Horror aequi

Horror aequi, also known as identity avoidance: 71  or avoidance of identity,: 100  is a linguistic principle that language users have psychological: 266  or physiological: 51  motives or limits on cognitive planning: 51  to avoid repetition of identical linguistic structures.

The term originated in 1909 in Karl Brugmann,: 219  who used it to explain dissimilation,: 266  the tendency for similar consonants or vowels in a word to become less similar,: 146  which can often be chalked up to simply "euphony".: 219  Today, however, the term is usually applied instead to grammatical elements or structures.: 219 

One of the most widely cited definitions: 39 : 71  is that of Günter Rohdenburg: "the horror aequi principle involves the widespread (and presumably universal) tendency to avoid the use of formally (near-)identical and (near-)adjacent (non-coordinate) grammatical elements or structures.": 205 

In the study of phonology, such avoidance falls under the obligatory contour principle,: 100  which holds that certain consecutive identical sounds are not permitted: 383–84  (such as in Mandarin Chinese, where two third tones are not used consecutively: 104 ).

The term horror aequi is sometimes extended to the stylistic preference to avoid repeating the same word in a given text, also known as elegant variation.

Horror aequi in English

One illustration of horror aequi in English is the use of and + verb rather than the typical to + verb following certain to-infinitive verbs such as wait, try and check in order to avoid repeating the to + verb pattern.: 236–42  Thus, speakers typically use:

But following a to-infinitive, speakers will often use and instead of to:: 236–42 

In addition to using and instead of to in order to avoid horror aequi, a strategy is to delay the second to + verb with intervening words.: 236  For example:

In some cases, the horror aequi principle is said to be responsible for stronger prescriptive rules, such as the ungrammatical use of verb + -ing followed by verb + -ing (gerund) where a to-infinitive in possible.: 39 

These pairs are grammatical:

However, when the first verb is in an -ing form, it is only grammatical to follow it with a to-infinitive. Thus, the latter of each pair is unacceptable:: 39 

Horror aequi does not influence verbs that may only be followed by an -ing verb.

Other examples clearly demonstrate how horror aequi helps prevent confusion. Sentences with repetitive words or forms can be nearly incomprehensible even when adhering to grammatical rules.: 101 

Confusion here comes from both the repeated embedded who relative clauses and from the lack of semantic variety. Merely adding semantic difference can add some clarity:: 101 

The horror aequi principle holds that both of these examples would be avoided.

See also