Wikipedia:WikiProject Articles for creation/Help desk

Main pageTalk pageSubmissions
Feed, Category, Sorting
ShowcaseApply
Participants, By subject
Reviewing instructions
Help desk
FAQ
Backlog
drives

Welcome to the Articles for Creation help desk

This help desk is for questions about draft articles submitted through Articles for Creation. We can help explain reviews, declines or rejections, sourcing and notability, resubmission, and the AfC process.

Before asking a question, you might find your answer in our Frequently asked questions page.

  • Need general help editing Wikipedia? Visit the Teahouse.
  • Need help understanding our policies and guidelines? See Everything you need to know.
  • Want to create a new draft? Use the Article Wizard.
  • Protect your privacy: Do not post your email address, telephone number, or other contact details. Answers will be posted publicly on this page.
  • Watch out for scams: If anyone asks you for money or any kind of payment to help you publish, protect, restore, or undelete a Wikipedia article or draft page, it is a scam. Learn about scams on Wikipedia.

If you still need help, click the Ask a new question button below.

Ask a new question
Answers will be posted on this page, so please check back for replies.


November 13

02:16, 13 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-60066-64

Hello,

I am requesting an independent assessment of the sources supporting my Wikipedia biography, Draft:Juan Fernando Herrera Ramos:

Draft:Juan Fernando Herrera Ramos

The draft has been declined four times under Wikipedia's biographical notability guidelines (WP:BASIC).

My full name is Juan Fernando Herrera Ramos, and I am the subject of the draft. I have disclosed my conflict of interest and have used the Articles for Creation process to ensure that the biography receives independent review.

Following the fourth rejection on October 30, 2026, I contacted the reviewer, Emmanbotan, on November 1 to request clarification. As of November 13, I have not received a response.

I understand that Wikipedia requires multiple reliable, independent, secondary sources providing significant coverage of the subject. However, I would appreciate a more specific explanation of why the following articles do not satisfy those requirements.

1. Storm Media (2020)

來自友邦的真心告白:台灣如何改變一個宏都拉斯男孩的人生?

https://www.storm.mg/article/3111176

This is a substantial biographical profile published by a Taiwanese news organization. It discusses my background in Honduras, education, experiences living in Taiwan, and community activities.

2. Crossing Magazine (October 16, 2020)

天差地別的台灣與家鄉,令他掉下眼淚──Fernando 的台灣故事

https://crossing.cw.com.tw/article/14062

This is a detailed feature written by a journalist discussing my life in Taiwan, professional background, and involvement in community organizing. It includes the journalist's own observations and reporting rather than consisting exclusively of a brief interview or quotation.

3. La Tribuna (March 31, 2026)

Analista hondureño proyecta su trabajo en medios de cinco continentes

https://www.latribuna.hn/2026/03/31/analista-hondureno-proyecta-su-trabajo-en-medios-de-cinco-continentes/

This article focuses on my journalism career, international publication record, and professional work as a geopolitical analyst. During an earlier discussion, one of the previous reviewers acknowledged that this article could be given weight as an independent source.

The draft also contains additional reporting from the Central News Agency, Deutsche Welle, Storm Media, Proceso Digital, and other publications documenting my professional activities over several years.

I would appreciate clarification on four questions: 1. Do these three articles constitute significant coverage of Juan Fernando Herrera Ramos under WP:BASIC? 2. If any of them are insufficient, is the problem their depth of coverage, editorial independence, reliability, or another requirement? 3. Can these sources be considered together to establish notability, or is additional independent biographical coverage necessary? 4. Is there a specific issue with the draft's presentation or sourcing that could be addressed through revision rather than obtaining further media coverage? I understand that publication in reputable newspapers does not automatically establish notability and that interviews, press releases, and articles primarily reproducing information supplied by the subject may not qualify.

I am not asking for preferential treatment or automatic acceptance. After four declines, I would simply appreciate a source-specific assessment to determine whether further revisions are worthwhile.

Thank you for your time and consideration. ~2026-60066-64 (talk) 02:16, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

For transparency, I submitted the question above while accidentally logged out. My registered Wikipedia account is Jfer2334, and I am the subject of Draft:Juan Fernando Herrera Ramos. Thank you. Jfer2334 (talk) 02:30, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Please don't use an LLM to edit or communicate on Wikipedia. Helpful Raccoon (talk) 05:23, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi Helpful Raccoon, thank you for your reply. I understand the concern about using large language models to edit or communicate with the Wikipedia community, I apologize if I wrote the question too formally. However, my question is directed to the application of WP to three specific published sources, and I would really appreciate if I could get an assessment of three mentioned articles.
Since I started this process I have received four AfC declines for Draft Juan Fernando Herrera Ramos, but I still have not been explained why the substantial biographical profiles published by Storm Media and Crossing Magazine (very influential media in Taiwan), together with the La Tribuna article (the biggest newspaper in Honduras), are insufficient.
I am asking whether these sources fail the significant coverage, reliability, or independence requirements, and why... I repeat that I am not requesting automatic acceptance of the draft. I would just really appreciate it if an experienced editor can look at them and give me a source-specific evaluation given the time an effort I have spent in this without obtaining clarity of what exactly I'm doing wrong.
Thank you. Jfer2334 (talk) 05:51, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Your comments here are transparently AI-generated, which is not allowed. Read the policies and guidelines yourself, then ask your questions in your own words. —ClaudineChionh (she/her · talk · email) 07:56, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi Claudine, the main question was in fact generated by an LLM, because I was trying to make the question as accurate as possible, every single answer on this thread has been written by me, including the last comment which you consider to be transparently AI generated.
I am a writer and a journalist, I have been a writer and a Journalist since at least 2019, way before the chatbots or the large language models became available to the public and I can guarantee you that this are my words, and that this is exactly how I write.
Once again, I am asking for help to get for an experienced editor to look at my sources, some of which go as far back as 2020, amd give me a source-specific evaluation becuase based on Wikipedia's criteria, I believe that the articles included provide sufficient independent coverage to establish notability and I am not sure what is the problem with them or what is it that I am doing wrong.
I would really appreciate someone to help me with this request. If posting the main question again in my writing would help to get past this issue and solve my actual concern, I would appreciate if someone tells me what is the best way to do that to avoid any more issues.
Thanks in advance for your help. Jfer2334 (talk) 08:20, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I don't know if anyone has yet signposted you to our guideline on autobiographies, WP:AUTOBIO, but I have just done so on your talk page. TL;DNR = you shouldn't, really, write about yourself. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 08:27, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi DoubleGrazing, thank you for sharing the guidelines to autobiographies. I want to clarify that I have in fact read them and that I have been following the procedure that those same guidelines recommends for people in my situation.
If you check under the section "Creating an article about yourself," the guideline says that "If you really think that you can meet the inclusion criteria, and if you are willing to accept that your article must be neutral and non-promotional, then submit a draft to Articles for Creation (AfC) instead of creating an article directly.", which is exactly what I did. I have also disclosed my conflict of interest, created a draft rather than publishing an article directly, and submitted it through AfC so that independent editors like yourself could assess it. I have also revised the draft many times in response to previous editors reviews.
I understand why Wikipedia discourages autobiographies, but the guidelines do not prohibit the procedure I have followed.
Now going back to this thread, my question is specifically about the independent media coverage supporting the draft that I have submitted. I would really appreciate an explanation of why the articles from Storm Media, Crossing Magazine, and La Tribuna do not satisfy the notability criteria. I am simply trying to understand whether the three sources I listed (along with the other supporting coverage) are insufficient and, if they are not, why.
Thanks in advance for your help. Jfer2334 (talk) 08:59, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for explaining some of our policies and guidelines to me.
You are right, autobiographies aren't strictly forbidden; hence why I said "you shouldn't, really, write about yourself", not "you must not".
What is however forbidden, is promotion of any kind. Promotion is a broader issue than merely using promotional language; it also includes telling the world about (in this case) yourself, see WP:YESPROMO. Especially when that is your only purpose here, it means you are not here to help us build an encyclopaedia, you are here to get yourself included in it, presumably because you feel this would further your career etc. interests. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 09:15, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for pointing out the conflict of interest guidelines, I have already reviewed them too and I have disclosed my conflict of interest in the draft following the instructions of previous reviewers who specifically asked me to do so.
The issue with the draft now appears to be notability, which is exactly what I am trying to get some help understanding.
Thanks again for your reply. Jfer2334 (talk) 09:24, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
If you really did write the previous comment yourself, then please explain:
  1. my question is directed to the application of WP to three specific published sources – what's "WP" supposed to refer to here?
  2. I have received four AfC declines for Draft Juan Fernando Herrera Ramos – can you work out why there is a red link here?
—ClaudineChionh (she/her · talk · email) 08:28, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi Claudine,
The WP was supposed to be WP:BASIC or the minimum basic criteria that Wikipedia establishes for notability.
As for the red link it must be because I forgot to type the colon after the word "Draft", it should have been Draft:Juan Fernando Herrera Ramos.
I hope that this answers both of your questions. If they do, could you please help me with my request about a specific source evaluation? In addition to the 3 that I included there are several others that I believe should be enough to establish notability, and I have already declared the COI of interest before so I am not sure what is it that I am doing wrong, and I would really appreciate your help to understand that.
Again, thank you for taking the time to reply. Jfer2334 (talk) 08:37, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
The picture of you appears to be professionally taken; this would mean that the photographer is the copyright holder, not you as you are currently claiming. If your contract with the photographer assigned you the copyright(which is rare) then you need to work with the editors on Commons to make that clear in the image information.
I'n wondering, why do you want to do this despite the advice against it?
The draft just describes your work, it does not summarize critical analysis and commentary about you or your work. For example, you write "In November 2021, Deutsche Welle interviewed Herrera Ramos about the Honduran presidential election"; why is that important? Why did Deutche Welle select you to offer comment? Do they view you as an authority on Honduran politics- and more importantly, is that view documented somewhere? "In 2023, Taiwan's Central News Agency reported his analysis of Honduran public opinion"; again, why did they do this? We need critical analysis and commentary about you, not just a listing of your work. 331dot (talk) 09:27, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi 33idot, thank you for taking the time to look at my draft and address my concerns. This is the kind of feedback I have been trying to obtain.
Regarding the picture, it was taken by a friend. There was no payment or contract involved, and I understand that being the person in the photograph does not make me the copyright holder, so if the copyright information is incorrect, I can remove the photograph from the draft and replace it with one I have taken myself, I don't think that this would be a big issue.
As for why I submitted the biography, I believe that the independent coverage of my activities and professional work was sufficient to meet Wikipedia's notability requirements, and still believe so. I understand that this is not something I can determine myself, which is why I disclosed my conflict of interest and submitted the draft through AfC for independent review. I have followed all the guidelines given to me and addressed all the issues that previous reviewers have made.
I also understand your point about the difference between being quoted by a newspaper and receiving significant coverage, one of the previous reviewers was kind enough to explain that difference and I completely reviewed the draft of the article based on his observations. As you can see, the three articles I highlighted in my original question are not simply interviews in which I provide commentary on other subjects. Storm Media published a biographical profile in 2020 covering my background, education, and activities in Taiwan in detail. Crossing Magazine published another substantial feature about me that same year, and La Tribuna published an article in 2026 about my journalism career.
Regarding Deutsche Welle and CNA, I was interviewed about Honduran politics and diplomatic relations with Taiwan, particularly during significant political developments. CNA identified me as a Honduran columnist and consulted me on multiple occasions, including during the 2023 diplomatic crisis. I have also been interviewed recently regarding the results of the Honduran elections and Trump's activities in Venezuela by Taiwan+, and by other TV outlets in the past. I understand that being interviewed by reputable news organizations does not automatically establish notability, but these articles document my work as a geopolitical commentator.
Could you please look at those three articles specifically and tell me whether they qualify as significant independent coverage under WP:BASIC? If they do not, I would appreciate knowing whether the problem is their independence, the depth of their reporting, or something else.
If the issue is how I have written the draft rather than the sources themselves, I would also appreciate knowing that, because it would help me understand what needs to change.
Thank you again for your time and assistance, I really appreciate it. Jfer2334 (talk) 10:21, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I understand that you believe you are notable(frankly, nearly everyone who attempts to write about themselves does) but more basic, why do you want to do this? Why do you care if Wikipedia has an article about you or not? Do you think it will aid your career in some way? There are actually good reasons to not want an article about yourself.
Two of the sources you provide here are interviews with you, which are not independent sources(being you speaking about yourself). The third has very little critical analysis and commentary about you. We are less interested in a point by point accounting of your work and more interested in what is said about your work; if you are selected by news organizations to offer comment or analysis of variout topics (like Honduran politics) we need sources that state that- but it is rare for a news outlet to publish in a reliable source why they select a certain individual to offer comment about a topic.
I personally in 15 years have never seen someone succeed at an autobiography, and I understand that the number of times it has happened when I wasn't looking can probably be counted on one hand, out of tens of thousands of attempts. Are you the rare person who can succeed where virtually everyone else fails? It is possible, but the odds are overwhelmingly against it, especially without broader editing experience.
It is difficult to write about journalists here(even when not writing about yourself) because journalists do not often write about other journalists. Unless one is on the level of a Tom Brokaw or Walter Cronkite or Bob Woodward, there usually is not enough appropriate sources with critical analysis and commentary about the person's work to merit a journalist an article. 331dot (talk) 10:34, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I actually don’t believe that having a Wikipedia article would benefit my professional career. Anyone searching for my full name can already find numerous articles mentioning me, articles I have written, and written and televised interviews in Spanish, English, and Chinese. I have also never included interviews or articles written about me in my CV. If anything, I highlight my own publications in international media.
On a more personal level, I believe that representation matters. Through my involvement in scholarship and educational initiatives, I have always tried to encourage young Hondurans to pursue opportunities beyond what they might consider possible. I want young people from my country to have reasons to dream, goals to aspire to, and examples that show them that their nationality or background does not determine how far they can go.
My understanding is that Wikipedia’s purpose is to make knowledge freely accessible to people worldwide. I believe that includes documenting individuals whose activities have received significant independent coverage, regardless of their nationality or whether they have achieved international fame. However, I understand that my personal beliefs and motivations do not establish Wikipedia notability. I am not asking for an exception to Wikipedia’s requirements. I have followed all the rules, and I am just asking whether the independent coverage already published about me satisfies the notability requirements.
If the two interviews are a problem, I can remove them from the draft. However, the three biographical profiles I have highlighted are a different matter. Two of them have already been examined by previous Wikipedia editors, with one editor indicating that, in their opinion, one of those sources would count toward establishing notability for him. The 2026 article also appears to me to satisfy the criteria for significant coverage in an independent and reliable source.
That is precisely why I am requesting a specific assessment of these three articles. I would like to understand whether there is a problem with their independence, reliability, or depth of coverage in the 3 articles mentioned in my main comment, or whether the issue is how I have presented the information in the draft.
If the problem is with the draft itself, I am more than willing to address it. Jfer2334 (talk) 11:54, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
So what you are saying is that you want to promote yourself for the purpose of inspiring young Hondurans to pursue a good, successful life. That's a great thing to do, but not something Wikipedia is concerned with doing even if it's a good thing. That's something you should do on your own website and social media. Autobiographies are inherently promotional, this is why they are discouraged- and it is rare in the extreme for someone to write about themselves and not be promotional; autobiographies are not absolutely forbidden in order to allow for that small possibility of success, but almost no one can do it. I feel you're just wasting your own valuable time, but you're free to do so.
Interviews do not establish notability- they can be used for other purposes, but not that. One acceptable profile as a source is not sufficient, we generally look for at least three acceptable sources to establish notability.
As I said already, we are less interested in a point by point accounting of your work than we are in a summary of critical analysis and commentary about you. If you truly feel that you can pass this process despite the overwhelming odds against it, I would limit the text in the draft to whatever critical analysis and commentary about you exists, and remove mere documentation of your work. 331dot (talk) 12:05, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I will also add that the Spanish Wikipedia is a separate project, with its own editors and policies, and your content may be acceptable there(in Spanish) even if it is not acceptable here. 331dot (talk) 12:07, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I understand your concerns, but I would like to clarify two points.
First, promoting myself is not my intention. I explained my personal motivations because you specifically asked why having a Wikipedia article mattered to me. I understand that Wikipedia is not intended for self-promotion, and I have never suggested that my personal motivations should override its notability requirements. As you can see, the promotional tone of the article has not been the reason for rejection and I have made explicit my conflict of interest precisely so that editors know I wrote it, but make a fair assessment of the coverage.
Second, I am not relying on just one biographical profile. The previous editor's assessment was made before the third article, published in Honduras in 2026, was available. My current request concerns three separate articles published by three different news organizations:
1. Storm Media (2020): https://www.storm.mg/article/3111176
2. Crossing Magazine (2020): https://crossing.cw.com.tw/article/14062
3. La Tribuna (2026): https://www.latribuna.hn/2026/03/31/analista-hondureno-proyecta-su-trabajo-en-medios-de-cinco-continentes/
I understand that interviews in which I provide commentary on political developments do not establish notability. However, these three articles are specifically about my background, experiences, and professional activities, rather than simply quoting my opinions on unrelated subjects.
I really thank you for the time that you have taken to reply, and I am asking whether you would be willing to help me assess these three sources individually against WP: BASIC.
If one or more of them do not qualify, I would genuinely appreciate knowing why. I will follow your advice on limiting the text to critical analysis and commentary that exist about me, but it would really help me to know if these 3 sources make me eligible, otherwise modifying and submitting the draft would be pointless.
That is the assistance I have been seeking from the beginning, and I would appreciate your help in understanding what specifically needs to be addressed. Jfer2334 (talk) 12:27, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Are you using an AI to compose your comments? I presume your first language is Spanish if you are Honduran; but even if your English is not perfect, we prefer to hear from you directly as one human to another. We do not expect perfect grammar and spelling in talk page posts.
I have already conducted the evaluation that you requested. The first two sources are interviews with you, so those are not acceptable sources to establish notability. The third is a very brief profile of you with little critical analysis and commentary about you. 331dot (talk) 12:33, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I am not using AI to compose my messages, Spanish is in fact my first language but I have been living in Taiwan for the past 11 year speaking, working, stuying and writing for the past 11 years. Also, as I already mentioned, I am a writer so I tend to type fast in write in a structured way. In any case thanks for the compliment, I do appreciate that people think that my writing is as good as AI haha.
And thanks for the assessment, my understanding is that an article containing an interview is not automatically excluded from consideration under WP. Storm Media published a dedicated biographical feature written by a journalist from an independent news organization. Although the article includes my statements, it also presents my background, education, and community activities in a broader narrative. In any case even with that one being taken it seems like I would be 2 articles short. I guess I will have to keep working.
Enjoy your weekend! Jfer2334 (talk) 12:53, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
The trouble with a source that contains an interview is that it is difficult to divorce the contents of the interview from anything else the writer says about you.
I think that if your goal is to inspire young Hondurans, you should focus your efforts on the Spanish Wikipedia so they can read it without needing a translator. As I said, your content may be acceptable there. 331dot (talk) 13:01, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Yeah, you have a point there, I assumed Spanish Wikipedia was just the translation of English Wikipedia lol, so I will give it a shot there too.
Thanks for the advice! Jfer2334 (talk) 13:04, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
It's not. Each Wikipedia project is its own thing, with its own standards and practices. —Jéské Couriano v^_^v Thriller Night! 17:50, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
FWIW, if someone thinks you write like an AI, I recommend you do not read that as a compliment. At best, writing like an AI means writing like a bland, mediocre robot. At worst, it means writing like a stupid liar. Professional writers (including journalists, academics, and PR copywriters) do have to unlearn some of their habits, and one of the ways you can do that is spend time reading some of our featured articles to get a sense of what the community considers good encyclopaedic writing. —ClaudineChionh (she/her · talk · email) 00:16, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Well, he international media that publishes me does not think that I write like a bland, mediocre robot, I just got an article accepted by the East Asia Forum in Australia yesterday, if you want I can come back here and paste the link so that you can judge my writing style.
As for the stupid liar comment, I think I have already demonstrated that I was not lying, if you want to continue to think so that is your prerogative.
I will continue to write in the style that I like, but thank you for the advise Claudine.
Have a great day. Jfer2334 (talk) 00:23, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
My exasperation got the better of me, and I'm sorry for the accusations. My second point stands: writing for an encyclopaedia is not like journalistic writing, and becoming more familiar with encyclopaedic writing, as well as our notability and verifiabilty requirements, will help you write material that can be accepted into Wikipedia articles. —ClaudineChionh (she/her · talk · email) 00:47, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

