| Language desk | ||
|---|---|---|
| < January 14 | << Dec | January | Feb >> | January 16 > |
| Welcome to the Wikipedia Language Reference Desk Archives |
|---|
| The page you are currently viewing is an archive page. While you can leave answers for any questions shown below, please ask new questions on one of the current reference desk pages. |
Hello. Is the phrase "It would be remiss of me" considered good formal English? I know it is better to say "I would be remiss to..." but the parallel construction I am working with right now would make that very awkward. Thanks. 24.92.85.35 (talk) 17:42, 15 January 2012 (UTC)
I've taken quite some time to write what I now have, but there are a few areas in it that I feel could do with a bit of improving or even be re-written completely. If you help me improve any areas that you might think weak or substitute words in there with better ones where and if it is needed, it will help me not only here and now, but it will also help me in the future as it will contribute to improve my understanding of the english language which I'm trying to improve, even though I think my english already is decent. _________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Here it goes:
Before them stood an old, hooded man with a strange-looking staff and a long white beard reaching almost down to his belly. He were dressed in old purple robes which may once have looked exquisitely grand and majestic, having showed him as a man of importance, but now it looked worn and its once rich color had long since faded from years and lengthy use. No doubt these robes had been a constant companion of his on many a journey. Although the long white beard had easily revealed him as an aged man it was first when he removed his large hood that one could actually see his face; he looked a man just past sixty, with a bald head and deep lines running across the forehead and around his blue eyes. He greeted them with a simple “hello”. His voice was deep and husky like was typical of an old man, but it did not sound frail and he did not otherwise seem like a typical sixty-year old. He stood upright like a young man, healthy and strong, and he did not lean on his staff as much as he carried it. Also, there was something about his eyes that made him look more… alive than one might have expected, like as if he had the eyes of a younger man. __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
I've highlighted the words/areas that I'm most displeased about in "fat writing" and which I think is in the most need of improving. I'm otherwise generally quite pleased with what I have managed, but I'm sure there's always room for improvement.
The Highlighted areas:
- I'm unsure whether its right to use both deep and husky to describe the one and same voice as these two words have very similar meaning.
- As for the other two areas I have highlighted I kind of lack the words to describe what I want... I think I manage to say what I want to say, but I feel that I say it in clumsy ways due to lacking the right words. So I guess I'm looking spesifically for ways to improve these two sentences and my english skills.
88.90.31.111 (talk) 21:12, 15 January 2012 (UTC)
thanks for feedback so far. I'm a bit prone to fall into the trap of changing to singular from plural in some cases. Probably because of the way my own language works, which differs a little bit in that regard from english.
As for me claiming 60 years to be old, you are right of course, and it is my bad to forget to mention that this old man is a man of the old days - from the middle ages you might say. People had shorter lives back then, and 60 years would be counted as old. But you make a fair point, seeing as i forgot to mention this. I apologize. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 88.90.31.111 (talk) 21:57, 15 January 2012 (UTC) "it was first when he removed..." — I think you mean "it was only". Choyoołʼįįhí:Seb az86556 > haneʼ 22:30, 15 January 2012 (UTC)
Thanks goes also to the one who gave the last of three replies so far. You seem to have a bit of knowledge about this and you explain very well the reasons for your views. Your feedbacks are strict :P but that is good, I need that. You make some good points and I will try to take lesson from them. 88.90.31.111 (talk) 22:50, 15 January 2012 (UTC)
I would rewrite it like this:
Before them wearing a hood stood an old man, a long white beard covering his chest. In his hand he bore a staff of gnarled wood, sinewy and two-toned. The purple robes he wore may have once proclaimed his prominence. They may have accompanied him on important journeys. But now they were faded from use. A bald head was revealed when he removed his hood. Deep lines traversed his forehead. His eyes were blue. His greeting was simple. His voice issued forth voice deep and throaty without a trace of frailty. He carried his own staff—his stature upright and steady. His eyes were unexpectedly youthful.
