Wikipedia:Cleanup process/Old instructions

Front matter

Sample terms to use
keep - fine - wikify - nonsense - OK now? - unimproved - insufficient - meta - stubified - substub - expand - nonexistent - obscure - idiosyncratic - ad/advert - selfpromotion - ungrammatic - silly - joke - repeat - link - chatty - rant - POV - NPOV - copyvio - brilliant - obscenity - blog - vanity page...

Reasons for listing an article here include

  1. It is a substub, and might need removal or merging with a broader article
  2. It needs extensive formatting, proofreading, or rephrasing in comprehensible English.
  3. It is a candidate for "speedy deletion" according to the deletion policy, but you're not a sysop and can't delete articles (a sysop may see it and delete it, or it may be improved into a decent article).
  4. You think it should be deleted (copyvio, unsalvageable POV), but aren't sure, and don't want to mistakenly put it on VfD (it will be moved to the appropriate page by somebody else).
  5. It needs to be changed urgently for some reason.

Style notes:

Removing Entries

To remove an entry, you should fix it first; but common sense should govern how large the cleanup page gets and how long entries are left there. A good rule of thumb is to keep the page size below 30k, and to reduce size by summarising past discussion rather than removing old entries when possible (this is not VfD; comments are not sacred).

When an entry is removed, it can be:

Some common types of entry follow, together with advice on how to handle them:

  • Harmful content (nonsense, personal essays/opinions, accuracy problems, or severe unedited bias): may be fixed by paring down content until nothing objectionable remains.
  • Bad article, perhaps listed on VfD, but an unlikely candidate for deletion - leave here; try to improve. Cleanup works on a longer timescale than VfD.
    • It is not always obvious whether an entry falls into this category or the one below; when in doubt, leave the entry here.
  • Bad article, likely candidate for deletion - move the entry to VfD. If it isn't voted for deletion it will generally be moved back here, somewhat improved.
    • Again, if in doubt, leave it here even if it is on VfD.
  • Raw text dump - remove only after the article has been wikified, reworded with better encyclopedic style, verified for accuracy, weeded for useless or unremarkable information, AND NPOVed.
  • Request for NPOV, fact checking or other faults which could make the article actively harmful - don't remove unless you're sure the article is fixed.
  • Request for expansion of a sub-stub - remove once it's a valid stub, or move it to Wikipedia:Requests for expansion if you think the topic needs more than a stub (see below).
  • Request for expansion of a non-stub, long-term reworking of an article, or better completion of a list, template, or overview - after a week, can be moved to Wikipedia:Requests for expansion. RPE works on a longer timescale than cleanup.
  • An article subject to an edit war or other active dispute - leave the entry here until it is a few days old, to draw attention to the problem. After a week it can be removed, since the dispute resolution process will fix the problem if possible.

Above all, fix things you know how to fix. If you're looking for something to do, aggressively target entries in the following places:

Stay frosty

Unlike VfD, it doesn't really matter whether an article is on cleanup or not.

If the fact that an article is on cleanup upsets you, you may be reading too much into it. Most articles need improvement; someone just happened to stumble over this one. One way or another, it will be off cleanup in a few weeks. And since cleanup comments must be short, assume notes like "horrible" or "?!" or "eek" are hasty abbreviations for "could be better", not abbreviations for "this is the worst article I've ever seen, and I hate whoever helped write it".

If the fact that a particular article is not on cleanup upsets you, list it again. But if it has already gone from the top of cleanup to the bottom and "fallen off", it may be better to think of another solution rather than just trying cleanup again.

Week Bars