Newikis
List of scientific debates
This is a list of notable
scientific debates
in the
history of science
and
mathematics
.
Biology
Nature versus nurture
, long-standing debate in biology on human behavior
1764–1778 Voltaire vs Needham, between
Voltaire
and
John Needham
and others on the validity of
preformationism
.
1830
Cuvier–Geoffroy debate
between
Georges Cuvier
and
Étienne Geoffroy Saint-Hilaire
on animal structure.
1860 Oxford evolution debate
between several scientists on
Charles Darwin
's
On the Origin of Species
.
1860–1862
Great Hippocampus Question
, between
Thomas Henry Huxley
and
Richard Owen
on the importance of
hippocampus minor
.
Chemistry and nanoscience
2001–2003
Drexler–Smalley debate on molecular nanotechnology
by
K. Eric Drexler
and
Richard Smalley
on the feasibility of
molecular assemblers
.
Mathematics
1654–1665
problem of points
, correspondence between
Blaise Pascal
and
Pierre de Fermat
on games and the fair share of a prize pot.
1655–1679
Hobbes–Wallis controversy
, between
Thomas Hobbes
and
John Wallis
on geometry and other topics.
1745 Leibniz–Bernoulli correspondence, between
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz
and
Johann Bernoulli
on the
logarithm
of negative numbers.
1902–1924 Nekrasov–Markov conflict, between
Pavel Nekrasov
and
Andrey Markov
on the relation between the
law of large numbers
and
free will
.
1903–1912 Poincaré vs. Russell, between
Henri Poincaré
and
Bertrand Russell
on
logicism
and mathematical paradoxes.
1907–1928
Brouwer–Hilbert foundational debate
or
Grundlagenstreit
, between
L. E. J. Brouwer
and
David Hilbert
on foundations of mathematics.
Physics and astronomy
1715–1716
Leibniz–Clarke correspondence
, between
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz
and
Samuel Clarke
on space being absolute.
1857–1901 Kelvin–Stokes
aether drag debate
, on whether the
luminiferous aether
was unstable when considered a
perfect fluid
. Debate between
Lord Kelvin
and
George Stokes
.
1895
Lübeck Debate
between
Ludwig Boltzmann
and
Wilhelm Ostwald
on the existence of
atoms
.
1920
Great Debate (astronomy)
between
Harlow Shapley
and
Heber Curtis
on the scale of
spiral nebulae
and the Universe.
1920
Bad Nauheim Debate
, between
Philipp Lenard
and
Albert Einstein
on the validity of
general relativity
. See also
Criticism of the theory of relativity
.
1922
Einstein–Bergson debate
between Albert Einstein and philosopher
Henri Bergson
, on the implications of
theory of relativity
and the nature of time.
1927–1935
Bohr–Einstein debates
between Albert Einstein and
Niels Bohr
on
interpretations of quantum mechanics
.
1936–1944
Chandrasekhar–Eddington dispute
, between
Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar
and
Arthur Eddington
on the limits of star masses.
1949–1964
Big Bang vs. steady-state
, dispute between
Fred Hoyle
supporter of the
steady-state model
of the universe and
George Gamow
supporter of the
Big Bang
.
Philosophy of science
1965
Kuhn–Popper debate
between philosophers
Thomas Kuhn
and
Karl Popper
on scientific research methodology.
1990s
Science wars
, series of debates on the role of natural sciences over social sciences
Science education
1989
Math wars
, series of debates on the
mathematics education
curriculum in the United States
Theology and science
2014
Bill Nye–Ken Ham debate
by
Bill Nye
and
Ken Ham
on science and
creationism
and
evolution
.
See also
List of scientific priority disputes