Career
Rio Grande Valley FC Toros
During August 2021, Garcia Jr. signed with USL Championship club Rio Grande Valley FC Toros, after having played for several years in the clubs academy. He made his professional debut on June 12, 2022, appearing as a starter in a 2–2 draw with Oakland Roots. A week later, on June 18, 2022, Garcia recorded his first clean sheet, leading RGVFC to a 1-0 victory over Pittsburgh Riverhounds SC.
El Paso Locomotive FC
On January 6, 2023, Garcia Jr. signed with USL Championship club El Paso Locomotive FC. He made his debut for the club on April 5, 2023, appearing as a starter in a 2-0 loss to Union Omaha in the Lamar Hunt U.S. Open Cup. He would re-sign with the club on November 15, 2023 and serve as the club backup goalkeeper. He would leave El Paso after the 2024 season, having appeared in 3 matches.
Texoma FC
On February 6, 2025, Garcia Jr. signed with USL League One club Texoma FC. Garcia Jr established himself a s a starter for the Texas side, being named USL League One Player of the Month for May 2025. During his three matches during the month which included a draw against AV Alta FC and victories against Union Omaha and Greenville Triumph SC he posted two clean sheets and 12 saves. He appeared in 24 league matches during the campaign and became the leagues all-time leader in penalty saves, having saved 6 pks.
AC Boise
On January 13, 2026, Garcia Jr. signed with USL League One side Athletic Club Boise. Garcia Jr. began the season as the clubs back-up goalkeeper. Being known for his prowess at stopping penalty kicks, he made his debut for the club on April 28, 2026, coming on as a last minute substitute in a USL Cup match against Las Vegas Lights FC. With the match tied at 1-1 it went into a penalty shootout, where Garcia made two decisive saves to give AC Boise the victory.
New York Cosmos
On May 6, 2026, with the New York Cosmos in need of stability at the goalkeeper position, Garcia Jr. was acquired from Athletic Club Boise. On May 15, 2026, Garcia made his debut for Cosmos, appearing as a starter in 3-2 comeback victory over Westchester SC in a USL Cup match. On July 8, 2026 recorded his first clean sheet of the season in 1-0 victory over FC Naples.
