Kem Kem Group

Kem Kem Group
Stratigraphic range: Cenomanian
~100–94 Ma
TypeGeological group
Sub-unitsDouira Formation, Gara Sbaa Formation
UnderliesCenomanian-Turonian limestone platform (Akrabou Formation)
Lithology
PrimarySandstone
Location
Coordinates32°50′N 4°50′W / 32.833°N 4.833°W / 32.833; -4.833
Approximate paleocoordinates18°48′N 4°06′W / 18.8°N 4.1°W / 18.8; -4.1
RegionEr Rachidia, Tafilalt
CountryMorocco
Extentcentral and eastern Morocco north and south of the Pre-African Trough
Kem Kem Group is located in Morocco
Kem Kem Group
Kem Kem Group (Morocco)

The Kem Kem Group (commonly known as the Kem Kem beds) is a geological group in the Kem Kem region of eastern Morocco, whose strata date back to the Cenomanian stage of the Late Cretaceous.

Dinosaur remains are among the fossils that have been recovered from the group. Recent fossil evidence in the form of isolated large abelisaurid bones and comparisons with other similarly aged deposits elsewhere in Africa indicates that the fauna of the Kem Kem Group (specifically in regard to the numerous predatory theropod dinosaurs) may have been mixed together due to the harsh and changing geology of the region, when in reality they would likely have preferred separate habitats and likely would have been separated by millions of years.

Stratigraphy and paleoenvironment

Although preserving a freshwater habitat located near a river delta (with some estuarine influence that increased over time as the sea level rose), the Kem Kem deposits were quickly submerged by the sea during the Cenomanian-Turonian boundary event, and are thus overlaid by the marine deposits of the younger latest Cenomanian and early-mid Turonian-aged Akrabou Formation, which was formerly also considered a member of the Kem Kem Group, but has been differentiated from it in more recent studies due to their differing paleoenvironments.

Its strata are subdivided into two geological formations, with the lower Ifezouane Formation and the upper Aoufous Formation used for the strata on the eastern side of the Atlas Mountains (Tinghir), with the Gara Sbaa Formation and Douira Formation used in the southern Tafilalt region. It is exposed on an escarpment along the Algeria–Morocco border. According to Ibrahim, the Lower Kem Kem consists of the Ifezouane & Gara Sbaa Formations, while the Upper Kem Kem is consisted of The Douira & Aufous Formations.

The unit unconformably overlies Paleozoic marine units of Cambrian, Silurian and Devonian ages and is itself capped by limestone platform rock of Cenomanian-Turonian age. It primarily consists of freshwater and estuarine deltaic deposits. The lower Gara Sbaa Formation primarily consists of fine and medium grained sandstone, while the Douira Formation consists of fining-upward, coarse-to-fine grained sandstones intercalated with siltstones, variegated mudstones, and occasional thin gypsiferous evaporites.

The Kem Kem is interpreted as being deposited in a tropical semi-arid climate, with brief monsoon rains. It is believed to Span the Lower to Middle Cenomanian, a span of roughly 100-95 mya.

Vertebrate paleofauna

Cartilaginous fish

Cartilaginous fish
GenusSpeciesLocationStratigraphic positionMaterialNotesImages
Acrodontidae indet. Indeterminate Members of Hybodontoidea
Bahariyodon B. bartheli A member of Hybodontoidea
Cenocarcharias C. tenuiplicatus One tooth A member of the family Cretoxyrhinidae
Distobatus D. nutiae A member of Hybodontoidea
Haimirichia H. amonensis One tooth A mackerel shark
Marckgrafia M. lybica 13 teeth A member of Batoidea
Onchopristis O. numida Various isolated, and some articulated remains A rajiform sawskate
Onchopristis rostrum and teeth fossils
Peyeria P. libyca Three teeth A sawskate. Might be a junior synonym of Onchopristis numida.
Tribodus T. sp. A member of Hybodontoidea