02:24, 13 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-60041-82

@Emmanbotan: Thank you for the comments. I have actually studied the guidelines and also made reference to published wikipedia pages for many academicians and doctors such as:

Francis Ka Leung Chan Joseph Sung Siew C. Ng

and I have included citations and reference (with secondary sources) as far as possible. May I respectfully ask if it is possible to reconsider the draft or kindly share specific comments how I might improve to be a qualified editor? Thank you very much for your guidance. ~2026-60041-82 (talk) 02:24, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

If you are the draft creator, remember to log in when posting.
I have fixed your links, the whole url is not needed, just the title in double brackets, like [[Francis Ka Leung Chan]].
We judge each article individually on their own merits and not based on the presence of other articles that themselves may be inappropriate but just not yet addressed by a volunteer, see other stuff exists. This is why, though understandable, it is a poor idea to use any random article as a model. Instead, use an article that is classified as a good article or even a featured articles.
If you feel that you have addressed the concerns of prior reviews, you may resubmit the draft, though you have not edited it since the last decline. 331dot (talk) 12:37, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

05:59, 13 November 2026 review of submission by MatthewMooreZeng

@Rht bd: I'd like to know which reference source doesn't meet Wikipedia's criteria. Please point it out to me so that I can replace it with other secondary sources responsibly. MatthewMooreZeng (talk) 05:59, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

It is not necessarily the sources themselves, but their content. The reviews you cite are more about the products of the company, not the company itself. Even those reviews are pretty skinny, largely boiling down to "they're good products".
Please read WP:PAIDADVICE, and show it to your superiors and colleagues. In short, you're not likely to succeed at this, especially as a new user without prior, broader Wikipedia editing experience. 331dot (talk) 09:36, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Second opinion requested: Draft:Felix Herwig Kuntz declined as AI-generated

Hello. I am Harbingerknight, and I am related to the subject of Draft:Felix Herwig Kuntz (my conflict of interest is disclosed on the draft's talk page). I am asking for a second opinion on the decline of this draft on November 12 by Helpful Raccoon, on the grounds that it appears to be LLM-generated, and on the reviewer's further comment that the subject's notability is "borderline at best."

On the AI finding: the decline states that the draft "appears to be" LLM-generated. No detector result was cited, no passage was identified, and no evidence was given. The finding rests on the reviewer's impression alone. I understand that reviewers must make judgment calls, and that a second reviewer may agree with this one. But I am asking whether suspicion, without more, should sustain a decline, particularly when the draft was prepared by the same process as three articles of mine that are live in mainspace, Harnett T. Kane, E. John Bullard, and Samuel Wilson Jr., which other editors have since edited without raising AI concerns. I am not claiming no AI assistance was involved in conducting research. I am saying this draft is as good as the other articles I submitted, and I am asking for a second reviewer's judgment on whether it should be treated differently from them.

For context, and without accusing the reviewer of anything: the same reviewer reverted my restoration of a passage on the New Orleans Museum of Art article in October 2024 and left a COI notice on an earlier draft of this biography. I mention this only as background for why I am asking for fresh eyes.

On notability: the reviewer noted he could not access most of the *States-Item* pieces. Those are offline newspaper sources from a paper that ceased publication in 1980, cited with publication, date, and page. I understand offline sources to be verifiable whether or not a given reviewer has access to them. I would ask that notability be judged on the sources as cited, not on the subset a reviewer could open. The sources he could open are the Tulane and NOMA pages; the independent press coverage is the material he could not reach. Three independent sources with significant coverage of the subject, all cited in the draft, are:

  • Charles L. "Pie" Dufour, "Felix Kuntz's gentility, gentleness, and warmth," *New Orleans States-Item*, August 14, 1971, p. 6, a full tribute column about the subject.
  • "N.O. Historian Expires at 81," *The Times-Picayune*, July 25, 1971, p. 24, the subject's obituary.
  • Leonard V. Adams, "Second Art Display Is Set At Presbytere," *New Orleans States-Item*, March 13, 1968, p. 43, coverage of the exhibition of the subject's collection.

These are professional press coverage, independent of Tulane University and the New Orleans Museum of Art. The 1968 exhibition's preview was attended by Mayor Victor H. Schiro, Louisiana State Museum director Peggy Richards, and Friends of the Cabildo president Beau L. Bassich, as the *Times-Picayune*'s January 30, 1968 photograph records.

One further point on standing. Prescott N. Dunbar's history of the New Orleans Museum of Art, published by Louisiana State University Press in 1990, records that Felix's interest in period rooms grew from his association with Joseph Downs of the Metropolitan Museum of Art's American Wing and H. F. du Pont, and that their example led him to want to do something similar for New Orleans. Downs and du Pont were the leading figures in American decorative arts collecting of their generation.

One further source is on its way. I have located H. Parrott Bacot's article "The Rosemonde E. and Emile Kuntz Rooms," in *Arts Quarterly*, Volume 5, number 2, April-June 1983, pages 17 and 18, and I have requested scans from the libraries that hold it. Bacot's account is the source behind Dunbar's statement about Downs and du Pont, and it may give the specifics of Felix's association with them. I intend to add it to the article once the article is published and I have the pages in hand, so that the subject's importance can be judged on the full record.

My questions: (1) Should the decline stand on an unproven finding? (2) If the AI concern stands, is whole-text deletion required, or would a targeted rewrite of the flagged portions suffice?

Thank you. Harbingerknight (talk) 09:04, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

If you used an AI on the draft in any capacity, the only way to really address that is to start fresh and do the work yourself, writing in your own words. AI often goes beyond what is asked of it, and it has a poor understanding of our guidelines. Trying to remove the influence of AI from a draft without starting fresh is like trying to remove rat poison from soup. It is possible with some effort, but far easier to start over. 331dot (talk) 09:33, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
You have not submitted any other articles through the AFC process. They have mostly not been reviewed by anyone. I note that Draft:Samuel Wilson Jr. was moved to draft space by a different reviewer and marked as containing LLM-generated text. Helpful Raccoon (talk) 10:20, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
FWIW, I only found that article because of this AFCHD request. Further discussion would probably be better off at Wikipedia:AI noticeboard/Harbingerknight. Kisseran (talk) 11:31, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
And please don't use LLMs to communicate with other editors on Wikipedia. This query mentions a source "cited in the draft" titled "Felix Kuntz's gentility, gentleness, and warmth", but that source is not contained in the draft. Helpful Raccoon (talk) 10:30, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
GPTZero says 100% AI generated slop. WP:TNT is required. Theroadislong (talk) 11:51, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Brandolini's law strikes again. —Jéské Couriano v^_^v Thriller Night! 17:46, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

10:00, 13 November 2026 review of submission by Fielder Football

@S0091: I have accidentially set up the same page that appears to have not been saved as a draft, so this page has been rejected for duplication. If someone can assist and delete the other one or tell me the best course of action so I can resubmit this one? Fielder Football (talk) 10:00, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

If you wish to address S0091 directly, you should use their user talk page; but if you are saying you would prefer to run the draft through this process, we can delete the actual article as an author request. 331dot (talk) 10:03, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
@331dot: If you're wondering why reviewers' names are appearing in questions now, § Automatic pinging of last reviewer on AfC Help Desk question was recently implemented. —ClaudineChionh (she/her · talk · email) 10:13, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Ah, I was indeed wondering that. Perhaps it would be better to place the ping at the end of the comment instead of the beginning, which suggests the comment is directed towards that user? 331dot (talk) 10:16, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I thought the draft process was the correct way, so if that is the best course of action then yes please. Fielder Football (talk) 10:14, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Done. 331dot (talk) 10:17, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you Fielder Football (talk) 10:20, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

10:55, 13 November 2026 review of submission by AJ4586

The draft article has not been accepted, with the following reasons given: This draft appears to contain text generated by a large language model (such as ChatGPT). You cannot use LLMs to generate, draft, or rewrite article content.

No AI or LLM was used in the creation of the text. I checked some of the sources using AI, looking for their veracity and age, but the text itself is entirely human written.

Is there any way of knowing if there are particular areas of the submission which appear more AI-generated than others? AJ4586 (talk) 10:55, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Do you have an association with this company?
The draft just lists what this company does and has no critical analysis and commentary about it. The awards mentioned do not contribute to notability as the awards do not have articles(like Nobel Peace Prize or Academy Awards). 331dot (talk) 11:06, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi, no I have no association with the company beyond having used it, as a consumer, to view live football streams. I will try to rewrite it with a more critical, analytical angle. Thanks for the suggestion. AJ4586 (talk) 16:42, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
@AJ4586 AI cannot check a source for "veracity" (which means "truth").
AI is also bad at determining whether the sources say what the draft claims they say. You must have already read the sources yourself, since of course you have created the draft by summarizing what the sources say. In order to do that, you must have already read the sources. David10244 (talk) 05:35, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
I used AI to check for other mentions online backing up the sources I had read. IE, that there wasn't one single mention of it on one random webpage of unknown trustworthiness. I thought that might be a worthwhile effort? AJ4586 (talk) 07:36, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello, @AJ4586. References on unreliable sites are irrelevant. What matters is what reliable sites say about the subject. ColinFine (talk) 22:14, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

11:47, 13 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-60076-99

socialmarketing.thaihealth.or.th is a reliable sources or not reliable sources according to these reference? ~2026-60076-99 (talk) 11:47, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Hello, @~2026-60076-99.
If I understand your draft correctly, then the company that produced the programme is Thaihealth.
If that is the case, then any source from thaihealth.or.th is not indepedendent, and is of very limited use, and no value in establishing notability.
A Wikipedia article should be a neutral summary of what the majority of people who are wholly unconnected with the subject have independently chosen to publish about the subject in reliable publications, (see Golden rule) and not much else. What you know (or anybody else knows) about the subject is not relevant except where it can be verified from a reliable published source.
Unless you start by finding several places where people who have no connection whatever with the programme or its production company have chosen to write independent commentary or analysis about the programme, and base your draft almost entirely on what those sources say, you are probably wasting your time.
My earnest advice to new editors is to not even think about trying to create an article until you have spent several weeks - at least - learning about how Wikipedia works by making improvements to existing articles. Once you have understood core policies such as verifiability, neutral point of view, reliable, independent sources, and notability, and experienced how we handle disagreements with other editors (the Bold, Revert, Discuss cycle), then you might be ready to read your first article carefully, and try creating a draft. If you don't follow this advice but try to create an article without this preparation, you are likely to have a frustrating and disappointing experience with Wikipedia. ColinFine (talk) 14:21, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

11:50, 13 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-60050-64

I was informed that my article was declined because the article had no citations supports references, etc. but what if my idea is new, new thought of? Original? Stupid policy. ~2026-60050-64 (talk) 11:50, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Wikipedia does not publish original ideas. Athanelar (talk) 11:57, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Then we can't have an article on it. Wikipedia is best thought of as a lagging indicator due to our reliance on published third-party sources that discuss a subject at length. We have no interest in novel ideas that haven't already been written about in the media or academia for that reason. —Jéské Couriano v^_^v Thriller Night! 17:43, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

12:45, 13 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-60172-52

@Paul W: where do I put in my 'declared interest' statement? ~2026-60172-52 (talk) 12:45, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Assuming that you are Sepukangri, you should do so on your user page, User:Sepukangri. 331dot (talk) 12:47, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

13:26, 13 November 2026 review of submission by SumanGhosh1975

@SumanGhosh1975: note that sources must be published; I'm not sure if eg. 'Home Department Proceedings' is? Similarly, even if you know something to be true, it cannot go into the draft unless it comes from a reliable published source.
When citing offline sources, you need to provide sufficient bibliographic details to allow the sources to be reliably identified for verification.
You also need to ensure that the draft is adequately supported by citations. There are currently several paragraphs that aren't referenced, and we therefore have no way of knowing where the information in them has come from and whether it is true.
Other than that, we don't assess sources here at the help desk, because that effectively amounts to a review; you will get one when you resubmit the draft. I will say, however, that by merely tagging on new sources to an existing draft isn't really how you should go about this, that is known as editing WP:BACKWARD – first writing the draft, and then adding some sources in the hope that they support the contents and establish notability. You should instead first research your sources, then summarise what they have said, as explained in WP:GOLDENRULE. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 13:44, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
SumanGhosh1975 I fixed your header so it links to your draft as intended and not to a nonexistent page entitled "Request for source assessment – Draft:Kalidas Ghosh*".
If you have made changes to the draft, you need to resubmit it to obtain another review, we don't do pre-review reviews, because this duplicates what the reviewer will do. 331dot (talk) 13:38, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello, and welcome to the Articles for Creation helpdesk. Your query appears to have been generated, in whole or in part, by some kind of AI chatbot or large language model. Using these tools to generate user-to-user communication runs contrary to Wikipedia's culture of collaborative communication. If you are using AI because you aren't confident in your English language skills or your knowledge of Wikipedia's processes, don't worry; we don't expect people to be perfect at either of those, just try your best to communicate with us in your own words. If you aren't sure why your draft was declined or rejected, please follow these steps;
  1. Make sure you've read the decline notice(s) (highlighted in red at the top of your draft) along with any comments left below by the reviewer(s).
  2. If any of the content in the decline notice is unclear, make sure to click all of the links in the decline notice and read the pages they take you to.
  3. If any of the content in the additional comments is unclear, you should ask for clarification from the reviewer who left the comment directly on their talk page.
If after doing all of the above, you still have additional questions, then this help desk is the place for it; please feel free to ask us any more specific questions you have, just please do so without help from any AI or LLM. Remember; if you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human effort. It is unfair and disrespectful to ask volunteer editors to use their time and effort helping you if you won't even use your own time and effort to do some reading and formulate your own question. Athanelar (talk) 17:26, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
@SumanGhosh1975: You shouldn't be editing about this topic full stop. —Jéské Couriano v^_^v Thriller Night! 17:33, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

14:04, 13 November 2026 review of submission by B S Buchanan 1

@AirshipJungleman29: I am now redrafting this entry. I am told it lacks "Secondary Sources". I am confused here. Most of the references are to secondary sources. 1) The material about Sherratt's career is from Cambridge University and Christ's College, not herself 2) All of the reviews of "Hitler's Philosophers" are from independent newspapers in the UK, US and Europe. They are long form reviews. 3) All the material corroborating the translations of "Hitler's Philosophers" is from independent publisher websites. I do link Sherratt's personal website as an "External Link" but I don't use her own material to corroborate any claims made. THis is my first attempt at a Wiki entry. What am I not understanding from the feedback? Thanks B S Buchanan 1 (talk) 14:04, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

B S Buchanan 1 I think what the reviewer is trying to say is that the book may be notable, but not necessarily the author. It is possible for a work to be notable but not the person who created it, it depends on what the coverage is actually about. You should refocus the draft to be about the book and not the author. 331dot (talk) 14:07, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
If Sherratt has made a major contribution to intellectual history, mainly through this book, does that mean she meets the "Criteria for Inclusion" for academics as specified by Wiki? Trying to get balance right between the biography and the big book. Thanks B S Buchanan 1 (talk) 14:14, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
It seems there are two possible ways (*) to establish notability here, either by showing objectively and supported by reliable evidence that this person meets one or more of the eight criteria enumerated in WP:NACADEMIC, or one of the four in WP:NAUTHOR.
Personally, I'm skeptical whether having authored a single noteworthy book is enough in either case, but I say that only in a general sense, not having looked at the details of this case.
(*) There is a third possibility, the general notability guideline WP:GNG, but that requires multiple secondary sources with significant coverage directly of the person, not her book(s). And on that point, you say that Christ's College Cambridge is a secondary source; it is not, it is primary. It may be a third party source in relation to Sherratt, although even that isn't actually the case since she works there. Same goes for publishers and other organisations, regardless of whether they are close to the subject or genuinely independent / arm's length. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 14:32, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
if Sherratt has made a significant contribution to intellectual history mainly through this book, does that mean she's "notable" under Wiki's criteria for academics? Thanks I really appreciate the speedy feedback ~2026-60145-24 (talk) 14:20, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Remember to log in when posting.
If the notability of the person is tied to a single book, there only needs to be an article about the book because the book is what is making her notable. 331dot (talk) 14:42, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Your question suggests that you should write an article about the book rather than the author. I once drafted a biography about an author whose books my son liked. The reviewer declined it, and suggested I re-cast the draft to be about the books, for which notability was clearer. I did that, and it was better. The draft was accepted, now in mainspace at Gameknight999. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 15:43, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
THank you for this suggestion. I think I will recast as an entry about the book. I assume I can still have a section which explains who the author is although I can see that in your example you didn't do this? B S Buchanan 1 (talk) 19:55, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Yes, my article Gameknight999 does have a short "Background" section about the author. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 20:03, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

18:48, 13 November 2026 review of submission by Aayushyaadf

The Orkla India article draft has been rejected multiple times. Could you please guide us on the process and requirements for getting the article approved? Orkla India is a publicly listed company with several published articles and press releases mentioning the brand. We would appreciate your assistance in understanding how these references can be leveraged to strengthen the draft and improve its chances of approval. Aayushyaadf (talk) 18:48, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

@Aayushyaadf This company does not meet our criteria for inclusion at this time, and therefore will not be considered further. There is nothing further you can do. As an employee of the company you are also required to disclose your relationship - failure to do so is a breach of Wikimedia Terms of Use. qcne (talk) 19:11, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Don't use a chatbot to talk to us.
Who is "we"? How many people access the "Aayushyaadf" account?
Your use of "we" suggests a financial relationship or other conflict of interest, which you have not disclosed as you agreed to do when you created this account.
As a paid editor, you are expected to be familiar with the content policies and guidelines before drafting an article. Your mention of "press releases", as if that's anything meaningful, indicates that you have failed to perform even the most rudimentary due diligence in learning what is required to get an article published. It isn't the responsibility of the Wikipedia community, whose donated time is far more valuable than your own, to waste that time holding your hand. You're the one being paid, after all. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 15:39, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

