Jay Johnston

Jay Johnston
Born (1968-10-22) October 22, 1968 (age 58)
EducationColumbia College Chicago (BA)
Occupations
  • Actor
  • comedian
  • handyman
Years active1995–2022
Children1

Jay James Johnston (born October 22, 1968) is an American former actor, comedian and handyman. He was a writer and cast member on Mr. Show with Bob and David and had roles on The Sarah Silverman Program, Moral Orel, Arrested Development, Bob's Burgers, and Mr. Pickles, as well as the lattermost's spin-off Momma Named Me Sheriff.

Johnston participated in the United States Capitol attack on January 6, 2021, and was arrested and charged on June 7, 2023. Following the incident, Johnston was fired from his longtime role as Jimmy Pesto on Bob's Burgers; he has not appeared in any films or television shows since. He pleaded guilty on July 8, 2024, and was sentenced to one year and one day in prison on October 28, 2024, but was pardoned by Donald Trump in January 2025.

Early life and education

Johnston was born and raised in Chicago, Illinois. He has a younger brother named Tim. He earned a Bachelor of Arts degree in acting from Columbia College Chicago in 1993.

Career

After graduating from college, Johnston later joined the Chicago Second City's touring comedy for a number of years and also performed in stage shows at the Annoyance Theater in Chicago.

From 1995 to 1998, Johnston worked as a sketch actor and writer on all four seasons of Mr. Show with Bob and David. After the conclusion of Mr. Show, Johnston had a recurring role on Arrested Development, as well as appearing in films such as Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy and Bicentennial Man.

Johnston and fellow Mr. Show regulars Dino Stamatopoulos and Scott Adsit were part of the creative team behind Adult Swim's stop-motion animation series Moral Orel, which ran from 2005 to 2008. Johnston wrote and directed episodes of the series and voiced multiple characters in the first two seasons.

Johnston starred on all three seasons of Comedy Central's The Sarah Silverman Program as "Officer Jay McPherson", the love interest of Sarah Silverman's sister Laura in the series. The series reunited Johnston with Mr. Show cast members Brian Posehn, Scott Aukerman, B. J. Porter, and Paul F. Tompkins.

Johnston had a recurring voice role as Jimmy Pesto Sr. in the Fox animated series Bob's Burgers from 2011 until his firing in 2021. The role was later recast to Eric Bauza in 2023.

Standing well over 6 feet tall, Johnston regularly played police and other law enforcement roles. Since his arrest, he has been a handyman.

United States Capitol attack

Photo released by the Justice Department and Washington Metro police showing Johnston at the riots.

In March 2021, a Twitter message by the FBI was seeking the identity of a man at the January 6 United States Capitol attack who bore a resemblance to Johnston and who was identified as Johnston by friends of the actor. In a December 21, 2021, article by The Daily Beast, two of Johnston's friends said he admitted to being at the Capitol on January 6. After the FBI tweet and the news of his alleged participation, Johnston's friends and colleagues from Mr. Show with Bob and David reached out to Johnston, but received no response. Johnston was fired from Bob's Burgers shortly after being identified.

The FBI arrested Johnston on June 7, 2023, and charged him with felony obstruction of officers during civil disorder as well as several misdemeanor offenses. He was released after paying a $25,000 bond.

Johnston pleaded guilty to a single felony count of obstructing officers during a civil disorder on July 8, 2024. On October 28, 2024, Judge Carl Nichols characterized Johnston's conduct as problematic and reprehensible, and sentenced him to one year and one day in prison, 40 hours of community service, and pay $2,000 in restitution.

In January 2025, Johnston was among those pardoned by Donald Trump when he entered office for his second term.

Personal life

Johnston has a daughter, born in 2011 or 2012. As of October 2024, he was engaged to Sara Radovanovitch.

