Wikipedia:Articles for improvement/TWAFI RFC workshop

Discuss at Wikipedia talk:Articles for improvement#Post-start RfCBEFORE (and relevant discussions).

Background

Initial discussion concerning this week's article for improvement (TWAFI, sometimes AFI) occurred here, here and here. The initial RfC (workshop here) was held from July 2 to August 11, and ended with a consensus to add TWAFI to the Main Page. The section was subsequently added on October 19. Confectionery store was the first article to be featured through it, followed by Mechanic.

AFI statistics

Both articles had a high rate of edits, around half of which were from unregistered temporary accounts or from new users (those who had registered since the start of 2026). Both articles also had a significant number of very new users, who registered during the week it was on the main page. However, a significant number of edits were reverted, and the newest users are also more frequently reverted than more established users.

Each article had approximately one edit per seventy pageviews, compared to an average (across all articles) of around one article edit per 2,900 article pageviews in those two weeks.

The drop in view counts in the second week is probably mostly due to a lack of novelty, but might also be linked to a broader drop in Main Page views (averaged 6.5m/day first week, 4.2m/day the second).

Notes

  1. ↑ 66 edits were removed from the article's history, making the final number 820
  2. ↑ Around 18-19% when including edits removed from the history

Removal

Should the articles for improvement (AFI) section continue to be featured on the Main Page?

Discussion (removal)

Placement

If AFI continues to be featured on the Main Page, where should it be placed? Rank ALL options from best to worst, for example: "B, A, C, E, D, F". (The section's colour will be decided separately in § Colour.)


A In the current slot for the featured article, which would be moved at the top

Welcome to Wikipedia, ...
 Today's featured article
 Help us impr.
 Did you know
 In the news
 On this day

B In a smaller section above the columns, below "Welcome to Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia that anyone can edit"

Welcome to Wikipedia, ...
 Help us improve this article!
 Feat. article
 Did you know
 In the news
 On this day

C Same as B but smaller, integrated in the introduction, and separated from the featured content (view example)

Welcome to Wikipedia, ...
    Help us improve this article!   
 Feat. article
 Did you know
 In the news
 On this day

D In the right column, next to the featured article (current)

Welcome to Wikipedia, ...
 Feat. article
 Did u know
 Help us impr.
 In the news
 On this day

E In the right column, between "In the news" (ITN) and "On this day" (OTD) (view preview)

Welcome to Wikipedia, ...
 Feat. article
 Did u know
 In the news
 Help us impr.
 On this day

F In the right column, below "On this day"

Welcome to Wikipedia, ...
 Feat. article
 Did u know
 In the news
 On this day
 Help us impr.

G Below the two columns

Welcome to Wikipedia, ...
 Feat. article
 Did you know
 In the news
 On this day
 Help us improve this article!

Survey (placement)

Discussion (placement)

Colour

In case the AFI section is kept but is moved away from the two columns, what colour should it be? (This does not apply if the option to place it inside the introduction succeeds.)

These colours are currently used on the Main Page:

Blue

 Help us improve this article!

Green

 Help us improve this article!

Purple

 Help us improve this article!

Pink

 Help us improve this article!

These colours are currently unused on the Main Page (and is not adapted to dark mode):

Red

 Help us improve this article!

Orange

 Help us improve this article!

Yellow

 Help us improve this article!

Survey (colour)

Discussion (colour)

Frequency

In case the AFI is featured on the first row of the Main Page, how often should it change?

Frequency if the section is moved

If the AFI section is moved below the first row of the Main Page, how often should it change? Respond with one of the options above; if you think the § Frequency should not be based on the row, only respond "Same".

Early change

If deemed necessary in order to pursue their goal of helping create new editors, can the AFI team decide to replace the AFI early in certain circumstances, such as when the level of activity from new editors is unexpectedly low or the topic proves excessively contentious?

Discussion (frequency)

Proportions

Should we set specific proportions between the left and right columns of the Main Page?

  • C ... both columns should always be of equal width
 LEFT 50%
 RIGHT 50%
  • D ... the left column should have a fixed width of 55% (used until AFI was added)
 LEFT 55%
 RIGHT 45%
  • D ... the left column should have a fixed width of 46% (current)
 LEFT 46%
 RIGHT 54%
  • E Other (specify)

Discussion (proportions)

Eligible topics

Currently, the criteria for nominating an article for improvement are:

Articles are ideal candidates for improvement if they are:

  1. Interesting to the general public and accessible to a broad audience. As a rough measure, this can be evidenced by page views.
  2. In need of significant improvement, with an extensive scope for expansion. Stubs, start-class, and short C-class articles are the most ideal for improvement. Higher-quality and more developed articles (i.e., B-class or higher) are rarely suitable. Free reliable sources should be available online.
  3. Highly important. Articles are worth improving the most if they are rated as "Top" or "High" importance to a WikiProject or classified as vital articles.
  4. Not targets of controversy. Articles that may generate heated discussions, edit warring, or questioned notability, and those classified as contentious topics, are not suited for the Main Page.
  5. Not about medical topics, biographies of living persons, or other topics that would not be ideal for new editors. Selections should be primarily focused on helping create new editors.

Media and brands

Should articles whose primary subject is a specific corporation or publication, a privately-held media franchise or fictional character, or a branded product or game be eligible for nomination under the AFI criteria?

  • A Yes
  • B Yes, but they should be featured on the Main Page one or two times as a trial; after that, a future discussion is required to continue
  • C No

Regional topics

Should articles about nationally rooted topics which lack significant recognition, appeal, or relevance outside a specific country, continent, or geographical region (excluding media and brands) be eligible for nomination under the criteria?

General discussion

Brainstorming new Main Page sections

This is a space for general discussion. Should the community consider redesigning the Main Page further or creating new sections in the future? For example, we could add the Signpost in a new section, move recent deaths into its own dedicated section, removing "On this day"

From French Wikipedia (which has an explanation of what Wikipedia is and how users can contribute), Tagalog Wikipedia (not a fan of the color scheme, but it has an explanation of what Wikipedia is and how users can contribute), Vietnamese Wikipedia (has boxes of what needs to be improved), Italian Wikipedia (they have a section for the Nobel Prize winners and feature the image/quote/source/desination of the day/month from a few of our sister projects), and Farsi Wikipedia (looks essentially the same to our Main Page, but they have a box describing Wikipedia below their FA and DYK equivalents). There are few that are radically different from ours too, like Basque Wikipedia (they have a lot educational videos!). I found it kind of funny that a few of these have uneven columns leading to whitespace.