20:19, 13 November 2026 review of submission by Pawansinhaguruji

What is the main reason for rejecting the article? it can be fixed, pleaase let me know... Pawansinhaguruji (talk) 20:19, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Wikipedia is not a place for people to tell about themselves. Please read the autobiography policy. 331dot (talk) 20:30, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Alright, understood the mistake... Can i correct my mistake? by re-writing it in a more neutral manner? Pawansinhaguruji (talk) 20:37, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
The mistake you are making is that you are telling us what you want the world to know about you. That is the wrong approach. A Wikipedia article about a person must summarize what independent reliable sources with signficant coverage have chosen on their own to say about the person, showing how they meet the special Wikipedia definition of a notable person. "Significant coverage" is critical analysis and commentary that discusses what makes the topic important/significant/influential as they see it, not how the topic views its own importance.
You need to set aside everything that you know about yourself, all materials you put out, and all sources that just discuss your activities, and limit yourself to summarizing critical analysis and commentary about you made by others wholly unconnected to you. Most people have great difficulty doing that.
The chances that you will succeed in writing about yourself are almost zero, especially without prior, broader Wikipedia editing experience. In the last 15 years or so(my tenure) I have never personally seen someone succeed at writing about themselves, and the number of times it has happened when I wasn't looking can probably be counted on one hand, out of tens of thousands of attempts. It is very, very rare. Are you the rare person who will beat the odds and succeed where everyone else fails? It's possible, but not very likely. More than likely you will just be wasting your own valuable time. If you want to tell the world about yourself, that is exactly what social media is for. 331dot (talk) 21:35, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Not only wasting his own time, but wasting the time donated by the Wikipedia community, which is far more valuable, and shouldn't be spent on publicity or vanity efforts.
The only example that comes to mind of an autobiography succeeding is Lexi Love (actress), and that was rather impressive because it had high hurdles to overcome, such as a prior AFD discussion and deletion, as well as an AFD discussion after it was accepted. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 06:00, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
I'll try to remember that. 331dot (talk) 09:48, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
There was another example in the last week or two - I remember the reviewer congratulating the editor on having achieved the near-impossible - but unfortunately I don't remember the name of the article. ColinFine (talk) 13:10, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

20:47, 13 November 2026 review of submission by Pawansinhaguruji

Hello Thilsebatti. I’m requesting reconsideration of the rejection of Draft:Dr. Pawan Sinha 'Guruji'. I understand the concern that the draft did not demonstrate an encyclopedic purpose and may have read as promotional. I have substantially revised it to use a neutral tone and reduce material based on the subject’s and associated organisations’ own sources. I would appreciate guidance on whether the independent discussion of Astro Uncle in Tania Lewis’s chapter in Globalization and Modernity in Asia (Amsterdam University Press, 2018, pp. 107–128), alongside the independent reporting cited in the draft, changes your assessment. I have disclosed my conflict of interest and will not create a duplicate draft. Could you clarify whether reconsideration is appropriate, or whether there are specific concerns I should address? Pawansinhaguruji (talk) 20:47, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Both your message and your draft appear to have been generated by AI, which is not allowed on Wikipedia. The only way your draft could be reconsidered is if you rewrite your draft entirely on your own, without using AI. Please also refrain from writing comments on Wikipedia with the help of AI; we want to talk to you, not a chatbot. In solidarity, 🏳️‍🌈JohnLaurens333 (They/them • Not a chatbot • Contribs) 20:53, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Note also that the draft has been rejected, meaning stop, move on to something else. The collective time of Wikipedia's volunteer community is too valuable to waste. If you are the subject of that draft, see also WP:Autobiographies. It is quite rare for the subject of an article to succeed at getting one published on Wikipedia. It is best if an independent person who has no association with you writes it. If you are notable, then notability is permanent, and someone will eventually write an article about you. It should not matter to you in the least if Wikipedia has an article about you next month or 50 years from now. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 21:02, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

21:01, 13 November 2026 review of submission by KAKContributor

Hello! I've been working on Draft:Stan Hall, which has been declined twice for insufficient independent coverage.

I've revised the article to include additional reporting from the Gwinnett Daily Post, particularly a 2008 article by Holley Calmes about his arts leadership and a 2009 profile by Josh Green. The draft also includes coverage of his career appointments and recognition from other newspaper articles.

Before resubmitting, I'd appreciate a second opinion on whether these sources establish notability under Wikipedia's guidelines for biographies.

Are the 2008 and 2009 articles sufficient independent coverage, or is there something specific still missing?

Thank you for your help! KAKContributor (talk) 21:01, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Hello, and welcome to the Articles for Creation helpdesk. Your query appears to have been generated, in whole or in part, by some kind of AI chatbot or large language model. Using these tools to generate user-to-user communication runs contrary to Wikipedia's culture of collaborative communication. If you are using AI because you aren't confident in your English language skills or your knowledge of Wikipedia's processes, don't worry; we don't expect people to be perfect at either of those, just try your best to communicate with us in your own words. If you aren't sure why your draft was declined or rejected, please follow these steps;
  1. Make sure you've read the decline notice(s) (highlighted in red at the top of your draft) along with any comments left below by the reviewer(s).
  2. If any of the content in the decline notice is unclear, make sure to click all of the links in the decline notice and read the pages they take you to.
  3. If any of the content in the additional comments is unclear, you should ask for clarification from the reviewer who left the comment directly on their talk page.
If after doing all of the above, you still have additional questions, then this help desk is the place for it; please feel free to ask us any more specific questions you have, just please do so without help from any AI or LLM. Remember; if you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human effort. It is unfair and disrespectful to ask volunteer editors to use their time and effort helping you if you won't even use your own time and effort to do some reading and formulate your own question. Athanelar (talk) 21:29, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
It's mostly local coverage, which doesn't establish notability. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 05:47, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

November 14

04:43, 14 November 2026 review of submission by DGurumayum

@EndTheWikiEditor: Hi,

I'd appreciate some guidance on my AfC draft, Draft:Richard A. Bales.

The latest feedback suggests that the subject could potentially meet either WP:NPROF or WP:NAUTHOR, but the current references don't establish notability.

Could someone please take a look at the draft and advise what kind of independent sources or additional evidence would help establish notability? In particular, would independent reviews of his books or academic discussions of his work be useful?

I'm happy to make further improvements based on the feedback.

Thanks for your help! DGurumayum (talk) 04:43, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

Don't use a chatbot to talk to us, write drafts, or generate any text whatsoever on Wikipedia.
Did you actually read WP:NPROF and WP:NAUTHOR? Your AI did not. See also WP:Golden rule as a minimum standard.
You have received feedback, multiple times. What exactly about the decline notices did you not understand? ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 06:05, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Yup, agreed - please use your own analytical skills to understand what my feedback meant, rather than AI. However, it's worth clarifying my feedback here, sorry!
I was attempting to say that the subject, given the achievements/career you've listed on this article, is not notable enough to meet WP:NPROF or WP:NAUTHOR. However, if there's something you've omitted so far, especially a national academic award, it could meet these criteria and thus be included.
The other side to that statement was that given this academic has an ongoing career, they may become notable in the future, but they just aren't right now.
TLDR; If there's no additional information to add to this article which would help it meet WP:NAUTHOR or WP:NPROF, there are very few improvements which could be made to make this article able to be included. Please read these linked policies and the feedback that Anachronist, myself, and other reviewers of your article have given you.
Cheers, End (talk) 08:53, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

17:45, 14 November 2026 review of submission by ClerkoftheCity

I've submitted twice, the second time adding additional references. The Company is a City of London Livery Company. There are 114 of these, of which all 113 others have articles. Being a Livery Company seems therefore to be evidence enough of notability (indeed, to attain Livery status requires an organisation to achieve a level of relevance beyond that required for a Wikipedia article in terms of age, membership size, activity, relevance to industry and so on). The Company is the newest/most recent Livery Company, so has fewer external references than others. I think it possible that the article is being rejected by editors who do not understand/know the context of City of London Livery Companies, and see a stub article for an HR organisation they've never heard of. Any advice on getting this to a level at which it would be accepted greatly appreciated! ClerkoftheCity (talk) 17:45, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

@ClerkoftheCity Please see WP:No special considerations. If indeed the organisation is as historic as you say, then you should have no problems finding appropriate sources to demonstrate that it meets our inclusion criteria for organisations and companies. If you cannot find such sources then there is no way for the company to have an article on Wikipedia. Athanelar (talk) 17:50, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
@ClerkoftheCity - I think the Company was referenced in the New Statesman recently ("sheep will be provided"). It will be a matter of time, and not a lot, before reliable secondary sources become available. Good luck with your sleuthing, it just needs better sources. ChrysGalley (talk) 19:03, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Don't make WP:OTHERSTUFF arguments. If Wikipedia has other substandard articles about livery companies, that's a reason to improve them or delete them. It isn't a reason to compound the problem by adding more of the same. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 20:06, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
To be fair, @Anachronist, @ClerkoftheCity hasn't said anything about the quality of the existing articles: it's more that they had the (very common) misunderstanding that a subject can merit a Wikipedia article by nature of what it is (or does) rather than the actual criterion of notability. ColinFine (talk) 17:25, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

22:15, 14 November 2026 review of submission by Ahmetcadirci2012

Why did you reject my submission? Ahmetcadirci2012 (talk) 22:15, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

You have not provided sny references which indicate the subject meets our requirement for notability. Athanelar (talk) 22:39, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

22:57, 14 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-60366-94

need advice ~2026-60366-94 (talk) 22:57, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

See WP:Your first article and give up on this draft. This topic has zero chance of meeting Wikipedia's notability guidelines. guninvalid (talk) 23:09, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

November 15

03:53, 15 November 2026 review of submission by Tihamer Toth-Fejel

Wikipedia is not a place for new ideas?

If not Wikipedia, then what would you suggest?

Thanks for any help you can give. Tihamer Toth-Fejel (talk) 03:53, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

@Tihamer Toth-Fejel See WP:Alternative outlets. Athanelar (talk) 06:14, 15 November 2026 (UTC)


Draft:SueEasy decline

Hi, I'm the author of Draft:SueEasy which was rejected on 15 November 2026 by 331dot due to failure to satisfy the company notability guideline. My conflict of interest is clear, as I co-founded the company, and this is noted on my user page and draft talk page.

The reason given for rejection included the Techcrunch40 semi-finalist achievement not providing notability. After my reply, the reviewer noted they had looked at all the sources and none provided any indication of notability. The two Techcrunch articles were particularly short and one was based on an email from the company.

Could you please clarify why the other sources do not provide notability? The draft references an article in the ABA Journal (21 April 2008) and a United Press International wire service article (15 April 2008). It also references an article in the Los Angeles Daily Journal (a legal trade journal) which mentions that there are over 1200 paid-for clients amongst attorneys and how much the service costs. These sources are all independent.

Are these sources considered to show significant coverage for a company? If not, is it because they lack depth, independence or reliability? I'm more than happy to improve my draft and re-submit. Just want to know what the standard is. Thank you.

SahilKazi1 (talk) 09:57, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

The sources do not provide significant coverage of your defunct company- this means critical analysis and commentary. They largely just document that it existed and told what it did.
You can't solve the problem of sources being insufficient; if sources don't exist, this defunct company does not merit an article at this time.
I'm curious why you want to write about your defunct companies. 331dot (talk) 10:02, 15 November 2026 (UTC)


I'm adding this comparison as it's part of the standard.

SecurityPal (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SecurityPal) has 7 mentions including TechCrunch. TechCrunch was mentioned in this thread as being too short to count for SueEasy. OFC Creations (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/OFC_Creations) was approved this month through Articles for Creation. It was approved by local Rochester papers, local TV and BroadwayWorld. It received regional and trade mentions similar to the Los Angeles Daily Journal article in the SueEasy draft. The article mentioned over 1200 paying customers and pricing. Agenda (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agenda_(app)) was approved this month by enthusiast blogs, MacStories, TidBITS and iMore. It had 3 mentions of their own website. Godot Gallery (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Godot_Gallery) was approved this month with 3 mentions of their own website.

The SueEasy draft mentions a feature from the ABA Journal, a wire report from United Press International and the Los Angeles Daily Journal. I was told that these 'largely just document that it existed'. The Daily Journal mentioned how many customers they have and their pricing. The ABA Journal came up with the term to describe their model that everyone else has used. This is analysing their business, not announcing their birth.

What do the sources in these 4 approved articles have that the sources in this draft don't?

SahilKazi1 (talk) 10:45, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

@SahilKazi1, we don't do comparisons, but review each draft on its own merits: see other stuff exists.
Looking at your first example, SecurityPal, @CNMall41 accepted it, but @Sulfurboy has disagreed on CNMall41's talk page, and has tagged it as possibly not meeting the requirements for notability - so this is an as yet unresolved challenge to its acceptability. ColinFine (talk) 17:38, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
GoDot and SecurityPal are the only two that look notable but that's my opinion based on WP:CORPDEPTH. The other two do not (on their face). We don't judge notability based on WP:OSE or we would have a website full of topics that fail notability guidelines miserably. Reviewers accepting drafts make a judgement call as to whether the topic will likely survive a deletion discussion. In this case, the person reviewing your draft feels it would not. --CNMall41 (talk) 18:44, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Draft:Filmmortal rejection

Hello, I am the author of Draft:Filmmortal, which was declined by 331dot company due to failure to meet its notability guidelines on 15 November 2026. There is an obvious conflict of interest as I am the founder of the company this is mentioned on my user page and draft talk page.

The reason for declining was because there was no evidence of notability. There was only a short mention on the website.

If you could explain why the sources don't show notability. The draft mentions a feature article in BusinessWeek (27 February 2009). This mentions they were bootstrapped with $130,000 from the founders. They charge $3,000 per placement and take 10%. Another source mentions there are approximately 80 different projects on the site (Media in Canada, 7 April 2009). This source has also been mentioned on IndieWire (27 October 2009). All sources are independent.

These sources do they show substantial coverage on the company? If they don't is it because they aren't detailed enough, independent or reliable? As the draft was declined I am wondering if there is any way to improve the draft and re-submit it. Thank you.

SahilKazi1 (talk) 10:04, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

A company raising funds/capital is a normal business activity that conveys no notability. 331dot (talk) 10:06, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Have you read WP:NCORP, specifically WP:CORPDEPTH and WP:CORPTRIV? Athanelar (talk) 10:07, 15 November 2026 (UTC)


As Athanelar asked if I had read WP:NCORP, WP:CORPDEPTH and WP:CORPTRIV I have. Here's how the draft fits. CORPTRIV: The information excluded is mundane, such as product launches and funding. Filmmortal never raised any external funding. They were bootstrapped using $130,000 of the founders own money. They never had a funding round to announce. The BusinessWeek article on 27 Feb 2009 is not a launch or funding story. It is a reported feature explaining how they are doing things differently with product placements. It gives details of how much they charge ($3000), the 10% commission and how the deals work. 331dot's answer refers to raising funding which isn't claimed in this draft. CORPDEPTH: The sources are BusinessWeek (27 Feb 2009) a reported feature. Media in Canada (7 Apr 2009) stating there are around 80 projects on the site and how it works differently to traditional placements ($30,000). IndieWire (27 Oct 2009) the trade press for the film industry. Product Placement News (17 Feb 2009) the trade magazine for the placement industry. 4 independent sources over 8 months. No press releases or the company's own site. As 331dot has already answered on the draft's talk page that he is "quite comfortable with the rejection" and won't decline it, I'm asking a volunteer who hasn't made a decision on this draft. As mentioned in my original post, do these sources not meet the criteria? If so please tell me which part (depth, independence or reliability) and which source. Just to give some scale, SecurityPal has 7 sources in the encyclopedia including TechCrunch. On this desk CNMall41 said 2 of the 4 recent articles don't look notable on the surface using CORPDEPTH, however they have been accepted. I'm not asking for an exception, I'm asking for the same criteria. SahilKazi1 (talk) 05:59, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Corptriv isn't just about funding rounds. It's about the routine business activities of the company in general, so details of how much they charge ($3000), the 10% commission and how the deals work is absolutely CORPTRIV. Athanelar (talk) 10:11, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
However the company obtained the money- it's still a normal business activity; many companies are started by the founders' own money. We consider each article or draft individually on their own merits and not based on the presence of other articles that themselves could be inappropriate and just not yet addressed by a volunteer, see other stuff exists. You are free to propose the removal of other articles you feel do not meet the guidelines that have been laid out to you. 331dot (talk) 10:23, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

11:01, 15 November 2026 review of submission by Alfio25

Hello,

I have prepared a draft biography about Andrea Afferni, an Italian tattoo artist, and submitted it for review through Articles for Creation.

I would appreciate an independent assessment of the draft, particularly regarding the notability of the subject, the reliability and independence of the sources, and whether the article meets Wikipedia’s requirements.

I would also appreciate any suggestions on how to improve the draft before it is reviewed.

