Ultra-realism is a school of thought within the discipline of criminology and the sub-discipline of zemiology. Ultra-realists revisit the fundamental question that underpins both disciplines - why, rather than seek solidarity and cooperation, do specific individuals, groups or institutions choose to risk harm to others as they pursue their own interests?
Early proponents of the ultra-realist perspective are Steve Hall and Simon Winlow. The original ultra-realist concepts first emerged from the mid-1990s onwards in a series of articles and books. The ultra-realist theoretical framework and research-programme began to take a clearly defined shape in three later works.
Ultra-realism is a new school of thought in western social science. Ultra-realists focus on the western way of life and its zemiological outcomes. Ultra-realism is a revisionist position constructed for the purposes of revisiting the research findings and fundamental domain assumptions of existing schools of thought to evaluate their validity and, where necessary, suggesting further investigation using ethnographic research methods and advanced concepts.
Ultra-realism's initial empirical focus is on broad crime trends that show discernable shifts over time in various locales, regions and nations. Drawing upon the work of criminologists such as Robert K. Merton, Jock Young and Robert Reiner, they connect these trends to shifts in political economy, culture and subjectivity, investigating their forms and dynamic relations, which together create probabilistic contexts at the local, regional and national levels.
Early preparatory work undertaken before the establishment of the ultra-realist name in 2015 drew evidence from the New Deal period in the US, which between 1933 and 1937 correlated with a significant reduction of crime, violence and homicide. This contrasts with the crime explosions in the US and UK during the deindustrialization process of the 1980s. Ultra-realists analysed the decline in traditional crime from the mid-1990s in the context of advances in detection technology and surveillance and increased incarceration rates. They also researched the mutation of criminal markets, a process in which traditional crimes declined as detection and surveillance advanced while criminal markets expanded silently in the background and new forms of minimally reported and recorded crime appeared, much of it online.
Winlow's sociological work on the displacement of traditional working-class identities and cultural pursuits by those promoted by mass-mediated consumer culture indicated that changes were taking place. His research on the drift into criminality added empirical and theoretical weight to Hall's claim that the cultural context of criminality is the combined pacification and intensification of a competitive-individualist norm. Further research added detail to the historical intensification of the practices around this norm and explained how an associated subjectivity was normalised and pacified, leading to the emergence of foundational ultra-realist concepts such as the pseudo-pacification process, objectless anxiety and special liberty. Further ethnographic and theoretical work associated these socioeconomic, cultural and subjective shifts with corresponding changes in crime trends and the expansion of criminal markets.
The construction of a theoretical framework for a renewed realist analysis of trends in crime and harm led to the establishment of the ultra-realist project in 2015. Ultra-realists agreed with the left realist and early feminist position that critical criminology must take crime, harm and victims more seriously. They borrowed selected concepts from other realist schools of thought - for instance critical realism's notions of depth structures and the causative impact of absence; speculative realism's critique of correlationism and its emphasis on realist contingency and agency in the anthropecene era; Mark Fisher's notion of 'capitalist realism', a culture that normalises and reproduces the cynical, 'zero-sum' subject frequently encountered by ultra-realist ethnographers in their research. The ubiquity of an indifferent attitude towards risking harm to others amongst respondents involved in crime and criminal markets prompted ultra-realism's first move towards zemiology.
Ultra-realists drew upon Slavoj Žižek's notion of fetishistic disavowal to formulate their concept of the 'chosen unconscious', which led to the early adoption of Adrian Johnston's transcendental materialism as a basis for the ultra-realist framework. Further theoretical development was prompted by researchers' empirical findings relating to subjectivity, particularly the clear distinction between expressive and instrumental forms of special liberty. The recognition of the use of criminal or harmful means of either remaining in or leaving specific situations led to the current reformulation of the ultra-realist framework, drawing upon the concepts of homeostasis, non-suffering, sacrifice, and existential difficulties in post-normal times.
