1968–69 Aston Villa F.C. season

Aston Villa
1968–69 season
PresidentSir Theodore Pritchett
Chairman(1) Norman Smith
(2) Doug Ellis
Manager(1) Tommy Cummings
(2) Arthur Cox (caretaker)
(3) Tommy Docherty
StadiumVilla Park
Second Division18th
FA CupFifth round
League CupSecond round
Second City Derby
31--23--23

The 1968–69 English football season was Aston Villa's 70th season in the Football League, playing in the Football League Second Division for the second consecutive season. The era was one of conspicuous underachievement. Aston Villa had been in decline for several years; the club had an ageing five-man board "who had failed to adapt to the new football reality". The club had neither developed a scouting network nor an effective coaching structure.

Events off the pitch came to a head in November 1968. With Villa lying at the bottom of Division Two, the board sacked Tommy Cummings, installing first-team trainer-coach, Arthur Cox, as caretaker. On 21 November 1968 the problems in the boardroom were highlighted when, under pressure from a militant group of supporters and shareholders, board member George Robinson resigned. Following his resignation, the board issued a statement: "[The board] would make available, by their resignation, such seats as new financial arrangements might require". Aston Villa F.C. was up for sale. After much speculation London financier Pat Matthews was tasked with restructuring the finances and installing new directors. He recruited Tommy Docherty and brought in local travel agent Doug Ellis as chair of the new board that was convened on 16 December 1968. Two days later Docherty was appointed as manager, his third club in six weeks after his resignation from Rotherham United and a brief spell at Queens Park Rangers.

In the pre-season, newspapers reported the arrival of Argentinian International Oscar Arce, formerly of Peñarol and Rosario Central. He was reportedly valued at £100,000 (at the time Martin Chivers was the League record signing at £125,000). Following Arce joining, in July 1968, Peter Doherty was appointed chief scout. Arce made seven appearance for the reserves, but, while skilful, he was criticised for his temperament, fitness and lack of effort. The club bought him out of his contract. There were debuts for Brian Tiler (107), Mike Ferguson (38), Dave Simmons (17), John Griffiths (3), John Chambers (2), and Barry Lynch (2). After just two years at Blackburn Barrie Hole (47) moved, this time to Aston Villa for £60,000 in September 1968. In a disappointing season, Hole won the Aston Villa Lions Club Terrace Trophy for the best player at Aston Villa as decided by the fans.

Second Division

Pos Team Pld W D L GF GA GAv Pts
16 Bristol City 42 11 16 15 46 53 0.868 38
17 Bolton Wanderers 42 12 14 16 55 67 0.821 38
18 Aston Villa 42 12 14 16 37 48 0.771 38
19 Blackburn Rovers 42 13 11 18 52 63 0.825 37
20 Oxford United 42 12 9 21 34 55 0.618 33
Source: [citation needed]
Rules for classification: 1) Points; 2) Goal average; 3) Goals scored