Thank you for your time and assistance. Alfio25 (talk) 11:01, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

The draft is actually in your sandbox, I fixed the link so it works. You have submitted it and it is pending, it is unnecessary to additionally ask for a review. 331dot (talk) 11:09, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
The independent assessment is when the draft is reviewed.
In any case, this article will almost certainly be declined, on multiple grounds. First, the sourcing is very poor; anything that isn't an interview or quoting Afferni only mentions them in passing. Some of these mentions in passing are extremely limited; things like simply being listed as attending a conference are not useful. There's nothing here that I see that represents independent, reliable sourcing that provides significant coverage of Afferni.
The article is also written like a résumé/CV in prose form. There's almost nothing about Afferni. I can tell that Afferni's a highly respected tattoo artist, but literally nothing else about the subject.
In addition, it's quite obvious that it was written by an LLM, as is your comment here. Neither are acceptable things on English Wikipedia, and even if the article would be usable otherwise, this would be a fatal flaw. CoffeeCrumbs (talk) 11:10, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

15:23, 15 November 2026 review of submission by Kahinakhando

@DoubleGrazing: Help submitting revised draft for Daniel Seth Toney Hughes (technical paste limit & citation check) Hello, I am working on a biography draft for the late bioinformatician Daniel Seth Toney Hughes (currently in my sandbox / draft space — replace this parenthetical with your exact draft link, e.g., User:YourUsername/sandbox or Draft:Daniel Seth Toney Hughes). Reviewer DoubleGrazing recently declined the draft due to a lack of inline citations and reliance on unreliable/uncited statements. I have since rewritten the article to trim all unsupported claims and placed inline <ref> tags after every sentence using published peer-reviewed papers (GigaScience, Science, Genome Biology, Nucleic Acids Research), a 2022 press release, and his 2024 alumni memorial in The Brown Book (Lady Margaret Hall, Oxford). However, I ran into two issues and would appreciate advice: 1. Technical saving issue: When I try to paste the full revised wikitext into the editor, it seems to hit a size/paste limit or filter and won't let me save the whole text at once. Is saving the draft section-by-section the best way around this for a newer account? 2. Source check: Once I get the revised text saved, could someone confirm whether my new inline citations and sources meet WP:V and WP:NPROF before I resubmit it for review? Thank you very much for your time and help! Kahinakhando (talk) 15:23, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Hello, and welcome to the Articles for Creation helpdesk. Your query appears to have been generated, in whole or in part, by some kind of AI chatbot or large language model. Using these tools to generate user-to-user communication runs contrary to Wikipedia's culture of collaborative communication. If you are using AI because you aren't confident in your English language skills or your knowledge of Wikipedia's processes, don't worry; we don't expect people to be perfect at either of those, just try your best to communicate with us in your own words. If you aren't sure why your draft was declined or rejected, please follow these steps;
  1. Make sure you've read the decline notice(s) (highlighted in red at the top of your draft) along with any comments left below by the reviewer(s).
  2. If any of the content in the decline notice is unclear, make sure to click all of the links in the decline notice and read the pages they take you to.
  3. If any of the content in the additional comments is unclear, you should ask for clarification from the reviewer who left the comment directly on their talk page.
If after doing all of the above, you still have additional questions, then this help desk is the place for it; please feel free to ask us any more specific questions you have, just please do so without help from any AI or LLM. Remember; if you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human effort. It is unfair and disrespectful to ask volunteer editors to use their time and effort helping you if you won't even use your own time and effort to do some reading and formulate your own question. Athanelar (talk) 15:25, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi Athanelar,
I am dyslexic so find the way of writing this so confusing! I really need help to write my late twin brother's wiki page. I went through each of his articles one by one to verify them. I need help getting his page ready so that it is accepted. Is there somewhere you can point me like a template that I can use to start doing it myself...thanks for your response. Sorry if its is confusing! Kahinakhando (talk) 15:32, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi, @Kahinakhando, thanks for dropping the AI and speaking to me directly. I'm sorry for your brother's relatively recent passing at such a terribly young age for it.
It seems at the moment that what you're trying to do is mostly record your brother's accomplishments as a sort of memorial to him. While this is understandable and admirable, it is unfortunately not what Wikipedia is for. A Wikipedia article should be a neutral summary of what the majority of people who are wholly unconnected with the subject have independently chosen to publish about the subject in reliable publications, (see Golden rule) and not much else. What you know (or anybody else knows) about the subject is not relevant except where it can be verified from a reliable published source.
That said, your brother may well qualify for inclusion here under our special criteria for academics; see WP:NACADEMIC.
Writing a Wikipedia article is a lot of hard work. I'm afrsid there's no easy way, shortcut, or template to fill in. You'll need to read basically all the pages I linked above, then follow Help:Your first article. If you don't feel up to it, please do not be tempted to pay somebody to do it for you; such offers are always scams. You may be contacted by people offering you such services and you should refuse them.
Above all, remember that Wikipedia is just an informational resource. There is nothing particularly desirable about being included here, and no specific reason you should strongly want your brother to be. Athanelar (talk) 16:01, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi @Athanelar, thanks for your lovely feedback. My brother spent his whole life dedicated to science and had his work published in multiple scientific journals, including major software tools and data infrastructure used by researchers and clinicians. I will do as you advised—take my time and slowly build his wiki page brick by brick. He already has a memorial page. This is about his academic work... Thank you so much for the guidance and feedback, I really appreciate it. I will start again slowly! :) Kahinakhando (talk) 16:41, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

15:29, 15 November 2026 review of submission by Prof. Hitesh D Raviya

Dear Wikipedia Editors,

My biographical draft, Draft:Hitesh D. Raviya, was recently declined due to concerns regarding reliable sources and notability.

I have since substantially revised the draft, replaced hidden research notes with visible biographical information, and added eight references, including reports from The Indian Express and The Times of India, alongside official university records.

I have also disclosed my conflict of interest, as I am the subject of the proposed biography.

I respectfully request guidance on whether the available evidence may satisfy Wikipedia's academic notability criteria under WP:NACADEMIC, and what additional independent sources or evidence of scholarly recognition would be required.

I understand that academic appointments, publications and institutional profiles alone do not automatically establish notability.

I would appreciate an independent assessment before resubmitting the revised draft.

Thank you for your time and guidance. Prof. Hitesh D Raviya (talk) 15:29, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Hello, and welcome to the Articles for Creation helpdesk. Your query appears to have been generated, in whole or in part, by some kind of AI chatbot or large language model. Using these tools to generate user-to-user communication runs contrary to Wikipedia's culture of collaborative communication. If you are using AI because you aren't confident in your English language skills or your knowledge of Wikipedia's processes, don't worry; we don't expect people to be perfect at either of those, just try your best to communicate with us in your own words. If you aren't sure why your draft was declined or rejected, please follow these steps;
  1. Make sure you've read the decline notice(s) (highlighted in red at the top of your draft) along with any comments left below by the reviewer(s).
  2. If any of the content in the decline notice is unclear, make sure to click all of the links in the decline notice and read the pages they take you to.
  3. If any of the content in the additional comments is unclear, you should ask for clarification from the reviewer who left the comment directly on their talk page.
If after doing all of the above, you still have additional questions, then this help desk is the place for it; please feel free to ask us any more specific questions you have, just please do so without help from any AI or LLM. Remember; if you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human effort. It is unfair and disrespectful to ask volunteer editors to use their time and effort helping you if you won't even use your own time and effort to do some reading and formulate your own question. Athanelar (talk) 16:02, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

16:30, 15 November 2026 review of submission by MrLegend0130

ABOUT REFERENCE

MrLegend0130 (talk) 16:30, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
The subject has zero hope of meeting our notability guidelines at this time. As such, the draft has been rejected and will not be considered further. Sulfurboy (talk) 16:38, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

16:39, 15 November 2026 review of submission by MrLegend0130

MY WIKIPEDIA PAGE GOT REJECTED .CAN YOU TELL ME HOW CAN I SOLVE IT PLEASE MrLegend0130 (talk) 16:39, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

AND ALSO I DIDNT PUT REFERNCE MrLegend0130 (talk) 16:40, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
You have answered your own question, you cannot create articles with zero sources. You need to start by finding three good reliable sources that cover you indepth and then report on what they say. Theroadislong (talk) 16:44, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Your draft was rejected because you do not meet Wikipedia's criteria for inclusion (you are not notable enough by Wikipedia's terms to have an article). Please move on, as your draft will not be accepted. In solidarity, 🏳️‍🌈JohnLaurens333 (They/them • Not a chatbot • Contribs) 16:42, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

16:44, 15 November 2026 review of submission by Giadrome76

@Sulfurboy: Hi, I would like to ask for some clarity as to why the Netherlands list has been declined under the standalone-list notability guidelines. I created the existing List of dog breeds originating from England, List of dog breeds originating from Scotland, and List of dog breeds originating from Wales, all of which were accepted. The Netherlands version follows the same principles, format and navigational purpose. I do appreciate that the fact that the previous lists were accepted doesn't automatically mean the Netherlands one has to be accepted as well. I would appreciate some clarity on wether the issue is the references, which I can strengthen if so, or if the grouping itself is the issue. Giadrome76 (talk) 16:44, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Please see WP:NLIST. We need to see reliable sources showing sigcov of the broader subject to establish notability. It looks like some of those other accepts might have been questionable. Sulfurboy (talk) 16:47, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi, thanks for the clarity. I have located two published academic sources that specifically discuss Dutch dog breeds collectively. I have added these sources to the draft. I also believe the list serves a recognised informational and navigational purpose, as contemplated by WP. Do these sources help address your concerns about notability of the list as a standalone subject? Giadrome76 (talk) 16:59, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
@Giadrome76 Why are you using an WP:LLM to talk to me? Did you use LLMs in the creation of these lists as well? Sulfurboy (talk) 17:20, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I did not use an LLM to respond to you and I did not use an LLM to draft the lists as well. I simply copied my English list and used that as a template and just replaced the dogs and wording. Giadrome76 (talk) 17:23, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

20:27, 15 November 2026 review of submission by Blitzite2

I want to get feedback on how to polish the article further to move it to mainspace/have it ready for review. Blitzite2 (talk) 20:27, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Instagram is not a reliable source. Replace it with a better source.
You have at least one assertion that isn't cited to any source at all. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 20:31, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Sorry, I got the source from the High Potential page, and I didn't see anything on the page saying it was wrong.
Could you expand on the second part, do you mean I need more assertions? Blitzite2 (talk) 21:14, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I meant that any assertion made about a living person must be backed up by a citation to a reliable source. Unsourced statements (such as your entire "early life" section) must either be removed, or a source must be found. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 23:36, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

21:37, 15 November 2026 review of submission by DargerDavies

@Sulfurboy: I am trying to fulfill all the requirements to get this article about my father made. He is a well-known person and has plenty of references to his works as well as his books. I also am trying to compile some photos to upload to his profile as well. I have dyslexia so I use LLM’s to correct my spelling and to search for the correct links for reference references.

Is there any thing that I can do to fulfill the requirements necessary to have this article published? DargerDavies (talk) 21:37, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

@DargerDavies The transcript that you've provided very obviously shows that your use of AI goes well beyond "correcting your spelling". It's literally doing the editing for you. You asked it Can you login and input the new references?
Have you read about the types of sources you need in order to show notability? Athanelar (talk) 22:04, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
You are right. While at work I tried to have it remove all references to TimLove’s website where he nested the actual copies of articles some from publications that were never made digital. The reason I did so wasn’t just laziness, the association of the reference numbers and the bibliography confuse me and it is difficult for me most espescially to reassociate all the data. But I’m going to delete the whole thing and start over simply with the hope that someone else will edit it more thoroughly with the references I added eventually as they are appropriate to the subject of the article. DargerDavies (talk) 06:16, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello, @DargerDavies.
A Wikipedia article should be a neutral summary of what the majority of people who are wholly unconnected with the subject have independently chosen to publish about the subject in reliable publications, (see Golden rule) and not much else. What you know (or anybody else knows) about the subject is not relevant except where it can be verified from a reliable published source.
So you should start with finding several sources that each meet all the requirements in the golden rule - people completely unconnected with him, and not working from information provided by him or his associates, have chosen to write in depth (commentary or analyis) about him specifically (not just about particular works) and been published in reliable places.
If you can find several such sources, then there is a possibility of an article about him, and your real challenge begins, as an editor with a conflict of interest: you will effectively need to forget everything that you know about him, and write a neutral summary of what those independent sources say about him. Not many people manage this task.
I suggest not worrying about pictures at this point: they will not affect whether or not your draft is accepted. If you can get a draft accepted, then consider finding suitable pictures. ColinFine (talk) 22:48, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I want to assume good faith, but sentences such as Tim Love’s enduring legacy upholding the ethics in advertising media and commercial speech have be lauded as significant contributions to the advertising and media world. His art as well endures as a testament to his passion for visual media and personal expression. make me skeptical that LLM use is limited to correcting spelling and finding sources. There's also a lot of the notorious chatbot habit of covering the coverage of the subject, not just reporting the facts with cites. These are not the only WP:AISIGNS here.
This person may be notable under Wikipedia's definition, but I'm not sure that this draft is helpful in getting them an article as you seem to have stuffed in every tangential thing you could think of, leading to an incredible amount of bloat. A short, disciplined article, completely written by you, backed only by the reliable sources that are independent and directly providing significant coverage about Tim Love would be far more likely to make a case for notability. There's a reason WP:COI drafts by new editors rarely work out; writing an article from scratch is the most difficult Wikipedia task even for an experienced editor. CoffeeCrumbs (talk) 01:24, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
There’s just so much material to sort through. I’m not entirely sure which are the most notable or reliable sources and would appreciate your insights into which ones to include or omit. In truth I am trying to do this as his son for the purposes of a birthday gift for him. For years he’s had to deal with bad SEO because of Chef Time Love being a more televised character but most definitely not more notable. But I’ll give this whole thing another try. My first attempts were attempts at being thorough. Simplicity I am realizing is the key as you’ve said. Thank you for any and all help you can provide. DargerDavies (talk) 04:38, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
@DargerDavies Multiple editors have provided helpful links to what do and don't constitute reliable sources, they also have advised you not to use LLMs. Expecting them to help you beyond that because you don't want to put in the time to learn isn't really appropriate. Further, we are an encyclopedia, not a place for you to make a misguided bespoke birthday gifts for someone. It seems you're WP:NOTHERE to actively contribute for anything other than what you had hoped would be an easy birthday present (one of the more absurd reasons I've heard for someone wanting to make an article) Sulfurboy (talk) 05:13, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Listen your own projections and hurt comes through in your response. I’m here to genuinely try but my dyslexia and the interface for submissions here is difficult to onboard to. So while I appreciate the advice I don’t appreciate the suspicion, snark and spiteful tone that that help comes with. DargerDavies (talk) 05:49, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

November 16

06:06, 16 November 2026 review of submission by Wizardking89

I'm a paid editor for EnerTribe as Wizardking89. In July 2025 I created Draft:Forest James as Mallen1189, and now I edit as Wizardking89. The article was rejected as AI-generated and deleted under G11, I was still fairly new to Wikipedia rules at that time. Both my new account and the old account are now linked and disclosed about their usage and relationship with EnerTribe and Forest James. I've now written a new draft with my own words around 200 words using only independent sources. Some of my strongest sources are:

A News Cafe, R.V. Scheide, 2015-10-19 https://anewscafe.com/2015/10/19/redding/indian-country-gets-wired-karuk-tribe-brings-broadband-to-the-boondocks/ Wyoming Public Media, Melodie Edwards, 2019-06-28 https://www.wyomingpublicmedia.org/post/super-speedy-internet-coming-soon-wind-river-reservation The Architect's Newspaper, Petala Ironcloud, 2026-08-28 https://www.archpaper.com/2026/08/colusa-indian-energy/

Here are my accounts: New: User:Wizardking89, Old: User:Mallen1189

Given the new sources and the proper disclosures on each account, is this enough to get approval for submission? Wizardking89 (talk) 06:06, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

@Wizardking89 Please read WP:PAIDADVICE. Athanelar (talk) 07:29, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

06:18, 16 November 2026 review of submission by LyoVrd

I made an interesting biography of me and got rejected , please can you describe whats wrong so i can make it right LyoVrd (talk) 06:18, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

@LyoVrd Wikipedia isn't a place to post jokes, unfortunately. Athanelar (talk) 07:27, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

06:36, 16 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-56826-67

@Giuliotf: I checked my content for AI, it is zero percent AI, I have written this with my own hands without using any AI tool. I do not understand why it has been rejected based on this reason?? ~2026-56826-67 (talk) 06:36, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

@~2026-56826-67 If you are @Gerneralknowldge106 you left a comment on the draft stating I used ChatGPT to assist with drafting and editing this article. Athanelar (talk) 07:26, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I did not used chatgpt, where do you see that written? ~2026-56826-67 (talk) 08:14, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I am not Gerneralknowldge106 ~2026-56826-67 (talk) 08:15, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I edited this page on - This page was last edited on 14 November 2026, at 13:33 (UTC). ~2026-56826-67 (talk) 08:16, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Then what is your connection to the subject of this draft which caused you to suddenly appear and 'try to save' the draft? Athanelar (talk) 08:18, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
because I want this to be published and it took me time to rewrite this without any AI model. ~2026-56826-67 (talk) 08:21, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
How do get an approval? ~2026-56826-67 (talk) 08:22, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Why do you want this to be published? Athanelar (talk) 08:28, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Because I pickup this task to get it published on my own. ~2026-56826-67 (talk) 08:31, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Yes, but how did you find the draft? Why is this subject of interest to you? It's very unusual for an unregistered editor to appear out of nowhere just to edit an existing draft about a particular company. Athanelar (talk) 08:32, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I do not understand how it is relevant to discuss that. But a lot of my friends do edit wikipedia articles. I came across this brand as I love Ayurveda and was exploring the brand, next I am going to see topics around squash if that interests you. Now can please someone help me get this published? ~2026-56826-67 (talk) 08:37, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Then you're better off familiarising yourself with our policies and guidelines and writing your own draft from scratch rather than trying to piggyback somebody else's AI-generated draft and make it your own.
Read WP:N, WP:V, WP:NPOV, WP:NCORP and then Help:Your first article. Preferably, spend a few weeks getting familiar with editing Wikipedia before you embark on this task, because new editors with no editing experience are extremely unlikely to succeed in creating new articles from scratch. Athanelar (talk) 08:44, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Querying your interest in this subject is entirely relevant, if you have a real-life relationship with it. You don't simply accidentally bump into a page in the draft space. You needed to be searching for Ayuvya, and when Wikipedia told you there is no such article, you needed to click on the red link in order to create one, only then will it even have mentioned that this draft exists. And yet, not only did you somehow find it, you started 'saving' it, and so far every one of your edits has to do with it. Of the millions of subjects that exist in Wikipedia, and the billions of viable topics in the world, this gets your singular interest. There's probably a reason for that?
Anyway, to answer your question about how to get this published, the latest decline template (which is again there, since I've restored it, twice) has a blue 'resubmit' button; you can click on that to send it for another review. It doesn't mean it gets published, in fact I can already now tell you it won't be accepted as it currently stands, but that is how it gets reviewed at least. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 08:53, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
I declined the draft over a month ago because the original creator declared AI use that was in violation of our LLM guidelines WP:NOLLM.
As you have re-written the article you are free to resubmit using the resubmit button in the decline notice. I would reccomend you leave a comment to say that you have rewritten the article so other reviewers can see right away that you have made an attempt to address the issue.
Even if the LLM issue has been addressed, I am skeptical that the draft would be accepted based on other policies and guidelines (e.g. WP:NORG) however you are welcome to try and I'll leave that decision for the future reviewer. Giulio 09:37, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
FYI a user (this user?) came into #wikipedia-en-help asking about this draft and I did a source assessment for them, and gave some more tips on notability. qcne (talk) 09:40, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Also know that alternative medicine is a formally designated contentious topic, where rules are enforced more strictly. See your user talk page.
331dot (talk) 09:41, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

07:01, 16 November 2026 review of submission by AhmadKhodrAtAloFor

My name is Ahmad Khodr, and I am the founder of AloFor. I have disclosed my connection to the company on Wikipedia.

I would like to ask about Draft:AloFor, which was declined twice because the sources were considered insufficient.

I have many sources and press articles, and I have also given a television interview. I now have three additional articles about the company, and I would like to know whether they help establish its notability.

I understand that these articles include an interview with me and information provided by the company, and I would appreciate an independent assessment of them.

Do any of these sources meet the WP:SIRS criteria? If they are not sufficient, what is still needed before I resubmit the draft?

