Five matches were contested at the event. In the main event, Samoa Joe defeated Shinsuke Nakamura to win the NXT Championship and became the first man to hold the title twice. It was also Mickie James's return to WWE for one night only in NXT.
TakeOver was a series of professional wrestlingevents that began in May 2014, as the American promotion WWE's developmental brand, NXT, held its second WWE Network-exclusive livestreaming event, billed as TakeOver. The "TakeOver" moniker subsequently became the branding for all of NXT's major events held periodically throughout the year. Announced on September 2, 2016, TakeOver: Toronto was scheduled as the 12th TakeOver event and took place on Saturday, November 19, 2016, as a support show for that year's Survivor Series for the main roster. It was held at the Air Canada Centre, the same venue as Survivor Series, and was named after the venue's city of Toronto, Ontario, Canada. It was in turn the second TakeOver held outside of the United States, after TakeOver: London in December 2015. Tickets went on sale on September 23, 2016, through Ticketmaster.
Storylines
The card included matches that resulted from scripted storylines. Results were predetermined by WWE's writers on the NXT brand, while storylines were produced on WWE's weekly television program, NXT.
On the September 28 episode of NXT, William Regal scheduled the second annual Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic, culminating with the finals at TakeOver: Toronto. The tournament started on the October 5 episode.
Next, The Authors of Pain (Akam and Rezar) faced TM-61 (Nick Miller and Shane Thorne) in the final of the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic, with Paul Ellering suspended above the ring inside a cage. In the end, The Authors of Pain performed "The Last Chapter" on Thorne to win the tournament.
In the main event, Shinsuke Nakamura defended the NXT Championship against Samoa Joe. During the match, Joe attempted a muscle buster but Nakamura countered and executed a "Kinshasa" on Joe for a nearfall. Nakamura attempted another "Kinshasa", but Joe avoided the attempt and applied the "Coquina Clutch". Nakamura attempted to escape, but Joe performed a German suplex followed by a dragon suplex and an X-Plex for a near-fall. When Nakamura executed another "Kinshasa" on Joe, Joe rolled out of the ring. Nakamura attempted a third "Kinshasa", but Joe avoided the attempt, attacked Nakamura with a low blow and performed a side slam onto the steel steps on Nakamura. Joe performed a muscle buster on Nakamura to win the title for a second time.
Aftermath
Two weeks after the event, on December 3, Shinsuke Nakamura defeated Samoa Joe to win back the NXT Championship in Osaka, Japan.
NXT Post show was in Toronto on November 23 and in Ottawa on November 30.
On December 29, WWE.com named The Revival vs. #DIY the "WWE Match Of The Year".
Following her appearance at the event, Mickie James turned heel on the January 17, 2017, episode of SmackDown, doing so by helping Alexa Bliss retain the SmackDown Women's Championship against Becky Lynch in a Steel Cage match, while revealing herself as the villainess under the "La Luchadora" mask. The appearance marked James' return to the main roster for the first time since 2010.
The 2016 TakeOver: Toronto would be the first of two in a TakeOver: Toronto chronology, a subseries of TakeOvers that were held in Toronto, Ontario, Canada at the Air Canada Centre, which was renamed to the Scotiabank Arena in 2018. The second Toronto event was held in 2019.
↑Austin Aries could not compete due to injury. William Regal decided that the winners would be determined by a singles match between TM-61's Shane Thorne and Aries' partner Roderick Strong.
↑Kota Ibushi's original partner, Hideo Itami, was injured before the tournament began; Itami was replaced by T. J. Perkins.
↑The Revival withdrew from the tournament after Dawson was injured.