Matches

10 August 1968 1 Sheffield United 3–1 Aston Villa Bramall Lane
Report (Willie Anderson), 79' (pen.)
Note: Mike Ferguson made his debut.
17 August 1968 2 Aston Villa 1–1 Fulham Villa Park
(John Woodward), 84' Report
Note:
19 August 1968 3 Aston Villa 1–1 Millwall Villa Park
(Willie Anderson), 26' (pen.) Report
24 August 1968 4 Blackburn Rovers 2–0 Aston Villa Ewood Park
Report
26 August 1968 5 Aston Villa 1–0 Bristol City Villa Park
(John Woodward), 73' Report
31 August 1968 6 Aston Villa 0–1 Blackpool Villa Park
Report
Note: Manager Tommy Cummings had set a target of ten points from the first six matches. Defeat to Blackpool meant they had actually achieved four.
7 September 1968 7 Derby County 3–1 Aston Villa Baseball Ground
Report (Mike Ferguson), 86'
14 September 1968 8 Aston Villa 1–1 Hull City Villa Park
(Willie Anderson), 46' Report
18 September 1968 9 Bolton Wanderers 4–1 Aston Villa Burnden Park
Report (Brian Godfrey), 64'
21 September 1968 10 Birmingham City 4–0 Aston Villa St Andrew's
Report
Note: In the Second City derby both teams won their home game.
28 September 1968 11 Aston Villa 2–0 Oxford United Villa Park
(Barrie Hole), 42' (Brian Godfrey), 83' Report
5 October 1968 12 Cardiff City 1–1 Aston Villa Ninian Park
Report (Brian Godfrey), 72'
8 October 1968 13 Bristol City 1–0 Aston Villa Ashton Gate
Report
12 October 1968 14 Aston Villa 1–1 Crystal Palace Villa Park
(Willie Anderson), 78' (pen.) Report
19 October 1968 15 Norwich City 1–1 Aston Villa Carrow Road
Report (Lew Chatterley), 3'
26 October 1968 16 Aston Villa 0–0 Carlisle United Villa Park
Report
2 November 1968 17 Huddersfield Town 3–1 Aston Villa Leeds Road
Report (Mike Ferguson), 3'
9 November 1968 18 Aston Villa 0–1 Preston North End Villa Park
Report
Note:
16 November 1968 19 Portsmouth 2–0 Aston Villa Fratton Park
Report
Note:
23 November 1968 20 Aston Villa 1–0 Middlesbrough Villa Park
(Own goal), 73' Report Attendance: 15,281
Note:
30 November 1968 21 Bury 3–2 Aston Villa Gigg Lane
Report (John Woodward), 50' (Willie Anderson), 59'
Note:
7 December 1968 22 Aston Villa 0–0 Charlton Athletic Villa Park
Report Attendance: 12,747
Note: The lowest gate of the season. GK John Dunn, CBs Dick Edwards, Fred Turnbull, RB Mick Wright, LB Charlie Aitken, Ms Alan Deakin, (33' for Brian Greenhalgh), Lionel Martin, Mike Ferguson, Willie Anderson, F Brian Godfrey, Peter Broadbent.
14 December 1968 23 Crystal Palace 4–2 Aston Villa Selhurst Park
Report (Lionel Martin), 75' (Dick Edwards), 88'
Note:
21 December 1968 24 Aston Villa 2–1 Norwich City Villa Park
(Dick Edwards), 4' (Barrie Hole), 82' Report Attendance: 19,923
Note: Barrie Hole, returning from a two-week club suspension, scored the second. The pre-Christmas fixture was typically the lowest gate of the season but, on 18 December Tommy Docherty had been announced the manager, and an additional 7,000 attended in comparison to the previous home game. Despite his appointment, Docherty left Arthur Cox and Peter Doherty in charge of the team, choosing to observe the match as a learning exercise.
26 December 1968 25 Aston Villa 2–0 Cardiff City Villa Park
(Barrie Hole), 31' (Brian Tiler), 70' Report Attendance: 41,250
Note: Brian Tiler scored the second on his debut on an 'unplayable' icy pitch. Tiler had been with Tommy Docherty at Rotherham and was the reason the new manager had only lasted 29 days at his previous club, Queens Park Rangers. Docherty had wished to sign Tiler but Rangers' chairman, John Gregory, baulked at Rotherham's £100,000 asking price prompting Docherty to walk-out on the club. The new Villa chairman, Doug Ellis managed to half the asking price and Tiler was installed as club captain in a team that had long since lost its way. The pre-Christmas fixture had typically been the lowest gate of the season but a healthy 19,923 had attended, buoyed by the new regime. Dochery went to the local papers: "My name is not Oliver, its Tommy. The 19,000 for Norwich was great. But please can I have some more...". Despite the atrocious weather, he was not disappointed.
28 December 1968 26 Carlisle United 0–1 Aston Villa Brunton Park
Report (Willie Anderson), 65'
Note: With many matches postponed due to weather, the media spotlight fell on this match. Carlisle were previously thirteen matches unbeaten but were undone by a single Willie Anderson goal on a rock-hard pitch. Carlisle manager Bob Stokoe was ungracious in defeat stating "I would rather sweep the streets than play like that..." referring to Villa's negative play and time-wasting tactics. Docherty hit back at Stokoe stating "he could get his fingers burnt" and threatened a complaint to the Football League.
11 January 1969 27 Aston Villa 1–0 Huddersfield Town Villa Park
(Barrie Hole), 8' Report
18 January 1969 28 Preston North End 1–0 Aston Villa Deepdale
Report
1 February 1969 29 Aston Villa 2–0 Portsmouth Villa Park
(Dave Rudge), 53' (Brian Godfrey), 78' Report
15 February 1969 30 Aston Villa 1–0 Bury Villa Park
(Dave Rudge), 73' Report
22 February 1969 31 Charlton Athletic 1–1 Aston Villa The Valley
Report (Dave Simmons), 4'
1 March 1969 32 Aston Villa 3–1 Sheffield United Villa Park
(Barrie Hole), 4' (Dave Simmons), 58' (Dave Simmons), 69' Report
4 March 1969 33 Middlesbrough 0–0 Aston Villa Ayresome Park
Report
8 March 1969 34 Fulham 1–1 Aston Villa Craven Cottage
Report (Own goal), 15'
15 March 1969 35 Aston Villa 1–1 Blackburn Rovers Villa Park
(Dave Simmons), 39' Report
22 March 1969 36 Blackpool 1–1 Aston Villa Bloomfield Road
Report (Brian Godfrey), 2'
29 March 1969 37 Aston Villa 0–1 Derby County Villa Park
Report
4 April 1969 38 Millwall 0–1 Aston Villa The Den
Report (Lionel Martin), 83'
5 April 1969 39 Oxford United 0–1 Aston Villa Manor Ground
Report
8 April 1969 40 Aston Villa 1–1 Bolton Wanderers Villa Park
(Own goal), 14' Report
12 April 1969 41 Aston Villa 1–0 Birmingham City Villa Park
(Dave Simmons), 55' Report
Note: In the Second City derby both teams won their home game.
19 April 1969 42 Hull City 1–0 Aston Villa Boothferry Park
Report
Note:

Source: avfchistory.co.uk

FA Cup

Third round proper

The 44 First and Second Division clubs entered the competition at this stage. The matches were scheduled for Saturday, 4 January 1969. Seven matches were drawn and went to replays. Kettering Town was the last non-league club left in the competition.

Tie no Home team Score Away team Date
8Aston Villa2–1Queens Park Rangers4 January 1969

Fourth round proper

The matches were scheduled for Saturday, 25 January 1969. Six matches were drawn and went to replays.

Tie no Home team Score Away team Date
3Southampton2–2Aston Villa25 January 1969
ReplayAston Villa2–1Southampton29 January 1969

Fifth round proper

The matches were scheduled for Saturday, 8 February 1969. However, for the first time in history, the entire fifth round draw for the FA Cup was unable to be played due to heavy snowfall across England, and the matches were replayed at various times after this date. Most took place by the following Wednesday (one of these requiring a replay), two were played a fortnight later, but the final match was not played until 1 March and required a replay two days later.

Tie no Home team Score Away team Date
5Tottenham Hotspur3–2Aston Villa12 February 1969

League Cup

Second round

Home team Score Away team Date
Aston Villa1–4Tottenham Hotspur4 September 1968