We can help determine whether the topic is fringe and if so, whether it is treated accurately and impartially. Our purpose is not to remove any mention of fringe theories, but to describe them properly. Never present fringe theories as fact.
If you mention specific editors, you should notify them. You may use {{subst:ftn-notice}} to do so. Deploy {{talk fringe|the fringe theory name}} to articles' talkpages under discussion. Please also notify any relevant Wikiprojects to encourage an increased visibility for the discussion.
We are not a forum to discuss fringe theories as such. Our goal is to improve articles about them, create new ones if needed, and discuss sources that are either usable as citations or which help us to better understand them.
13 Nov 2026 –Action type approach(talk·edit·hist) was PRODed by IndrasBet (t·c): fails WP:GNG and WP:FRINGE even the article itself seems to mainly cover it lacking evidence
11 Nov 2026 –Mythotherapy(talk·edit·hist) was PRODed by IndrasBet (t·c): no independent, or sigcov as far as I can tell - sources are an etymology dictionary and unsourced claims, and searches find only practitioner blogs and marketing, so it fails WP:GNG and WP:FRINGE
Bloop has an iceberg-based explanation written out but also a coordinate that is incompatible with it. I am not sure if the coordinate is actually sourced, either. Probably needs a replacement or a rewrite. JoJo Eumerus mobile (main talk) 07:03, 25 October 2026 (UTC)
What does my first motorcycle have to do with this? It was a Suzuki B120, which inherited its "bloop" nickname from the B100P. Phil Bridger (talk) 14:17, 25 October 2026 (UTC)
The sources seem to say otherwise; do you have a source that says it's impossible? Slatersteven (talk) 14:30, 25 October 2026 (UTC)
What WP:RS says it is incompatible? — VPP (t/c) 15:41, 26 October 2026 (UTC)
+, essentially - 50 degrees south is far north of the Antarctic sea ice boundaries and notably, these sources do not discuss how or why an iceberg sound would originate this far north of the sea ice boundary. That said, the source for the coordinate does not actually seem to mention the coordinate in question? Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk) 17:09, 26 October 2026 (UTC)
Looks like NOAA itself puts it at those coordinates? I guess most of the sourcing derives from that. — VPP (t/c) 17:27, 26 October 2026 (UTC)
Do you have a source that says this lies "far north of the Antarctic sea ice boundaries". Slatersteven (talk) 17:33, 26 October 2026 (UTC)
See the maps and images above. And, come to think of it, this one. ^^So I guess that that citation needs to be swapped. JoJo Eumerus mobile (main talk) 08:24, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
That source does not say that. In fact Fig. 1 shows a lot of Icebergs north of 50. Slatersteven (talk) 09:25, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Only in the Atlantic or upwind of New Zealand, though, at 100W one has to go quite far south to get any icebergs (never mind sound-producing ones, I presume) - never mind that the new source says "between the Bransfield Strait and the Ross Sea" which is definitively not close. But OK, I guess we can just say that the old version of the source gave the coordinate and the new one an azimuth (the text currently doesn't reflect this change) and call it a day. Jo-Jo Eumerus (talk) 16:14, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
This has been tagged since December 2025. We need to either address whatever the issues are or remove the tag.
Puthoff is one of those cases where someone does some real science and then dives off the deep end into pseudoscience.
Similar cases, presented so we can compare how Wikipedia handles this sort of thing:
Louis Leakey: Prominent scientist. Some people (including archaeologist Mary Leakey) think that his later work on the Calico Early Man Site was somewhere in the range of pseudoscience to disputed science.
Linus Pauling: One of the greatest scientists of all time. His later claims that vitamin C prevent colds, treats cancer, and treats brain-injury in children were pure quackery.
Duane Gish: Prior to 1971 he authored or co-authored approximately 40 technical, peer-reviewed papers in reputable scientific journals within the field of biochemistry. Then he went all in as a creationist and never did any real science after that. So he was a real scientist, but not a particular notable one, and is super notable as a creationist.
Did not know that Leakey and Pauling went off the deep end in their later career. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 02:06, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
I think we split the career and early life from each other and merge and greatly reduce the size of the other sections into a section called "Fringe theories". I'll also note that this page has a few AI tells. Nothing drastic, but enough to raise my eyebrows here. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 02:11, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Actually scrap that, probably half of this page is AI. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 02:16, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
That certainly is one heck of an infobox image! -Guy Macon (talk) 02:43, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
There is almost definitely a better image available. Where to find it, I don't know. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 02:47, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Good luck. I spent an annoying amount of time tracking just that one down. — VPP (t/c) 12:50, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Actually scrap that, probably half of this page is AI.
