Causality conditions are classifications of Lorentzian manifolds according to the types of causal structures they admit. In the study of spacetimes, there exists a hierarchy of causality conditions which are important in proving mathematical theorems about the global structure of such manifolds. These conditions were collected during the late 1970s.
The weaker the causality condition on a spacetime, the more unphysical the spacetime is. Spacetimes with closed timelike curves, for example, present severe interpretational difficulties. See the grandfather paradox.
It is reasonable to believe that any physical spacetime will satisfy the strongest causality condition: global hyperbolicity. For such spacetimes the equations in general relativity can be posed as an initial value problem on a Cauchy surface.
There is a hierarchy of causality conditions, each one of which is strictly stronger than the previous. This is sometimes called the causal ladder. The conditions, from weakest to strongest, are:
Given are the definitions of these causality conditions for a Lorentzian manifold . Where two or more are given they are equivalent.
Notation:
(See causal structure for definitions of , and , .)
A spacetime is called distinguishing when it is both future and past distinguishing, that is, when each point is determined (distinguished) by its chronological future and also by its chronological past.
For each of the weaker causality conditions defined above, there are some manifolds satisfying the condition which can be made to violate it by arbitrarily small perturbations of the metric. A spacetime is called stably causal if it satisfies any of the following equivalent conditions:
Hawking (1969) proved that condition 1 implies 2, and Bernal and Sánchez (2005) proved that 2 implies 3, while it is not difficult to check that condition 3 implies 1. See Sánchez for a detailed account, as well as its relation with the folk problems of smoothability
A spacetime is called causally continuous when it satisfies: (a) it is distinguishing and (b) the chronological future and past varies continuously with the point .
There are several ways to express formally the meaning of this continuity. One of them starts by regarding and as set-valued functions from the manifold into the set of parts of (i.e., the points of are the subsets of ). Notice that is endowed with a topology, and a topology on can be defined as follows. For any compact , the subsets of not intersecting form a subset of , which is defined as open, then, these open sets are a base for the required topology. Thus, the condition (b) means that the maps are continuous as maps on topological spaces.
A spacetime is called causally simple when it satisfies: (a) it is causal and (b) and are closed for every point.
Hawking and Ellis (1973), Beem, Ehrlich and Easley (1996) and others traditionally required the condition of strong causality. However, following a result by Bernal and Sánchez (2007), the simpler condition of causality is now used in the definition.
Robert Geroch showed that a spacetime is globally hyperbolic if and only if there exists a Cauchy surface for . This means that:
Moreover, it also admits the global orthogonal splitting obtained by Bernal and Sánchez (2005), thus showing that space and time can be globally distinguished (in a highly non-unique way).
It is worth pointing out that all the levels of the ladder are preserved when narrowing the cones (that is, when the original metric is replaced by a metric whose causal vectors are included in the causal vectors for ), except causal continuity and causal simplicity, as shown by García-Parrado and Sánchez with an explicit counterexample.