Ray-finned fish

Ray-finned fish
GenusSpeciesLocationStratigraphic positionMaterialNotesImages
Adrianaichthys A. pankowskii Isolated scales and two skulls A member of Lepisosteiformes. Originally described as a species of Lepidotes, but subsequently transferred to a separate genus.
Life restoration of Aidachar
Life restoration of Bawitius
Life restoration of Calamopleurus
Life restoration of Concavotectum
Serenoichthys
Afrocascudo A. saharaensis A neopterygiian fish, either an ancient loricariid catfish or a juvenile obaichthyid lepisosteiform.
Agassizilia A. erfoudina Possibly a member of the family Pycnodontidae.
Agoultichthys A. chattertoni A long-bodied member of Actinopterygii of uncertain phylogenetic placement. Might be a member of the family Macrosemiidae or Ophiopsiellidae.
Aidachar A. pankowskii Ifezouane Formation Isolated braincase and teeth A member of Ichthyodectiformes
Bartschichthys B. sp. Isolated pinnulae (spines that support each dorsal finlet) A cladistian
Bawitius cf. B. sp. Isolated scales and jaw fragments A cladistian
Calamopleurus C. africanus A partial skull A member of Amiiformes
Concavotectum C. moroccensis Tizi Moumrad, Chaaft, and Douira Isolated braincases, post cranial remains A member of Tselfatiiformes
Dentilepisosteus D. kemkemensis A member of Lepisosteiformes
Diplomystus D. sp. A deep-bodied teleost belonging to the group Clupeomorpha
Diplospondichthys D. moreaui A member of Actinopterygii of uncertain phylogenetic placement, possibly a teleost
Erfoudichthys E. rosae Isolated skull A small-bodied teleost of unknown affinity
Neoproscinetes N. africanus A member of the family Pycnodontidae
Obaichthys O. africanus Ifezouane Formation Isolated scales A member of Lepisosteiformes
Oniichthys O. falipoui Near complete skeleton including skull A member of Lepisosteiformes
Palaeonotopterus P. greenwoodi A member of Osteoglossomorpha
Serenoichthys S. kemkemensis Several articulated skeletons A small cladistian
Spinocaudichthys S. oumtkoutensis An elongate freshwater acanthomorph
Stromerichthys S. aethiopicus
Sudania S. sp. An isolated pinnula A cladistian

Lobe-finned fish

Lobe-finned fish
GenusSpeciesLocationMaterialNotesImages
Arganodus A. tiguidiensis A lungfish
Life restoration of Axelrodichthys
The Queensland Lungfish, the only living member of Neoceratodus
Axelrodichthys A.? lavocati A mawsoniid coelacanth; this species was previously assigned to Mawsonia, and its generic assignment is still not certain
Neoceratodus N. africanus Isolated tooth plates A lungfish

Amphibians

Amphibians
GenusSpeciesLocationStratigraphic positionMaterialNotesImages
Anura indet. Indeterminate Douira Formation Incomplete left ilium
Cretadhefdaa C. taouzensis Douira Formation Posterior portion of the skull, incomplete squamosal, incomplete maxilla, three incomplete presacral vertebrae, one incomplete sacral vertebra A neobatrachian frog with possible hyloid affinities.
cf. Kababisha Indeterminate A salamander belonging to the family Sirenidae
?Neobatrachia indet. Indeterminate Douira Formation Incomplete humerus A frog, possibly a member of Ranoidea.
Oumtkoutia O. anae A frog belonging to the family Pipidae

Lizards and snakes

Color key
Taxon Reclassified taxon Taxon falsely reported as present Dubious taxon or junior synonym Ichnotaxon Ootaxon Morphotaxon

Notes
Uncertain or tentative taxa are in small text
crossed out taxa are discredited.

Lizards and snakes reported from the Continental Red Beds
Genus Species Location Stratigraphic position Material Notes Images

Bicuspidon

B. hogreli

A polyglyphanodontid lizard.

Jeddaherdan

J. aleadonta

Partial mandible with teeth.

An iguanian belonging to the group Acrodonta, possibly a relative of the uromastycine agamids. Argued by Vullo et al. (2022) to actually come from Quaternary beds, and to be based on a fossil material of a member of the genus Uromastyx.

Lapparentophis

L. ragei

Two isolated trunk vertebrae

An early snake.

Madtsoiidae indet.

Indeterminate

Vertebrae

An early snake.

?Nigerophiidae indet.

Indeterminate

Dorsal vertebrae

An early snake.

Norisophis

N. begaa

One posterior and two mid-trunk vertebrae

A stem-snake.

Indeterminate

A mid-trunk vertebra

Simoliophis

cf. S. libycus

Vertebrae

An early snake.