It is half AI? What half? Most of the article appears unchanged since at least January 2000:
The parapsychology and pseudoscience section is filled with AI tells, and I have quite a few suspicions over the early life and career section as well. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 21:52, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Nevermind. Looking at the revisions again, nearly half of what I thought was AI has been here since 2000. The section headers are a problem though. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 21:54, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Spell out the exact text you are alleging is AI? — VPP (t/c) 21:54, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Right now, the exact text which I think is AI is "Early life and career" and "Parapsychology and pseudoscience". Those two alone are enough to set alarm bells off in my head but humans are notoriously unreliable at detecting AI so there's every chance I could be wrong. All of the other tells I originally suspected have been there since 2000. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 21:57, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Also, those two are pretty huge AI tells, especially the "early life and career" one, so I don't think I'm grasping at straws here. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 22:00, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
"Early life and career" is a common staple section name on Wikipedia articles. — VPP (t/c) 22:04, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
I've never seen it. Most of what I've seen is two separate sections called "early life" and "career". It appears I am wrong. I withdraw my statement. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 22:06, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
@Johnjbarton I apologise for the AI accusations. I should have been more thorough in background checking. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 22:16, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Sorry, are your entire AI tells... the section names...? — VPP (t/c) 22:01, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Yes. I'm being serious here. Not only is this an AI tell listed at signs of AI writing, but I've been conducting a bit of research into AI writing recently and it's come up a bit. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 22:05, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Harold E. Puthoff as an article doesn't even have one of those sections. Perhaps you should move on from these AI allegations. — VPP (t/c) 22:11, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
It is a general "x and y" format of section titles, but awards and recognition is the most common one. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 22:15, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Just FYI, User:Johnjbarton is apparently the main editor of Harold E. Puthoff, and is a very well respected editor on Wikipedia. I have notified the main author of the article, apparently post 2014 from edit stats, of the AI/LLM accusation on their talk page:
There may possibly be some AI-generated text in recent edits. If there is, it can be fixed. Dealing with the broader issues will likely resolve this anyway. AndyTheGrump (talk) 13:04, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
(I appreciate your kind words). Based on the edit history I rewrote the "Zero point energy" section in Feb 2024. The edits since that time include some small additions, corrections to citations, and formatting.
I don't see any evidence of AI involvement in these additions. I removed the AI tag pending evidence from @F0malhaut42
The undue tag was set by @LuckyLouie in Dec 2025 I can't see how three paragraphs amounts to undue weight given the complexity of the topic. Note that the fringe theories that Puthoff was involved in was parapsychology not ZPE. I'm sorry did not catch this at the time.
@Johnjbarton there's the first two section titles, the fact that source 8 is cited twice in the same sentence, the rule of three in the lead, Terence Hines's writing being introduced twice and in two separate ways. The fact that Zero-Point energy is a separate section to parapsychology and pseudoscience is also slightly interesting, although that one could be human error. But given the rest, I am fairly confident that this was AI assisted. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 21:39, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
ZPE ideas of Puthoff are also fringe claims. Right now the article is treating them much too kindly. jps (talk) 21:32, 29 October 2026 (UTC)
Shouldn't this discussion be on the Puthoff talk page and not here? Why is an article being discussed in-depth in "what to do with it?" way outside of its talk page? And no, Linus Pauling did not go off the deep end on his emphasis on humans should take over 1000mgs of Vitamin C daily (unless the deep end is where the good stuff is). Randy Kryn (talk) 13:18, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
@Guy Macon The Harold E. Puthoff was, in my opinion, mistagged, so it is easily fixed. I don't understand you overall post however. Verifiable facts presented in a neutral way about Puthoff, Leakey, Pauling, or Dish belong in the encyclopedia independent of our opinions on the character of those facts. Johnjbarton (talk) 16:17, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
No need to ping me. If I make a comment I see any replies on my watchlist.
I am well aware of Wikipedia's rules on sourcing, having edited Wikipedia for over twenty years. Yet there are still areas where editors have to make decisions. Consider scientist A, who publishes a few run of the mill papers before converting to pseudoscience and becoming on of the most prominent slingers of bullshit ever. Now consider Scientist B, who makes major discoveries and wins Nobel prizes, late in life comes to believe in a bit of pseudoscience, but is in no way famous for doing so. In both cases we present verifiable facts in a neutral way independent of our opinions, but we also apply WP:WEIGHT when deciding what to put in the first couple of sentences and what to put much farther down in the page. Look how far you have to go down the Ted Kaczynski page before you see any mention of his work in geometric function theory.
