| 9 Wins (5 knockouts, 4 decisions), 8 Losses (3 knockouts, 5 decisions), 2 Draws |
| Result |
Record |
Opponent |
Type |
Round |
Date |
Location |
Notes |
| Loss |
25-4 |
Pedro Agosto |
KO |
2 |
14/06/1973 |
Roberto Clemente Coliseum, San Juan, Puerto Rico |
|
| Loss |
3-0-1 |
Donnie Ray Sherman |
PTS |
6 |
20/05/1968 |
Philadelphia Arena, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania |
|
| Loss |
-- |
Walter Sterling |
KO |
2 |
10/01/1968 |
Oakland Auditorium Arena, Oakland, California |
|
| Loss |
14-4-2 |
Greatest Crawford |
PTS |
6 |
10/07/1964 |
Madison Square Garden, New York City |
|
| Draw |
14-8-2 |
David E. Bailey |
PTS |
6 |
26/03/1963 |
Allentown, Pennsylvania |
|
| Loss |
23-10-1 |
Alex Miteff |
KO |
3 |
31/08/1961 |
Olympic Auditorium, Los Angeles, California |
McCarter knocked out at 1:48 of the third round. |
| Win |
7-3-2 |
Dave Furch |
UD |
10 |
22/06/1961 |
Olympic Auditorium, Los Angeles, California |
8-5, 5-3, 9-4. |
| Win |
14-6-2 |
Floyd Joyner |
SD |
10 |
20/04/1961 |
Olympic Auditorium, Los Angeles, California |
5-4, 8-4, 5-6. |
| Loss |
42-23-7 |
Willi Besmanoff |
UD |
10 |
18/10/1960 |
Seattle Civic Auditorium, Seattle, Washington |
|
| Loss |
6-10-4 |
Otis Fuller |
UD |
10 |
14/06/1960 |
Olympic Auditorium, Los Angeles, California |
93-97, 93-95, 91-96. |
| Draw |
6-10-3 |
Otis Fuller |
PTS |
10 |
03/05/1960 |
Olympic Auditorium, Los Angeles, California |
95-95, 93-95, 97-96. |
| Win |
3-3-1 |
Eddie Jackson |
RTD |
5 |
12/04/1960 |
Olympic Auditorium, Los Angeles, California |
|
| Win |
15-12-6 |
Yancy D Smith |
TKO |
1 |
01/03/1960 |
Olympic Auditorium, Los Angeles, California |
Referee stopped the bout at 2:44 of the first round. |
| Win |
14-9-1 |
Duke Sabedong |
MD |
10 |
26/01/1960 |
Olympic Auditorium, Los Angeles, California |
95-95, 98-94, 97-94. |
| Win |
6-10-1 |
Anthony Emanuel |
KO |
2 |
22/12/1959 |
Olympic Auditorium, Los Angeles, California |
|
| Loss |
7-7-2 |
Jack Jarrod |
SD |
6 |
14/11/1959 |
Olympic Auditorium, Los Angeles, California |
|
| Win |
2-6-1 |
Andy Isaacs |
PTS |
4 |
10/10/1959 |
Olympic Auditorium, Los Angeles, California |
|
| Win |
2-3 |
Herbert Hair |
KO |
3 |
29/05/1959 |
Legion Stadium, Hollywood, California |
|
| Win |
0-1-1 |
Bob Mumford |
KO |
4 |
16/04/1959 |
Olympic Auditorium, Los Angeles, California |
|