Critical response to A Lively Mind was negative. At Metacritic, which assigns a normalised rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream critics, the album has received an average score of 40, based on 9 reviews. The album was nominated for the Grammy Award for Best Dance/Electronica Album in 2007.
↑Bronson, Kevin (28 May 2006). "Trapped by conventions". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 18 May 2026. Instead of finding a different voice as a writer and producer of original material, Oakenfold seems trapped by dance-music genre conventions.
↑"Paul Oakenfold: A Lively Mind". Spin. Vol.22, no.6. June 2006. p.83. These thumping, Ibiza-inflected excursions into pop and R&B aren't quite as catchy
↑"Paul Oakenfold: A Lively Mind". Uncut. No.109. June 2006. p.108. It'll work neither in the club or in the home.
↑"Paul Oakenfold: A Lively Mind". URB. No.135. April 2006. p.90. Mind plays like a collection of tracks destined for car commercials, Hollywood movies and Superbowl half-time shows.