I would appreciate your help. AhmadKhodrAtAloFor (talk) 07:01, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Hello, and welcome to the Articles for Creation helpdesk. Your query appears to have been generated, in whole or in part, by some kind of AI chatbot or large language model. Using these tools to generate user-to-user communication runs contrary to Wikipedia's culture of collaborative communication. If you are using AI because you aren't confident in your English language skills or your knowledge of Wikipedia's processes, don't worry; we don't expect people to be perfect at either of those, just try your best to communicate with us in your own words. If you aren't sure why your draft was declined or rejected, please follow these steps;
  1. Make sure you've read the decline notice(s) (highlighted in red at the top of your draft) along with any comments left below by the reviewer(s).
  2. If any of the content in the decline notice is unclear, make sure to click all of the links in the decline notice and read the pages they take you to.
  3. If any of the content in the additional comments is unclear, you should ask for clarification from the reviewer who left the comment directly on their talk page.
If after doing all of the above, you still have additional questions, then this help desk is the place for it; please feel free to ask us any more specific questions you have, just please do so without help from any AI or LLM. Remember; if you are asking for human attention, demonstrate human effort. It is unfair and disrespectful to ask volunteer editors to use their time and effort helping you if you won't even use your own time and effort to do some reading and formulate your own question.
Please also read WP:PAIDADVICE. Athanelar (talk) 07:23, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
i am Ahmad Khodr founder of the global company AloFor and I have disclosed my relationship with the company on wikipedia.
i would like to ask about the draft article Alofor which was declined twice because of insufficient sources
I have many sources and press articles in many countries around the world and I also gave a television interview on the lebanese channel red tv there are three new articles and i would like to know if these materials are enough to prove that the company meets the requirements
for this reason i am asking for an independent review of them
is the draft good? and i want to tell you that many newspapers and media outlets have talked about me and my company AloFor
i ask for your help and thank you for your quick reply and understanding AhmadKhodrAtAloFor (talk) 13:40, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Press releases, articles in trade publications, and interviews are irrelevant for assessing notability.
Furthermore, emphasizing publication names and describing the existence of coverage is a sign of using an LLM chatbot as an author or co-author, which is prohibited on Wikipedia.
Exactly why does it matter that your company have an article on Wikipedia? ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 23:13, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

08:07, 16 November 2026 review of submission by Debfaith91

Hi Wikipedia Team; I would like to publish the article Deborah Faith Ramkhelawan -- screenplaywriter, writer, author. Thank you so much. Debfaith91 (talk) 08:07, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Hi, @Debfaith91
At the moment, your article stands no chance of being published, because it doesn't demonstrate that you (and I assume you are writing about yourself, based on your username) meet our special definition of a notable author, or our broader special definition of a notable person. You have to demonstrate in your article that you meet one of these standards in order for it to have any chance of being accepted.
That said, you should know that people are almost never successful at publishing autobiographies on Wikipedia. You can read our autobiography policy for more information; writing a Wikipedia article is the most difficult task for anyone to do on the site, doubly so if they have no prior editing experience, and triply so if they're doing something like writing an autobiography. The chances of success very rapidly approach zero. The best advice anybody here could give you would be to go about your career as if you had never heard of Wikipedia. Find yourself a publisher, publish a couple dozen more books through that publisher, and let somebody else write the article about you once they hear about your work a few years down the line when you may meet our definition of notability. Do not bother trying to write the article yourself--if nothing else because there are good reasons to not want an article about yourself here--and certainly do not accept any offers you may receive to publish an article about you here in response for payment, such offers are always scams and the people who make them have no special power to bypass our processes and standards and get your article published. Athanelar (talk) 08:14, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

08:33, 16 November 2026 review of submission by MPReed

@Sulfurboy: Hi

This article has been declined for a second time due to not meeting the criteria for music, but I had thought I had addressed the point of being significantly covered by multiple reliable and independent sources -

I added reviews and coverage from The Scotsman and Edinburgh Evening News daily print newspapers, and an article by Broadway World website - all three have entries within Wikipedia.

Can anyone offer guidance please? MPReed (talk) 08:33, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

You linked to the reviews, but do not summarize what the reviews say. 331dot (talk) 08:40, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Thanks - I've added a Reviews section quoting from and linking to the reviews. MPReed (talk) 09:00, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
It's not just about who says something, it's also about what they say. A source which establishes notability must be reliable AND independent AND contain significant coverage, or alternatively must establish that one of the special criteria at WP:NMUSIC is met (for example Has had a single or album on any country's national music chart). So, it's all well and good to say "I've linked to coverage from Big Name 1, 2, and 3" but if that coverage doesn't contain anything of use, it's no good.
All of the pieces you've described here are just reviews of and context for this one particular album, and don't really give a lot of significant coverage about the band themselves. Athanelar (talk) 08:41, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Thanks for the feedback. I've added a reviews section and quoted from it to hopefully focus not just on the album itself. I've included links to other sites with pieces that talk about the band outwith the album which I used as source material to write the page MPReed (talk) 09:05, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

08:54, 16 November 2026 review of submission by Amandinedermaux

@Avgeekamfot: In the article, you mentioned there is promotional language and personal commentary in the article. Can you please let me know where this is situated so I can change it?

Thanks a lot Amandinedermaux (talk) 08:54, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

@Amandinedermaux Promotion in Wikipedia articles is not normally solved by just changing a few lines; it's an issue of intent, not style. Please read WP:PAIDADVICE. Athanelar (talk) 09:00, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi, thanks a lot. I have read the artikel you have shared about paid advice. But what can I do now? regards Amandinedermaux (talk) 12:42, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
@Amandinedermaux: promotional editing isn't just limited to promotional language. When you are telling the world about your employer, saying whatever they want you to say, that is also inherently promotional (see WP:YESPROMO) regardless of the language used.
This draft has 14 citations. Six of them are to you company's own website. Five are to made-in.be, which looks to me like a thinly-veiled churnalism or export promotion outlet, with the content in those cited articles likely originating at your business. This isn't what we want to see, we instead want you to summarise what reliable and entirely independent secondary sources have said about your business, as explained in WP:GOLDENRULE. That is pretty much the only approach that will result in an acceptable draft, including but not only resolving the problem of promotional content. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 12:59, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
As @DoubleGrazing has pointed out, the sources you're using are not doing you any favors in producing an adequate draft. AfC is broken by design so it's very important that you review all of the guidelines and submit something that is acceptable both in terms of writing and showing notability. Avgeekamfot (talk) 03:38, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

11:09, 16 November 2026 review of submission by ArcherEnterprise1

@Sulfurboy: I got this other rejection from you of reliable independent sources that are providing significant coverage of the page subject. I do not understand the reason for this happening and need some explanation or second opinion in this regard. Some of the citations were a bit off and I have edited those links and all appears to be clear now. Perhaps that was the problem? ArcherEnterprise1 (talk) 11:09, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Hi ArcherEnterprise1, I've commented on the sources you've used below:
1: Interview, not independent
2: Okay coverage, bit short, and very niche regional publication
3: N/A
4: Not significant coverage
5: Not significant coverage
6: Link broken
7: Interview, not independent
8: Court documents, not independent
I'd suggest reading WP:42 for a short explanation of what good sources are like. InfernoHues (talk) 05:59, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

11:16, 16 November 2026 review of submission by ArcherEnterprise1

@Sulfurboy: I changed the title of the page because most f the references cited it in this way. Does that help? ArcherEnterprise1 (talk) 11:16, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

11:18, 16 November 2026 review of submission by Abdulnayeem412

please guide me Abdulnayeem412 (talk) 11:18, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Hello, @Abdulnayeem412.
I will guide you to read WP:autobiography, and understand that very very very very very few people have ever succeeded in writing about themselves in English Wikipedia, and my advice is to forget about Wikipedia and concentrate on your career.
It is unlikely that you meet Wikipedia's criteria for notability - most people in the world do not - and if you don't, then nobody could successfully write an article about you.
And, now that you have tried, I must warn you that it is possible that somebody will contact you offering to create an article for payment. That will be a scam, and you should not pay anybody to edit Wikipedia on your behalf. See WP:SCAM. ColinFine (talk) 11:46, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

12:20, 16 November 2026 review of submission by ChadHicks

@WXchaser: Hello,

I have been trying to create this article for several years now. I attempt to address reviewer comments like "requires reliable sources" by providing reliable sources, but the result is the same. And there is no explanation for why the sources I am providing are unreliable. They are after all the nation's top media outlets - it does not get more reliable in Canada.

There are numerous pages for similar persons that have far less reliable sourcing.

So, before giving up, I thought I'd ask here what the real guidelines are for reviewers since I would say this process is overly opaque. Perhaps it requires someone actually from Canada to review it?

Thank you. ChadHicks (talk) 12:20, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

The advice you've been given is This draft is not adequately supported by reliable sources. Wikipedia's verifiability policy requires that all content be supported by reliable sources. You seem to have misinterpreted this as meaning that your article has a whole has too few reliable sources. What it means is that not all of the information in your draft is properly sourced.
Looking at your draft, I see whole paragraphs that lack a source, such as Sills was awarded a BSc and Certificate of Meteorology in 1993 and earned a PhD in Atmospheric Science in 1998, all from York University in Toronto.
In biographies of living persons, every potentially contestable claim must be supported by a source. Beyond that, I also see that some of the previous declines relate to notability; you need to also prove that your subject meets our special definition of a notable academic.
Please click and read all of the links you've been given in the past decline notices. They contain information about relevant policies and guidelines. Athanelar (talk) 12:26, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Thanks for the reply. Everything that is currently in the article is a response to past decline notices. I've added sources, removed sources, tried to make the article resemble numerous other similar published articles for other similar scientific researchers. It just keeps getting declined with one-line explanations that don't help. And the declines often contradict each other.
You may think this is all quite clear - but it's not. Like I said, after pursuing this for years, I'm ready to give up. I have other articles that were accepted on the first try - including a biography of a living person. There's something about a Canadian weather scientist that reviewers don't seem to get. What that is remains a mystery. ChadHicks (talk) 13:01, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Conversely, in the 'Media' section, the simple statement "Sills has appeared numerous times in national, regional and international media to explain severe storms science and to raise awareness of tornado risk in Canada." has ten (!) citations supporting, as a prime example of WP:REFBOMBING. Usually a single citation suffices, maybe two for particularly extraordinary claims; there is never the need for ten. In this case the ten are probably there to demonstrate the "numerous times" part of the statement, but this in itself is pointless, because appearing in media to comment on things provides zero evidence of notability, so the entire section could just as well be left out as blatant peacockery. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 12:36, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Indeed it's very normal for academics to be called for comment in the media, so "Expert comments on their subject of expertise" is about as significant a statement as "Plumber fixes leaking sink" Athanelar (talk) 12:47, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
This person does many dozens of media interviews per year, right across the country and beyond. He is not *an* expert, he is *the* expert on this subject - which I would think makes him notable. The impact of these interviews can't be expressed by citing them all, so I've cited mostly national media. Again, if there is a better way to do this, please let me know. If I am making incorrect assumptions, that would be good to know, too. And once again, there are many, many Wikipedia articles about people of a similar stature and with even less notability and sourcing. So why the inconsistency? That's the most frustrating part. ChadHicks (talk) 13:17, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
There are plenty of articles in mainspace that do not meet our requirements and should be edited or deleted; finding and actioning those articles is a constant part of the work we do on this project. Not every article has been subject to thorough scrutiny to ensure it meets our requirements. Anybody with an autoconfirmed account can publish articles directly into mainspace without them ever being checked by anybody. These articles do get placed into the new pages patrol queue, but that queue is backlogged with literally tens of thousands of articles. By submitting your article as a draft via AfC, you are specifically requesting that it be scrutinised to ensure it meet all of the requirements. When we tell you it doesn't, there is therefore no sense in comparing it against articles that may never have received that scrutiny. We are telling you what the requirements are and why your article doesn't meet them, whether other articles do or do not exist is irrelevant. Athanelar (talk) 13:37, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
That is useful to know. I didn't understand that distinction. Many thanks! ChadHicks (talk) 15:54, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
So trying to establish notability through citations is refbombing. Trying to establish notability without sources will definitely result in a decline. "Peacockery"? I'm just trying to get this simple page published, and trying to figure out what the reviewers doing the declining really want - which is challenging. I would very much appreciate it if you could take the time to let me know a better way of doing this. ChadHicks (talk) 13:10, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Like I said, Looking at your draft, I see whole paragraphs that lack a source, such as "Sills was awarded a BSc and Certificate of Meteorology in 1993 and earned a PhD in Atmospheric Science in 1998, all from York University in Toronto." In biographies of living persons, every potentially contestable claim must be supported by a source. That's what the latest decline was for. Athanelar (talk) 13:32, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Understood. I'll give it another go and hope I get it right this time. Thanks! ChadHicks (talk) 15:55, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

14:17, 16 November 2026 review of submission by Info.Forscher

My draft "Giselle Anne" was rejected again. "EndTheWikiEditor" says it seems that I have used ChatGPD/LLMs. I have been trying to publish my article for a long time and inbetween I learned a lot about Wikipedia guidelines, credible sources etc. I totally wrote my draft with my own words. I never used ChatGPD or AI tools. So I was completely surprised that the article was rejected. I don't want to give up. What shall I do? I need help. Info.Forscher (talk) 14:17, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Even if you have not used any AI whatsoever, this draft currently stands no chance of acceptance. It is written from an obviously promotional point of view, is little more than the subject's resume, and does not demonstrate that the subject meets our definition of a notable person. These are core issues you'll need to resolve, AI or no AI. Athanelar (talk) 14:24, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Thanks a lot. I have to think about it. Info.Forscher (talk) 15:31, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
GPTZero says the draft is 100% AI generated and it certainly looks like it. Theroadislong (talk) 15:34, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Thanks Theroadislong - This is also a surprise. I heard about ChatGPT and AI, but until now I never used it and I never heard of GPTZero before. I can tell you that the answer of GPTZero is definitely wrong. In the last months I tried to shorten the text and to to search reliable sources for every statement (using internet, buying books). It was a lot of work. The result, according to Athanelar, evidently is that „the person does not meet the definition of a notable person“. So I`ll try to improve this point. Other advices are welcome. Info.Forscher (talk) 16:51, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello, @Info.Forscher. Leaving aside the question of LLM, note that A Wikipedia article should be a neutral summary of what the majority of people who are wholly unconnected with the subject have independently chosen to publish about the subject in reliable publications, (see Golden rule) and not much else. What you know (or anybody else knows) about the subject is not relevant except where it can be verified from a reliable published source.
If a draft reads as what the subject wants people to know, then it is promotional, and not acceptable. ColinFine (talk) 16:44, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello, @ ColinFine - Thanks for your helpful suggestions. I will take them into account when revising the draft. Info.Forscher (talk) 17:02, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

16:04, 16 November 2026 review of submission by Knile

Hi! I'm hoping to get this up with appropriate language. I've been working to use neutral tone and find all the citations I can, but the business aspects are hard to simplify sometimes. Trying to understand how WP Solutions can guide me and also looking for any other advice on smoothing this over! Knile (talk) 16:04, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Are you associated with FreeWheel in some way?
The draft largely summarizes the normal business activities and offerings of the company, and no critical analysis and commentary as to what makes the company a notable company. 331dot (talk) 16:08, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
If you're referring to WP:SOLUTIONS, that essay simply describes an error you made in your prose, which is typical of editors with a conflict of interest regarding a company.
I don't see the notability as a standalone article, especially given that your sources are WP:CORPROUTINE and don't contribute to notability. It might be best to expand the Comcast article with a paragraph about FreeWheel. It's currently mentioned in the lead but nowhere else, so it should be mentioned in the body text. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 23:03, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

16:13, 16 November 2026 review of submission by Xargoyle

Am I required to have a strong vocabulary for writing an article for Wikipedia or is my broken one sufficient enough for a draft review? For can it be improved later on? Xargoyle (talk) 16:13, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Hello, @Xargoyle.
No, we would rather you write in imperfect English than try to use an AI tool to polish your text.
I'm not convinced that any of your sources are acceptable - they all seem to be from companies marketing their services, whereas we prefer independent sources.
Please make sure you have read WP:LISTGLOSSARY and WP:Manual of Style/Glossaries. (I'm not saying that you are failing to follow these - just bringing them to your attention in case you're not aware of them). ColinFine (talk) 16:54, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Heard, but how okay is it to rely on dictionaries like Oxford and Merriam-Webster instead? Xargoyle (talk) 17:10, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

19:13, 16 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-60520-51

I thought I'd created a good article for my football club's new Goalkeeper Draft:Charlie Patmore and thought Aldershot_Town_F.C. was a senior enough professional club (at Step 1 in England) to be notable (inc it's players) and had quoted reputable sources. Can you help me improve the article, or is it a complete no go? ~2026-60520-51 (talk) 19:13, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Notability is not inherited, so being part of a notable club does not make a player notable. You can reference WP:SPORTBASIC for the notability requirements for football players. Athanelar (talk) 19:37, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

19:51, 16 November 2026 review of submission by ComposeAdela

@Meadowlark: Hi, I would like to ask the following: 1. I can keep most of the sources I used, I just need to add at least 3 sources that meet the criteria in WP:42? 2. The content in general is okay, or does it require more/less detail? Can I keep it as it is (more or less), backed up with a few independent sources + maybe find some book reviews? Do the book reviews need to be "professional", or are reader/bookstagrammer reviews sufficient? Thank you! ComposeAdela (talk) 19:51, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Reader reviews won't work as those carry no weight; reviews should be from professional critics/reviewers. 331dot (talk) 20:16, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

20:58, 16 November 2026 review of submission by Besaurus

Hi Team, This is my first Wiki page and I'm struggling a bit to figure out which parts need more work. I'd have thought Tom's Guide and PC Gamer are reliable sources. Would a draft more focused on the original Redactle meet the requirements? I can remove the weakly cited content about the development history, but it is important to note that redactle.com is abandoned, and enumerate the current options for someone wanting to play Redactle. Besaurus (talk) 20:58, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

It is very much not important as far as Wikipedia is concerned to enumerate the current options for someone wanting to play Redactle. See WP:NOTHOWTO. A Wikipedia article should be a neutral summary of what the majority of people who are wholly unconnected with the subject have independently chosen to publish about the subject in reliable publications, (see Golden rule) and not much else. What you know (or anybody else knows) about the subject is not relevant except where it can be verified from a reliable published source. Athanelar (talk) 22:01, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

22:20, 16 November 2026 review of submission by TammyVail

Hi – I previously submitted an article on Rootstock Software and am working on edits to resubmit. The article was previously rejected, and I am trying to read more entries to understand the neutral type of writing that makes for a good article.

One thing that would help me is that I’m trying to round up my article resources for notability, and I thought if I could run at least three resources by the Help Desk, I would get a feel for what’s a good resource and what’s not.

Here are three resources, that I’ve collected as options on Rootstock Software. Any feedback would greatly assist in my effort to find the right type of resources. Thank you in advance for your help!

