Wikipedia:Requests for permissions/Autopatrolled

Autopatrolled

(add request · view requests)

User:ItsShandog

I have been editing since May last year and have created more than 25 articles. Two of them are rated B‑class, and most of the others are C‑class or Start‑class. Two of my articles, Presley Gerber and Killing of Sonia Exelby, were nominated for deletion because of differing views on their notability, but both were kept. Thanks. — Preceding unsigned comment added by ItsShandog (talk • contribs) 11:59, 22 October 2026 (UTC)

Hi @ItsShandog, could you explain how you created Brendan Megraw in Diff/1290863082? Why did you use the {{navbox}} template in Diff/1290872406 and how did you produce that in such a short amount of time? Why did you remove the {{ai-generated}} tag (added in Diff/1348062842), along with utm_source=chatgpt.com parameters, in Diff/1348070103 and then restore the original redirect in Diff/1379884757 a couple of months later? ‑‑gurkubondinn 14:59, 24 October 2026 (UTC)
That would have been around the time I was new to Wikipedia from what I can recall, and looking at it now, it was days after I joined when I would have used ChatGPT. That was before I knew much about AI or about Wikipedia. I stopped using it a long time ago, as I saw how unreliable it was even before the ban on Wikipedia. I cannot explain the navbox, as I have no idea what that is. I would assume it was something to do with ChatGPT at that time. In regard to restoring it to a redirect, that was more to do with the fact that I was editing the disappeared page that covers all those people, and the page more or less repeats the same thing. It does not have any more information than the disappeared page. It was not anything to do with my old edits, as I did not even notice the ChatGPT bit on it. I forgot about that edit, as it was over a year ago. If I had remembered, I would have gone back and fixed all of that, but it is better as a redirect anyway. ItsShandog (talk) 15:17, 24 October 2026 (UTC)
The reason for the removal of the AI part was that this was at the point when I did not use it anymore, but I had not fixed the page at that stage, so I should not have removed it. That was my own fault. There were so many pages I would have edited when I was new that I could not remember them all, but any I come across now I try to fix. I probably removed the ChatGPT part because I would have assumed that was what the template was referring to. That would have been me trying to fix the page, but to be honest I did not know the ins and outs of AI until recently, or all the different ways it is incorrect. Even back in April I just assumed a page was tagged with that because it had old links from ChatGPT and that type of thing. It is only when I have started to read the AI signs page on Wikipedia that I have learned about all the different things it does. If I had known that in April, I would have done a lot of copyediting and fixing of that page. ItsShandog (talk) 15:21, 24 October 2026 (UTC)
Your account became eligible for autopatrolled last month. Virtually all of your creations are on (potentially) criminal acts, some of which are in my view of debatable notability. (The Presley Gerber AfD wasn't closed as "keep" but as no consensus.) While your creations appear properly sourced, the marginal notability issues and the past AI use make me think it would be beneficial for your creations to be patrolled for the near future. Feel free to check back for another review in a few months.  Not done for now. Dclemens1971 (talk) 19:41, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Fair enough, but I'm just wondering why their notability is considered debatable. Another user who is an admin has created a lot of similar pages, so I'm a bit confused by that. I'm also wondering how it will be any different in a few months, as I'll still have the same pages. Am I not just going to run into the same issue again? All of the pages are sourced and have ongoing coverage, so I don't really understand the notability issue and would just appreciate some clarification as to why exactly their notability is considered debatable. ItsShandog (talk) 20:07, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
Some of the events don't seem to have substantial coverage over a sustained period to meet WP:NEVENT, just a burst of coverage at the time of the incident and a limited amount of routine followup coverage. It's not open-and-shut, and I'm not planning to bring AfDs. For all I know, everything is notable. But a bare 27 creations, many at the edge of notability don't give me comfort to grant AP. Perhaps another admin will feel differently. Dclemens1971 (talk) 20:29, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
I understand, and I appreciate your explanation. It probably is a bit soon to request it, as you said, since I only recently became eligible. The only reason I requested it was because someone else suggested I should try when I asked how long it takes for pages to be reviewed, and another admin has previously reviewed pages for me, including the one I mentioned who has created similar pages. Some of them could be debatable, yes, but I don't think every event page is going to have sustained coverage over a long period of time. Eventually, they won't be reported on as much, particularly once trials and other developments have concluded. I wouldn't create a page if I didn't think there was enough coverage, so I'm not really sure what can be done about that. A new user recently took a number of my pages to AfD, including the Sonia Exelby article, which was ultimately kept. Anyway, thank you for taking the time to explain everything. I'll try again in a few months. ItsShandog (talk) 20:41, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

User:Godsy

I have only created 12 articles from scratch (and some of them were not 'fresh' creations but rather over redirects or older ones of poor quality). Quite frankly, I have never seen the need to request this user right for myself until this week (e.g. why would more sets of eyes on a new article be ever be a bad thing?). A good portion of my work over the past few years has been in the realm of soft redirects. If my understanding is correct, soft redirects enter the NPP queue; this, in turn, encourages and compels a patrol. What I can say for sure is that they are not covered by redirect autopatrol, as I eventually received the standard notice that they were all reviewed by other human reviewers (and would also have been patrolled much sooner by the bot if that were the case). I had to fix approxiamtely 10 new soft redirects a couple days ago because (seemingly inexperienced) reviewers, in good faith, applied inapplicable maintenance tags (e.g. here and here). Thus, for the first time, I saw the need to enter my name here to potentially make less work for many hands (admittedly, including mine) in the future. Thanks and warmest regards, — Godsy (TALKCONT) 12:16, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

User:CaptainAngus

Requesting autopatrolled permission for myself. I've written ~130 articles over the last few years and hope to keep doing so, producing output consistent with my history. Thank you! CaptainAngus (talk) 04:16, 19 November 2026 (UTC)