Ultra-realists replaced the Lacanian notion of 'the void' in the psyche with the fundamental 'molecular question' - to stay or go - at the root of all organisms. This is a bodily demand for a primordial action-oriented metaphysics that only the affective system's deep 'mood' emotions can translate and mediate. Because the molecular body understands only 'non-suffering' as its initial objective, the stay-go decision involves a calculation of sacrifice, which becomes mythologised to dramatize narratives and enhance the emotional credibility of any answers to the molecular question provided by experience, culture and ideology. The more persistent and committed criminals encountered by ultra-realist researchers throughout the social structure had accepted the cyncial belief that the 'zero-sum' world is natural and timeless. The onus is on individuals to stay with it and actively compete against others but avoid sacrifice at all costs by levering themselves up the hierarchy of non-suffering by any means possible, legal or otherwise.
Ultra-realists argue that criminology can make firmer contributions to the pragmatic political interventions required to stabilise economies, reduce sociosymbolic competition, transcend zero-sum subjectivity and restore ethics to the heart of economy, society, culture. In an attempt to lay the foundations for a theoretical framework that encompasses these issues, ultra-realists constructed the following new concepts specifically for criminological and zemiological research:
Drawing upon earlier ethnographic work from Winlow, ultra-realists argue that criminological researchers are capable of capturing the details of the drivers behind crime and criminal markets by networking and generating qualitative data from different geographical locations and sections of the population. For example, projects undertaken to examine rioting in various locations of the UK and political protests around Europe revealed both differences and similarities in experiences, interpretations, motivations and outcomes. Networked ethnographers working in various spaces gathered data from observations and interviews to be analysed in the ultra-realist framework.
A number of researchers have used ultra-realist concepts as they construct their research projects and analyze their findings. Ultra-realists criticize 'backwards research' and insist on 'forwards research'. In the period 2015 to 2025 ultra-realism has provided a platform for research in the following areas:
Early criticism from reviewers focused on ultra-realism's complexity, opacity and lack of diversity. Ultra-realists responded by arguing that students and early career researchers experience little trouble in dealing with the complexity, that the ethnographic networking method enables and highlights diversity, and that ultra-realism's theoretical concepts can be adopted by any researcher in any part of the world.
Debates followed around the relative conceptual value of the civilizing process and the pseudo-pacification process. Ultra-realists regard the latter as more representative of reality while defenders of Elias's concept argue that the nuances of his thesis have been ignored or misunderstood. Ultra-realists responded by pointing out that the roots of the pseudo-pacification process were in 12th-century England. It is an alternative theory rooted in a time that predates the roots of the civilizing process in 17th century Europe.
Further criticisms focused on ultra-realism's naturalization of violent drives, the incoherence of the connection between the pseudo-pacification process and special liberty, a tendency towards monocausality, essentialism and reductionism associated with the 'direct causality' of the economic context, the denial of human agency, and neglect of gender relations as epiphenomenal. Ultra-realists responded by pointing out that special liberty motivates and permits individuals to move beyond the legal and normative boundaries of pseudo-pacification, therefore they are integrated parts of the same process. The ultra realist concept of the 'chosen unconscious' suggests that the thesis is grounded in agency and choice. The economic context is probabilistic, not directly causal, because ultra-realists use crime trends as initial indicators of the need for further investigation using ethnographic methods to investigate the complex relations between economy, culture, and individual situations. Gender relations have featured centrally in ultra-realist research.
More recent debates have discussed the possibility that ultra-realism doesn't offer anything new, its causal logic is tautological and can't be falsified, and the transcendental materialist framework is unverifiable. Ultra-realists responded by arguing that concepts such as the pseudo-pacification process and special liberty are unique to ultra-realism. Whereas ultra-realists agreed that they require more research to address the issue of falsification, Hall and Winlow also agreed with Lakatos's claim that Popper's notion is flawed because the falsifying premises themselves are often preferences that have evaded falsification. The criticism that the transcendental materialist framework is currently unverified has been accepted. Hall and Winlow addressed this issue by integrating recent neuroscientific and neuropsychoanalytic work into their theoretical framework. This produced the concept of 'the molecular question', the combined biological, affective and metaphysical process that seems to underlie what Lacan proposed as a 'void'.