Tautological consequence

In propositional logic, tautological consequence is a strict form of logical consequence in which the tautologousness of a proposition is preserved from one line of a proof to the next. Not all logical consequences are tautological consequences. A proposition Q is said to be a tautological consequence of one or more other propositions (P1, P2, ..., Pn) in a proof with respect to some logical system if one is validly able to introduce the proposition onto a line of the proof within the rules of the system; and in all cases when each of (P1, P2, ..., Pn) are true, the proposition Q also is true.

Another way to express this preservation of tautologousness is by using truth tables. A proposition Q is said to be a tautological consequence of one or more other propositions (P1, P2, ..., Pn) if and only if in every row of a joint truth table that assigns "T" to all propositions (P1, P2, ..., Pn) the truth table also assigns "T" to Q.

Example

a = "Socrates is a man." b = "All men are mortal." c = "Socrates is mortal."

a
b
∴c

The conclusion of this argument is a logical consequence of the premises because it is impossible for all the premises to be true while the conclusion false.

Joint Truth Table for a ∧ b and c
a b c a ∧ b c
TTTTT
TTFTF
TFTFT
TFFFF
FTTFT
FTFFF
FFTFT
FFFFF

Reviewing the truth table, it turns out the conclusion of the argument is not a tautological consequence of the premise. Not every row that assigns T to the premise also assigns T to the conclusion. In particular, it is the second row that assigns T to a ∧ b, but does not assign T to c.

Denotation and properties

Tautological consequence can also be defined as P1 ∧ P2 ∧ ... ∧ Pn → Q is a substitution instance of a tautology, with the same effect.

It follows from the definition that if a proposition p is a contradiction then p tautologically implies every proposition, because there is no truth valuation that causes p to be true and so the definition of tautological implication is trivially satisfied. Similarly, if p is a tautology then p is tautologically implied by every proposition.

See also