First Rutte cabinet

First Rutte cabinet
Rutte–Verhagen cabinet

Cabinet of the Netherlands
Installation of the cabinet by Queen Beatrix at Huis ten Bosch on 14 October 2010
Date formed14 October 2010 (2010-10-14)
Date dissolved5 November 2012 (2012-11-05)
2 years, 22 days in office
(Demissionary from 23 April 2012 (2012-04-23))
People and organisations
Monarch
Queen Beatrix
Prime Minister
Mark Rutte
Deputy Prime Minister
Maxime Verhagen
No. of ministers
12
Ministers removed
1
Total no. of members
13
Member party
  People's Party for Freedom and Democracy (VVD)
  Christian Democratic Appeal (CDA)
  Party for Freedom (PVV) (Confidence and supply)
Status in legislature
Right-wing minority government
History
Incoming formation
2010 formation
Outgoing formation
2012 formation
Election2010 election
Outgoing election
2012 election
Legislature terms2010–2012
PredecessorFourth Balkenende cabinet
SuccessorSecond Rutte cabinet

The first Rutte cabinet, also called the Rutte–Verhagen cabinet was the executive branch of the government of the Netherlands from 14 October 2010 until 5 November 2012. The cabinet was formed by the conservative-liberal People's Party for Freedom and Democracy (VVD) and the Christian-democratic Christian Democratic Appeal (CDA) after the election of 2010. The cabinet was a right-wing coalition and had a minority in the House of Representatives but had confidence and supply from the Party for Freedom (PVV) for a slim majority with Liberal Leader Mark Rutte serving as Prime Minister. Christian Democratic Leader Maxime Verhagen served as Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Economic Affairs, Agriculture and Innovation.

The cabinet served in the early years of the 2010s. Domestically, it had to deal with the fallout of the 2008 financial crisis but it was able to implement several major social reforms to law enforcement, victims' rights and immigration. Internationally, it had to deal with the European debt crisis, the war on terror and the government support for the Task Force Uruzgan. The cabinet suffered several major internal and external conflicts because of the confidence and supply construction from the Party for Freedom. The cabinet fell just 18 months into its term on 23 April 2012 after the Party for Freedom withdrew its support following a disagreeing with the coalition over stronger austerity measures to reduce the deficit following the 2008 financial crisis. The cabinet continued in a demissionary capacity until it was replaced by the second Rutte cabinet following the election of 2012.

Formation

Composition of the cabinet in relation to the rest of the legislature

Following the collapse of the fourth Balkenende cabinet on 20 February 2010, elections for the House of Representatives were held on 9 June 2010. As usual in Dutch politics, none of the parties had a majority and several informateurs were appointed to investigate the formation of a coalition cabinet. A broad coalition consisting of the People's Party for Freedom and Democracy (VVD), Christian Democratic Appeal (CDA) and the Labour Party (PvdA) was briefly looked at, but dismissed. Then negotiations for a "purple plus" coalition consisting of the VVD, PvdA, Democrats 66 and GreenLeft lasted for about three weeks, but the parties could not reach agreement on the amount of budget cuts.

Finally, a construction which is rare for the Netherlands was investigated: a minority coalition consisting of the VVD and Christian Democratic Appeal (together 52 out of 150 seats in the House of Representatives), supported in parliament by the Party for Freedom (PVV, 24 seats), to make the smallest possible majority of 76 seats. The right wing PVV had the largest gains in the recent elections.

The stated reason for this construction was that parties agreed that the largest party (the VVD) and the party with the largest gains (considered the 'winner' in Dutch politics) needed to be in power. Only CDA could or wanted to help make a majority, but they were against forming a proper coalition with PVV because of their different views on Islam and immigration. Therefore, negotiations were held to form a coalition agreement between the VVD and CDA), and to form a "parliamentary support agreement" between all three parties, which were successfully finished on 30 September 2010.

When Rutte took office on 14 October, it marked the first time that the VVD had led a government since its formation in 1946. It also marked the first liberal-led government since 1913.

Opposition parties and commentators expected that the coalition would prove to be unstable because at a special Christian Democratic Appeal conference, about a third of the party members voted against the formation of this cabinet. Also, at least three members of parliament in the CDA parliamentary fraction indicated to have difficulties with the cabinet. Eventually they left the parliament or supported the deal, pointing to the approval by the majority of the party conference.

