Toehider was founded in 2008 by Michael Mills (the musician) and Andrew Saltmarsh (the illustrator). After the release of their debut EP Toe Hider in the same year, another twelve EPs were released from May 2009 to April 2010 as part of a 12in12 project, in which the release took place on the twelfth of each month for twelve consecutive months. During these recordings, the band experimented with different styles of music. The EPs were each provided with cover artwork and a 2-page comic by Andrew Saltmarsh (also known by his nickname, "Salt" or "Salty").
In 2011 the debut album To Hide Her was released, and in 2012 an EP Children of the Sun Part 2. The band's second album What Kind of Creature Am I? was released in 2014. They toured with the Protomen in 2013. In 2015 the EP Mainly Songs About Robots was recorded with Vinny Appice on drums and released in September of the same year.
The album I LIKE IT! was released in 2020, consisting of selected songs from a list of demos voted by the fans to be recorded for the album.
Michael Mills has guest-starred as a singer on the Ayreon albums The Theory of Everything, Transitus, and The Source, as well as on the live project Ayreon Universe.
Discography
Album
2011: To Hide Her
Track Listing
"Oh My God, He's an IDIOT" 03:31
"The Most Popular Girl in School" 05:00
"Daddy Issues" 06:18
"In This Time" 02:47
"To Hide Her" 05:45
"There's a Ghost in the Lake" 06:57
"Giants Who Walk With Man" 04:19
"Everybody Knows Amy" 02:48
"Fireside" 03:06
"Aren't They Just Out Playing on the Swing?" 06:49
2014: What Kind of Creature Am I?
Track Listing
"You and I Both Lose (But 5 Wins)" 5:00
"Whatever Makes You Feel Superior" 6:17
"The Thing With Me" 4:13
"What Kind Of Creature AmI?" 4:18
"Smash It Out" 2:04
"Spoilt For Choice" 3:00
"Whoa" 4:31
"Under The Future, We Bury The Past" 7:07
"Meet The Sloth" 12:34
"Geese Lycan" 2:41
2017: Good
Track Listing
"Good" 1:17
"[funnythings]" 6:10
"This Conversation is Over" 4:30
"Millions of Musketeers" 4:34
"How Do Ghosts Work?" 8:01
"Dan VS Egg" 3:07
"I've Been So Happy Living Down Here in the Water" 5:28
"It's So Fikkis!" 4:29
2020: I Like It!
Track Listing
"GO FULL BORE!" 4:04
"wellgivit" 4:38
"Rancorous Heart" 5:02
"Moon and Moron" 6:20
"Concerning Lix & Fairs" 6:34
"The Ultimate Exalter" 5:06
"Died of Dancing" 3:27
"Bats Aren't Birds" 3:25
"The Guy That No-One Really Knows" 6:24
"He's There... And Then He Does THAT" 6:07
"How Much For That Dragon Tooth?" 5:36
"I LIKE IT!" 6:21
2022: I Have Little To No Memory of These Memories
Track Listing
"I Have Little To No Memory of These Memories" 47:47
EPs
2008: Toe Hider
2009: Not Much of a Man
2009: Old, Old, Old
2009: Toehider Too!
2009: How Did Counterquistle Lose His Pyjamas
2009: Metaltarsus
2009: In All Honesty
2009: Under the Mistletoe
2010: 9
2010: Do You Believe in Monsters?
2010: Never Mind the Hallux
2010: Done and Dusted
2012: Children of the Sun Part 2: Another Collection of Under-appreciated Cartoon Themes from the 70's, 80's and 90's
2015: Mainly Songs About Robots
2023: Quit Forever?
2023: Snapshots From Beacontown Spring Dance '85
2023: The 4 Castles of Stelcoaryn
2023: Horse EP
2023: Take on a Tank
2024: Children of the Sun 3: A Collection of Cartoon Theme Songs from an Alternate Timeline in Which All Cartoons Are Duck-Themed
2024: Toad Hirer
2024: Stereo Night Ash: Music for Relaxation, Meditation, Decatastrophizing and Deep Sleep
2024: SPACE FAMOUS
2024: X
2024: Rediscovery
2024: Warts and All - Live in Chicago
Singles
2011: The Most Popular Girl in School
2012: Smash It Out
2013: All I Want for Christmas Is You (feat. Phoebe Pinnock, Mariah Carey Cover)