Wikipedia:Simple talk

Skip to top
Skip to bottom

Review request for Nikhil Goel draft

Hello,

I have prepared a draft article about Nikhil Goel in my user sandbox:

https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:AdvertoutAjith/sandbox

I am a paid contributor through Advertout Digital working on behalf of Nikhil Goel, and I have disclosed this relationship.

I would like an independent editor to review the draft before it is moved into the main article space.

Could someone please check the draft for:

I will make any changes recommended by independent editors before moving the article.

Thank you. AdvertoutAjith (talk) 13:01, 10 November 2026 (UTC)

Hello AdvertoutAjith, where did you disclose your paid editing here? NDG (talk) 13:09, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello NDG,
I have now added the paid editing disclosure to my user page here:
https://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:AdvertoutAjith
I am affiliated with Advertout Digital and am contributing on behalf of Nikhil Goel.
Please let me know if any additional disclosure is needed.
Thank you. AdvertoutAjith (talk) 17:04, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
You've got a draft on en wiki, my suggestion would be to focus on that and only if that is accepted, create a simplified version here. Ravensfire (talk) 18:14, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

Military unit vs military organization

When it comes to putting, say, a squad, brigade, regiment, corps, etc into a category, it seems like they are separated into either Category:Military units (see Fireteam, Squad, and Section) or Category:Military organizations (see Battalion, Platoon, Regiment, and Squadron). Should we add both categories to every military unit page, or should they only have one of the two categories? ~2026-59740-74 (talk) 17:41, 11 November 2026 (UTC)

Are you also considering how civilian entities like police would be categorized? Barbara (talk) 20:19, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

November 2026 Wikimedia Café: the Newcomer homepage & Home experience

The logo for the Wikimedia Café

The Wikimedia Foundation's Contributor teams are migrating the Newcomer homepage to a new experience called Home. This page will evolve with users, introducing them to new personalized opportunities based on their interests, and helping them develop into experienced contributors.

In November 21–22 sessions of the Wikimedia Café, Kirsten Stoller (senior product manager, Growth) and Sam Walton (senior product manager, Moderator Tools) will share an overview of this feature, plans for its future, and demos of interactive prototypes which we can explore together.

A quote which I hope will inspire your attendance or at least good wishes, from Grace Hopper: "The most important thing I've accomplished, other than building the compiler, is training young people. They come to me, you know, and say, 'Do you think we can do this?' I say, 'Try it.' And I back 'em up. They need that. I keep track of them as they get older and I stir 'em up at intervals so they don't forget to take chances."

This month's schedule:

  • Session A: 21 November at 16:00 UTC (timestamp converter), at a time friendly to the Americas, Africa, and Europe
  • Session B: 22 November at 04:00 UTC (timestamp converter), at a time friendly to Asia and the Pacific

Please see the Café page for more information, including how to register!

Attendees of the Café are encouraged to bring a favorite beverage. (In the eternal words of Captain Picard, "Tea, Earl Grey, hot.")

To subscribe or unsubscribe for Café notices on your talk page please go here.

cropped image of colored pencils

༄ᨒ𖠰 Pine (✉) 23:56, 11 November 2026 (UTC)

Soccer categories in general

The set-up for soccer categories on en.wiki and simple.wiki is completely the opposite way round. On Simple Wiki, categories are Category:2025–26 in European football, but this doesn't take into account domestic leagues which go throughout an entire year - for example, you couldn't put 2024 Eliteserien into Category:2023–24 in European football. This is contrary to logic.