When the cabinet took office, the three parties had a minority in the Senate of 35 out of 75 seats. The parties hoped this would change following the Dutch Senate election of 2011, but they obtained 37 seats, one short of a majority. A small protestant party, the Reformed Political Party, which obtained one seat, supported the cabinet in the Senate however.

The cabinet consisted of 12 Ministers and 8 State secretaries. The positions where divided equally among the coalition members, regardless of their respective size: People's Party for Freedom and Democracy (31 seats in parliament) supplied 6 Ministers and 4 State secretaries, and Christian Democratic Appeal (21 seats) also supplied 6 Ministers and 4 State secretaries.

Term

Policy

In accordance with the People's Party for Freedom and Democracy (VVD) approach to laissez-faire and a small government, the number of ministers and State Secretaries was reduced from the previous cabinet by merging several ministries. The Ministry of Agriculture, Nature and Food Quality was merged with the Ministry of Economic Affairs to form a combined Ministry Economic Affairs, Agriculture and Innovation. The Ministry of Housing, Spatial Planning and the Environment was merged with the Ministry of Transport and Water Management to form the new Ministry of Infrastructure and the Environment.

The portfolio of public security was transferred from the Ministry of the Interior and Kingdom Relations to the Ministry of Justice which was renamed as the Ministry of Security and Justice, in line with the tough security profile of the coalition parties, especially the VVD which delivered both the minister and state secretary for this department. Also the position of the Minister for Development Cooperation, a long serving Minister without portfolio title that had been used continuously since 1965 (except for a small break from 2002 to 2003), was scrapped and replaced by the return of a Minister without portfolio for Immigration and Asylum Affairs like in the previous Cabinets Balkenende I, II and III, but this time this post was placed at the department and budget of the Ministry of the Interior and Kingdom Relations instead of the Ministry of Security and Justice.

Withdrawal of support of the Party for Freedom

Because of the financial crisis in the Netherlands and because of the rules of the Euro convergence criteria that the deficit should be maximum 3%, the Leaders of the People's Party for Freedom and Democracy Mark Rutte, Christian Democratic Appeal Maxime Verhagen and the Party for Freedom Geert Wilders decided to talk with each other about new, severe austerity measures, worth about 14 billion Euro. The negotiations about the measures were held in the Catshuis and lasted 7 weeks and ended on 21 April when Geert Wilders walked out of the negotiations. The reason he gave was that the measure would negatively impact people who receive benefits from the pensions law. Both Mark Rutte and Maxime Verhagen blamed Wilders for the failure of the negotiations. As a result, the government resigned and a new election was called.

Composition changes

On 16 December 2011, Minister of the Interior and Kingdom Relations Piet Hein Donner (CDA) resigned after he was nominated as the new Vice-President of the Council of State succeeding Herman Tjeenk Willink. He was replaced as Minister of the Interior and Kingdom Relations by former Chairwoman of the Christian Democratic Appeal Liesbeth Spies. Piet Hein Donner as Minister of the Interior and Kingdom Relations was responsible for the portfolio of Integration. When he resigned the Integration portfolio was transferred to Minister without portfolio Gerd Leers.