Plesiosaurs

Plesiosaurs
GenusSpeciesLocationStratigraphic positionMaterialNotesImages
Leptocleididae cf. Leptocleidus indeterminate Isolated teeth, a humerus and vertebrae
Life restoration of Leptocleidus

Turtles

Turtles reported from the Continental Red Beds
Genus Species Location Stratigraphic position Material Notes Images

Dirqadim

D. schaefferi

A Euraxemydid
Skull of Galianemys

Galianemys

G. emringeri

A Cearachelyin

G. whitei Skull material

Hamadachelys

H. escuilliei

Skull and mandible A basal Podocnemidoid

Crocodylomorphs

Crocodylomorphs reported from the Continental Red Beds
Genus Species Location Stratigraphic position Material Notes Images

Aegisuchus

A. witmeri

"Partial braincase of a large individual with skull roof, temporal, and occipital regions."

An aegyptosuchid that may be a synonym of Laganosuchus.

Aegisuchus
Antaeusuchus
Araripesuchus
Elosuchus cherifiensis
Hamadasuchus rebouli
Laganosuchus

Antaeusuchus

A. taouzensis

Near Jebel Beg'aa, Taouz

Paired mandibles and a partial right mandible

A peirosaurid.

Araripesuchus

A. rattoides

Douira Formation

Elosuchus

E. cherifiensis

  • Gara Sbaa Formation
  • Douira Formation

A pholidosaurid. The material may represent two different species.

Hamadasuchus

H. rebouli

  • Gara Sbaa Formation
  • Douira Formation

A peirosaurid.

Kemkemia

K. auditorei

Errachidia Province, Morocco

Known from an isolated caudal vertebra.

Initially thought to be a neotheropod, but subsequently discovered to be an indeterminate crocodyliform.

Laganosuchus

L. maghrebensis

A stomatosuchid.

Lavocatchampsa

L. sigogneaurusselae

Anterior portion of a rostrum with mandible, with an almost complete dentition

A candidodontid notosuchian.

Notosuchia indet. Indeterminate Douira Formation Teeth Indeterminate notosuchians. Represent by distinct multicuspid teeth,similar to Adamantinasuchus & Yacarerani. Suggestive of a herbivorous diet.
cf. Sarcosuchus Indeterminate Teeth and Osteoderms Possible remains of Sarcosuchus. Additional Cenomanian occurrences known from Algeria.

Dinosaurs

Indeterminate lithostrotian remains once misattributed to the Titanosauridae are present in the province of Ksar-es-Souk, Morocco.

Color key
Taxon Reclassified taxon Taxon falsely reported as present Dubious taxon or junior synonym Ichnotaxon Ootaxon Morphotaxon

Notes
Uncertain or tentative taxa are in small text
crossed out taxa are discredited.

Ornithischians

Ornithischians reported from the Continental Red Beds
Genus Species Location Stratigraphic position Material Notes Images

Thyreophora

Indeterminate

Douira Formation

An isolated tooth.

An indeterminate thyreophoran. Possibly an ankylosaur.

Ornithopoda

Indeterminate

Douira Formation

A large, clover-shaped, three-toed footprint. A smaller print is known as well.

Comparable in size and shape to tracks typically attributed to Iguanodon. Smaller possible ornithopod track is known as well.

Sauropods

Sauropods reported from the Continental Red Beds
Genus Species Location Stratigraphic position Material Notes Images

Rebbachisaurus

R. garasbae

Ksar-es-Souk province, Morocco.

Gara Sbaa Formation

A rebbachisaurid.

Rebbachisaurus garasbae

Somphospondyli

Indeterminate

Anterior dorsal vertebra, partial right ischium

The vertebra might belong to a basal titanosaurian, possibly distinct from Aegyptosaurus and Paralititan. The ischium is not identifiable beyond Somphospondyli; it preserves numerous grooves and pits which might be feeding traces left by a very large non-avian theropod.

Titanosauria

Indeterminate

  • Ifezouane Formation
  • Douira Formation

Isolated teeth, caudal vertebrae, a partial humerus, a tarsal bone and proximal partial ulna.

Fossil material of one or more titanosaurian sauropods. Some fossils are indicative of large body size comparable to Paralititan stromeri. The largest specimens hail from the Douira Formation. An ulna from Doira has a width of 51 cm.

Rebbachisauridae Indet. Indeterminate
  • Douira Formation
Teeth Teeth referred to an indeterminate rebbachisaurid.

Theropods

Theropods reported from the Continental Red Beds
Genus Species Location Stratigraphic position Material Notes Images

Abelisauridae

Indeterminate

Isolated teeth.
Partial right femur. Partial right maxilla. A cervical vertebra. Left maxilla.