And having a category Category:2024 in European football doesn't make any sense because that implies calendar years, not seasons. Bobo. 03:45, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

I do think we should try and go for less categories where simpler but this in my opinion is a clear case where two separate ones (one for season, one for an entire year) are required. Bobo192, I just want to ask how you think they should be sorted, should there be 2024 and 2024-25 cats to try and address this issue or do you think it should be sorted a different way? --Ferien (talk | join TBA!) 21:33, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Not Bobo192 here, but seeing as I consider the sport is my main area of expertise here, I feel like there should be both. One the one hand, those that cover two years (2023–24 for example) is useful for leagues and tournaments that span both years (like the Premier League, UEFA Champions League or UEFA Nations League), while those that cover one year would be good for both leagues that only span one year (like the Eliteserien or League of Ireland Premier Division) and international tournaments like UEFA Euro 2024, as well as youth tournaments like the (which has happened in every odd year since 2009). ShadowBallX (talk) 23:51, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Global ban for XiaoFui

Hello, this message is to notify that XiaoFui has been nominated for a global ban at m:Requests for comment/Global ban for XiaoFui. You are receiving this notification as required per the global ban policy as they have made at least 1 edit on this wiki. Thanks, Peterxy (talk) 11:42, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Bad articles

Do we really need articles like 18th millennium and so on? They're completely pointless and someone could keep creating them forever. ~2026-60823-60 (talk) 19:40, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Agreed. Following what English Wikipedia did and made it a redirect to Timeline of the far future. TDKR Chicago 101 (talk) 23:31, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
This (and the similar articles) are all from an LTA. Current temp account is ~2026-60689-58 (talk · contribs), but look at the contributions from the underlying /48 range. They also hit the Ice Age articles, adding bad information about the original studio being reopened (it's not) and fake future films added. Quite annoying. Ravensfire (talk) 16:09, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Ravensfire, I've blocked the temporary account. I have blocked a /64 range, I haven't blocked the /48 range you mention, but I will keep an eye on it. --Ferien (talk | join TBA!) 16:16, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Appreciate that! It's been an annoyance for a while, but juuuust below the point where I would go to AN. Ravensfire (talk) 18:11, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Article guidance: opt-out proposal

Hello all.

In recent months, a new feature, "Article Guidance" has been introduced to this Wikipedia. While we were invited to try this article guidance in a test environment in April, this invitation was never accepted by any member of the community but the experiment continued ahead- and another thread was written to us in October that still received no response that proposed making it the default option for article creation. It means now all editors with under 100 edits must run through the process at Special:NewArticle for creating new articles. I understand this was also A/B tested with more experienced editors, but can now be skipped.

I am first concerned that while these changes can seemingly have positive effects, the WMF has assumed our silence as acceptance of the trial despite this being a major change to the way article creation operates on this Wikipedia. Beyond two Simple talk posts from UOzurumba (WMF), we have not received any notice of this, and as WMF staff make quite a few procedural notices on Simple talk this might not have been noticed as it was assumed as this (I am thinking similarly to w:banner blindness). It is difficult to say this has been taken in collaboration with our Wikipedia when no single user has indicated support for it.

Personally I have only heard about this 7 months on from the original proposal when it happened to be bought up in an off-wiki channel, and am certainly not the only admin who was not made aware of this. No notice was ever given on the administrators' noticeboard even though Wikipedia talk:Article Guidance I understand is a venue that requires administrators to monitor, but all responses since July have gone unanswered. I have no idea how to answer or resolve these requests.

No or very action from the community has been taken on this project. Observe all templates at Special:Prefixindex/Wikipedia:Article Guidance/ are created almost entirely by WMF staff and only some have been simply copyedited later on. As far as I have seen so far no "experienced editor" (using my definition of an editor I recognise mainly from reasonable activity on this project) has ever edited one of these subpages as is the intention. The general statements about "significance" on some feel like an opening towards LLM generation in articles (which I believe this project has been built to avoid) and against our aim of trying to explain things simply and in plain language. I find generally that the templates themselves do not feature Simple English, and the advice is not geared enough to ensuring Simple English is used.