I've taken the liberty of leaving a lot out, and rearranging some of the ideas, and just using expressions that I like. I've elaborated on the man's staff—if it was "strange-looking" I wanted to describe it. You may want to assign different qualities to it. Bus stop (talk) 23:02, 15 January 2012 (UTC)
Before them stood an old, hooded man holding a strange-looking staff, his long white beard reaching almost down to his belly. He was dressed in ancient purple robes which may at one time have looked exquisitely grand and majestic, showing him as a man of importance, but now looking worn and faded, their once rich color long since darkened by the years of lengthy use, a constant companion on many of his journeys.
Although the long white beard had revealed him as an aged man, it wasn't until he removed his large hood that one could actually see his face; he looked like a man just past sixty, with a bald head and deep lines running across his forehead and around his (piercing/soulful/timeless/knowing/etc.) blue eyes.
He greeted them with a simple "Hello", his voice deep and husky, most unlike that of the typically frail voice of an old man - nor did he seem much like a typical sixty-year old as he stood upright, healthy and strong, carrying the staff rather than leaning on it for support. Similarly, there was something about his eyes that made him look more alive than one might have expected, as if he had the (keen/bright/etc.) eyes of a younger man. Chaosdruid (talk) 02:35, 16 January 2012 (UTC)
No need for anyone to disagree or worry about me copying directly from what you say. All advise given here have proven good advise, even the ones I don't use. It still helps to see how other people would express the same thing that I am trying to express. It helps me to see how things can be done, not necessarily how it must be done. As one of you said before, it's usually more than one way to do/achieve something. It is important that I keep the orignality of what I first wrote, I agree about that, because I'm the one doing it.
I learned from much of what you said, not only in regard to this particular writing about the old man, but in general as well. Some of the mistakes you have pointed out are obvious ones which I already knew deep down, but I needed someone to highlight them for me before I could see them. Besides, I was also out to improve my vocabulary a little, which I did.
I might paste my finished version here soon, IF I finish it relatively soon. I haven't really decided yet the appearance of the staff (except that it's a wizard's staff with a gem placed on the tip) or how to make the transition at the end to allow myself to continue writing from here. So there's also chance I'll end up writing at another front for a while :P Tnx again — Preceding unsigned comment added by 88.90.31.111 (talk) 12:23, 16 January 2012 (UTC) ____________________________________________________________________________________
This is what I have decided to go with, if of any interest:
____________
Before them stood an old, hooded man with a strange-looking staff of gnarled wood and a long white beard reaching down to just below his chest. He was dressed in old purple robes which may once have looked exquisite, having showed him as a man of importance, but now they looked worn and their once rich color had long since faded from years of lengthy use. No doubt these robes had accompanied him on many a journey. Although the long white beard had easily revealed him as an aged man, it was only when he removed his large hood that one could actually see his face. He looked a man just past sixty, with a bald head and deep lines running across the forehead and around his knowing blue eyes. He greeted them with a simple “hello.” His voice was deep and husky, in keeping with his advanced years, but it lacked the frailty that was typical in an old man’s voice, and he didn’t otherwise seem like a typical sixty-year old either. He stood upright like a young man, healthy, lean and strong, and Galverey took notice that he did not lean on his staff as much as carry it. There was something about his eyes as well that made him look more alive than Galverey might have expected from a man his age, as if he had the eyes of a younger man. There was little doubt that this had to be the wizard from Nalanther that the prior had spoken of.
____________
I liked the word "gnarled", and it described well what I was aiming for so I had to put that in. As for more details on the staff, it will be described very soon, after or in tandem with the dialogue that is about to start off between the old wizard and the named man (main character). As for someone saying that one or two of my sentences were too long and confusing, I have split sentence 4 into what is now sentence 4 and 5. I see it works better, and usually I do aim to avoid making too long sentences. I will keep doing that. I also removed two adjectives (Grand and majestic) from sentence 2 to make it less... confusing as u said. I think this also works better. Other than that I feel some minor changes done to the last half improved things a great deal. "In keeping with his advanced years", I liked that one.
There's two minor things: in the sentence second to last I use the word "alive", but I also considered "lively". I didn't quite manage to decide which one worked best but I felt I had to go with "alive".
Also, "...deep lines running across the forehead and around his knowing blue eyes." here I considered the possibility of instead saying "...deep lines running across the forehead and around a pair of knowing blue eyes."
Anyway, I certainly found these lines challenging tnx for replies.
88.90.31.111 (talk) 14:03, 16 January 2012 (UTC)