Just as the lead of the Ted Kaczynski page highlights the bombings, I think the Harold E. Puthoff page should highlight the claims of psychic powers, remote viewing, communication without electromagnetism, zero-point energy, UFOs, and alien technology. Right now it doesn't, and that violates WP:WEIGHT. --Guy Macon (talk) 16:53, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
The Puthoff introduction concisely summarizes the article. Nothing undue about it. It is almost exactly what you wrote minus the bits barely mentioned in the article. The article has one sentence about UFO/alien technology "Puthoff is a participant ...". Omitting this trivia from the intro is normal.
The article is fine, we should move on. Johnjbarton (talk) 17:04, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
The ZPE content needs addressing. Right now, up until the Pigliucci quote, the article misleadingly treats Puthoff's ideas as though they are/were thoughtfully considered claims within the physics community when that is not the case. jps (talk) 21:35, 29 October 2026 (UTC)
Note that this edit seems highly problematic to me. jps (talk) 21:38, 29 October 2026 (UTC)
I don't understand why this section keeps getting put back in. No one is paying attention to his ideas about (anti-)gravity which are, let's be honest, claims relating to his UFOlogy beliefs. jps (talk) 15:17, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
Was going to comment that "Polarizable vacuum" is a better search term and hey:
looks like has mostly gone unnoticed until Guy Macon just saw it. I mean, it looks like maybe a valid topic for history of science? But the only people is see calling it 'Polarizable vacuum' look pretty crankish. fiveby(zero) 15:55, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
I think this one should go the AfD route. I have a strong sneaking suspicion enough sources will shake out of the WP:GNG tree that anyone can simply (legitimately) brute force it trivially back in if just deconstructed like that. And if it passes WP:GNG, it's not our call wholly anyway. I'd say AfD if anyone thinks it's out. — VPP (t/c) 17:06, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
Would someone please make a template for use on articles so i can keep these people straight:
I'm confused. Why would anyone think Harold E. Puthoff is a congresscritter? --Guy Macon (talk) 18:20, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
Well, sure. But you have to go through the full checklist. Some people are members of both Congress and Team Space Ghost. fiveby(zero) 01:03, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
Puthoff was, in fact, part of NIDS. Feoffer2 (talk) 04:47, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
Thanks! I've added key people to the NIDS and AATIP infoboxes to help us start to untangle the gordian knot of overlapping names in these various groups. I can never keep it straight myself. Feoffer2 (talk) 13:48, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
Nice changes, but the article still reads as PROFRINGE. I don't have the time to rewrite the article right now but I'll do it in a few hours if nobody else has done it already. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե(Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 22:02, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
TA pushing the POV that the subject was actually guilty of the Satanic ritual abuse allegations against him, editorializing from primary news reports about the criminal allegations (e.g. editorializing about news coverage with However, reports confirmed when the sources do not); scholars (e.g. Mattias Gardell) quite unanimously agree that he was not and he was never charged. This is quite WP:PROFRINGE. My attempt to revert was reverted and I have tagged the section. Could use more eyes. PARAKANYAA (talk) 18:01, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
Representative of the second satanic mode is the Temple of Set, founded in 1975 by former LaVey confidant Michael Aquino and now led by mystery novelist Uncle Setnakt, or Don Webb.18 Born in 1946, political scientist Aquino is a Vietnam veteran and military intelligence officer who specializes in psychological warfare.19 This has earned him a special reputation among conspiracy believers. Cathy O’Brien identifies Aquino as a child-molesting mind-controller working for a satanic globalist conspiracy. In the late 1980s, a Salem witch hunt rerun hit the United States, with a “Satanic scare” spreading like wildfire. Hundreds of alleged “survivors” claimed to have been victims of bizarre sexual torture and to have witnessed satanic homicides and cannibalistic rituals, accusing hundreds of named individuals. Aquino was among the accused but was never charged, as the case against him could not be substantiated.PARAKANYAA (talk) 18:14, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
Is this part of the same recent concerted effort to shift the POV of "Recovered Memory Syndrome"? Simonm223 (talk) 18:19, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
@Simonm223 I'd call it part of the broader resurgence in people trying to revive old SRA allegations/rewrite history of it being actually true. The recovered memory thing is part of that. PARAKANYAA (talk) 18:22, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
I had a look and the TA's edits look like a WP:BLPCRIME vio - kind of within WP:ATTACK. The book about the black-painted room is mentioned further down in the context of him suing over it - that suit was settled out of court. I would suggest, in light of that, we shouldn't be saying "but like this journalist said he really did have a room with black paint." it's clearly trying to imply something. Simonm223 (talk) 18:31, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
@Simonm223 Hence what I argued. (though he isn't a BLP he died in 2019).