Resource 1 from Diginomica: https://diginomica.com/change-air-cloud-erp-vendor-rootstock-heres-why

Resource 2 from Enterprise Times: https://www.enterprisetimes.co.uk/2018/01/12/veni-vidi-vici-the-rootstock-way/

Resource 3 from TechTarget: https://www.techtarget.com/news/Rootstock-adds-analytics-to-Salesforce-based-SaaS-ERP/850523/

TammyVail (talk) 22:20, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Have you read WP:NCORP, specifically WP:CORPDEPTH and WP:CORPTRIV? That's the perfect, comprehensive guidance on the type of sources you'll need. Athanelar (talk) 22:29, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
  • TammyVail I fixed your header so it links to your draft as intended and not to a nonexistent page entitled "Requesting help on resources". 331dot (talk) 22:47, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
    Thank you for fixing that! TammyVail (talk) 23:48, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

23:55, 16 November 2026 review of submission by Jankok9

Janko kustudic Jankok9 (talk) 23:55, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Hello, @Jankok9.
What is your question about Handball player?
That is an article, while this helpdesk is generally for drafts being submitted through WP:AFC.
I note that on your user page you have attempted to create an article, apparently about yourself.
Your user page is for information about you as a Wikipedia editor: it should not contain very much that does not relate to Wikipedia editing, and it must not look like an article: see WP:UPNO.
Please note that successfully writing a new article is extremely difficult for a new editor, and I don't recommend that any new editor try it until they have spent at least a few weeks learning how Wikipedia works.
On top of that, writing about yourself in Wikipedia is so mind-blowingly difficult that very very few people have successfully managed it: see autobiography.
If you meet Wikipedia's criteria for notability, or the more specific criteria for notability for a sports person, then there could be an article about you. As I said above, you are very unlikely to be successful at writing it yourself (you would need to forget everything you know about yourself, and write a summary of what people you don't know and haven't communicated with you have chosen to publish about you).
If you do not meet those criteria, then no article about you is possible.
In short, you must delete the content from your user page (you are permitted to cut and paste it to a user-subpage, such as User:Jankok9/sandbox, but I doubt that there is any point, because you have written it WP:BACKWARDS); and then my advice it to forget that Wikipedia exists, and continue with your career. If at some time you do meet the criteria for notability, then somebody will eventually write an article about you.
Now that you have tried this, it is possible that somebody will contact you, offering to "create your page" for money. This will be a scam, and you should not accept their offer: see WP:SCAM. ColinFine (talk) 10:28, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

November 17

Advice on sources for a possible biography — Mark Davies

Advice on sources for a possible biography — Mark Davies Mitchell

Message:

Hello. I am Mark Davies, a paranormal investigator based in Cornwall. I also write under the name Mark Davies Mitchell. The proposed biography would be about me, so I am declaring that connection openly.

Before creating a draft, could someone assess whether the following coverage might meet Wikipedia’s notability requirements?

Television appearance — ITV’s Judge Rinder, October 2018:

https://www.cornwalllive.com/news/celebs-tv/paranormal-investigator-appears-judge-rinder-2168471

Kennall Vale investigation, January 2019:

https://www.cornwalllive.com/news/cornwall-news/alien-demon-caught-camera-cornwall-2411468

Falmouth Cemetery investigation, February 2019:

https://www.cornwalllive.com/news/cornwall-news/cornwall-ghost-hunter-says-hes-2578492

Cornish Owlman investigation with Chris Power, August 2019:

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/weird-news/half-man-half-owl-scares-18996119

An episode review also identifies us in Unexplained: Caught on Camera, series two, episode five, listing Really and Discovery+:

https://www.higgypop.com/news/unexplained-caught-on-camera-series-2-episode-5/

Some newspaper stories were republished elsewhere. I understand those versions should not be counted as separate independent sources.

I also independently publish horror and fantasy fiction, including the Spectrum Fantastic books The Whispering Stones and The Deep Chime, which are set in Cornwall and centre on a magical child on the autism spectrum. My Amazon author page is:

https://www.amazon.co.uk/stores/author/B0HHZDXYQW

I understand that Amazon listings support publication details but do not establish notability.

No article has been submitted. AI has helped me organise these links and this enquiry; I am asking for human assessment, not submitting AI-generated article text.

Would these sources be sufficient for someone to consider an independently written biography? If this is the wrong place to ask before creating a draft, please direct me to the appropriate venue.

Thank you. ~2026-60719-84 (talk) 00:27, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Please do not use AI to talk to us. It's not allowed.
Wikipedia editors do not normally carry out "notability assessments" about article subjects on request, nor assess the suitability of individual sources. If you want to write an article on Wikipedia, you are expected to familiarise yourself with the notability standard(s) which apply to your subject, and then demonstrate to us that your subject meets those requirements by finding suitable sources. The "notability assessment" is your job as the article creator to carry out. General information about notability can be found here. The golden rule is a handy rule of thumb; if you can find at least three sources about your subject which meet that golden rule, your subject is probably notable. If you want help determining whether or not a particular source is suitable, please give your own opinion (and I mean your own opinion, don't ask AI to do it for you) of whether you think it is or it isn't and why, so that we can see you've made a good faith effort to assess the sources yourself. Athanelar (talk) 00:38, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello, @~2026-60719-84.
Please note that writing about yourself successfully on Wikipedia is so insanely difficult that very very few people have ever done so: see autobiography.
Also note that promotion is forbidden on Wikipedia, so if there is ever an article about you, it will not necessarily say what you would like it to say: A Wikipedia article should be a neutral summary of what the majority of people who are wholly unconnected with the subject have independently chosen to publish about the subject in reliable publications, (see Golden rule) and not much else. What you know (or anybody else knows) about the subject is not relevant except where it can be verified from a reliable published source.
Finally, note that now you have expressed this wish, it is possible that a scammer will contact you offering to create an article for a fee. Please see WP:SCAM. ColinFine (talk) 10:31, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Notability assessment for Draft:Dany Eid

Hello Wikipedia editors,

I would appreciate an independent assessment of the notability of Draft:Dany Eid.

I am Dany Eid, a Lebanese architectural, aerial and landscape photographer based in Dubai, United Arab Emirates. I have already disclosed my conflict of interest on my Wikipedia user page.

Before submitting the draft for review, I would like to understand whether the available independent media coverage meets Wikipedia’s general notability guideline (WP:GNG).

Two potentially significant independent editorial sources are:

  1. CNN Arabic (21 July 2020): A dedicated article discussing my photography and professional work. https://arabic.cnn.com/style/article/2020/07/21/dubai-photographer-dany-eid
  2. The National (30 April 2020): An editorial feature about my photography of Dubai and my professional background. https://www.thenationalnews.com/arts/dubai-photographer-reveals-how-to-capture-city-s-stunning-skyline-from-your-balcony-1.1013182

Additional publications, including Architectural Digest, have credited my architectural photography. My work also includes photography for Expo 2020 Dubai and published photography books.

I understand that professional achievements, image credits, institutional profiles and official recognition do not automatically establish Wikipedia notability.

I would appreciate guidance on whether the two independent articles provide sufficient significant coverage, or whether further independent sources are necessary before submitting the draft.

Thank you for your time and advice. Dany Eid Photography (talk) 00:41, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Please don't use AI to talk to us. It's not allowed.
Wikipedia editors do not normally carry out "notability assessments" about article subjects on request, nor assess the suitability of individual sources. If you want to write an article on Wikipedia, you are expected to familiarise yourself with the notability standard(s) which apply to your subject, and then demonstrate to us that your subject meets those requirements by finding suitable sources. The "notability assessment" is your job as the article creator to carry out. General information about notability can be found here. The golden rule is a handy rule of thumb; if you can find at least three sources about your subject which meet that golden rule, your subject is probably notable. If you want help determining whether or not a particular source is suitable, please give your own opinion (and I mean your own opinion, don't ask AI to do it for you) of whether you think it is or it isn't and why, so that we can see you've made a good faith effort to assess the sources yourself. Athanelar (talk) 00:45, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello, @Dany Eid Photography. Please see the answer I gave to the previous section, #Advice on sources for a possible biography — Mark Davies, all of which applies equally to you.
Also, your Username is not acceptable, as it gives the impression it is editing on behalf of a company. See WP:ORGNAME. If you intend to continue to edit Wikipedia, you must change it: see WP:CHU. ColinFine (talk) 10:34, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

09:34, 17 November 2026 review of submission by Zdog007

Hi y'all, I am requesting an independent review of my draft, which was declined under WP:NEWLLM. I spent quite a bit of time researching and writing this article myself using archival records and reliable secondary sources, so I believe this decline was a false positive. Could another editor take a look at the draft and let me know if any specific passages look problematic, or confirm that it is ready to move forward? Thanks! :) Zdog007 (talk) 09:34, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Zdog007 We don't do pre-review reviews; if you have changed it to address the concerns of the first review, please resubmit it. The originally submitted draft certainly reads like an AI/LLM, it just names facts without summarizing any critical analysis and commentary. Did you use an LLM or any tool on the draft in any capacity? 331dot (talk) 09:45, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
(see Wikipedia:AI noticeboard/Zdog007, which I just filed, for context) Helpful Raccoon (talk) 09:47, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

10:21, 17 November 2026 review of submission by HoxHomo

@Sulfurboy: Can you help me write the article?Xiang Chinese is an important language in Chinese. HoxHomo (talk) 10:21, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

We already have an article on Xiang Chinese, as well as on the Hunanese people who speak it. Athanelar (talk) 10:27, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
But Wu, Gan all have anticles about people.[[Wu Chinese-speaking people]], [[Gan Chinese-speaking people]] HoxHomo (talk) 10:30, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Please do not try to hijack the Hunanese people article and replace it with the content of your draft as you have just done. If you think the title of that article should be changed, you can follow the WP:RM procedure.
The Wu Chinese-speaking people and Gan Chinese-speaking people are both articles about ethnolinguistic subgroups that are defined primarily by the language they speak. While Xiang Chinese is primarily spoken in Hunan, as you say, not all Hunanese people speak Xiang, and they are not defined by their relationship to the Xiang language.
For there to be an article about the "Xiang Chinese-speaking people" you'd need to demonstrate that Xiang speakers as a distinct group have been discussed in appropriate sources. The lack of sources is why your draft has so far been declined. Athanelar (talk) 11:30, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Not all Hunanese say Xiang Chinese. HoxHomo (talk) 10:32, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

13:07, 17 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-60652-21

@LifeLearning: this was declined due to not meeting BLP. This individual meets WP:ANYBIO, specifically WP:CREATIVE points 1 and 2, as they are recognised by Time 100 and are one of the first to pioneer underwater live streaming. They also meet GNG with multiple articles from People magazine, KITV, etc. I ask for this to be reassessed by a more experienced editor. (I'm not affiliated with the subject, and this is not AI.) Much appreciated ~2026-60652-21 (talk) 13:07, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

People mag article - Has substantial commentary on her life, background and career. This is sigcov. People is reliable according to WP:PEOPLEMAG.
Time 100 Creators piece - Two paragraphs is not enough for sigcov, but this is a very significant recognition from one of the most reputable magazines in the world.
Green Matters article - contains commentary on BTS stuff relating to her work. Not a source that's been assessed by Wikipedia to my knowledge, however they have editorial rules and disclose sponsored content (which that article isn't).
There's also this Newsweek article.
I'm surprised by the decline, especially on the basis that there "isn't multiple published secondary sources", when clearly there is. ~2026-60652-21 (talk) 13:22, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi @~2026-60652-21,
Declining isn't rejecting, and you can always improve the article and resubmit.
Yes, there are some good sources, but the way it is structured and sourced does not meet the criteria for WP:BLP of significant coverage. If she is a pioneer, as you write here, the draft article and coverage should reflect that.
Happy to look at it again once after some heavy lifting is done. LifeLearning (talk) 19:35, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
My browser tab expired so I lost the temp account. Thanks for the reply. I am a former editor, unlike some of the problematic new editors that frequent this noticeboard. i should point out that structure and prose are not relevant to whether an AfC submission passes (unless it is AI generated). as for sourcing, I would appreciate an explanation from yourself as to why they do not meet BLP (which isn't actually the page that outlines notability). if you can rebut why CREATIVE and GNG are not met I will concede. If your assessment stands, I will not be continuing work on the draft, as no other sources exist at this time, and those that are there should suffice. ~2026-60327-97 (talk) 02:13, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
a third opinion also wouldn't go amiss. ~2026-60327-97 (talk) 02:15, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

13:49, 17 November 2026 review of submission by Wesley Mendes-Da-Silva

I am the subject of [] (COI declared on my user page and on the draft's talk page). I rewrote the draft myself after it was declined for AI-generated text. Do the sources now show notability under NPROF C7 or GNG? Wesley Mendes-Da-Silva (talk) 13:49, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Wesley Mendes-Da-Silva I have fixed the header so it links to your draft as intended and not to a nonexistent page entitled "Draft:Wesley Mendes Da Silva – COI, rewritten after decline".
Please read the autobiography policy; you are extremely unlikely to succeed at this, especially as a new user without prior, broader Wikipedia editing experience. Almost everyone who attempts to write about themselves fails at it; only a literal handful of people have succeeded, out of tens of thousands of attempts. Are you the rare person who will succeed where everyone else fails? It is possible, but the odds are overwhelmingly against it.
If you have fundmentally rewritten the draft(not just made superficial changes), you may resubmit it to obtain a new review, we don't do pre-review reviews, as that duplicates what the reviewer will do. 331dot (talk) 13:56, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

13:56, 17 November 2026 review of submission by Jopla2

This is a new page and it was just rejected. The guidelines about AI use have been interpreted too strictly in my opinion. I only used AI to correct grammar and language, as English is not my native language. The text wasn't written by AI. The only option I've been given is to rewrite the entire page, which really is not an option for me. Jopla2 (talk) 13:56, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Your draft is at Draft:18 Carat Garbage. If you used an AI on it in any capacity, that renders it too influenced by AI to be usable.
If you are not confident enough in your English skill to write without using an AI or other automated tools, you should contribute to the Wikipedia of your primary language instead(the German Wikipedia?) We do not expect perfect grammar and spelling, or even fluent English, but you must be able to contribute without using any AI tools. This is a human written project and we want humans to do the work. 331dot (talk) 14:02, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Indeed, our requirement for English proficiency is only that you have the ability to read and write English well enough to avoid introducing incomprehensible text into articles and to communicate effectively without AI. If you're not confident in doing that, another language Wikipedia (or maybe just smaller editing tasks than writing entire articles) would be the sensible thing to do. Athanelar (talk) 14:05, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
"IN any capacity"? I don't think so.
"The new guideline also clarifies when it is okay for editors to use LLMs. It says editors can use them “to suggest refinements to their own writing, and to incorporate some of them after human review, provided the LLM doesn’t introduce content of its own.”"
https://reporterslab.org/2026/03/23/wikipedia-editors-adopt-stronger-guideline-against-ai-generated-content/ Jopla2 (talk) 18:48, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
"Provided the LLM doesn't introduce content on its own"- that's usually the problem- AI often does this. 331dot (talk) 18:50, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Well, I stand behind every word in that article. Jopla2 (talk) 18:52, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Why the hell are you citing some random article from March at the people who are actually here, right now, telling you how the rules work? The people who actually participated in writing and defining the guideline the article is about? Prime example of WP:EGGS. Athanelar (talk) 18:54, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I give up, just delete the page. Jopla2 (talk) 19:03, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Our rules against AI clearly state two permissible exceptions for simple corrections and for translation between two languages in which you are fully proficient. If you are not fully proficient in English to the point where you require AI in order to be able to write encyclopedically, then the exceptions do not apply and the guideline has been applied correctly. Considering the obviously AI generated edit summaries in your edit history, I struggle to believe you only used it for "corrections". Athanelar (talk) 14:03, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Obviously AI generated edit summaries? Jopla2 (talk) 18:43, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Yes, that turn of phrase is a common feature of AI generated edit summaries. There are so many attempts at AI writing on Wikipedia that reviewers see very similar terminology over and again. Before AI a typical edit summary (where provided at all) were phrases like "minor changes", "spllng" or "finish this section". ChrysGalley (talk) 00:04, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

15:53, 17 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-52411-16

@Jerodlycett: We are beginning to work on this page again. Please don't delete it -- we should have an updated page soon. Thank you. ~2026-52411-16 (talk) 15:53, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

I don't see anyone proposing that it be deleted. Drafts are deleted after six months of inactivity, but all that is needed to avoid that is to edit the draft.
Who is "we"? 331dot (talk) 18:51, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

21:22, 17 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-61079-37

@Helpful Raccoon: Good Afternoon,

Hope you are well. My name is Nitin Singh and I am seeking help to publish my wikipedia page. The original wikipedia page was rejected. Please let me know if we can work towards having it approved.

Thank you kindly, Sincerely, Nitin R. Singh ~2026-61079-37 (talk) 21:22, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

As Helpful Raccoon already pointed out, this subject isn't notable and the draft won't be considered further. Sulfurboy (talk) 21:29, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

21:52, 17 November 2026 review of submission by Jcholo

This article was recently denied on the basis it was supposedly written using an LLM. It was not. This is entirely my own original content, and no AI was utilized whatsoever. Jcholo (talk) 21:52, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Did you use an AI or any automated tool on the draft in any capacity? 331dot (talk) 23:02, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
None whatsoever. Without getting into personal details I have friends and family who've lost jobs to AI and so have a certain level of antipathy for it and LLMs in general. This is my own original writing. I copied the infobox for a movie from another film page here on Wiki, and I also copy/pasted <ref> templates, but that's it. Otherwise I wrote this all myself, not counting quotes from reviews.Jcholo (talk) 23:40, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Good. Look through it and either remove any statements that aren't backed up by citations, or find sources to cite.
If there are any names of reviewers who are notable, wikilink them. Coverage in niche, tabloid, or local sources may make notability a reach, though. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 00:50, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

22:08, 17 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-60866-44

Hi,

I submitted a draft page and keep getting a message that AI was used for the article. I'm not sure that I can change my draft further since it's representative of my career with references (These were AI generated because Im not familiar with citations). Please let me know if Ive missed anything or need to edit further....Thank you! ~2026-60866-44 (talk) 22:08, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

If you are NinaMcGrew, remember to log in when posting.
Please review the autobiography policy. While not absolutely forbidden, writing about yourself is highly discouraged(though the draft process is the correct way to do so) and is extremely unlikely to succeed, especially without broader Wikipedia editing experience. An autobiography is inherently promotional, and people naturally write favorably about themselves. The number of successful autobiographies in the last 15 years is exceedingly small, out of tens of thousands of attempts. Are you the rare person who will succeed where everyone else fails? Possibly, but the odds are overwhelmingly against it. More than likely you are just wasting your own valuable time.
Please review Referencing for beginners to learn how to format citations. Awards/honors only contribute to notability when the award itself merits an article(like Nobel Peace Prize or Heisman Trophy). An article should primarily summarize critical analysis and commentary about you, not merely name your stats and experience. 331dot (talk) 22:59, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

23:49, 17 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-60710-41

The page was rejected on the grounds that "cppreference is not a reliable source", but plenty of C++ articles cite cppreference, there is no WP:RS forbidding it, and Herb Sutter, the former chair of the ISO C++ Committee described as "the premier public reference site for documenting and tracking the C++ language" here. I don't see why the article should be disqualified just on the regard of having cited cppreference; not to mention that the article cites several other, independent sources. Some of those sources are formatted as blogs, but they are company-endorsed blogs/reports rather than an individual blogs.

