| Paratetragraptus | |
|---|---|
| Fossil of Paratetragraptus approximatus | |
| Scientific classification | |
| Kingdom: | Animalia |
| Phylum: | Hemichordata |
| Class: | Pterobranchia |
| Subclass: | Graptolithina |
| Order: | †Graptoloidea |
| Suborder: | †Dichograptina |
| Family: | †Phyllograptidae |
| Genus: | †Paratetragraptus Obut, 1957 |
| Type species | |
| †Tetragraptus approximatus Nicholson, 1873 | |
| Species | |
| |
| Synonyms | |
|
Synonyms of P. approximatus
Synonyms of P. vestrogothus
| |
Paratetragraptus is a genus of phyllograptid graptolite that lived in the early Floian (from the P. approximatus to Tshallograptus fructicosus zones worldwide). It can be distinguished from related genera by the roughly parallel orientation of its stipes and mostly horizontal tubarium, which makes it appear H- or X- shaped in dorsoventral view, and by the slightly declined proximal end.
The type species P. approximatus was first described by H. A. Nicholson as a species of Tetragraptus in 1873 and was assigned to the subgenera T. (Etagraptus) and T. (Eotetragraptus) before the subgenus T. (Paratetragraptus) was named in 1957 by A. M. Obut. P. approximatus lived in the epipelagic zone and was a cosmopolitan species that first appears at roughly the same time worldwide, and as a result, its first appearance datum is used as the definition for the base of the Floian.
The type species of Paratetragraptus, P. approximatus, was first described by Henry Alleyne Nicholson as Tetragraptus approximatus in his 1873 paper On some fossils from the Quebec group of Point Lévis, Quebec. Rudolf Ruedemann included T. approximatus in his subgenus Tetragraptus (Etagraptus), which he named, based on the type species Tetragraptus (Etagraptus) lentus, to encompass "Horizontal species in which the second order branches form with the funicle the letter H," and named several new species that would turn out to be synonyms of P. approximatus. In 1951, the Czech paleontologists Bedřich Bouček and Alois Přibyl included T. approximatus in their subgenus Tetragraptus (Eotetragraptus), based on the type species Tetragraptus quadribrachiatus, and divided the subgenus into species with X-shaped tubaria and species with H-shaped tubaria.
In 1957, the Russian paleontologist Aleksandr Mikhaĭlovich Obut named the subgenus Paratetragraptus based on Tetragraptus approximatus and related graptolites with H-shaped tubaria (but excluding Tetragraptus lentus) but did not describe the genus, instead referring to Bouček and Přibyl's discussion of T. approximatus. Henry S. Williams and Robert K. Stevens, in their 1988 paper on graptolites from the Cow Head Group of Newfoundland, described for the first time the proximal development of Tetragraptus approximatus and considered Paratetragraptus an invalid subgenus, as the proximal development of T. approximatus was identical to that of Tetragraptus sensu stricto and the orientation of the stipes in Tetragraptus was variable.
Alfons H.M. VandenBerg's 2018 paper revising the early Floian stratigraphy of Victoria, Australia resurrected Paratetragraptus and elevated it to the rank of genus based on the declined funicle and deflexed second-order stipes. Jörg Maletz accepted the genus in both the Second Revision of the Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology volume on graptolites and in his 2023 paper on the Lower Ordovician graptolites of the Diabasbrottet quarry in Sweden, and modified the definition to include the parallel-oriented second-order stipes.
Paratetragraptus is a genus of phyllograptid with four second-order stipes (branches) that are mostly horizontal with respect to the sicula. The four stipes are connected by a 'bridge' called the funicle, which is formed by the first two thecae (thecae 11 and 12). Its differences from true Tetragraptus are minor, but the most prominent are the paired, roughly parallel-oriented stipes which result in an H- shaped tubarium (as in the type species P. approximatus) when they are parallel throughout or X-shaped tubarium (as in P. vestrogothus and P. acclinans) when they are more spread out. The apparent width of the stipes on either side of the funicle can differ, which suggests that the stipes were oval in cross-section. The thecae are typical 'dichograptid' thecae, being simple tubes that curve outwards and widen considerably close to the thecal apertures.
Unlike Tetragraptus, the funicle of Paratetragraptus is slightly declined, as the two thecae of the funicle hang slightly below the sicula. In P. approximatus, the thecae of the funicle are angled at between 90 and 118 degrees with respect to each other. The proximal (earliest) portions of the stipes are also declined (with an angle between stipes from 86 to 118 degrees in P. approximatus), but the stipes curve dorsally and become horizontal for most of their length. Most mature specimens are preserved in dorsoventral view, creating the appearance of a flat, H- or X- shaped tubarium and hiding the three-dimensional form of the tubarium. The declined nature of the funicle and early portions of the stipes can only be seen in rare specimens preserved in lateral view, and in those specimens the proximal region of the tubarium forms a small 'peak' above the horizontal region of the stipes that is composed of the sicula and funicle.
The proximal development is well known from Paratetragraptus based on flattened, isolated material from the Cow Head Group of Newfoundland and is similar to that of Tetragraptus. The sicula in P. approximatus is conical and between 2.0 and 2.2 mm long, with a prosicula between 0.3 and 0.35 mm. The sicular aperture is adorned with a tongue-like rutellum on its ventral side. The first theca, theca 11 (th11), originates low from the prosicula and gives rise to theca 12 (th12), which grows down and across the sicula. Th12 is the first dicalycal theca, giving Paratetragraptus isograptid proximal development, and produces th21 (which grows across the sicula towards th11) and th22 (which grows away from the sicula). The four stipes are formed by dicalycal thecae at th31 (which buds from th21) and th32 (which buds from th22).