For further context Aquino did a BLPREQUESTDELETE in like 2007 while he was alive (he was probably too notable for this to work in the modern day but no one actually checked for good coverage) due to these same allegations and for years people were remaking the article under different titles.
After he died, someone remade it again, I tried to clean it up so it wouldn't get deleted for being poorly sourced slander for the 12th time - he is a very important studied figure in the scholarly study of these movements - and got it unsalted. But as he is one of the most targeted figures in the whole "satanic panic" mythos people try to POV push those allegations frequently. More eyes on this page besides me would be nice because I have to revert bad edits very frequently. PARAKANYAA (talk) 19:05, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
I am familiar with who he was. I just thought he was still kicking around. LOL Simonm223 (talk) 19:08, 3 November 2026 (UTC)
Readers of my contributions will find out how I stumbled on this, but I think this is an area which needs a bit of contextualization. The more I look into it, the more I think this is a scam similar to life coaching. The certifications for "thanatologist" are all closed-shop and the three hour exam the Association for Death Education and Counseling makes you sit for to get this (what seems to me to be) pointless certification is based on textbooks written by the board members and published by Cengage. The sample questions for the exam are pretty pedestrian.
Our article is very poorly written and seems to me to be basically putting on airs that this is a real academic discipline or, absurdly, some sort of legitimate interdiscipline area of study. Should we clean it up and are there good critical sources to be had for this? Or, worse, is this not really a thing? Is AfD or merge in order? Death studies anyone?
My undergrad university had a 2-year thanatology cert as a specialization basically of their BSW program. It looked basically like a social work specialty more than a unique discipline. Simonm223 (talk) 23:23, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
But it is NOT social work because you cannot get licensed in it. Social work is a well-regarded field of practice. Thanatology looks like it is a grift. Please explain how it isn't if you have any sources that can help.
I'm not saying your university was necessarily engaging in this certification grift, but... well... if my university was doing this I probably would be a pain in the provost's side until they explained how they weren't just doing the bidding of a closed-shop professional society that looks like a cargo cult for licensed therapeutic interventions and medical science. jps (talk) 23:27, 7 November 2026 (UTC)
So is this the study of the effects of death, which is clearly science, or is it a methodology or something for a specialized sort of care worker to help people with the process of death? Like a death doula? — VPP (t/c) 00:30, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
Most dictionary entries are "the scientific study of death and the practices associated with it, including the study of the needs of the terminally ill and their families" There is an effort to have a "multidisciplinary" and "holistic" field of study as seen in that paper i linked below, Handbook of Thanatology (2013) published by Association for Death Education and Counseling and Handbook of Death & Dying (2003), Clifton D. Bryant ed., Sage, that i've seen. This seems to encompass anything education, sociology, biology, anthropology, psychology, etc. that has anything to do with death and dying. The origin seems to be from bereavement counseling (or maybe those 1974 undertakers which i haven't found a good source for).
The term has been revitalized and given new definitions since it looks like the '60s, i like the original just "a study of death", not necessarily the study nor even a scientific one. fiveby(zero) 03:51, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
It seems pretty clear to me it is not the scientific study of the effects of "death" sui generis. Otherwise, the ADEC would be funding scientists who study senescence, semelparity, and epidemiology. jps (talk) 05:31, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
That would, by the way, be a good band name. — VPP (t/c) 00:31, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
Huh, I had no idea: Death doula. — VPP (t/c) 00:33, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
You saw:
Élie Metchnikoff Metchnikoff, Élie (1903). Etudes sur la nature humaine[The nature of man: Studies in optimistic philosophy]. I think it extremely probable that the scientific study of old age and of death, two branches of science that may be called gerontology and thanatology, will bring about great modifications in the course of the last period of life.
thanatologyetymonline By 1889 as "a doctrine of or a discourse on death." Related: Thanatological. In 1970s, some undertakers made a bid to be called thanatologists; but from 1974 that word has been used principally in reference to specialists in the needs of the terminally ill. There also is an isolated use of it from 1901.