Abelisaurid material belonging to one or two distinct taxa. Some of the material has been noted as similar to Rugops, but the diagnostic features in that genus are on the orbital bones;not preserved in the Kem Kem material. Preventing definitive referral.

Carcharodontosaurus saharicus
Deltadromeus agilis
Sigilmassasaurus
Spinosaurus aegyptiacus

Carcharodontosaurus

C. saharicus

Ksar-es-Souk province, Morocco. Douira Formation Partial skull, including braincase, nasals, postorbitals, jugals, left lacrimal and right maxilla with most teeth.

A carcharodontosaurid theropod.

Carcharodontosauridae Indeterminate Southeast of Taouz, Errachidia Province Ifezouane Formation partial maxilla and partial jugal A carcharodontosaurid theropod different from C. saharicus

Deltadromeus

D. agilis

Gara Sbaa Formation

"Partial skeleton, isolated limb elements."

A noasaurid ceratosaurian, May be synonymous with Bahariasaurus.

Dromaeosauridae

Indeterminate

Isolated teeth.

Originally described as teeth of indeterminate dromaeosaurids. Hendrickx et al. (2024) reinterpreted this fossil material as teeth of abelisauroid theropods, including noasaurids and juvenile abelisaurids.

cf. Elaphrosaurus

Indeterminate

Ksar-es-Souk province, Morocco.

Fossils previously referred to cf. Elaphrosaurus are actually indeterminate theropod remains.

Noasauridae

Indeterminate

An anterior cervical vertebra
Isolated teeth

"Osteoporosia" "O. gigantea" A tooth and a possible neural arch from another specimen. A theropod, possibly synonymous with Sauroniops.

Saurischia

Indeterminate

An isolated cervical vertebra.

An indeterminate saurischian.

Sauroniops

S. pachytholus

Ifezouane Formation

"An isolated and almost complete left frontal, and a possible tooth and neural arch from two other specimens."

A carcharodontosaurid thought to be distinct from Carcharodontosaurus, considered a nomen dubium by Kellerman et al.

Sigilmassasaurus S. brevicollis Tafilalt Oasis region, Morocco. A single neck vertebrae. A controversial spinosaurid theropod.

Spinosaurus

S. aegyptiacus

Ksar-es-Souk province, Morocco. Douira Formation Partial skeleton, including parts of the skull, neck, torso, and most of the tail and hind limbs.

Numerous isolated bones.

A spinosaurid theropod.
Averostra indet Indeterminate Tooth Said to belong to either a non-abelisaurid ceratosaur or a megaraptoran.
Abelisauroidea indet. Indeterminate Douira Formation Pedal ungualLarge vertebrae An indeterminate abelisauroid, known from a 7 cm long pedal ungual. Likely an abelisaurid or noasaurid. The vertebrae came from a giant abelisauroid.

Pterosaurs

Pterosaurs of the Kem Kem Beds
Genus Species Location Stratigraphic position Abundance Notes Images

Afrotapejara

A. zouhri

Takmout Ifezouane Formation

A fragment of bone interpreted as a fragment of anterior mandibular symphysis, and additional jaw fragments that pertain to the rostrum as well as indeterminate jaw fragments.

A tapejarid pterosaur. Originally believed to belong to either the family Thalassodromidae or an additional specimen of Alanqa saharica.

Afrotapejara zouhri
Akharhynchus martilli
Alanqa saharica
Anhanguera
Coloborhynchus
Leptostomia
Ornithocheirus
Akharhynchus A. martilli Tafilalt Ifezouane Formation A fragment of the anterior part of the premaxillae A tropeognathine anhanguerian.

Alanqa

A. saharica

Ifezouane Formation The holotype is a mandibular symphysis, of different parts of the jaw A pterosaur of uncertain phylogenetic placement, probably an azhdarchid.

Anhanguera

A. cf. piscator

upper Ifezouane Formation

Partial mandibular symphysis

Apatorhamphus

A. gyrostega

Ifezouane Formation

Partial rostrum and mandible, with additional referred jaw fragments

A possible chaoyangopterid azhdarchoid pterosaur. Originally believed to be a possible pteranodontid, a possible dsungaripterid, a possible non-azhdarchid azhdarchoid or nyctosaurid, or a specimen of Alanqa saharica.

Azhdarchidae indet.

Indeterminate

Numerous middle cervical vertebrae and a femur.

Indicative of multiple taxa. Some of these vertebrae may pertain to Alanqa saharica.

Azhdarchoidea indet.

