Wikipedia:Mentoring for FAC

Discussions (August 2016) on the WP:FAC talkpage highlighted a concern at the low rate of promotion at FAC for first-time nominators – around 15 percent. This rises to about 50 percent for editors with one successful nomination behind them, and is significantly higher for more experienced editors. To help resolve the problem of the low promotion rate for first-timers, a voluntary mentoring scheme for first-time nominators has been implemented.

How it works

Finding mentors

There are three ways in which a nominator may find a mentor:

Mentors

The following editors have indicated their willingness to act as mentors in this scheme. Note: this is a general, not a specific commitment, and no mentor is obliged to accept any specific request.

(Note: when adding your name here, you may wish to indicate preferred subject areas but this is not essential)

  1. Gerda Arendt — I was engaged in music (Requiem (Reger)) and literature (Franz Kafka), but am open to initial general help on any subject.
  2. Wehwalt
  3. Iridescent — I work mainly on 19th-century England, but am happy to take a look at articles on any topic if asked
  4. Iry-Hor — My Wiki work is exclusively on Ancient Egypt, but I can help in Ancient History, and Mathematics and Physics articles.
  5. Nick-D — I mainly work on military history articles, but can provide detailed advice on most history-related topics and more general advice on other topics.
  6. FunkMonk — I mainly work on zoology articles, but have an interest in art (broadly speaking) and history as well.
  7. Dudley Miles — My main interests are history, evolution and geology.
  8. Hurricanehink — My main interests are meteorology, transport, American pop music after 1920, and space.
  9. David Fuchs — I tend to focus on film, video game, and media articles, but open to helping out on any subject; generally work on image and sourcing issues at FACs.
  10. Harry Mitchell — I can offer advice on prose and MoS compliance and I sometimes look at sourcing quality and comprehensiveness. Editing interests include transport infrastructure, architecture, and bits of history but I dabble in a wide variety of things. Generally not video games/popular culture but that's not a firm rule.
  11. Gen. Quon — My editing interests are all over the place, but I have the most Wikipedia experience in television (post-1990 shows mostly) and pop culture-related fields (e.g. popular and alt. rock music). As of 2026, I'm a bit strapped for time, but I'm willing to help out here and there, when possible.
  12. Masem - Particularly areas of video games and contemporary pop culture (television, films, music), but can also do physical sciences and engineering-related works too. Also anything where non-free media may be of concern, getting through the ins and outs of NFC policy.
  13. Josh Milburn — Potentially happy to take on lots of things; I have particular interests in philosophy, biology, culture (popular or otherwise), religion, and British history. Confident with image licensing, sourcing and writing, less confident with templates, tables and accessibility.
  14. Nikkimaria
  15. Casliber - biology, astronomy, other sciencey stuff, sports, popular culture.
  16. Jimfbleak. Mainly science, but I'll have a go at anything except software or popular culture Jimfbleak (talk) 06:18, 30 August 2016 (UTC)
  17. Simon Burchell - Mesoamerica (and archaeology in general), and the Spanish Conquest (and early modern warfare in general), but am willing to look at many other subjects, although I am not particularly interested in pop culture.
  18. Imzadi1979—my niche is American state highways and major roadways, and I can help with such topics in other countries, or more general advice on preparing a nomination on just about any other topic.
  19. Peacemaker67 military history, my speciality is the Balkans, but I also do a bit of Australian military history and even political bios.
  20. Magiciandude Popular Spanish-language music, mainly after the mid-1980s. Erick (talk) 20:50, 22 September 2016 (UTC)
  21. Ceranthor - Science, biography, mythology.
  22. Hog Farm - Military history; mainly the American Civil War. You could also probably talk me into United States historic sites or baseball. Hog Farm Talk 04:31, 21 September 2021 (UTC)
  23. The Rambling Man – review mostly anything, write mostly sport, especially association football and rowing. The Rambling Man (Keep wearing the mask...) 18:07, 28 October 2021 (UTC)
  24. Ceoil – Mostly art, archecture, archaeology, and music c. 1400-2021 AD. Ceoil (talk) 22:28, 29 October 2021 (UTC)
  25. Iazyges Ancient and medieval history, mostly related to Roman and Byzantine history, but happy to help with military or ancient history. Iazyges Consermonor Opus meum 00:20, 13 February 2023 (UTC)
  26. AirshipJungleman29 History is my default, but topics like sports are also within my range.
  27. Epicgenius - I specialize in architecture but am happy to help out with other subjects as well.
  28. SchroCat. A generalist with a short attention span and low boredom threshold
  29. UndercoverClassicist: Ancient world, archaeology and academic biographies, mostly.
  30. Fathoms Below - I focus on video games, especially indie video games.
  31. Noleander - Engineering, math, science, feminism, history ... but happy to help with any topic.
  32. Z1720 - Political/social history (not warfare), especially Canadian history. I can also help cut prose in non-technical articles. I will also consider co-noming.
  33. ErnestKrause

See also