Russian Scare

The Russian Scare was a period in the history of New Zealand, from 1870 to 1885, during which at least six separate incidents occurred that led to popular fear that New Zealand would be invaded by Russia. Despite significant public panic, neither contemporary evidence nor archival modern evidence supports that Russia ever planned to attack New Zealand. Rather, a combination of isolation and neglect from colonial overlord Britain, the Great Game, nascent nationalism, erroneous reports of foreign vessels, and outright hoaxes led to a prolonged period of paranoia.

Background

In the 1870s New Zealand was a young self-governing colony of the United Kingdom. It had developed no coastal defences of any consequence and was becoming increasingly sensitive to how vulnerable its harbours were to attack by a hostile power or opportunistic raider. Fears of invasion by the expanding Russian Empire were common, especially due to the founding of Russia's Pacific port at Vladivostok. While the British Navy was among the world's strongest, local British sea power was lacking; ten or fewer ships were assigned to the entirety of Australia and New Zealand during the 1860s. New Zealand military planners were keenly aware that they lacked sufficient coastal defenses or naval power to hold off an attack by a foreign power.

Russophobia was also high in 19th century New Zealand. Many anti-Russian novels, newspaper articles, and other works were published in New Zealand.

In 1871, very few Russian ships were even remotely close to New Zealand; only four Russia ships were operating within 3,000 mi (4,800 km). Just one Russian warship had visited Australia in the 1860s.

Still, Russia and the United Kingdom were playing the Great Game. The two nations battled in the Crimean War from 1853 to 1856. During the 1860s, Russia had expanded deeply into Central Asia, raising fears of a clash over Britain's possessions in India. New Zealanders feared that a clash between Russia and the UK would put a target on their isolated island.

Scares

Whatever the cause, government efforts to strengthen New Zealand against Russian attack picked up notably in the early 1870s. Governor George Bowen, a noted Russophobe, repeatedly wrote to John Wodehouse, Secretary of State for the Colonies, regarding New Zealand's tenuous position in the event of a Great Powers conflict. Bowen requested additional weapons, and eventually conversation turned to the subject of Russia.

Erroneous reports began to inflate fears among the government. In a July 1871 dispatch from Bowen to Wodehouse, Bowen included a communique that claimed that a Russian corvette had been prowling in New Zealand the year before with the intent to attack New Zealand, when war seemed possible between Russia and the UK. But the only Russian ship that had actually been near was the Russian corvette Vityaz, which was circumnavigating the world and had stopped in New Guinea to disembark scientist Nicholas Miklouho-Maclay. Nevertheless, public speculation went wild and concluded that the Vitayz was there so as to cut off mail service to Britain.

But naval intelligence never indicated that Russia was considering an attack. The Russians had not dispatched ships to the south Pacific, nor did they appear to have plans to—nor does modern archival research indicate that such plans ever existed.

The connection of Australia to Britain via telegraph in 1872 greatly sped up the rate of news transmission, which had previously taken a month via ship to arrive to the colonies, and heightened the potential for scares.

1873 hoax

Part of a hoax article run in the Daily Southern Cross, 17 Feb 1873, falsely proclaiming war with Russia. Its four tier headline, indicating great newsworthiness, was almost unprecedented.

Fears intensified after David Luckie, editor of the Daily Southern Cross, ran a fanciful hoax article on 17 February 1873. The article proclaimed that war had been declared between England and Russia, and that a fictional Russian naval cruiser, the Kaskowiski (a wordplay on "cask of whiskey"), had attacked Auckland.

[The Kaskowiski] – whose very name should have made sober readers suspicious – had allegedly entered Auckland Harbour on the previous Saturday night and proceeded to capture a British ship, along with the city's arms and ammunition supply, and hold a number of leading citizens for ransom. The 954-man Russian vessel obviously meant business, with a dozen 30-ton guns as well as a remarkably new advance in warfare, a paralysing and deadly "water-gas" that could be injected into enemy ships from a great distance.

The article, in small print, clarified that the whole thing was a hoax and that no such horrors had come to pass. But many Aucklanders didn't read past the headline, and panic gripped the city. Luckie, who had long bemoaned the unreadiness of New Zealand's defences, was pleased with the effect and felt that he had achieved his goal of alerting New Zealanders to the risk of foreign invasion. The paper published a disavowal and explanation of the hoax the next day, on 18 February 1873.

The Southern Cross article created panic and the Government commissioned its first reports on the colony's defences. It was now clearly understood that Britain would protect its territories and vital shipping routes, but the defence of individual ports was the responsibility of each self-governing colony.

Tensions with Russia

The next few scares were based on geopolitical events

Russia declared war on the Ottoman Empire in 1877. While Britain was officially neutral, Britain was nearly dragged into war in 1878 when the Russians, violating the terms of a truce with the Ottomans,[citation needed] marched to take Constantinople. The British sent a fleet to intimidate the Russians, forcing their way through the Dardanelles, pushing both countries to the brink of war and causing another scare.

New Zealanders found cause for concern in 1881, when Russia completed its conquest of what is now Turkmenistan with victory at the Battle of Geok Tepe. They also grew concerned at the 1884 conquest of Merv.

Tensions over Afghanistan helped lead to the preparation of coastal defenses. An 1884 report by Sir William Jervois, the Governor of New Zealand, included recommendations for military forts to be constructed at the country's four main ports at Auckland, Wellington, Lyttelton and Port Chalmers. These coastal artillery fortifications or land batteries were to be based on British designs. Heavy artillery pieces and ammunition was ordered from Britain. By 1885, work started in earnest on the construction of what eventually became seventeen forts, further encouraged by yet another Russian scare.