"Jaw morphotype A" Two jaw fragments Different from all named Kem Kem pterosaur taxa
"Jaw morphotype B" Partial mandible fragment Probably had a similarly long jaw to Leptostomia
"Jaw morphotype C" Partial jaw fragments May belong to Apatorhamphus or Xericeps

Indeterminate

Five cervical vertebrae, a scapulocoracoid, two humeri, two ulnae, a metacarpal IV, and a tibiotarsus

Coloborhynchus C. sp. A. Hassi El Begaa Premaxillae fragment Possibly a specimen of Nicorhynchus fluviferox.

Leptostomia

L. begaaensis

Aferdou N' Chaft

upper Ifezouane Formation

Partial rostrum and partial mandibular synthesis

A small, long-beaked pterosaur, likely a member of Azhdarchoidea.

Nicorhynchus

N. fluviferox

Possibly Aferdou N'Chaft, Hassi El Begaa

Ifezouane Formation

An anterior portion of the rostrum.

Originally described as a species of Coloborhynchus but subsequently transferred to the genus Nicorhynchus.

Ornithocheirus

O. cf. simus.

upper Ifezouane Formation

Premaxillae fragment

Siroccopteryx

S. moroccensis

Anterior part of a rostrum

Classified by some authors as a species belonging to the genus Coloborhynchus.

Xericeps X. curvirostra Aferdou N'Chaft Douira Formation Mandibular symphysis and partial mandible An indeterminate azhdarchoid, possibly a chaoyangopterid.

Non-vertebrate paleofauna

The formation contains fossils of various insects, crustaceans, mollusks, and sea urchins. There are also traces of insect and priapulid activity.

Color key
Taxon Reclassified taxon Taxon falsely reported as present Dubious taxon or junior synonym Ichnotaxon Ootaxon Morphotaxon

Notes
Uncertain or tentative taxa are in small text
crossed out taxa are discredited.

Unicellular organisms

Genus Species Stratigraphic position Material Notes Image
Eukaryote Indeterminate Douira Formation Biofilm of bacteria or fungi.
Fossilized biofilm
Foraminifera Douira Formation, Aoufous Formation Foraminiferal tests Various foraminifera.

Mollusc

Gastropods and ammonites were found in the upper units.

Genus Species Stratigraphic position Material Notes
?Margaritifera Ifezouane Formation Shell A freshwater bivalve.
Goumardonaia G. radieri Shell A large (83 mm) freshwater bivalve.
Kemkemnaia K. parvum Shell with preserved gill structures. A freshwater bivalve.
Monginella M. cf. flattersensis Shell A freshwater bivalve.
Trigonioidoidea Indeterminate Shell A freshwater bivalve.
Unio U. radleyi Shell A freshwater bivalve.
Unionidae Indeterminate Shell A freshwater bivalve.

Arthropods

Genus Species Stratigraphic position Material Notes Image
Cretapenaeus C. berberus A freshwater prawn.
Cubiculum C. ornatus Traces of bone borings on dead animals. A terrestrial necrophagous insect.
Bone boring left by Cubiculum
Odonata Indeterminate A dragonfly larva.
Ostracoda Different types of ostracods.
Troponoma T. constricta Feeding traces on a leaf. A herbivorous insect.

Paleoflora

Color key
Taxon Reclassified taxon Taxon falsely reported as present Dubious taxon or junior synonym Ichnotaxon Ootaxon Morphotaxon

Notes
Uncertain or tentative taxa are in small text
crossed out taxa are discredited. Based primarily on Krassilov & Bacchia.

Genus Species Stratigraphic position Material Notes Image
Abietites A. (Tritaenia) cf. linkii Gara Sbaa Formation Needles A conifer.
Barykovia B. cf. tschuckotika Leaf A potentially fagalean angiosperm.
Cocculophyllum C. cf. fucinerve Leaf A climbing angiosperm.
Coniopteris C. cf. Dicksonia mamiyai Leaflet A fern.
Dryophyllum D. cf. subcretaceum Leaf A potentially fagalean angiosperm.
Frenelopsis F. cf. teixeirae Shoot A cheirolepidiacean conifer.
Garasbahia G. flexuosa Branching shoot with leaves A cabombacean angiosperm.
Pseudotorellia P. cf. ensiformis Leaf A ginkgoalean.
Sulcatocladus S. cf. robustus Shoot A conifer.
Weichselia W. reticulata Shoot A tree fern.
Welwitschiophyllum W. sp. Leaf A possible welwitschialean.

See also