Based on the short off-wiki conversation it appears the feature is unpopular potentially to such an extent that it is discouraging article creation. After reviewing the feature myself in more detail, I am still not sure I understand the scope it has been used on this project so far, but I certainly do not see it as necessary or helpful for the reasons above. Creating Simple English pages can be difficult but I do not think this assists it in a way that is helpful for us. Our main issue is with language used, structure is not really as much of a concern. I appreciate the idea, and think it could be helpful for notability, but for the level of maintenance and setup necessary I do not think it would be of proportionate benefit for us. I am proposing for us to opt out of article guidance. Any administrator can disable the feature at Special:CommunityConfiguration/ArticleGuidance, however I think now would be a good time to have a conversation of what we want out of this. --Ferien (talk | join TBA!) 15:35, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Strong support. Article guidance is a good idea with bad implementation. Frankly, we don’t have the collective time to maintain this feature. I am quite upset that WMF was met with nothing but negative feedback overall and still decided that our silence meant that we wanted this. Garsh (talk) 17:59, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
As I said in the (not real) secret cabal zone, from what I understand of AG, it is a decent idea with poor execution, so support disabling AG locally.- FusionSub (Talk page) (Contributions) 09:06, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
I had to request Quick Deletion for two created articles that still had unfinished edits. It appears that these two editors had begun these articles while still in the middle of their Article guidance. I don't think article guidance is good to have on Simple. Barbara (talk) 18:31, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
Hello all,
I am sorry that my communications on Simple Talk and the Discord channel didn’t reach the people they needed to. I will cross-post to the administrators channel next time. The unanswered requests you mentioned were from contributors indicating topics they needed to write about that did not have an outline, and the feature triggered a notification. Therefore, they were for experienced contributors to see the types of articles people wanted to create that didn't have outlines and decide whether they were relevant to create. They were not for WMF to reply to, which is why it was moved to the Simple: Wikipedia:Article Guidance talk page for visibility. The feature has improved, so the notifications no longer apply.
The absence of an outline, which was a drop-off point that filtered a higher proportion of attempts to create articles during the A/B experiment, has been resolved by using default or generic outlines when topic-specific ones don’t exist. With generic outlines, along with other improvements documented on this page, the need to create more outlines has been reduced.
I can also support you in any way to help you understand how the markups in outlines work so you can gradually create any relevant outline, or edit the existing outlines to fit your editing practices.
Now that Article guidance can be exposed through the CommunityConfiguration, you, as a community, can decide how you want to expose it. You might leave it on and not expose it until you can identify the issues and present them to our team for a solution.
I would also say that we need clearer feedback on what is not working well for consideration, which can help us improve the feature for the Simple English Wikipedia community, as there are some nuances the A/B experiment that overall shows articles that were created through the Article guidance had a 12% higher chance of surviving a 30-day period than those created without the workflow won't have captured. I look forward to your feedback soon. Best regards, UOzurumba (WMF) (talk) 19:01, 20 November 2026 (UTC)

Lithium oxide

I think the article is not simple at all? @MADISONV33: Things like

The dominate intrinsic defects to the ideal lithium oxide structure are point defects, either cation vacancies or cation Frenkel pairs in the lithium sublattice. Schottky disorder can occur but is less favorable.

is highly technical language, and also a long sentence. I don't think this is appropriate for Simple English Wikipedia. Is there a better way to express this that fits more with the purpose of this project? ~2026-61035-14 (talk) 19:29, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

~2026-61035-14, thank you for noticing this. I have reverted the changes as they are not in Simple English. They can be simplified and then readded to the article later. --Ferien (talk | join TBA!) 21:29, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Article for review?

Hi, could an experienced editor check a draft I've made for an article about Floyd-Steinberg dithering? The draft can be found here. Deuteranopizza (talk) 08:48, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

Brake Pads

Hello, can someone rename the page Brake Pads to "Brake pad"? Thank you. ~2026-59740-74 (talk) 12:48, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

 Done. Axolitl (talk | contribs) 15:19, 19 November 2026 (UTC)