OED is down right now thru TWL, but looks like there might be more etymology there. Originally meaning a treatise on death, a proposed field of forensic medicine early 20th, within psychiatry 1970, undertakers 1974, and now "the idea of death studies (also known as thanatology)" I think possibly a disambiguation page could be left over after the merge to death studies? fiveby(zero) 01:01, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
Oh, i thought there was actually a "death studies" article, but it's a redirect to a journal? Here's thanatology as near-death studies
In 1976, the New York Times reported on the burgeoning scientific interest in “life after death” and the “emerging field of thanatology”. The following year, Moody and several fellow thanatologists founded an organisation that became the International Association for Near-Death Studies. In 1981, they printed the inaugural issue of Vital Signs, a magazine for the general reader that was largely devoted to stories of near-death experiences. The following year they began producing the field’s first peer-reviewed journal, which became the Journal of Near-Death Studies. The field was growing, and taking on the trappings of scientific respectability. Reviewing its rise in 1988, the British Journal of Psychiatry captured the field’s animating spirit: “A grand hope has been expressed that, through NDE research, new insights can be gained into the ageless mystery of human mortality and its ultimate significance, and that, for the first time, empirical perspectives on the nature of death may be achieved.”
Yeah, this doesn't look good. ADEC, the most on the up-and-up of the groups who self-identify as thanatology-connected at least maintains itself as a 501(c)3 even as it seems to me its certification schema is pretty thin. They seem to be attempting to monopolize the certification game by federally registering a trademark for their certification. Not a great look for a group trying to look less like a credentials-buying outfit. jps (talk) 09:11, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
The profession would be social work wouldn't it? With degree programs, licensure and training in Hospice, Palliative care, and Geriatrics? Looking for scoping reviews from these areas which mention 'thanatology'. fiveby(zero) 13:14, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
DeVeny Incorvala, Aubrey (2024). "Death Positivity in America: The Movement—Its History and Literature". OMEGA – Journal of Death and Dying. 89 (3). The 1960s ushered in a new academic discipline of "thanatology" in which journals were created, as were new university courses and organizations that focused exclusively on death studies.Full access available to users of The Wikipedia Library.
Doka, K. J.; Heflin-Wells, E. N.; Martin, T. L.; Redmond, L. M.; Schachter, S. R. (2011). "The Organization of Thanatology". OMEGA - Journal of Death and Dying. 63 (2). Full access available to users of The Wikipedia Library. can't get to the full text of this yet as Sage is being slow, but abstract looks promising
There needs to be some kind of parent article here to contextualize Thanatology and other articles such as these organizations, death doula, Death Cafe, and maybe more. I don't know what to call it tho, "Death and Dying in America", "Death culture in the U.S.", "Death movements"
What i see is very U.S. centric, and don't know how international the movements are
the movements are in opposition to approach taken by medical practitioners: Movement proponents aim to modify society’s “conventional” death framework, which is characterized as medicalized, institutionalized, impersonal, and lacking psychosocial emotional preparation and engagement.
there's obviously a similar trend in medicine, but how much credit can these organized movements claim for that?
seems pretentious in claiming Metchnikoff and things like hospice care and some of the scholarship
don't like calling things fringe, but WP:FRIND should definitely apply. The best sources should be independent of those claiming to be part of an organized movement
thanatology could live as a section of a parent article or on its own
still kind of like a disambiguation page at thanatology, like the history of things and you people are infected by presentism
Can start putting together a bibliography, but don't know where to put it.fiveby(zero) 16:06, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm wondering if the US centricity is the reason for the difference we're seeing between thanatology as something associated with social work (my prevarication is because the program my Alma mater offered was also open to people who wanted to study to be funeral home directors and the school-associated seminary) with some of these more pseudoscientific examples. Are we perhaps really discussing thanatologies? Simonm223 (talk) 16:14, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
I think so, but not all the other thanatologies are pseudoscientific, for instance Élie Metchnikoff who may have been the first to propose an field rather than just "a study of" isn't. Been browsing Oxford Bibliographies to see which topics refer to our "emerging scientific field" with mixed results. Isis Current Bibliography has three mentions, German and Russian, neither connected to the U.S. thanatology. Looking for Szabo, John F. Death and Dying: An Annotated Bibliography of the Thanatological Literature from the OB"Grief and Comparative Literature". fiveby(zero) 17:06, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
~2,200 works The greatest volume of material is on grief, mourning, bereavement, and loss, a "Thanatolgy" section with 27 works. Of those 27 all look U.S., offhand two look pseudoscientific (Roswell Park, Parapsychology and Thanatology), 1919-2010, primarily bereavement i think, and don't see any that i know are associated with the Death awareness movement. Possible FRINGEish sections: "Eschatology", "Immortality", "Near-Death Experiences", "Philosophical Studies", "Rituals". fiveby(zero) 17:35, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
Has been massively changed by an IP. Can people interested in panspermia look at it? --Hob Gadling (talk) 16:42, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I see three IPs, but they act the same, so probably one editor.
