Stephen Thomas Erlewine from AllMusic wrote that "the album follows the same blueprint as the first record, offering highly polished, professionally produced, expertly performed interpretations of gems from the Motown vaults; it's the sound of young America in the '60s reinterpreted for the adults of the new millennium." USA Today felt that McDonald's "versions of "What's Going O" and "Mercy, Mercy Me" won't make anyone forget Marvin Gaye's, but his bouncy take on Smokey Robinson's "I Second That Emotion" is sure to please adult-contemporary fans who like their R&B served over easy."