Jim Thorpe Trophy

The Jim Thorpe Memorial Trophy was an American football award presented by the Newspaper Enterprise Association (NEA) to the most valuable player (MVP) of the National Football League (NFL) from 1955 to 2008. It was the only NFL MVP award whose winner was chosen by a poll of NFL players. By 1975, the Jim Thorpe Trophy was described by the TimesDaily as "one of the pros' most coveted honors." In 1983, the Del Rio News Herald called it the "highest professional football award, period." Earl Campbell was the first player to win the award in consecutive seasons, capturing three straight from 1978 to 1980. Quarterbacks Charlie Conerly (1959) and Roman Gabriel (1969) won the trophy despite not being voted to the NEA's All-Pro first team in their respective seasons—Johnny Unitas was named to the first team over Conerly, while Sonny Jurgensen got the nod over Gabriel.

The award was founded by Murray Olderman, a sportswriter and cartoonist for the NEA. It was named in honor of Jim Thorpe, a professional football pioneer who was a player and the first president of what became the NFL. At the award's inception, Olderman sent ballots to every player in the league. Coaches joined the players in the voting process in 1975. Starting in 1987, the award became a joint project between the NEA, Jim Thorpe Association, and National Football League Players Association (NFLPA). Olderman also left the NEA that year and ended his association with the award. The NFLPA took over the balloting and added Pro Football Hall of Fame members to the voting panel in place of coaches.

The first recipient of the Jim Thorpe Trophy was Harlon Hill of the Chicago Bears, who was presented the trophy by NEA sports editor Harry Grayson in a televised halftime ceremony from the 1956 Pro Bowl in Los Angeles. In addition to Pro Bowl halftimes, subsequent years also saw the presentation televised on the final regular season weekend in either a pregame or halftime event. It was even on The Ed Sullivan Show in 1958. The presentation moved to the pregame show for the NFL championship game starting in 1961. In 1967, the winner was presented the trophy in a party at CBS Television City in Los Angeles for NEA's All-Pro selections, which was filmed and shown nationally during halftime of the Pro Bowl. In subsequent years, CBS aired a half-hour special before the Pro Bowl featuring the Jim Thorpe Trophy winner along with the All-Pros. After years of holding an awards banquet in New York, the ceremony was discontinued around 1980. Olderman and the NEA sought a sponsor. The Jim Thorpe Association of Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, took over the presentation of the trophy in 1987, presenting it at the existing awards banquet for their Jim Thorpe Award, which honors the top defensive back in college football. The NFL trophy was redesigned that year to feature a bronze statuette of Jim Thorpe.

Awardees

Award winners
SeasonPlayerTeamPosition Ref
1955 Harlon HillChicago BearsEnd
1956 Frank GiffordNew York GiantsRunning back
1957 Johnny UnitasBaltimore ColtsQuarterback
1958 Jim BrownCleveland BrownsFullback
1959 Charlie ConerlyNew York GiantsQuarterback
1960 Norm Van BrocklinPhiladelphia EaglesQuarterback
1961 Y. A. TittleNew York GiantsQuarterback
1962 Jim TaylorGreen Bay PackersRunning back
1963 Y. A. Tittle (2)New York GiantsQuarterback
Jim Brown (2)Cleveland BrownsRunning back
1964 Lenny MooreBaltimore ColtsHalfback
1965 Jim Brown (3)Cleveland BrownsRunning back
1966 Bart StarrGreen Bay PackersQuarterback
1967 Johnny Unitas (2)Baltimore ColtsQuarterback
1968 Earl MorrallBaltimore ColtsQuarterback
1969 Roman GabrielLos Angeles RamsQuarterback
1970 John BrodieSan Francisco 49ersQuarterback
1971 Bob GrieseMiami DolphinsQuarterback
1972 Larry BrownWashington RedskinsRunning back
1973 O. J. SimpsonBuffalo BillsRunning back
1974 Ken StablerOakland RaidersQuarterback
1975 Fran TarkentonMinnesota VikingsQuarterback
1976 Bert JonesBaltimore ColtsQuarterback
1977 Walter PaytonChicago BearsRunning back
1978 Earl CampbellHouston OilersRunning back
1979 Earl Campbell (2)Houston OilersRunning back
1980 Earl Campbell (3)Houston OilersRunning back
1981 Ken AndersonCincinnati BengalsQuarterback
1982 Dan FoutsSan Diego ChargersQuarterback
1983 Joe TheismannWashington RedskinsQuarterback
1984 Dan MarinoMiami DolphinsQuarterback
1985 Walter Payton (2)Chicago BearsRunning back
1986 Phil SimmsNew York GiantsQuarterback
1987 Jerry RiceSan Francisco 49ersWide receiver
1988 Roger CraigSan Francisco 49ersRunning back
1989 Joe MontanaSan Francisco 49ersQuarterback
1990 Warren MoonHouston OilersQuarterback
1991 Thurman ThomasBuffalo BillsRunning back
1992 Emmitt SmithDallas CowboysRunning back
1993 Emmitt Smith (2)Dallas CowboysRunning back
1994 Steve YoungSan Francisco 49ersQuarterback
1995 Brett FavreGreen Bay PackersQuarterback
1996 Brett Favre (2)Green Bay PackersQuarterback
1997 Barry SandersDetroit LionsRunning back
1998 Randall CunninghamMinnesota VikingsQuarterback
1999 Kurt WarnerSt. Louis RamsQuarterback
2000 Marshall FaulkSt. Louis RamsRunning back
2001 Kurt Warner (2)St. Louis RamsQuarterback
2002 Rich GannonOakland RaidersQuarterback
2003 Peyton ManningIndianapolis ColtsQuarterback
2004 Peyton Manning (2)Indianapolis ColtsQuarterback
2005 Shaun AlexanderSeattle SeahawksRunning back
2006 LaDainian TomlinsonSan Diego ChargersRunning back
2007 Tom BradyNew England PatriotsQuarterback
2008 Kurt Warner (3)Arizona CardinalsQuarterback

Multiple-time winners

List of multiple-time winners
AwardsPlayerTeamYearsHall of Fame induction
3Earl CampbellHouston Oilers1978, 1979, 19801991
Jim BrownCleveland Browns1958, 1963, 19651971
Kurt WarnerSt. Louis Rams1999, 2001, 20082017
2Brett FavreGreen Bay Packers1995, 19962016
Emmitt SmithDallas Cowboys1992, 19932010
Johnny UnitasBaltimore Colts1957, 19671979
Peyton ManningIndianapolis Colts2003, 20042021
Walter PaytonChicago Bears1977, 19851993
Y. A. TittleNew York Giants1961, 19631971

See also