Do the edits look like AI to anyone? I figure that it's either AI or someone who has edited Wikipedia before.
Removed "This article may present fringe theories" notice from the top.
Removed "Wickramasinghe has advanced numerous fringe claims, including the argument that various outbreaks of illnesses on Earth are of extraterrestrial origins, including the 1918 flu pandemic and certain outbreaks of polio and mad cow disease."
Removed "Cephalopod alien origin" section.
Completely changed what the "Participation in the creation-evolution debate" section says, based on a primary source (McLean v. Arkansas Bd. of Ed., 529 F. Supp. 1255 E.D. Ark. 1982)
I am inclined to revert the whole thing. Does anyone disagree? --Guy Macon (talk) 02:25, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Not me. I also note that Shildt's Journal of Cosmology should never be used as a reliable source for, well, anything. JoJo Anthrax (talk) 03:20, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Done. --Guy Macon (talk) 03:30, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Mary Magdalene de' Pazzi
New user claiming that the Wikipedia article for mystic Mary Magdalene de' Pazzi is biased as it documents her mortification and sadomasochistic activities. . User identifies as a Catholic and said the article is "propaganda" and is resorting to personal attacks calling me a "leftist". I do not believe we should remove the sourced content documenting her odd activities. Carrot juice (talk) 00:27, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
We are documenting her "odd activities" the wrong way. The article should describe the behavior from a WP:NPOV based upon reliable sources such as historians. It should not offer up any medical diagnosis from someone over 400 years in the future. The fact that the diagnosis' for the most part are sourced to popular authors and not to scientists, historians, or medical professionals just makes it worse.
In my opinion, judging the 16th century version of Mortification of the flesh by 21st century standards is a fringe view. --Guy Macon (talk) 02:58, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I agree with removing non-academic sources but these two sources in my opinion were reliable . In regard to psychiatrists offering medical opinions for historical individuals, this is widespread on Wikipedia and is used on many articles related to Catholic mystics or saints etc. Many of these women suffered from eating disorders and neurological issues. Diagnosis was not available in there time but later professional opinion is valid and not a fringe view based on accounts and eyewitness reports. Psychiatrist Kathryn J. Zerbe for example suggesting in her opinion Pazzi was a sufferer of Anorexia mirabilis after reading historic reports of her starving herself is hardly a fringe view. Carrot juice (talk) 15:37, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I can see a section -- with attribution -- about a psychiatrist saying that a historical figure shares similarities to someone with a modern medical diagnosis. Asserting that the historical figure suffered from a particular medical condition -- attributed or not -- should not be allowed. The same principle applies to any other MD who diagnoses someone without examining them, as has happened multiple times with the last two US presidents. --Guy Macon (talk) 16:18, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
If you look at the diff I provided it was actually Anorexia mirabilis. This is an eating disorder largely affecting Catholic nuns during the Middle Ages. There is nothing controversial or "fringe" about a historian or psychiatrist suggesting Mary Magdalene de' Pazzi had this. Many books have been written on the topic by historians and psychiatrists. Have you read the Anorexia mirabilis Wikipedia article? So by your criteria we should be removing loads of references from that article like for Catherine of Siena or for Wilgefortis of Portugal as well? I do not think you have thought what you are saying through.
"Asserting that the historical figure suffered from a particular medical condition -- attributed or not -- should not be allowed", as said this isn't in Wikipedia policy anywhere. If you honestly believe this and you want to be consistent then go to Crucifixion#Cause_of_death and remove almost every source there because countless medical conditions have been suggested for Jesus and his Crucifixion and obviously none of those authors examined him. Carrot juice (talk) 17:57, 15 November 2026 (UTC)