Record World said that it "exhibits Barbra's stylish vocals adorning a punchy disco beat".
"The Main Event/Fight" spent four weeks at number three on the US Billboard Hot 100. In Canada it reached number five. It was also a major Adult Contemporary hit, reaching number two and number one in those nations, respectively. The song did not chart outside North America and was largely left out of recurrent rotation, having among the highest amount of drop-off in radio airplay of the hits of 1979 (Streisand's other singles of that year also fared poorly in maintaining airplay).