Filmography

Film

Film work by Jay Johnston
Year Title Role Notes
1998 Jack Frost TV Weatherman
1999 Bicentennial Man Charles
2000 The Independent Soldier
Desperate but Not Serious Mustachioed Cop
2001 Not Another Teen Movie Roadie
Hollywood Palms Young Cop
2002 Men in Black II Agent
The Master of Disguise Rex
2003 Brainwarp Guy Suave Direct-to-video
2004 Anchorman: The Legend of Ron Burgundy Eyewitness News Member
Wake Up, Ron Burgundy: The Lost Movie
2005 Dirty Love Waiter
2006 Tenacious D in The Pick of Destiny Gang Member
2007 Project Clear Visions: The Anthrax Conspiracy Michael Patrick
2008 The Wayside Dad
2009 Secret at Arrow Lake Dr. William Hardin
2011 Demoted Kline
2015 Hell and Back Rick the Lost Soul Voice
2021 Something About Her George
2022 Wing Dad Allen Marcus

Television

Television work by Jay Johnston
Year Title Role Notes
1995 Ellen Transition Guy Episode: "Hello, I Must Be Going"
1995–1998 Mr. Show with Bob and David Various characters 28 episodes; also writer
1997 Just Shoot Me! Exterminator Episode: "Lemon Wacky Hello"
Alright Already Overnight Parcel Guy Episode: "Again with the Porno Video"
1999 Ultimate Trek: Star Trek's Greatest Moments Spock Television film
2000 Tenacious D FBI Agent Episode: "Road Gig"
2001 DAG Chainsaw Episode: "Prom"
Two Guys and a Girl Cab Driver Episode: "An Eye for a Finger"
Spring Break Lawyer Reporter Television film
Curb Your Enthusiasm Jeremy Episode: "Shaq"
2002 Malcolm in the Middle Ed Episode: "Reese Drives"
Next! Various Pilot
2004 Sweetwater Tides Abbott Lewison Television film
Last Laugh '04 Pervert
2004–2013 Arrested Development Officer Taylor 10 episodes
2005 Weekends at the D.L. Bill Combs / Darnell Dickerson 2 episodes
2005–2008 Moral Orel Coach Stopframe / Various voices 30 episodes; also writer and director
2006 American Misfits The Boss 3 episodes
Lovespring International Carl Jason 2 episodes
Last Laugh '06 Officer 'Shuggatitz' Television film
2007 Human Giant Whale Trainer Episode: "Let's Go"; also consultant writer
Bad Dad Drunk Bad Dad Episode #1.2
Larry the Cable Guy's Christmas Spectacular Mormon Guy Television film
2007–2010 The Sarah Silverman Program Officer Jay McPherson 32 episodes
2009 Reno 911! FBI Agent Episode: "Viacom Grinch"
Parks and Recreation Ranger Episode: "Hunting Trip"
2010 Community Police Officer #2 Episode: "The Science of Illusion"
2010–2012 Mary Shelley's Frankenhole The Wolfman / Various voices 11 episodes
2011 Jon Benjamin Has a Van Greg Devlin Episode: "Little Little Italy"
Nick Swardson's Pretend Time Various roles 5 episodes
Guy Suave: Homicidal Spy Guy Suave Television film
2011–2021 Bob's Burgers Jimmy Pesto / Foodie (voice) 43 episodes; replaced by Eric Bauza
2012 Anger Management Rodney Episode: "Charlie Tries to Prove Therapy Is Legit"
NTSF:SD:SUV:: The Letterer Episode: "Wasilla Hills Cop"
2013 Childrens Hospital Capt. Beach-House Episode: "Imaginary Friends"
High School USA! Officer Dumphy (voice) 5 episodes
2013–2019 Mr. Pickles Mr. Goodman / various voices 30 episodes
2014 Comedy Bang! Bang! Repairman Episode: "Ellie Kemper Wears a Purple Ruffled Sleeveless Top & Lavender Flats"
2015 Rick and Morty Coldstone Creamery Employee (voice) Episode: "A Rickle in Time"
W/ Bob & David Various roles 4 episodes; also writer
2016 Modern Family Carl Episode: "Crazy Train"
Hidden America with Jonah Ray John Episode: "Los Angeles: All That Glitters Is Not Gold"
2016–2017 Love Pastor Lewis 4 episodes
2017 Animals Ad Man 4 Episode: "Humans"
2018 Take My Wife Guy Episode #2.3
The 5th Quarter James Naismith Episode: "Hashbrowns & Potaters"
2019 Kevin Hart's Guide to Black History Various roles Television film
Dope State Paul Standinghpin
2019–2021 Momma Named Me Sheriff Mr. Goodman / Buff Swede (voice) 18 episodes
2020 Better Call Saul Don Wachtell Episode: "Wexler v. Goodman"

See also