Conservative parties in Newfoundland (pre-Confederation)

The Conservative Party of Newfoundland was a political party in the Dominion of Newfoundland prior to Confederation with Canada in 1949.

History

Formation

The party was formed by members and supporters of the establishment around 1832. In the 1840s, they opposed the proposal for responsible government which was finally granted in 1855. Since the concept was opposed generally by members of the Anglican establishment, the early party was almost entirely Protestant. As politics in Newfoundland developed along sectarian lines, the Conservatives became the Protestant party (with strong links to the Orange Order), while the Liberals were the Catholic party.[additional citation(s) needed]

Union and collapse

Under Sir Frederick Carter, the Conservatives supported joining Canadian Confederation, and campaigned on the proposal in the 1869 general election. The party was badly defeated by Charles Fox Bennett's Anti-Confederation Party. The Conservatives returned to power in 1874, but never proposed joining Canada again.[citation needed]

The Conservative party later absorbed the rival Liberals, putting an end to sectarian divisions with a 'denominational compromise'.

The united party collapsed in the 1880s when members of the Orange Order abandoned the government of William Whiteway, and formed a new Reform Party under Robert Thorburn. The Reform Party won the 1885 election on a platform of 'Protestant Rights'.

Later period

Whiteway founded a new Liberal Party after the collapse of the Reform Party. Members of the Orange Order formed a new Tory Party, which formed two short-lived administrations in the 1890s before disappearing.

Individual Conservatives were elected as Opposition or United Opposition MHAs before being subsumed into the Newfoundland People's Party (later the Liberal-Labour-Progressive Party) formed by Edward Patrick Morris in 1907 after he resigned from the Liberal government of Sir Robert Bond.

In 1924, the Liberal-Conservative-Progressive Party was formed by members of the LLP Party who were largely conservatives and discontented members of the ruling Liberal Reform Party. This new party won the 1924 general election, making its leader Walter Stanley Monroe the new prime minister. In practice, the party was essentially a Tory party.

The party was defeated in 1928 under new leader Frederick C. Alderdice; however, they returned to power in 1932 as the United Newfoundland Party (UNP). The UNP ruled for two years until the suspension of responsible government.

Loss of independence

When responsible government was suspended, Newfoundland's status as an independent dominion within the British Empire was brought to an end. The Government of the United Kingdom appointed a Commission of Government to govern Newfoundland, bringing an end to party politics on the island.

Party politics returned to Newfoundland when it joined Canadian Confederation in 1949. At this time, the modern Liberal and Progressive Conservative parties were formed. These new parties were unrelated to the parties that existed prior to 1934.

List of leaders

Conservative Party of Newfoundland

Reform Party of Newfoundland

Conservative Party of Newfoundland

Newfoundland People's Party

Liberal-Progressive Party

Liberal-Labour-Progressive Party

Liberal-Conservative Progressive Party

United Newfoundland Party

Election results

Election Leader Votes % Seats +/− Position Status
1832 N/a 3,025 40.9
10 / 15
Increase 10 Increase 1st Majority
1836 N/a N/a N/a
3 / 15
Decrease 7 Decrease 2nd Opposition
1837 N/a N/a N/a
2 / 15
Decrease 1 Steady 2nd Opposition
1842 N/a N/a N/a
7 / 15
Increase 5 Steady 2nd Opposition
1848 N/a N/a N/a
6 / 15
Decrease 1 Steady 2nd Opposition
1852 N/a N/a N/a
6 / 15
Steady Steady 2nd Opposition
1855 Hugh Hoyles N/a N/a
12 / 30
Increase 6 Steady 2nd Opposition
1859 3,129 30.2
12 / 30
Steady Steady 1st Opposition
1861 84 1.5
16 / 30
Increase 4 Increase 1st Majority
1865 Frederick Carter 10,187 59.2
22 / 30
Increase 6 Steady 1st Majority
1869 N/a N/a
9 / 30
Decrease 13 Decrease 2nd Opposition
1873 N/a N/a
14 / 30
Increase 5 Steady 2nd Opposition
1874 10,284 55.1
18 / 30
Increase 4 Increase 1st Majority
1878 William Whiteway N/a N/a
21 / 30
Increase 3 Steady 1st Majority
1882 25,873 65.5
26 / 33
Increase 26 Steady 1st Majority
1885 Robert Thorburn 12,213 39.8
21 / 36
Increase 8 Steady 2nd Majority
1889 22,292 36.5
7 / 36
Decrease 14 Decrease 2nd Opposition
1893 Walter B. Grieve and
Moses Monroe
35,546 45.6
12 / 36
Increase 5 Steady 2nd Opposition
1897 James S. Winter 47,581 55.9
23 / 36
Increase 11 Increase 1st Majority
1900 Alfred B. Morine 29,217 35.4
4 / 36
Decrease 19 Decrease 2nd Opposition
1904 34,697 39.6
6 / 36
Increase 2 Steady 2nd Opposition
1908 Edward Morris 47,487 49.3
18 / 36
Increase 12 Steady 2nd Tie
1909 54,111 52.3
26 / 36
Increase 8 Increase 1st Majority
1913 51,451 45.6
21 / 36
Decrease 5 Steady 1st Majority
1919 Michael P. Cashin 43,250 36.7
12 / 36
Decrease 9 Decrease 2nd Opposition
1923 John R. Bennett 60,658 48.0
13 / 36
Increase 1 Steady 2nd Opposition
1924 Walter S. Monroe 57,391 57.9
25 / 36
Increase 12 Increase 1st Majority
1928 Frederick C. Alderdice 45,787 42.8
12 / 40
Decrease 13 Decrease 2nd Opposition
1932 82,037 70.9
24 / 27
Increase 12 Increase 1st Majority

Notes

  1. 1 2 The Conservative caucus in this election were elected entirely by acclamation, and the only votes the government received were through an unsuccessful candidate.
  2. 1 2 As the Reform Party
  3. ↑ As the United Opposition Party
  4. 1 2 3 As the People's Party
  5. ↑ As the Liberal-Progressive Party
  6. ↑ As the Liberal-Labour-Progressive Party
  7. 1 2 As the Liberal-Conservative Progressive Party
  8. ↑ As the United Newfoundland Party

See also

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 Senior, Elinor (1959). The Origin and Political Activities of the Orange Order in Newfoundland (PDF) (Thesis). University of Newfoundland. Retrieved 2025-11-18.
  2. ↑ Hiller, James K. (1997). "The Confederation Election of 1869". Heritage Newfoundland and Labrador. Retrieved 18 November 2025.