The Batter Up controller worked by sensing the timing of the swing and simulating a fire button press in response, so it was compatible with a wide range of games that supported a sufficiently simple control scheme. Sports Sciences also made TeeV Golf, a similar motion-sensing controller for golf games which had to be configured using a card for each game it supported.
According to a 1995 press release, Batter Up was chosen as a winner of Innovations '95 by the Consumer Electronics Show.
Popular Science included Batter Up in their list of 1994's 100 Greatest Achievements in Science and Technology. Wired included it in their roundup of new products in April 1995, saying Who says videogames encourage lethargy?... I wonder what would happen if you used it to play Mortal Kombat?, and Playboy similarly highlighted it as a cool sports gadget in March 1995. Men's Health identified Batter Up as part of a 1995 trend for exertainment products that combined exercise equipment and computers.
Electronic Games reviewed the Sega Genesis version of Batter Up in April 1995, with reviewer Ed Dille noting that the controller was limited to sensing the timing of the swing and not the direction, and describing it as more a toy than a tool.
Steve Bauman reviewed the PC version for Computer Games Strategy Plus in October 1995, again noting the limitations of the sensors, but saying that it was one of the cheapest ways to add a pseudo-virtual reality device to your PC... still the ultimate party favor for your next baseball get-together.
123Jacobs, David (April 1995). "Fetish". Wired. Vol.3, no.4. p.59. Retrieved July 17, 2026.
12Bauman, Steve (October 1995). "Review: Batter Up". Computer Games Strategy Plus. No.59. p.119. Retrieved July 17, 2026.
↑Albert Kim, "Get In There, Scottie! Playing with an NBA star is only one thing you can do with these new titles[link removed]" Sports Illustrated Vault (December 12, 1994).
12Dille, Ed (April 1995). "Batter Up!". Electronic Games. Vol.3, no.7. p.64. Retrieved July 17, 2026.
12Herman, Leonard (July 2018). "The Sporting Life". Old School Gamer Magazine. No.5. p.19. Retrieved July 19, 2026.