Fortifications of the Russian Scare

Fort Location Waypoint Ordnance c. 1890 Range Dates Notes
North Head Auckland 36°49′39″S 174°48′44″E / 36.82750°S 174.81222°E / -36.82750; 174.81222 (North Head) 1 × BL 8 in (200 mm) gun
RML 7 in guns
64 lb (29 kg) guns
1870 At Devonport, divided into three sub-forts:
  • North Battery (to defend Rangitoto Channel)
  • South Battery (with a 7 in (180 mm) gun to protect the inner harbour)
  • Fort Cautley (with the 8 in (200 mm) gun on the summit).
Bastion Point Auckland 36°50′43″S 174°49′29″E / 36.84528°S 174.82472°E / -36.84528; 174.82472 (Bastion Point) 2 × BL 6 in (150 mm) guns 1885– In Mission Bay. Not completed.
Fort Resolution Auckland 36°50′59″S 174°47′31″E / 36.84966°S 174.79183°E / -36.84966; 174.79183 (Fort Resolution) 2 × BL 6 in (150 mm) guns 1885 In Parnell.
Fort Takapuna Auckland 36°48′55″S 174°48′24″E / 36.81528°S 174.80667°E / -36.81528; 174.80667 (Fort Takapuna) 2 × BL 6 in (150 mm) guns 1886–
Fort Victoria Auckland 36°49′36″S 174°47′56″E / 36.82661°S 174.79881°E / -36.82661; 174.79881 (Fort Victoria) 1 × BL 8 in (200 mm) gun 1885 On Mount Victoria, Devonport. The gun fired only once because of complaints from residents whose windows were broken.
Fort Ballance Wellington 41°17′41″S 174°50′02″E / 41.29472°S 174.83389°E / -41.29472; 174.83389 (Fort Ballance) 2 × 7" RML guns
1 × 6" BLHP gun
2 × QF 6 lb (2.7 kg) Nordenfelt guns
1885 (1885–1886) Point Gordon. At Miramar. Wellington's primary military fort until 1911 when Fort Dorset opened.
Fort Gordon Wellington 41°17′41″S 174°50′02″E / 41.29472°S 174.83389°E / -41.29472; 174.83389 (Fort Ballance) 1 × 8" BLHP gun 1895-1924 Point Gordon
Fort Buckley Wellington 41°15′38″S 174°47′17″E / 41.26056°S 174.78806°E / -41.26056; 174.78806 (Fort Buckley) 2 × 64 lb (29 kg) RML guns 3.2 km (2 mi) At Kaiwharawhara.
Point Haswell Battery Wellington 41°17′06″S 174°49′34″E / 41.28506°S 174.826°E / -41.28506; 174.826 (Point Halswell Battery) 1 × BL 8 in (200 mm) gun 1889 At Miramar.
Kau Point Battery Wellington 41°17′23″S 174°49′54″E / 41.28978°S 174.83177°E / -41.28978; 174.83177 (Kau Point Battery) 1 × BL 8 in (200 mm) gun 1891-1922 At Miramar.
Fort Kelburne Wellington 41°14′46″S 174°48′53″E / 41.24623°S 174.81471°E / -41.24623; 174.81471 (Fort Kelburne) 2 × BL 8 in (200 mm) guns 1885 At Ngauranga. Since been demolished due to construction of the Wellington Urban Motorway.
Battery Point Lyttelton 43°36′10″S 172°44′25″E / 43.60278°S 172.74028°E / -43.60278; 172.74028 (Battery Point) 2 × 7 in RML guns
1 × QF 6 2.7 kg (6 lb) Nordenfelt guns
1885 On the north side of Lyttelton Harbour, 4.8 km (3 mi) from mouth.
Fort Jervois Lyttelton 43°37′11″S 172°45′15″E / 43.61972°S 172.75417°E / -43.61972; 172.75417 (Ripapa Island) 2 × 8 in (200 mm) BL guns
2 × 6 in (150 mm) BL guns
1886 On Ripapa Island on the south side of Lyttelton Harbour. Fort Jervois is an internationally rare 1880s “Russian Invasion Scare” structure, which has retained a high level of authenticity of both structure and hardware (6” and 8” disappearing guns). It is one of only five examples of this type of fortification in the world. The Island has been managed by the Department of Conservation since 1990.
Spur Point Battery Lyttelton 43°36′16″S 172°44′03″E / 43.60435°S 172.73405°E / -43.60435; 172.73405 (Spur Point Battery) 1 × 64 lb (29 kg) RML gun 1885 Site of battery, quarried away as part of land reclamation during the 1970s to build Cashin Quay.
Lawyers Head Battery Dunedin 45°54′32″S 170°32′06″E / 45.90889°S 170.53500°E / -45.90889; 170.53500 (Lawyers Head Battery) 1885 Eastern Ocean Beach, Dunedin South.
Ocean Beach Battery Otago Peninsula 45°54′25″S 170°30′25″E / 45.90686°S 170.50702°E / -45.90686; 170.50702 (Ocean Beach Battery / Central Battery) 1886
St Clair Battery Dunedin 45°54′51″S 170°29′15″E / 45.9142°S 170.48752°E / -45.9142; 170.48752 (St Clair Battery / Forbury Head Battery) 1885 On a spur of Forbury Hill above Second Beach, Dunedin. No remnants remain; the area was cleared and subdivided for residential housing.
Fort Taiaroa Otago Peninsula 45°46′26″S 170°43′40″E / 45.77389°S 170.72778°E / -45.77389; 170.72778 (Fort Taiaroa) 1 × BL 6 in (150 mm) gun 1885 Otago Harbour. This Armstrong Disappearing Gun was installed in May 1889 and was recommissioned during World War II. It is the only one of its kind working and is still in its original gun pit.