Insular dwarfism

Skeletons of the extinct Palaeoloxodon falconeri, native to Sicily and Malta, it is one of the smallest known species of dwarf elephant. Adult males measured about one meter (3.3 ft) in shoulder height and weighed about 250 kg (550 lb). Females were smaller.

Insular dwarfism, a form of phyletic dwarfism, is the process and condition of large animals evolving or having a reduced body size when their population's range is limited to a small environment, primarily islands. This natural process is distinct from the intentional creation of dwarf breeds, called dwarfing. This process has occurred many times throughout evolutionary history, with examples including various species of dwarf elephants that evolved during the Pleistocene epoch, as well as more ancient examples, such as the dinosaurs Europasaurus and Magyarosaurus. This process, and other "island genetics" artifacts, can occur not only on islands, but also in other situations where an ecosystem is isolated from external resources and breeding. This can include caves, desert oases, isolated valleys and isolated mountains ("sky islands").[citation needed]

Insular dwarfism is one aspect of the more general "island effect" or "Foster's rule", which posits that when mainland animals colonize islands, small species tend to evolve larger bodies (island gigantism), and large species tend to evolve smaller bodies. This is itself one aspect of island syndrome, which describes the differences in morphology, ecology, physiology and behaviour of insular species compared to their continental counterparts. Arguably the most famous case is that of the Shetland pony, an animal only half the height of its parent species, although this, through both artificial breeding and its presence on the Shetland Islands to begin with, may partially be the work of man.

Possible causes

A qualitative digram representing the interdynamics of possible factors that collectively produces insular dwarfism.

There are several proposed explanations for the mechanism which produces such dwarfism.

One is a selective process where only smaller animals trapped on the island survive, as food periodically declines to a borderline level. The smaller animals need fewer resources and smaller territories, and so are more likely to get past the break-point where population decline allows food sources to replenish enough for the survivors to flourish. Smaller size is also advantageous from a reproductive standpoint, as it entails shorter gestation periods and generation times.

In the tropics, small size should make thermoregulation easier.

Among herbivores, large size confers advantages in coping with both competitors and predators, so a reduction or absence of either would facilitate dwarfing; competition appears to be the more important factor.

Among carnivores, the main factor is thought to be the size and availability of prey resources, and competition is believed to be less important. In tiger snakes, insular dwarfism occurs on islands where available prey is restricted to smaller sizes than are normally taken by mainland snakes. Since prey size preference in snakes is generally proportional to body size, small snakes may be better adapted to take small prey.

Differences of dwarfism and gigantism

The inverse process, wherein small animals breeding on isolated islands lacking the predators of large land masses may become much larger than normal, is called island gigantism. An excellent example is the dodo, the ancestors of which were normal-sized pigeons. There are also several species of giant rats, one still extant, that coexisted with both Homo floresiensis and the dwarf stegodonts on Flores.

The process of insular dwarfing can occur relatively rapidly by evolutionary standards. This is in contrast to increases in maximum body size, which are much more gradual. When normalized to generation length, the maximum rate of body mass decrease during insular dwarfing was found to be over 30 times greater than the maximum rate of body mass increase for a ten-fold change in mammals. The disparity is thought to reflect the fact that pedomorphism offers a relatively easy route to evolve smaller adult body size; on the other hand, the evolution of larger maximum body size is likely to be interrupted by the emergence of a series of constraints that must be overcome by evolutionary innovations before the process can continue.

Factors influencing the extent of dwarfing

For both herbivores and carnivores, island size, the degree of island isolation and the size of the ancestral continental species appear not to be of major direct importance to the degree of dwarfing. However, when considering only the body masses of recent top herbivores and carnivores, and including data from both continental and island land masses, the body masses of the largest species in a land mass were found to scale to the size of the land mass, with slopes of about 0.5 log(body mass/kg) per log(land area/km2). There were separate regression lines for endothermic top predators, ectothermic top predators, endothermic top herbivores and (on the basis of limited data) ectothermic top herbivores, such that food intake was 7- to 24-fold higher for top herbivores than for top predators, and about the same for endotherms and ectotherms of the same trophic level (this leads to ectotherms being 5 to 16 times heavier than corresponding endotherms).

It has been suggested that for dwarf elephants, competition was an important factor in body size, with islands with competing herbivores having significantly larger dwarf elephants than those where competing herbivores were absent.