A few specimens of Paratetragraptus approximatus and P. vestrogothus from the Diabassbrottet section show a web-like structure around the proximal region. The webs in P. approximatus are small and form a rim around the funicle, but the webs in P. vestrogothus are much more expansive. Several large specimens of P. vestrogothus lack a proximal web, suggesting that it was only developed in extremely old (gerontic) specimens. A single expansive, but poorly preserved, proximal web is also present in a specimen of P. acclinans from Australia.
Paratetragraptus approximatus (historically known as Tetragraptus approximatus) is a highly variable species, and juveniles appear very different from mature specimens due to both compaction and due to the thicker stipes in adults. As a result, several species have been named from the lower Floian (for instance, by Ruedemann and Laverdière, 1935 and Ruedemann, 1947) that are in fact juveniles of P. approximatus.
Williams and Stevens (1988) named the subspecies Tetragraptus approximatus robustus, but Mu et al. (2002) noted that it was identical to the earlier species Tetragraptus (Etagraptus) prionodus Xu and Huang, 1979, which they made a subspecies of T. approximatus. Maletz (2023) suggested that it was unclear whether T. a. robustus was a separate subspecies or simply an intraspecific variant of P. approximatus and tentatively synonymized the two.
Valid species following Williams and Stevens (1988), Mu et al. (2002), VandenBerg (2017), and Maletz (2023):
| Species | Tubarium shape | Lateral stipe width | Thecal count | Thecal inclination | Sicula length | Funicle length | Age |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paratetragraptus approximatus | H-shaped | 0.8–1.2 mm proximally, 2.0 mm distally | 10 in 10 mm proximally, 7 in 10 mm distally | 20–40° | 2.0–2.2 mm | 2.0–3.5mm | Tetragraptus phyllograptoides–Baltograptus vacillans zones |
| Paratetragraptus vestrogothus | X-shaped | 1.5–1.6 mm distally | 35–40° | 2.5–2.8 mm | 2.5–3.0 mm | Expansograptus protobalticus–Baltograptus vacillans zones | |
| Paratetragraptus acclinans | X-shaped | 1.8–2.0 mm distally | 9 in 10 mm | 45° | 2.1–4.5 mm | upper P. approximatus–P. akzharensis zones | |
| Paratetragraptus thomassmithi | H- or X- shaped | 0.5–0.9 mm proximally, 1.3–1.4 mm distally | 8–9 in 10 mm proximally, 6–7 in 10 mm distally | 40–55° | 2.8 mm | 1.8–3.2 mm | La3 (P. approximatus)–Be1 (P. approximatus + Tshallograptus fructicosus) zones |
| Paratetragraptus? henrywilliamsi | X-shaped | 0.8–1.0 mm proximally, 1.1–1.3 mm distally | 35–40° | 1.6–1.7 mm | 2.6–3.0 mm | La3 (P. approximatus)–Be1 (P. approximatus + Tshallograptus fructicosus) zones |
Paratetragraptus approximatus is a cosmopolitan species (though it was initially considered to be restricted to the low-latitude 'Pacific' faunal province before specimens were found in Europe), as it is distributed worldwide, and is a characteristic member of the Floian pandemic fauna at Hunneberg. P. approximatus resided in the epipelagic zone and was thus part of the epipelagic biotope, which is characterized by an abundance of phyllograptids, horizontal didymograptids (like Expansograptus), and axonophorans along with an absence of isograptids, sigmagraptids, and sinograptids. P. approximatus is rare in continental shelf environments and only appears sporadically, but is more consistently present in deeper-water shelf environments. In Scandinavian sequences, P. approximatus can be a dominant species in some geological horizons, but is also often absent for long stratigraphic intervals.
The base of the Floian Stage (477.08 Ma) is defined by the International Commission on Stratigraphy by the first appearance datum of Paratetragraptus approximatus at the Diabasbrottet Quarry in Västergötland, Sweden. P. approximatus is a morphologically distinctive and cosmopolitan species that first appears at roughly the same time in most stratigraphic sequences, making it a useful index fossil to identify the base of the Floian globally. However, it is a long-ranging species (extending from the earliest Floian Tetragraptus phyllograptoides zone to the Baltograptus vacillus zone in Scandinavia), limiting its use in defining individual biozones.
The first appearance datum of P. approximatus coincides with the base of the Tetragraptus phyllograptoides biozone in the Diabasbrottet section. In addition, the FAD of P. approximatus is just above the bases of both the Megistaspis (P.) planilimbata trilobite zone and the Oelandodus elongatus–Acodus deltatus deltatus subzone of the Paroistodus proteus conodont zone in the Diabasbrottet section, allowing the base of the Floian to be recognized even in sections lacking graptolites.
Paratetragraptus akzharensis (a junior synonym of P. vestrogothus) has been used as an index fossil for the P. akzharensis biozone, which occurs above the earliest Floian P. approximatus zone in Newfoundland and above the T. phyllograptoides zone, which is of similar age to the P. approximatus zone, in South America. An 'explosion' in diversity occurs in the P. akzharensis zone in Newfoundland, with the origination of several species as well as the continuation of nearly all species from the earlier P. approximatus zone. However, the characteristic fauna of the P. approximatus and P. akzharensis zones in Newfoundland largely went extinct in the succeeding Tshallograptus fructicosus zone. A peak in diversity is also known from the P. akzharensis zone in South America along with a reduction in diversity at the boundary with the succeeding Baltograptus cf. deflexus zone, though the decline may be associated with the lack of thoroughly-sampled stratigraphic sections at the zonal boundary.