If the issue is that cppreference.com in particular was cited on the page, I would be happy to remove the links referring to it, but I cited them specifically to get the signatures of symbols that the library contains. ~2026-60710-41 (talk) 23:49, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

It wasn't rejected, it was declined. "Rejected" means end of the line, it won't be considered further. "Declined" means it can be improved and resubmitted.
It was declined due to poor sourcing. cppreference is a wiki, and as such isn't a reliable source.
See WP:Golden Rule for the kinds of citations we are looking for before a draft can be approved. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 00:44, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
So is the article submittable if those citations are removed? ~2026-60710-41 (talk) 01:49, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
That is not what I said. Please read my reply, and the link I provided. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 04:53, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

November 18

04:32, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Esthernaya

My article was rejected for purpose not suited for wikipedia. I need specifics on why and what i can do to make the article better Esthernaya (talk) 04:32, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

You can start again, writing the draft in your own words without the use of an AI. 331dot (talk) 09:23, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

04:42, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Esthernaya

I wrote the article from scratch and your reviewers keep saying i used LLM models which is false. I sourced for references, spent about 4 hours writing and revising and reviewing. What exactly about my writing gives off AI. It is becoming frustrating at this point. Esthernaya (talk) 04:42, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Multiple WP:AISIGNS. I have zero doubts the draft is chock full of LLM generated material. The only thing worse than violating WP:LLM is being dishonest about it, you're going to have a very hard time getting anyone to help you until you start following the rules. Sulfurboy (talk) 04:54, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

04:50, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Thaicredit

Could an independent reviewer take a second look at the 18 November decline of Draft:Prungsak Chaowachart?

I’m posting on behalf of the subject of the draft. The subject says the reviewed version was written without AI. Could you identify which passages in the reviewed revision raised the concern and tell me what documentation would help clarify how that version was written?

I understand that the earlier concern about substantial independent coverage still needs to be addressed separately. I’m asking for guidance on the authorship issue before any resubmission. Thank you. Thaicredit (talk) 04:50, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Why are you posting on behalf of the subject? Sulfurboy (talk) 04:52, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
We are not stupid. That shows obvious signs of being authored, or co-authored, by an AI. Whoever told you it wasn't written with AI help is lying. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 04:55, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
This question was drafted with an LLM; please don't use LLMs to communicate with other editors. Helpful Raccoon (talk) 05:29, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

05:02, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Torontotitan

Hi, I recently submitted Draft:Josh Connors, but it was rejected for notability and repeated AI-assisted submissions.

I understand the concerns about AI use, and I'm willing to rewrite the article myself.

I'm hoping another editor could take a look at the sources and give me a second opinion. There are multiple articles about Connors from 3DownNation, including an individual scouting analysis, as well as coverage from many different websites.

I'm wondering whether these sources are enough to establish notability, or whether additional independent coverage is needed. I'd also appreciate some guidance on whether the rejection can be reconsidered.

Thanks for your help! Torontotitan (talk) 05:02, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

None of the provided sources pass the WP:GOLDENRULE and it shouldn't take multiple warnings to get you to agree to not use AI. Further, your comment here is AI polished, at the very least, which makes me think you're not actually serious about not using LLMs. This draft will not be considered further at this time. Sulfurboy (talk) 05:07, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

05:40, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Zaidm3

Hi, I'm requesting a second opinion on the rejection of Draft Inc. The original manuscript was human-written, with ChatGPT subsequently used for Wikipedia markup and citation formatting. I've disclosed that assistance and made manual revisions. Could someone advise whether the draft can be reconsidered and what specific changes would be required? Thank you. Zaidm3 (talk) 05:40, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Happy to provide the original text or take another pass if needed.Zaidm3 (talk) 05:43, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
The draft has been rejected, which means stop, end of the road, move on to something else, the community will not waste any more of its valuable donated volunteer time on it. The sources look like WP:CORPROUTINE and don't indicate notability. If you really want to appeal, you need to do it directly with the reviewer who rejected it.
If you are associated in any way with Kong Inc, then you need to disclose that. If you are an employee or consultant, then you must disclose that, because you entered into a legal obligation to do so when you created your account. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 05:54, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Thanks for the feedback. I've already reached out to the original reviewer regarding the rejection.
On notability, I'd appreciate clarification on which sources are considered routine corporate coverage versus significant independent reporting. The draft includes coverage from Bloomberg, TechCrunch, and ComputerWeekly, and I'd like to better understand whether those sources satisfy Wikipedia's requirements.
Thanks for your guidance. Zaidm3 (talk) 06:10, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Did you read the guideline I linked? Funding rounds and acquisitions are routine coverage. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 07:00, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

07:00, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Rkosloff

I wrote this article myself using latex under overview this is not a LLM generated text. What can I do now? The article is based on my own work on quantum molecular dynamics andI collected all the references from my own years of study. Rkosloff (talk) 07:00, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Rkosloff There is nothing that you can do, the draft was rejected. Wikipedia is not for posting original research. Also see conflict of interest. 331dot (talk) 09:18, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
The article I wrote is not original research.
I am one of the founders of the research field Quantum Molecule Dynamics starting in 1983 ( J. Chem. Phys., 79, 1823-1833 (1983)).
Since then this topic has developed considerably where many people contributed to this topic.
Browsing recently through Wikipedia I found out that this topic is missing. Two realted topics Classical Moleculer Dynamics
and a specialized approximation quantum molecular dynamics exist (MCTDH).
My intension was to fill the gap using 45 years of experience in the field.
Do you have any advice? ~2026-58177-50 (talk) 11:04, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Draft:TempOff

Hello! I'm posting to get feedback for Draft:TempOff .

I found articlees where this dental instrument has been covered. the professional dental publications I found, include clinician-authored reviews in: Dental Economics and Dental Products Report and Dentistry today.

Specifically, TempOff was reviewed independently by Dr. Joshua Austin (October 2024) and Dr. Howard Glazer (November 2024).

I understand that product announcements, sponsored content, and press releases generally do not establish credibiilty. Could someone help clarify whether these clinician-authored articles qualify as "significant coverage" under Wikipedia's guidelines?

If they don't, I'd appreciate further explanation. Thank you!! — Preceding unsigned comment added by Chaiteayorkie (talk • contribs)

Chaiteayorkie The draft was rejected, meaning it will not be considered further. Note that it is not permitted to use an AI in writing a draft, we want humans to do all the work here, see WP:LLM. Please see referencing for beginners to learn how to format references.
If you are associated with TempOff or its creator, that must be disclosed, see WP:COI and WP:PAID. 331dot (talk) 09:20, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

09:43, 18 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-55494-28

@Sulfurboy: i want to submt an article abut this person in wikipedia he is an young entrepreneur at india ~2026-55494-28 (talk) 09:43, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

@~2026-55494-28: this draft has been rejected and will therefore not be considered further. It is entirely unreferenced, with zero evidence that the person is notable. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 09:55, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

10:37, 18 November 2026 review of submission by StarvingPelican

@ChrysGalley: Hi thank you for reviewing my personal article.The research was done by an LLM who gathered all the information about me from various sources. It was also submitted by my agent. I am not sure why it sounds like an LLM wrote it. I did write the article itself, but I do have to use the third person when writing in order to comply with the rules and to keep the language unbiased. If you want me to write with a different tone, that is possible, but I was trying to keep it as specific and direct as possible. I did not know that submitting by agent was not allowed. If that is the case, I sincerely apologize. I understood the rules as such that articles must be written by a human, yet did not find any rules disallowing anything pertaining to anything human written, yet submitted by an agentic AI. If I am mistaken I would be glad to resubmit the human written article myself. I just figured the agent would understand the editing of Wikis better, would make less mistakes with the coded sections, and would know better than me, how to submit it. Thank you for your attntion and help. StarvingPelican (talk) 10:37, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Are you saying that an AI operated your account and submitted the draft, or a human agent? If it's the former, that's a new one for me.
Please review the autobiography policy. Almost everyone who attempts to write about themselves(either directly or via a representative) fails at it, especially without first getting broader Wikipedia editing experience. Out of thousands of attempts, maybe a literal handful succeed. Are you the rare person who will succeed where everyone else fails? Possibly, but the odds are overwhelmingly against it. 331dot (talk) 10:42, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
The trouble with AI is that it has a poor understanding of our policies, and will often go beyond what is asked of it. This is a human written project and we want humans to do the work. We do not expect perfect grammar and spelling especially on a first attempt. Many editors enjoy tasks like copyediting and any errors will eventually be fixed. 331dot (talk) 10:46, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I'll add, would you as a photographer/filmmaker want to be replaced by an AI? 331dot (talk) 10:48, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Technically we already have. Sad but true. StarvingPelican (talk) 11:54, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
We're trying to avoid that here, so please don't use an AI. 331dot (talk) 13:58, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
@StarvingPelican - I am also unclear as to what the "agent" relates to, but straightforwardly LLM input is not allowed under WP:NOLLM except for 2 very narrow exceptions which do not apply here. If you consider, for example, WP:AIATTR you will perhaps see where I am coming from in terms of the decline. My advice is that the draft is rewritten from scratch, by a human being, with zero LLM / AI assistance. ChrysGalley (talk) 10:46, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Ok no problem. I just wanted to document my work in Wikipedia. I'm not good at talking about myself so I got an agent to help me but I am a writer, so I don't have a problem writing. My issue is talking about myself. And yes, agents can submit work if you have made an account yourself and have the page open and give them the permissions. I will try and figure out how to write better about myself. I just want my legacy recorded before I die. I am just afraid of being forgotten. I have worked so hard and no one ever cares. StarvingPelican (talk) 10:56, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Well Wikipedia may not be the best way to record a personal legacy, it's certainly not one of the reasons for Wikipedia's existence, and there is a specific ban on using the site as a memorial site. Writing about oneself is incredibly hard, almost impossible, very few editors can do it. It isn't something I could do for myself, for example. The underlying principle is that it does not matter what you know about yourself, we are a secondary source encyclopedia and so we report on what other people say about you, even if it's wrong. So if you know you were born in say 1970 but all secondary sources say you were born in 1960, then in theory the latter has to prevail even though you know differently. ChrysGalley (talk) 11:02, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I understand, but I have been a huge fan and monetary supporter of this site for well over 30 years or however long it has existed so I want to contribute to its information. I was on this site the first year it opened. Not as an editor--I have always felt scared to edit anything on here--but as a reader. I have used it to cite papers I have written when I was in school, and used it to find source information for things I wanted to learn.
I finally feel I have made significant contributions to the human race. I even have my books recorded in the Library of Congress, so I feel it is justified to include my work on here. It is not out of vanity, but merely to share in the knowledge of my experience so that others can learn more about the history I have documented. After all, no one is going to do it for me, I dont have any PR people or managers that will write it for me. I might not be well known, but I might be more of a somebody to know. I have stories to tell to anyone willing to listen. Anyway, I will revise my article and I will also include the Library of Congress citation. I apologize for any trouble I have put you through. I really didn't want this to be an issue but now it is and I regret that. Thanks for your help. StarvingPelican (talk) 11:39, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I've never heard of an editor handing their account to an AI before. I guess that's not against policy, but again, we want humans to do the work here.
If you just want to document your work, you may wish to consider an alternative outlet where that is permitted. 331dot (talk) 11:28, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I know, but technically Im not an editor here, am I? I'm a published author who writes about abandoned places. So I guess our priorities are a bit different, and I did not understand the rules correctly. I understand them now and again, I will write it myself. I do feel sufficient citations and articles and a documentary, documenting my work as well as a Library of Congress citation for my books. If you feel that is insufficient, I can delete my article alltogether. StarvingPelican (talk) 11:49, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Although I would like to add, I wouldn't mind regularly contributing. I'm a pretty decent editor for clarity, myself. StarvingPelican (talk) 11:56, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
@StarvingPelican, yes that would be most welcome, all editors have to start somewhere and it's an important way to contribute to future generations' education. The usual advice is to start with small updates, checking older articles to see if the sources still exist. Some older Wikipedia entries would not now be published due to poor sourcing. Then find your first article draft, keep it short but meeting the WP:GOLDENRULE three times over, and building editing abilities from there. And eventually joining the AFC review team! ChrysGalley (talk) 16:03, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello, @StarvingPelican.
A Wikipedia article should be a neutral summary of what the majority of people who are wholly unconnected with the subject have independently chosen to publish about the subject in reliable publications, (see Golden rule) and not much else. What you know (or anybody else knows) about the subject is not relevant except where it can be verified from a reliable published source.
Most people in the world (even including many writers and editors!) have not been written about sufficiently to make this possible - that is what notability is mostly about.
It's great that you want to be an editor here (you already are one, by the way: you have made 13 edits under this account). Some of your skills will be very useful - other skills may trip you up. Have a look at WP:WRITINGFORWP (which is mostly aimed at paid editors, but is of more general applicability). ColinFine (talk) 16:09, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

11:09, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Big Joe Akamantso 1

I’m unable to publish my biography because I was told I lack enough sources to back my claims Big Joe Akamantso 1 (talk) 11:09, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

 Courtesy link: Draft:Big Joe (Cameroonian musician)
@Big Joe Akamantso 1: that's correct, your draft is almost entirely unreferenced, with no evidence that you are notable. Besides, you shouldn't really be writing about yourself in the first place, see WP:AUTOBIO. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 11:15, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Please with due respect. I need my autobiography on Wikipedia. I’m a true Cameroonian license musician with album released. Please can you be of assistance to me to enable my autobiography published on Wikipedia. I will really appreciate this Favour if I’m help out. It’s very disappointing to me as a musician but I can have my biography published here on Wikipedia. Please help . Big Joe Akamantso 1 (talk) 11:38, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Your draft has only one source and that doesn't even mention you. Theroadislong (talk) 11:54, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
What things do you want me to send so that you can help publish my works please. I urgently need your assistance here please Big Joe Akamantso 1 (talk) 11:56, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
@Big Joe Akamantso 1 You would need to prove you meet our definition of a notable musician. But given that your intention here seems purely promotional, you are certain not to succeed, because we explicitly forbid promotion. There are also good reasons to not want an article about yourself. Athanelar (talk) 12:07, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello Sir, I’m not here for any promotional reasons. I’m here base in the works I got out there and need a helping hand for my biography to be published here. All I need is assistance from team Wikipedia. Big Joe Akamantso 1 (talk) 12:12, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
@Big Joe Akamantso 1: you don't seem to be hearing what you're being told. There is precisely zero evidence in your draft that you are notable. Without solid proof of notability, you draft will simply not be accepted. And trying to force the issue is likely to get you blocked sooner or later.
And, just so we're clear, you are doing this to promote yourself. The fact that your draft is you telling the world about yourself makes it inherently promotional. I'm also assuming that the reason why you so 'urgently' want this is because you believe it would help further your career or otherwise benefit you somehow. All that is pretty much the definition of promoting. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 12:19, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
@Big Joe Akamantso 1: If a manager is telling you that you need a Wikipedia article, fire him for incompetence. A Wikipedia article isn't going to help your career (and in fact may damage it). —Jéské Couriano v^_^v Thriller Night! 19:30, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

12:20, 18 November 2026 review of submission by RonnieJoyce

@Greenman: Why did you reject Jowaine_Parrott, who won the gold medal at the 1995 All Africa Games, as an article and yet you accept the All African Games as an article or source? RonnieJoyce (talk) 12:20, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

@RonnieJoyce: can you point out which of the nine criteria in WP:NATH this person meets, and what evidence supports that? -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 12:26, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

14:27:26, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Justgreatdonuts

Hi, my draft Draft:Aaron Kipness was declined for notability. I am the subject of the article and I have disclosed my COI. I responded to the reviewer on his talk page (User talk:Thilsebatti#Draft:Aaron Kipness) but haven't heard back yet.

In my draft, I included reliable, independent sources with significant coverage for two separate contributions I am recognized for in the musical instrument field: (1) founding Clavinet.com and manufacturing the first replacement parts for the Hohner Clavinet, which is credited with bringing the instrument back into use, and (2) inventing the patented Gizmotron 2.0, a redesigned version of a 1970s guitar effects device.

My sources are as follows: 1. A full-page sidebar profile of myself, with a photo, in the book Classic Keys, University of North Texas Press, 2019.

2. Independent, reliable coverage spanning a decade, from 2014 to 2024, in established music and trade publications, including Vintage Guitar, Sound on Sound, Electronic Musician, Guitar Player, Red Bull Music Academy, and Modern Machine Shop, and in a 2024 memoir by Simon Raymonde, covering my work reviving the Gizmotron. I included quotes from some of them, on his talk page and in the draft’s citations, where the authors specifically describe me, my background, and the process I used to bring the product to market.

I believe the Classic Keys university press book covers me in depth on its own, and that WP:BASIC allows multiple independent, reliable sources to be combined to meet the notability requirement. Are these sources sufficient to satisfy the requirement? Thank you. Justgreatdonuts (talk) 14:27, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

14:59, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Ik. Ghislain

I really need help in understanding what Wikipedia wants from me. The article I'm trying to publish is simply a recap of the musical career of an upcoming and underground rapper called: Ik Gix. He might not have extensive references online as he is not mainstream but he remains existing and active. When I provide links for confirmation wikipedia rejects and when I remove what may serve as evidence you still reject. I am honestly frustrated, life is tough enough and now through honest means we try to get our brand out there and we still get rejected. Ik. Ghislain (talk) 14:59, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

@Ik. Ghislain: Wikipedia is an encyclopaedia, not a marketing channel for you to "get [y]our brand out there". This is draft is pure promotion with zero evidence of notability, and your description of an "upcoming" rapper pretty much confirms that. So to answer your initial question, what Wikipedia wants is for you to not try to use it to promote anything or anyone. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 15:08, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Sir please, the article I wrote features no promotional material. It features a recap of an artist's career with the links providing serving as reference to verify the existence and activity of said artist rather than serving as promotional material. I believe there in an ambiguity with regards to the intent. The purpose of this is to encapsulate the journey of said artist in an article. Now with regards to your statement I would like to kindly as, does this mean that "upcoming artists" are prohibited from tracing their journey through a wikipedia page or article ? I understand your point of view but would like to precise that the intent behind the links and references is not promotional but instead intended for verification and confirmation. PLEASE. Ik. Ghislain (talk) 15:15, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
@Ik. Ghislain: what "links"? The only links I see are two links to the same Apple Music page. That in itself is further promotion. And yes, the draft is 100% promotional, for which reason I'm about to delete it.
Wikipedia articles summarise what reliable and independent secondary sources have previously published about a subject; we are never the first to publish anything. An "upcoming" artist, film, book, etc. by definition hasn't had such coverage published in secondary sources yet, therefore there is nothing for us to summarise, and hence no Wikipedia article is possible.
If you want to tell the world about this person (yourself?), you need to find a different platform for that. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 15:21, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Alright I understand better now. Thank you. Ik. Ghislain (talk) 15:25, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

15:42, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Isabella21312123

@Thilsebatti: Thanks for reviewing this. Just checking why the draft was considered to lack significant coverage in reliable, independent secondary sources? The Guardian published a "long read" - a 7,000 word piece yesterday. openDemocracy published a substantial investigation last year, and Tax Policy Associates has also published detailed reporting. There is also independent coverage in Citywire and MLex of Stamp's (notable) early finance career. And more recent articles on Stamp's failed legal cases vs openDemocracy and a large number of banks.

would be helpful to understand how the draft can be improved. Isabella21312123 (talk) 15:42, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Notability aside, we can't accept this draft as it is LLM generated. Sulfurboy (talk) 16:45, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
yuck. Didn't realise that. I'll take a look. Isabella21312123 (talk) 19:20, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

16:52, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Penedium202

@Stuartyeates: Hello, I have been working on this draft and I am confused by your comment that the citations are AI slop. The new articles I cited are from independent newspapers and 3 of the 5 have unambiguous human authors. Additionally, many of the articles are from before the advent of robust or widespread generative language models (e.g. 2016). As for the other components of Wikipedia's inclusion policy, at least 2-3 of the articles go into rather significant detail or discussion (many paragraphs) and after doing some more research on the main pages the editorial oversight appears at least reasonable. Could you please let me know how I could find better secondary sources or properly integrate the current ones? Thanks! Penedium202 (talk) 16:52, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

I'd be very surprised if this niche grant program had the significant coverage in independent sources to show notability. 331dot (talk) 16:56, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
@Penedium202: without commenting on the AI issue, sources 1 thru 9 are all primary, and 10 onwards are just routine business reporting (the ones I can see, at least; three are not available in my geography). Wikipedia articles should be compiled by summarising what reliable and independent secondary sources have said about a subject, and this clearly isn't the case here.
As to how you could find better secondary sources, I've no idea, except to say that, having been involved in the British and EU grant activities for many years, I don't recall ever having seen genuinely independent secondary coverage of individual programmes, only of wider frameworks like Horizon Europe (and not much of them, either). Which is not to say that this subject couldn't have received such coverage, possibly even to such an extent as is needed to establish notability, but if so, then like 331dot (above), I, too, would be surprised. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 17:06, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Thanks both 331dot and DoubleGrazing. I appreciate the help.
I managed to access those other three and some of them involved real independent reporting. I'm not sure if it's enough to establish notability but there is something real there. I guess the question is just because a secondary source asks for a subscription does that mean it can't be used on Wikipedia? I would think that subscription pays real people to do the reporting - especially when it comes to newspapers - possibly improving it's reliability.
I started this draft because I saw many fellowship grant programs had Wikipedia pages (I provide those in the See Also heading of the draft and here: DoD NDSEG Fellowship, Computational Science Graduate Fellowship and NSF Graduate Research Fellowship Program). These other Wikipedia pages have similar rationale, sources, impact etc. Hence, it appears there may be a current bias. Maybe these pages should be removed and incorporated into larger pages? As it stands though, this is an inconsistency on Wikipedia.
Would you recommend this fellowship be referenced in a larger established wiki page such as for the USDA or National Institute of Food and Agriculture? Penedium202 (talk) 17:47, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
@Penedium202 See WP:OTHERSTUFF. Your idea to merge the info into a larger article is probably best. Sulfurboy (talk) 17:49, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Fair enough! Thanks! Penedium202 (talk) 17:59, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

The AI comment specifically related to https://grantedai.com/ links, which are an AI-regurgitation of US public documents. Stuartyeates (talk) 22:27, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

17:23, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Kayte Spillman

I am trying to create a submission that will have enough editorial merit to earn publication. I'd like to add these sources to the Wiki draft for the Simple Modern page. Would these be helpful?