Examples

Non-avian dinosaurs

Recognition that insular dwarfism could apply to dinosaurs arose through the work of Ferenc Nopcsa, a Hungarian-born aristocrat, adventurer, scholar, and paleontologist. Nopcsa studied Transylvanian dinosaurs intensively, noticing that they were smaller than their cousins elsewhere in the world. For example, he unearthed six-meter-long sauropods, a group of dinosaurs which elsewhere commonly grew to 30 meters or more. Nopcsa deduced that the area where the remains were found was an island, Hațeg Island (now the Haţeg or Hatzeg basin in Romania) during the Mesozoic era. Nopcsa's proposal of dinosaur dwarfism on Hațeg Island is today widely accepted after further research confirmed that the remains found are not from juveniles.

Sauropods

Example Species Range Time frame Continental relative

Ampelosaurus
A. atacisIbero-Armorican IslandLate Cretaceous / Maastrichtian
Nemegtosaurids

Europasaurus
E. holgeriLower SaxonyLate Jurassic / Middle Kimmeridgian
Brachiosaurs

Magyarosaurus
M. dacusHațeg IslandLate Cretaceous / Maastrichtian
Rapetosaurus

Lirainosaurus
L. astibiaeIbero-Armorican IslandLate Cretaceous

Paludititan
P. nalatzensisHațeg IslandLate Cretaceous / Maastrichtian
Epachthosaurus

Other

Example Species Range Time frame Continental relative

Langenberg Quarry
torvosaur (blue)
UnnamedLower SaxonyLate Jurassic / Middle Kimmeridgian
Torvosaurus

Struthiosaurus
S. austriacusIbero-Armorican, Australoalpine, and Hațeg IslandsLate Cretaceous
Edmontonia
S. transylvanicus
S. languedocensis

Telmatosaurus
T. transsylvanicusHațeg Island
Hadrosaurids

Thecodontosaurus
T. antiquusSouthern EnglandLate Triassic / Rhaetian
Plateosaurs

Zalmoxes (purple)
Z. robustusHațeg IslandLate Cretaceous
Tenontosaurus
Z. shqiperorum

In addition, the genus Balaur was initially described as a Velociraptor-sized dromaeosaurid (and in consequence a dubious example of insular dwarfism), but has been since reclassified as a secondarily flightless stem bird, closer to modern birds than Jeholornis (thus actually an example of insular gigantism).

Birds

Example Binomial name Native range Status Continental relative Insular / mainland
length or mass ratio

Hawaiian flightless ibises
Apteribis glenosMolokaiExtinct (Late Quaternary)
American ibises
Apteribis brevisMaui
Cozumel curassowCrax rubra griscomiCozumelUnknown
Great curassow

Kangaroo Island emu
Dromaius novaehollandiae baudinianusKangaroo Island, South AustraliaExtinct (c. AD 1827)
Emu

King Island emu (black)
Dromaius novaehollandiae minorKing Island, TasmaniaExtinct (AD 1822)LR ≈ 0.48
Dwarf yellow eyed penguinMegadyptes antipodes richdaleiChatham Islands, New ZealandExtinct (after 1300 AD)
Yellow-eyed penguin

Cozumel thrasher
Toxostoma gluttatumCozumelCritically endangered
Other thrashers

Squamates

Example Binomial name Native range Status Continental relative Insular / mainland
length or mass ratio

Madagascar dwarf chameleon
Brookesia minimaNosy Be island, MadagascarEndangered
Madagascar leaf chameleons

Nosy Hara chameleon
Brookesia micraNosy Hara island, MadagascarVulnerable
Roxby Island tiger snakeNotechis scutatusRoxby Island, South AustraliaUnknown
Tiger snake
Dwarf Burmese python Python bivittatus progschaiJava, Bali, Sumbawa and Sulawesi, Indonesia
Burmese python
LR ≈ 0.44
Tanahjampea reticulated python Python reticulatus jampeanusTanahjampea, between Sulawesi and Flores
Reticulated python
LR ≈ 0.41, males
LR ≈ 0.49, females

Mammals

Pilosans

Example Binomial name Native range Status Continental relative

Pygmy three-toed sloth
Bradypus pygmaeusIsla Escudo de Veraguas, PanamaCritically endangered
Brown-throated sloth

Acratocnus
A. antillensisCuba, Hispaniola and Puerto RicoExtinct (c. 3000 BC)
Continental ground sloths
A. odontrigonus
A. ye
ImagocnusI. zazaeCubaExtinct (Early Miocene)

