| Computing desk | ||
|---|---|---|
| < January 7 | << Dec | January | Feb >> | January 9 > |
| Welcome to the Wikipedia Computing Reference Desk Archives |
|---|
| The page you are currently viewing is an archive page. While you can leave answers for any questions shown below, please ask new questions on one of the current reference desk pages. |
Dear Wikipedians:
The Linux mailx program seems to be able to directly check the
/var/spool/mail/[username]
mailbox. However, Thunderbird for Windows requires either a POP3 or an IMAP server to work (only the SMTP server is setup on my Linux box).
I am wondering if there is any Windows equivalent of mailx that can check Linux mailboxes directly remotely, using just the IP address of the remote Linux box and its SMTP port (port 25)?
Thanks,
69.158.78.39 (talk) 02:36, 8 January 2016 (UTC)
A while ago, an article about a fake artist was deleted. She sold music on iTunes, Spotify, Tidal, Microsoft music, Google Music and Amazon. However, the music was actually performed by Katharine McPhee (easily confirmed with Shazam). I wanted to report it, because I am a regular customer of two of these sellers, and I don't like doing my shopping in places where stolen goods is being sold. So I reported it to Spotify, who actually has a button for flagging tracks that are problematic for any reason (including piracy), and I filled in a form at IFPI's web site, www.ifpi.com/contacts. The latter appeared to be broken, as I got no on-screen confirmation that the message had been received (just a blank page), and no email confirmation. Spotify responded swiftly, and the music is now gone from Spotify, but available on the other platforms. IFPI has not responded so far.
I don't want to spend an exessive amount of time on this, but I still would like to see the music removed from the other platforms. So I have been thinking about how to get the message through, and be done with it, without using public forums where I use my personal name. This idea occurred: write the story in some blog where I am reasonably anonymous, and use a reasonably anonymous twitter account to link to the post. I actually do have a suitable twitter account. My questions:
--NorwegianBlue talk 10:00, 8 January 2016 (UTC)
While it's theoretically possible for your message to go viral and for the companies to take action themselves; it's also very likely this won't happen. Even with a regular twitter account with a few real followers. A middle ground would be if the right fans, supporters or whatever notice and they complain to the sites but despite her popularity there's still a fair chance this won't happen either. Ultimately McPhee and her agents or the representatives for whoever publishes her music are the people who have the most interest and who will also find it easiest getting all the sites to take down the content since they are the copyright holder.
So it would be better to concentrate on getting this to someone who will hopefully direct it to such people. Beyond Twitter, perhaps her official site . Her Facebook page doesn't allow you to PM or post anything on her wall, but you can do what other people may do and post it in response to one of her posts. But Facebook doesn't really allow anonymity. Note that as with Twitter, it's important that you get the key points across preferably early, rather than relying on someone reading the blog.
BTW, since you're posting this here in a public place, I'm going to assume you're okay with people linking to it if you don't say something to the contrary. If my request to join her official site forum is ever accepted I may post a link to this thread along with an explaination of the problem. Possibly to Facebook as well. @NorwegianBlue:
Nil Einne (talk) 12:10, 8 January 2016 (UTC)
---NorwegianBlue talk 14:19, 11 January 2016 (UTC)
Also, while one could achieve the other, I think getting the tracks taken down and publicising the issue of scammers selling the works of others to unwitting customers should largely be approached as seperate goals. For the later, it'll be best to push your blog/message to journalists involved in the field. I think it is a message which will resonate with many, since even those who torrent etc and don't generally care about copyright aren't likely to support scammers who make money by selling the work of others to unwitting customers.
BTW, I'm not really sure whether there's much risk it will encourage people to get her music for cheap. Firstly, many of the scammer tracks seem to be sold at the same price as originals. Second, while I guess most of these services will keep the tracks for purchasers even after removed from their service so it'll be a minor advantage, I think most who can't be bothered paying will alreaddy have them from torrents, Youtube or whatever.
In terms of anonymity, I don't know much about Blogger but in general I think there are no simple answers as it depends who you are trying to be anonymous from, how much effort you go to, what you've done before etc. For example, you may already realise this, but it's unlikely it would be that hard to find this discussion if someone was researched well enough, even with the removal of the scammers name (which I agree was a good thing). From there, it may be possible for someone to figure out a fair amount about you from what you've done on wikipedia.
And even if you hadn't talked about this anywhere before or after you made a blog post and use a blog service which is supposed to be anonymous, it's possible someone may use social engineering to fool either you or whoever is providing the service. Unfortunately if you want to be truly anonymous, you have to take great care. (I would probably only ever update the blog over Tor, make sure I used a randomly generated password etc.)
Then again, even if it goes viral, I don't think it's that likely anyone is going to care enough to find out much about you, but it's impossible to say for sure.
Nil Einne (talk) 16:11, 12 January 2016 (UTC)
Dear Wikipedians:
I notice that when I take off the execution bit of rc.sendmail (that is, sendmail daemon is not running on my Linux box), even mailx'ing an email to myself, the new message will not appear in my mbox.
Is Sendmail required for mailx to work on Linux?
Thanks,
45.56.154.62 (talk) 23:23, 8 January 2016 (UTC)