{'} .

The doubled system $⟨ ⟨ \cdot ⟩ ⟩$ is ferromagnetic in $τ, τ^{'}$ because $- H (σ) - H (σ^{'})$ is a polynomial in $τ, τ^{'}$ with positive coefficients

\begin{matrix} \sum_{A} J_{A} (σ_{A} + σ'_{A}) & = \sum_{A} J_{A} \sum_{X \subset A} [1 + (- 1)^{| X |}] τ_{A ∖ X} τ'_{X} \end{matrix}

Besides the measure on $τ, τ^{'}$ is invariant under spin flipping because $d μ (σ) d μ (σ^{'})$ is. Finally the monomials $σ_{A}$ , $σ_{B} - σ'_{B}$ are polynomials in $τ, τ^{'}$ with positive coefficients

\begin{matrix} σ_{A} & = \sum_{X \subset A} τ_{A ∖ X} τ'_{X}, \\ σ_{B} - σ'_{B} & = \sum_{X \subset B} [1 - (- 1)^{| X |}] τ_{B ∖ X} τ'_{X} . \end{matrix}

The first Griffiths inequality applied to $⟨ ⟨ σ_{A} (σ_{B} - σ'_{B}) ⟩ ⟩$ gives the result.

More details are in and.

Extension: Ginibre inequality

The Ginibre inequality is an extension, found by Jean Ginibre, of the Griffiths inequality.

Formulation

Let (Γ, μ) be a probability space. For functions f, h on Γ, denote

⟨ f ⟩_{h} = \int f (x) e^{- h (x)} d μ (x) / \int e^{- h (x)} d μ (x) .

Let A be a set of real functions on Γ such that. for every f₁,f₂,...,f_n in A, and for any choice of signs ±,

\iint d μ (x) d μ (y) \prod_{j = 1}^{n} (f_{j} (x) \pm f_{j} (y)) \geq 0.

Then, for any f,g,−h in the convex cone generated by A,

⟨ f g ⟩_{h} - ⟨ f ⟩_{h} ⟨ g ⟩_{h} \geq 0.

Proof

Let

Z_{h} = \int e^{- h (x)} d μ (x) .

Then

\begin{matrix} Z_{h}^{2} (⟨ f g ⟩_{h} - ⟨ f ⟩_{h} ⟨ g ⟩_{h}) \\ = \iint d μ (x) d μ (y) f (x) (g (x) - g (y)) e^{- h (x) - h (y)} \\ = \sum_{k = 0}^{\infty} \iint d μ (x) d μ (y) f (x) (g (x) - g (y)) \frac{(- h (x) - h (y))^{k}}{k!} . \end{matrix}

Now the inequality follows from the assumption and from the identity

f (x) = \frac{1}{2} (f (x) + f (y)) + \frac{1}{2} (f (x) - f (y)) .

Examples

To recover the (second) Griffiths inequality, take Γ = {−1, +1}^Λ, where Λ is a lattice, and let μ be a measure on Γ that is invariant under sign flipping. The cone A of polynomials with positive coefficients satisfies the assumptions of the Ginibre inequality.
(Γ, μ) is a commutative compact group with the Haar measure, A is the cone of real positive definite functions on Γ.
Γ is a totally ordered set, A is the cone of real positive non-decreasing functions on Γ. This yields Chebyshev's sum inequality. For extension to partially ordered sets, see FKG inequality.

Applications

The thermodynamic limit of the correlations of the ferromagnetic Ising model (with non-negative external field h and free boundary conditions) exists.

This is because increasing the volume is the same as switching on new couplings J_B for a certain subset B. By the second Griffiths inequality

\frac{\partial}{\partial J_{B}} ⟨ σ_{A} ⟩ = ⟨ σ_{A} σ_{B} ⟩ - ⟨ σ_{A} ⟩ ⟨ σ_{B} ⟩ \geq 0

Hence

⟨ σ_{A} ⟩

is monotonically increasing with the volume; then it converges since it is bounded by 1.

The one-dimensional, ferromagnetic Ising model with interactions $J_{x, y} \sim | x - y |^{- α}$ displays a phase transition if $1 < α < 2$ .

This property can be shown in a hierarchical approximation, that differs from the full model by the absence of some interactions: arguing as above with the second Griffiths inequality, the results carries over the full model.

The Ginibre inequality provides the existence of the thermodynamic limit for the free energy and spin correlations for the two-dimensional classical XY model. Besides, through Ginibre inequality, Kunz and Pfister proved the presence of a phase transition for the ferromagnetic XY model with interaction $J_{x, y} \sim | x - y |^{- α}$ if $2 < α < 4$ .
Aizenman and Simon used the Ginibre inequality to prove that the two point spin correlation of the ferromagnetic classical XY model in dimension $D$ , coupling $J > 0$ and inverse temperature $β$ is dominated by (i.e. has upper bound given by) the two point correlation of the ferromagnetic Ising model in dimension $D$ , coupling $J > 0$ , and inverse temperature $β / 2$

⟨ 𝐬_{i} \cdot 𝐬_{j} ⟩_{J, 2 β} \leq ⟨ σ_{i} σ_{j} ⟩_{J, β}

Hence the critical

β

of the XY model cannot be smaller than the double of the critical

β

of the Ising model

β_{c}^{X Y} \geq 2 β_{c}^{I s};

in dimension D = 2 and coupling J = 1, this gives

β_{c}^{X Y} \geq \ln (1 + \sqrt{2}) \approx 0.88 .