Megalocnus
M. rodensCuba and HispaniolaExtinct (c. 2700 BC)
M. zile

Neocnus
Neocnus spp.Extinct (c. 3000 BC)

Proboscideans

Example Binomial name Native range Status Continental relative
Sulawesi dwarf elephantElephas celebensisSulawesiExtinct (Early Pleistocene)
Asian elephant
Cabarruyan dwarf elephantElephas beyeriLuzonExtinct
Cretan dwarf mammothMammuthus creticusCrete
Mammuthus

Channel Islands mammoth
Mammuthus exilisSanta Rosae islandExtinct (Late Pleistocene)
Columbian mammoth

Sardinian mammoth

Mammuthus lamarmoraiSardinia
Steppe mammoth
Taiwan mammothMammuthus trogontherii taiwanicusTaiwanExtinct
Saint Paul Island woolly mammothMammuthus primigeniusSaint Paul Island, AlaskaExtinct (c. 3750 BC)
Woolly mammoth

Siculo-Maltese elephants
Palaeoloxodon antiquus leonardiSicily and MaltaExtinct
Straight-tusked elephant
(left)
P. mnaidriensis
P. melitensis
P. falconeri
Cretan elephantsP. creutzburgiCrete

Cyprus dwarf elephant
Palaeoloxodon cypriotesCyprusExtinct (c. 9000 BC)
Naxos dwarf elephantPalaeoloxodon sp.NaxosExtinct
Tilos dwarf elephantPalaeoloxodon tiliensisTilos
Rhodes dwarf elephant Palaeoloxodon sp. Rhodes
Bumiayu dwarf sinomastodontSinomastodon bumiajuensisBumiayu Island (now part of Java)Extinct (Early Pleistocene)
Sinomastodon

Japanese stegodont
Stegodon miensisJapan (Also Taiwan for S. aurorae)
Chinese Stegodon
Stegodon protoaurorae
Stegodon aurorae
Greater Flores dwarf stegodontStegodon florensisFloresExtinct (Late Pleistocene)
Sundaland Stegodon
Javan dwarf stegodontsStegodon hypsilophusJavaExtinct (Quaternary)
S. semedoensis
S. sp.
Mindanao pygmy stegodontStegodon mindanensisMindanao and SulawesiExtinct (Middle Pleistocene)
Sulawesi dwarf stegodontStegodon sompoensisSulawesiExtinct
Lesser Flores dwarf stegodontStegodon sondaariFloresExtinct (Middle Pleistocene)
Sumba dwarf stegodontStegodon sumbaensisSumba, Indonesia
Timor dwarf stegodontStegodon timorensisTimorExtinct
Dwarf stegolophodontStegolophodon pseudolatidensJapanExtinct (Miocene)
Stegolophodon

Primates

Example Binomial name Native range Status Continental relative
Nosy Hara dwarf lemurCheirogaleus sp.Nosy Hara island off MadagascarUnknown
Dwarf lemurs

Flores Man
Homo floresiensisFloresExtinct (Late Pleistocene)
Homo erectus

Callao Man
Homo luzonensisLuzon, Philippines
Modern pygmies of FloresHomo sapiensFloresExtantother members of Homo sapiens
Early Palau modern humans (disputed)PalauExtinct (?)
AndamaneseAndaman IslandsExtant

Sardinian macaque
Macaca majoriSardiniaExtinct (Pleistocene)
Barbary macaque

Zanzibar red colobus
Piliocolobus kirkiiUngujaEndangered
Udzungwa red colobus

Carnivorans

Example Binomial name Native range Status Continental relative Insular / mainland
length or mass ratio

Sicilian wolf
Canis lupus cristaldiiSicilyExtinct (AD 1970)
Gray wolf

Japanese wolf
Canis lupus hodophilaxJapan (excluding Hokkaido)Extinct (AD 1905)

Sardinian dhole
(forward)
Cynotherium sardousCorsica and SardiniaExtinct (c. 8300 BC)
Xenocyon
Trinil dogMececyon trinilensisJavaExtinct (Pleistocene)
Cozumel coatiNasua narica nelsoniCozumelCritically endangered
Yucatan white-nosed coati

Zanzibar leopard
Panthera pardus pardusUngujaCritically endangered or Extinct
African leopard
Taiwan leopard Panthera pardusTaiwanExtinct (Pleistocene)
Amur leopard

