Wikipedia:Articles for improvement/Processes

OverviewNominationsHolding areaScheduleProcessesTalk

Welcome to the Articles for improvement processes! This page covers in detail all the inner procedures that allow the project to run smoothly, including each type of nomination and how they are handled.

General review process

Since only one article can be featured every week and the holding area contains far more candidates than can be used, our review process is intended to only approve nominations that receive substantial support, rather than every nomination that is merely not opposed by the majority.

  1. Based on the criteria, any editor may vote or comment on the inclusion of the article in the holding area. (For other nominations, "keep" and "reserve" are tallied as supports.)
  2. Once a nomination reaches a quorum of at least eight responses (including neutral votes but not general comments), it is:
    Approved when supports make up at least three quarters of responses and it has been open for seven days.
    no Not approved when the majority of respondents opposes and it has been open for seven days.
    no Not approved when opposes make up at least three quarters of respondents.
    A nomination that has not yet reached the quorum can only be reviewed when:
    The article nominated for approval was already in the holding area.
    no Out of the first six respondents, five oppose it.
    no The article is in the schedule.
    no The nomination failed to reach any outcome within 14 days. (Removal nominations can be reviewed under this criterion only after reaching the quorum.)
    no The article had another open nomination, or its most recent nomination of the same type failed in the last six months.
    no The nominator has agreed to withdraw their nomination.
  3. Any registered editor, including the nominator, may review a nomination in the cases above by placing {{Approved}} or {{Not approved}} below the numbered list. If a review proves controversial, an uninvolved reviewer may be requested.
  4. After four hours, a bot will archive reviewed § Nominations and, if approved, add the articles to the bottom of the holding area. (For other types of nominations, the holding area needs to be updated manually.)
  5. An article may have only one open nomination at a time and may not be nominated twice under the same process for six months after a failed nomination. Check previous nominations using the search box below.
  6. Each editor may have at most ten open nominations at any time. (Bundled nominations count as one.)

Specific review processes