The Wall Street Journal China’s Power Shortfalls Begin to Ripple Around the World Oct. 1, 2021 TIME As Prime Day Nears, Amazon Sellers Anticipate More Hardship July 11, 2022 Modern Retail Simple Modern Wants to Solve ‘Everyday Hydration’ With Its New Brand Trevi Dec. 2024 AdExchanger Why Simple Modern, An Amazon-Native Brand, Ditched the Amazon Ad Platform (For Now) Kayte Spillman (talk) 17:23, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

I corrected the link to point to the actual draft. --ColinFine (talk) 17:28, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
@Kayte Spillman, it's obvious looking at their titles that most, if not all, of your sources fail to meet some of the requirements in the golden rule: either they are not independent, or do not have significant coverage of the company. Several are obvious WP:CORPTRIV, which means that they will be based on press releases, so are not independent.
The draft has now been rejected, on the fourth attempt.
Have you read WP:PAIDADVICE? ColinFine (talk) 17:31, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for the feedback. I understand the distinction between coverage that establishes notability and coverage that simply verifies individual facts.
There are two additional sources I would appreciate your perspective on before determining whether to pursue this further:
Would sources of this nature be more appropriate for establishing corporate notability, assuming they meet the independence requirements?
I appreciate your guidance and do not intend to resubmit the draft without sufficient evidence that it meets Wikipedia's criteria. Kayte Spillman (talk) 17:36, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

17:28, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Ysgoldt

I am requesting a second opinion on the decline of teh article I wrote by Helpful Raccoon.

I researched for and wrote this article myself in markdown before transferring it into Wikipedia.

The reviewer declined the article as LLM-generated and instructed me to delete and rewrite the entire article, but did not identify any particular passages or explain what evidence led to their conclusions.

I am happy to address any legitimate concerns but I would appreciate an independent assessment of the draft and clarification on the specific evidence supporting the LLM accusation before being asked to discard or unnecessarily rewrite my work. Ysgoldt (talk) 17:28, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

@Ysgoldt: this one defeats me, or maybe I'm just too tired... @Helpful Raccoon: can you help (helpful as you are), what did you see that I didn't? -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 18:06, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Both the draft and this query are blatantly LLM-generated (among other things, LLM-generated denials of LLM usage very commonly ask to identify specific passages). As one example, a pointless identification such as The Smithsonian Institution identifies her as "Mrs. John Norton (Sarah Low)" in its catalogue record for her portrait by Matthew Harris Jouett is strongly characteristic of LLM usage. Helpful Raccoon (talk) 18:16, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm not sure what to say other than that is the way I wrote it after reading many other articles to make sure it sounded offical and was done well. I wanted to add an entry for the red name project highlighting women authors. I don't think anything I say is really going to change your mind. Ysgoldt (talk) 18:22, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
It seems highly unlikely that you or any other human author would actually choose to write the words was an American Methodist writer and correspondent associated with Lexington, Kentucky. as opposed to "...writer and correspondent from Lexington, Kentucky", or that you'd say Samuel Davies Baldwin published a book-length biography, rather than simply "a biography". Both of these among other things are very common signs of AI usage. Athanelar (talk) 18:54, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
(gets his crittin' collar on)
To the extent you have usable sources, I can't assess them, with one pointing to a different, much better, work to cite and the other being walled. I also have little interest in reading published religious biographies. —Jéské Couriano v^_^v Thriller Night! 19:26, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
This is my first article. I can definitely fix up some of the language I used if that makes it better, and I probably went overboard on some places trying to make it sound more 'professional' or credible. I'm not sure what else to do other than that though. It's my word against yours, and at this point is just a matter of perspective. I tried my best. Ysgoldt (talk) 20:06, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

17:36, 18 November 2026 review of submission by ~2026-60851-58

I am seeking a second opinion regarding the denial and that AI was used to write the article. This is my life and I have lived every second of it. I am not sure what phrases or citations led to this conclusion; however I wrote it the information. I have years of news articles and other supporting documents that tells of my child-care advocacy. Please provide a second opinion. ~2026-60851-58 (talk) 17:36, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

@~2026-60851-58: if you are HeritageResearcher26, please remember to log into your account.
The citations are appended with ?utm_source=chatgpt.com, that's a bit of a clue. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 17:59, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for your response. I did use Chat trying to find articles of a newspaper clippings that were without a date, and to organize the information but not to write my story. The links containing Chatgpt were unintentional. However the historical information comes from my personal knowledge and newspaper articles, magazine publications, and legislative records. I guess my desire to provide the supporting documents was a major focus and when I realized some of the articles were without dates, and more than twenty years old, I sought to find them through links to help me accurately depict to Wiki the time line. I am willing to make the necessary corrections. My objective is to present an accurate, neutral biography supported by independent historical documentation. Other than the link, any specific guidance on what needs to be corrected would be greatly appreciated. ~2026-60851-58 (talk) 19:16, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Another giveaway is that there is a clear focus on the fact that there's been articles written about her, rather than on what those articles said about her. --bonadea contributions talk 18:30, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for explaining the distinction. I think I understand your point. This is my first attempt with writing for Wiki. My intention was to present the historical events documented in the articles, not to emphasize the fact the newspapers had written about me. I will admit I am true novice to understand what you have been doing for years, I am however wing to correct by focusing on what the articles reported and using the publications as supporting references. I appreciate your guidance. I want to make the necessary corrections while preserving the accuracy of the historical record. ~2026-60851-58 (talk) 19:27, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Request for take a look at the draft and provide feedback

Skype7 (talk) 17:49, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

@Skype7: and what draft would that be, Draft:Nagarukhra?
It has been resubmitted and is awaiting review. We don't do on-demand reviews here at the help desk, you'll have to wait until a reviewer gets around to it. If you have specific questions, meanwhile, you may ask those of course. -- DoubleGrazing (talk) 17:56, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

18:40, 18 November 2026 review of submission by AliMohammedPhoto

Hello I have made several changes to my draft since the previous review I have added more published sources corrected the references and revised the content to make it more neutral and suitable for Wikipedia

I would appreciate it if an editor could review the updated version again and let me know whether it is ready for publication or if further changes are needed

Thank you for your time AliMohammedPhoto (talk) 18:40, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

No, none of your new sources are acceptable. I have now rejected the draft. qcne (talk) 18:43, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello thank you for your feedback.
I would like to share all the media sources that have published articles or interviews about my work as an Iraqi sports photographer
Here are the sources:
  1. https://ina.iq/ar/sport/275970-2030.html
  2. Al-Sabah: https://alsabaah.iq/136676-.html
  3. Iraqi Network Media: https://magazine.imn.iq/ryadh/9646-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%B5%D9%88%D8%B1-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%B6%D9%8A-%D8%B9%D9%84%D9%8A-%D9%85%D8%AD%D9%85%D8%AF-%D9%84%D9%80-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B4%D8%A8%D9%83%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B9%D8%B1%D8%A7%D9%82%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%A3%D8%AD%D9%84%D9%85-%D8%A8%D8%AA%D9%88%D8%ث%D9%8A%D9%82-%D9%85%D8%AC%D8%AF-%D8%B9%D8%B1%D8%A7%D9%82%D9%8A-%D8%B9%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D9%8A.html
  4. Al-Watan (Qatar): https://www.al-watan.com/article/258360/%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%B6%D8%A9/%D8%B9%D9%84%D9%8A-%D9%85%D8%AD%D9%85%D8%AF-%D9%88%D8%AA%D8%AC%D8%B1%D8%A8%D8%A9-%D9%81%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%AF%D8%A9-%D9%81%D9%8A-%D9%82%D8%B7%D8%B1-2022
  5. Al-Ghad (Jordan): https://alghad.com/Section-143/%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%B6%D8%A9-%D9%85%D8%AD%D9%84%D9%8A%D8%A9/%D9%85%D9%87%D8%AF%D9%8A-%D9%85%D8%B5%D9%88%D8%B1-%D8%B9%D8%B1%D8%A7%D9%82%D9%8A-%D9%8A%D9%85%D8%AA%D9%84%D9%83-%D9%85%D8%AE%D8%B2%D9%88%D9%86%D8%A7-%D9%85%D9%86-%D8%B5%D9%88%D8%B1-%D9%85%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%86%D8%B4%D8%A7%D9%85%D9%89-2096305
  6. Ahram Business: https://business.ahram.org.eg/News/131401.aspx
  7. Al-Sabah Al-Jadeed: https://newsabah.com/newspaper/309454
  8. Al-Nahar (Kuwait): https://www.annaharkw.com/Article.aspx?id=1057623&date=27102026
  9. Ad-Dustour (Jordan): https://www.addustour.com/articles/1602755
  10. Omder Times: https://omdertimes.com/?p=166269
  11. Al-Adaa News: https://www.aldaaenews.com/AR/Details/61579
  12. https://m.youm7.com/amp/2019/1/24/%D9%85%D8%B4%D8%A7%D8%B9%D8%B1-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%88%D8%B7%D9%86%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%BA%D9%84%D8%A8%D8%AA%D9%87-%D9%85%D8%B5%D9%88%D8%B1-%D8%B9%D8%B1%D8%A7%D9%82%D9%89-%D9%8A%D8%A8%D9%83%D9%89-%D8%A3%D8%AB%D9%86%D8%A7%D8%A1-%D8%AA%D8%B5%D9%88%D9%8A%D8%B1-%D9%85%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%A9-%D8%A8%D9%84%D8%A7%D8%AF%D9%87/4116664
I understand that the article is about me and that this creates a conflict of interest I am not asking you to accept the draft automatically I would simply appreciate your advice on which of these sources if any meet Wikipedia’s requirements for independent and significant coverage
I am willing to make further changes based on your guidance
Thank you for your time AliMohammedPhoto (talk) 19:00, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
These are all much the same very obvious promotional paid-for pieces that are both unreliable and not independent. qcne (talk) 19:06, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for your feedback I just want to clarify that I have never paid for media coverage or promotional articles The interviews and reports were published independently by media outlets
I am not necessarily asking for a Wikipedia article about myself I simply wanted to show that my work as a sports photographer is genuine and publicly documented
Here are some examples of my work and public coverage:
Wikimedia Commons (18 photographs): https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Works_by_Ali_Mohammed
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/alimohammed111_/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/alimohammed81/
I respect Wikipedia s policies but I would appreciate it if my work was not described as paid promotion without evidence
Thank you for your time AliMohammedPhoto (talk) 19:17, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Of course these are all paid-for promotional pieces. Just read the "sources" you provided. I won't be responding further. Please do not attempt to create this draft again. qcne (talk) 19:20, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
We also don't cite Wikimedia Commons, Instagram, Facebook, Xitter, Bluesky, Mastodon, etc. Presenting those as sources is a waste of time. —Jéské Couriano v^_^v Thriller Night! 19:33, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

19:27, 18 November 2026 review of submission by Ricbraun

@Timtrent: Good afternoon!

My name is Ricardo Braun. My late father Eitel Henrique Gross Braun, received a gold medal from the government of South Korea in 1967 for his work and dedicated services of mapping the soils of South Korea, as part of the above mentioned FAO- UNESCO Project.

This was a long time ago so many of his work in on paper. Some reports he developed / or helped to develop in the past, I have scanned and uploaded to my Wordpress in order to prove his work. Some information I have linked to official websites such as FAO / UN, EMBRAPA's SNLCS in Brazil. The information presented is backed by published, reliable, and independent third-party sources.

I believe the gold medal award is an historical event for both the government of South Korea as well as for the government of Brazil.

Please let me know what should I do specifically for Wikipedia to publish information about this historical event.

Thanks for your time.

Best regards

Ricardo Braun, PhD. Ricbraun (talk) 19:27, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

@Ricbraum: Have you looked at Help:Referencing for beginners? The problem is you don't actually cite anything. —Jéské Couriano v^_^v Thriller Night! 19:35, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Also keep in mind that your task is not to merely prove his work to us. We don't publish articles about subjects merely because the facts can be proven to be true. A Wikipedia article should be a neutral summary of what the majority of people who are wholly unconnected with the subject have independently chosen to publish about the subject in reliable publications, (see Golden rule) and not much else. What you know (or anybody else knows) about the subject is not relevant except where it can be verified from a reliable published source. Athanelar (talk) 19:57, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
@Ricbraun I can add nothing to a combination of my review and Athanelar's comments. Your late father, the man, must pass WP:BIO for an article to succeed here. I suggest that you are standing too close to your late father and may find it truly hard to hear this and also to wrote an article about him. 🇵🇸‍🇺🇦 FiddleTimtrent FaddleTalk to me 🇺🇦‍🇵🇸 22:25, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

November 19

00:25, 19 November 2026 review of submission by My Venona

Review of second submission. Pursuant to feedback on initial draft, the second draft was NOT created by an LLM. I ask that you review the submission again, if you decline again, please show the results of LLM testing. My Venona (talk) 00:25, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

@My Venona Are you the same person as @NKCollective or are you somebody else? What is your relation to the subject of the draft? Athanelar (talk) 00:39, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
p.s., wikipedia.gptzero.me identifies the draft as 100% chance of being AI generated, so there's your result. Athanelar (talk) 00:40, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

00:39, 19 November 2026 review of submission by ZygonCorrector

This draft keeps being rejected by the same person for spurious reasons. ZygonCorrector (talk) 00:39, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

You have repeatedly failed to heed the advice you've been given both about the content of your draft initially as well as about removing decline notices; which, to state it again, you must not do. That's why your draft has ultimately been rejected. If you want to be able to keep resubmitting your draft for reviews you need to demonstrate that you're heeding and acting on the feedback you're getting in good faith. Athanelar (talk) 00:45, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

Request for review: Draft:NAVA (singer) and Draft:Farbod Mehr

Hello. I have submitted two drafts, Draft:NAVA (singer) and Draft:Farbod Mehr. I have a declared conflict of interest (see my user page), so I have not moved them myself. I would be grateful for any feedback on sourcing or tone, or a review when a volunteer has time. Thank you. Jasonjons (talk) 01:03, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

You have already submitted the drafts for review, which means they're already in the queue. A volunteer will get to it soon. Please continue to be patient, as it says on the template on both your drafts.
Note, however, that Apple Music, SoundCloud, and any other user-generated sources do not qualify as a reliable source under Wikipedia's guidelines.In solidarity, 🏳️‍🌈JohnLaurens333 (They/them • Not a chatbot • Contribs) 01:13, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

02:17, 19 November 2026 review of submission by Algaesuki

Help with declined draft: COI disclosure, tone, and WP:CORPDEPTH

Hello! I am a new editor looking for advice on my submission, [Draft:Chitose Group], which has been declined twice at Articles for Creation.

First, I want to disclose that I am an employee of Chitose Group (I have noted this on the top of the draft).

My draft was declined in May and August for having an advertorial tone and for not demonstrating [WP:CORPDEPTH]. I left replies on my talk page [User talk:Algaesuki] asking for specific examples of promotional phrasing and clarification on my sources, which include coverage in The Japan Times and Nikkei, alongside Japanese government (NEDO) and academic sources, but haven't received a response yet.

As a side note, the Japanese page (https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/ちとせグループ)of the company has been existing for a few years, and I wanted to create an English one as well, since the English coverage has also increased.

Could an experienced editor take a look at the draft and point out which specific sections still sound promotional, and advise on what kind of additional secondary coverage is needed to meet corporate notability guidelines?

Thank you for your help! Algaesuki (talk) 02:17, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

I'm going to be blunt.
  • As a paid editor, you are expected to know the policies and guidelines before you attempt to write an article, which is the most difficult task there is on Wikipedia, and not recommended for new editors without first getting a lot of practice editing outside their conflict of interest.
  • Almost no new editor writing about their employer succeeds. Most other company articles on Wikipedia were not written by a company representative, but by volunteers who have no association with the company.
  • You are getting paid to know the rules. You are not being paid to get free help from the volunteer community, who is donating their time to this project, and that donated time is far more valuable than your paid time.
  • The guideline for appropriate company sources is covered in WP:SIRS. A guideline for inappropriate sources would be WP:CORPROUTINE.
  • Whatever exists on other language Wikipedias is irrelevant here. The English Wikipedia has the strictest standards.
  • Do not use AI to communicate with us, or to write any text on Wikipedia. Using AI as an author or co-author is prohibited.
That said, the tone is not promotional, but as a whole it comes across as an information brochure that says what the company wants the world to know. ~Anachronist (who / me) (talk) 05:25, 19 November 2026 (UTC)