Bali tiger
Panthera tigris sondaicaBaliExtinct (c. AD 1940)
Sumatran tiger

Javan tiger
JavaExtinct (c. AD 1975)

Cozumel raccoon
Procyon pygmaeusCozumelCritically endangered
Raccoon

Island fox
Urocyon littoralisSix of the Channel Islands of CaliforniaNear Threatened
Gray fox
LR ≈ 0.84
LR ≈ 0.75
Cozumel foxUrocyon sp.CozumelCritically endangered or Extinct

Non-ruminant ungulates

Example Binomial name Native range Status Continental relative

Eumaiochoerus
Eumaiochoerus etruscusBaccinello, MontebamboliExtinct (Miocene)
Microstonyx

Malagasy dwarf hippopotamuses
Hippopotamus laloumenaMadagascarExtinct (c. AD 1000)
Hippopotamus
H. lemerlei
H. madagascariensis
Bumiayu dwarf hippopotamusHexaprotodon simplexBumiayu Island (now Java)Extinct (Early Pleistocene)
Asian hippopotamuses

Cretan dwarf hippopotamus
Hippopotamus creutzburgiCreteExtinct (Middle Pleistocene)
Hippopotamus antiquus

Maltese dwarf hippopotamus
Hippopotamus melitensisMaltaExtinct (Pleistocene)
Hippopotamus (H. amphibius)

Sicilian dwarf hippopotamus
Hippopotamus pentlandiSicily

Cypriot pygmy hippopotamus
Hippopotamus minorCyprusExtinct (c. 8000 BC) Unclear, either H. amphibius or H. antiquus.
Cozumel collared peccaryPecari tajacu nanusCozumelUnknown
Collared peccary

Bovids

Example Binomial name Native range Status Continental relative
Sicilian bisonBison priscus siciliaeSicilyExtinct (Late Pleistocene)
Steppe bison
Sicilian aurochsBos primigenius siciliae
Eurasian aurochs
Cebu tamarawBubalus cebuensisCebu, PhilippinesExtinct
Wild water buffalo

Lowland anoa
Bubalus depressicornisSulawesi and Buton, IndonesiaEndangered
Bubalus grovesiBubalus grovesiSulawesi, IndonesiaExtinct

Tamaraw
Bubalus mindorensisMindoro, PhilippinesCritically endangered

Mountain anoa
Bubalus quarlesiSulawesi and Buton, IndonesiaEndangered

Balearic Islands cave goat
Myotragus balearicusMallorca and MenorcaExtinct (after 3000 BC)Gallogoral
NesogoralNesogoral spp.SardiniaExtinct
Dahlak Kebir gazelleNanger soemmerringi ssp.Dahlak Kebir island, EritreaVulnerable
Soemmerring's gazelle

Tyrrhenotragus
Tyrrhenotragus gracillimusBaccinelloExtinctAntilopinae sp.

Cervids and relatives

Example Binomial name Native range Status Continental relative

Cretan deer
Candiacervus spp.CreteExtinct (Pleistocene)Unknown

Sardinian deer
Praemegaceros caziotiSardiniaExtinct (c. 5500 BC) Praemegaceros

Ryukyu dwarf deer
Cervus astylodonRyukyu IslandsExtinct
Sika deer (?)
Cervus praenipponicus (?)
Jersey red deer populationCervus elaphus jerseyensisJerseyExtinct (Pleistocene)
Red deer

Corsican red deer
Cervus elaphus corsicanusCorsica and SardiniaNear Threatened
Sicilian red deerCervus siciliaeSicilyExtinct (Late Pleistocene)

Hoplitomeryx
Hoplitomeryx spp.Gargano IslandExtinct (Early Pliocene)
Pecorans
Sicilian fallow deerDama carburangelensisSicilyExtinct (Late Pleistocene)Fallow deer

Florida Key deer
Odocoileus virginianus claviumFlorida KeysEndangered
White-tailed deer

Svalbard reindeer
Rangifer tarandus platyrhynchusSvalbardVulnerable
Reindeer

Philippine deer
Rusa mariannaPhilippines
Sambar deer

Plants

Possible example Binomial name Native range Status Continental relative

Insular elephant cacti
Pachycereus pringleiRemote islands in the Sea of Cortez (e.g. Santa Cruz, San Pedro Mártir)Not evaluated
Mainland elephant cacti

See also