Cabinet members

Ministers
Ministers Title/Ministry Term of office Party
Begin End
Mark Rutte Mark Rutte
(born 1967)		 Prime Minister General Affairs 14 October 2010 5 November 2012[Continued] VVD
Maxime Verhagen Maxime Verhagen
(born 1956)		 Deputy
Prime Minister		 Economic Affairs,
Agriculture and
Innovation		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012 CDA
Minister
Piet Hein Donner Piet Hein Donner
(born 1948)		 Minister Interior and
Kingdom Relations		 14 October 2010 16 December 2011[App] CDA
Liesbeth Spies Liesbeth Spies
(born 1966)		 16 December 2011 5 November 2012 CDA
Uri Rosenthal Dr.
Uri Rosenthal
(born 1945)		 Minister Foreign Affairs 14 October 2010 5 November 2012 VVD
Jan Kees de Jager Jan Kees de Jager
(born 1969)		 Minister Finance 23 February 2010 5 November 2012[Retained] CDA
Ivo Opstelten Ivo Opstelten
(born 1944)		 Minister Security and
Justice		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012[Continued] VVD
Hans Hillen Hans Hillen
(born 1947)		 Minister Defence 14 October 2010 5 November 2012 CDA
Edith Schippers Edith Schippers
(born 1964)		 Minister Health, Welfare
and Sport		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012[Continued] VVD
Henk Kamp Henk Kamp
(born 1952)		 Minister Social Affairs and
Employment		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012 VVD
Marja van Bijsterveldt Marja van
Bijsterveldt
(born 1961)		 Minister Education, Culture
and Science		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012 CDA
Melanie Schultz van Haegen Melanie Schultz
van Haegen
(born 1970)		 Minister Infrastructure and
the Environment		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012[Continued] VVD
Minister without portfolio
Minister Title/Ministry/Portfolio(s) Term of office Party
Begin End
Gerd Leers Gerd Leers
(born 1951)		 Minister Interior and
Kingdom Relations		 • Immigration
and Asylum		 14 October 2010 16 December 2011 CDA
• Immigration
and Asylum
• Integration
• Minorities		 16 December 2011 5 November 2012
State Secretaries
State Secretary Title/Ministry/Portfolio(s) Term of office Party
Begin End
Ben Knapen Dr.
Ben Knapen
(born 1951)		 State Secretary
[Title]		 Foreign Affairs • European Union
• Benelux
• Development
Cooperation		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012 CDA
Frans Weekers Frans Weekers
(born 1967)		 State Secretary Finance • Fiscal Policy
• Tax and Customs
• Governmental
Budget		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012[Continued] VVD
Fred Teeven Fred Teeven
(born 1958)		 State Secretary
[Title]		 Security and
Justice		 • Public
Prosecution
• Civil Law
• Property Law
• Victims' Rights
• Judicial Reform
• Youth Justice
• Penitentiaries
• Debt
• Gambling
[Title]		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012[Continued] VVD
Henk Bleker Dr.
Henk Bleker
(born 1953)		 State Secretary
[Title]		 Economic Affairs,
Agriculture and
Innovation		 • Trade and Export
• Agriculture
• Food Policy
• Fisheries
• Forestry
• Postal Service
• Tourism
• Animal Welfare		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012 CDA
Marlies Veldhuijzen van Zanten Marlies
Veldhuijzen
van Zanten
(born 1953)		 State Secretary Health, Welfare
and Sport		 • Elderly Care
• Youth Care
• Disability Policy
• Medical Ethics
• Pharmaceutical
Policy		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012 CDA
Paul de Krom Paul de Krom
(born 1963)		 State Secretary Social Affairs and
Employment		 • Social Security
• Unemployment
• Occupational
Safety
• Social Services		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012 VVD
Halbe Zijlstra Halbe Zijlstra
(born 1969)		 State Secretary Education, Culture
and Science		 • Higher
Education
• Adult
Education
• Science Policy
• Culture
• Art		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012 VVD
Joop Atsma Joop Atsma
(born 1956)		 State Secretary Infrastructure and
the Environment		 • Aviation
• Water
Management
• Environmental
Policy
• Weather
Forecasting		 14 October 2010 5 November 2012 CDA
Continued in the next cabinet
Retained from the previous cabinet
Designated with the diplomatic rank of Minister
Appointed as Vice-President of the Council of State

References

  1. ↑ "Mark Rutte: eerste liberale premier sinds 1918" (in Dutch). eenvandaag.nl. 7 October 2010. Archived from the original on 26 May 2012. Retrieved 23 April 2012.
  2. ↑ "CV | Mark Rutte". rijksoverheid.nl. Archived from the original on 20 March 2012. Retrieved 23 April 2012.
  3. ↑ "Mark Rutte" (in Dutch). VVD. Archived from the original on 26 July 2014. Retrieved 15 September 2020.
  4. ↑ (in Dutch) Benoeming Spies tot minister vrijdag verwacht, NOS, 15 December 2011
  5. ↑ (in Dutch) Donner naar Raad van State, NOS, 16 December 2011
  6. ↑ (in Dutch) 'Spies volgt Donner op in kabinet', NU.nl, 16 December 2011