There exists a version of the Ginibre inequality for the Coulomb gas that implies the existence of thermodynamic limit of correlations.
Other applications (phase transitions in spin systems, XY model, XYZ quantum chain) are reviewed in.

References

↑ Griffiths, R.B. (1967). "Correlations in Ising Ferromagnets. I". J. Math. Phys. 8 (3): 478–483. Bibcode:1967JMP.....8..478G. doi:10.1063/1.1705219.
↑ Kelly, D.J.; Sherman, S. (1968). "General Griffiths' inequalities on correlations in Ising ferromagnets". J. Math. Phys. 9 (3): 466–484. Bibcode:1968JMP.....9..466K. doi:10.1063/1.1664600.
↑ Griffiths, R.B. (1969). "Rigorous Results for Ising Ferromagnets of Arbitrary Spin". J. Math. Phys. 10 (9): 1559–1565. Bibcode:1969JMP....10.1559G. doi:10.1063/1.1665005.
1 2 3 Ginibre, J. (1970). "General formulation of Griffiths' inequalities". Comm. Math. Phys. 16 (4): 310–328. Bibcode:1970CMaPh..16..310G. doi:10.1007/BF01646537. S2CID 120649586.
↑ Glimm, J.; Jaffe, A. (1987). Quantum Physics. A functional integral point of view. New York: Springer-Verlag. ISBN 0-387-96476-2.
↑ Friedli, S.; Velenik, Y. (2017). Statistical Mechanics of Lattice Systems: a Concrete Mathematical Introduction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9781107184824.
↑ Dyson, F.J. (1969). "Existence of a phase-transition in a one-dimensional Ising ferromagnet". Comm. Math. Phys. 12 (2): 91–107. Bibcode:1969CMaPh..12...91D. doi:10.1007/BF01645907. S2CID 122117175.
↑ Aizenman, M.; Simon, B. (1980). "A comparison of plane rotor and Ising models". Phys. Lett. A. 76 (3–4): 281–282. Bibcode:1980PhLA...76..281A. doi:10.1016/0375-9601(80)90493-4.
↑ Fröhlich, J.; Park, Y.M. (1978). "Correlation inequalities and the thermodynamic limit for classical and quantum continuous systems". Comm. Math. Phys. 59 (3): 235–266. Bibcode:1978CMaPh..59..235F. doi:10.1007/BF01611505. S2CID 119758048.
↑ Griffiths, R.B. (1972). "Rigorous results and theorems". In C. Domb and M.S.Green (ed.). Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena. Vol. 1. New York: Academic Press. p. 7.

[gr1-1] Griffiths, R.B. (1967). "Correlations in Ising Ferromagnets. I". J. Math. Phys. 8 (3): 478–483. Bibcode:1967JMP.....8..478G. doi:10.1063/1.1705219.

[ks-2] Kelly, D.J.; Sherman, S. (1968). "General Griffiths' inequalities on correlations in Ising ferromagnets". J. Math. Phys. 9 (3): 466–484. Bibcode:1968JMP.....9..466K. doi:10.1063/1.1664600.

[3] Griffiths, R.B. (1969). "Rigorous Results for Ising Ferromagnets of Arbitrary Spin". J. Math. Phys. 10 (9): 1559–1565. Bibcode:1969JMP....10.1559G. doi:10.1063/1.1665005.

[g-4] 1 2 3 Ginibre, J. (1970). "General formulation of Griffiths' inequalities". Comm. Math. Phys. 16 (4): 310–328. Bibcode:1970CMaPh..16..310G. doi:10.1007/BF01646537. S2CID 120649586.

[5] Glimm, J.; Jaffe, A. (1987). Quantum Physics. A functional integral point of view. New York: Springer-Verlag. ISBN 0-387-96476-2.

[6] Friedli, S.; Velenik, Y. (2017). Statistical Mechanics of Lattice Systems: a Concrete Mathematical Introduction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. ISBN 9781107184824.

[7] Dyson, F.J. (1969). "Existence of a phase-transition in a one-dimensional Ising ferromagnet". Comm. Math. Phys. 12 (2): 91–107. Bibcode:1969CMaPh..12...91D. doi:10.1007/BF01645907. S2CID 122117175.

[8] Aizenman, M.; Simon, B. (1980). "A comparison of plane rotor and Ising models". Phys. Lett. A. 76 (3–4): 281–282. Bibcode:1980PhLA...76..281A. doi:10.1016/0375-9601(80)90493-4.

[9] Fröhlich, J.; Park, Y.M. (1978). "Correlation inequalities and the thermodynamic limit for classical and quantum continuous systems". Comm. Math. Phys. 59 (3): 235–266. Bibcode:1978CMaPh..59..235F. doi:10.1007/BF01611505. S2CID 119758048.

[10] Griffiths, R.B. (1972). "Rigorous results and theorems". In C. Domb and M.S.Green (ed.). Phase Transitions and Critical Phenomena. Vol. 1. New York: Academic Press. p. 7.