Wikipedia:Good article reassessment

Good article reassessment
Good article reassessment

Good article reassessment (GAR) is a process used to review and improve good articles (GAs) that may no longer meet the good article criteria and if necessary, delist them. All users are welcome to contribute to the process, regardless of whether they were involved with the initial nomination. Editors should prioritize bringing an article up to standard above delisting. Reassessments are listed for discussion below and are concluded according to consensus.

GAs are held to the current standards regardless of when they were promoted. Good article reassessment is not a peer review process; for that use peer review. Content disputes on GAs should be resolved through normal dispute resolution processes. Good article reassessment only assesses whether the article meets the good article criteria. Many common problems (including the presence of dead URLs, inconsistently formatted citations, and compliance with all aspects of the Manual of Style) are not covered by the criteria and therefore are not grounds for delisting. Instability in itself is not a reason to delist an article. Potential candidates for reassessment may be found on the cleanup listing. Delisted good articles may be renominated as good articles if editors believe they have resolved the issues that led to the delisting.

Good article reassessment
Good article reassessment
Good article reassessment instructions

Before opening a reassessment

  1. Consider whether the article meets the good article criteria.
  2. Check that the article is stable. Requesting reassessment during a content dispute or edit war is usually inappropriate.
  3. Consider raising issues at the talk page of the article or requesting assistance from major contributors.
  4. If there are many similar articles already nominated at GAR, consider delaying the reassessment request. If an editor notices that many similar GARs are open and requests a hold, such requests should generally be granted.

Opening a reassessment

  1. To open a good article reassessment, use the one-click GAR-helper script on the article. Detail your reasons for reassessing the article and submit. Your rationale must specify how you believe the article does not meet the good article criteria. GARs whose rationale does not include the criteria may be speedily closed.
  2. The user script does not notify major contributors or relevant WikiProjects. Notify these manually. You may use {{subst:GARMessage|ArticleName|page=n}} ~~~~ to do so, replacing ArticleName with the name of the article and n with the number of the reassessment page (1 if this is the first reassessment).
  3. Consider commenting on another reassessment (or several) to help with any backlog.
Manual opening steps
  1. Paste {{subst:GAR}} to the top of the article talk page. Do not place it inside another template. Save the page.
  2. Follow the bold link in the template to create a reassessment page.
  3. Detail your reasons for reassessing the article and save the page. Your rationale must specify how you believe the article does not meet the good article criteria. GARs whose rationale does not include the criteria may be speedily closed.
  4. The page will automatically be transcluded to this page via a bot, so there is no need to add it here manually.
  5. Transclude the assessment on the article talk page as follows: Edit the article talk page and paste {{Wikipedia:Good article reassessment/''ArticleName''/''n''}} at the bottom of the page. Replace ArticleName with the name of the article and n with the subpage number of the reassessment page you just created. This will display a new section named "GA Reassessment" followed by the individual reassessment discussion.
  6. Notify major contributing editors, including the nominator and the reviewer. Also consider notifying relevant active WikiProjects related to the article. The {{GARMessage}} template may be used for notifications by placing {{subst:GARMessage|ArticleName|GARpage=n}} ~~~~ on user talk pages. Replace ArticleName with the name of the article and n with the subpage number of the reassessment page you just created.

Reassessment process

  1. Editors should discuss the article's issues with reference to the good article criteria, and work cooperatively to resolve them. Comments should focus on the article's contents and adherence to the criteria.
  2. The priority should be to improve articles and retain them as GAs rather than to delist them, wherever reasonably possible.
  3. Interested editors can indicate their intention to fix the article and give updates on their progress in the GAR. Commentators should periodically check the GAR and give additional comments when necessary. Wikipedia is not compulsory and editors should not insist that commentators, interested editors, or past GAN nominators make the suggested changes, nor should they state that edits should have been completed before the GAR was opened.
  4. If discussion has stalled and there is no obvious consensus, uninvolved editors are strongly encouraged to add a new comment rather than closing the discussion.
  5. If discussion becomes contentious, participants may request the assistance of GAR coordinators at the GAN discussion page. The coordinators may attempt to steer the discussion towards resolution or make a decisive close.

Closing a reassessment

To close a discussion, use the one-click GANReviewTool script on the reassessment page of the article and explain the outcome of the discussion (whether there was consensus and what action was taken).

  1. GARs typically remain open for at least two weeks (14 days).
  2. Anyone may close a GAR, although discussions which have become controversial should be left for closure by experienced users or GAR coordinators.
  3. If a clear consensus develops among participants that the issues have been resolved and the article meets good article criteria, the reassessment may be closed as keep.
    • If there is no consensus, the reassessment may also be closed as keep.
    • If the article has been kept, consider awarding the Good Article Rescue Barnstar to the editor(s) who contributed significantly to bringing it up to standard.
  4. After at least two weeks (14 days), if the article's issues are unresolved, and editors have clearly ceased making good-faith improvements to the article, and there are no objections to delisting, the discussion may be closed as delist.
Manual closing steps
  1. Locate {{GAR/current}} at the the reassessment page of the article. Replace it with {{subst:GAR/result|result=outcome}} ~~~~. Replace outcome with the outcome of the discussion (whether there was consensus and what action was taken) and explain how the consensus and action was determined from the comments. A bot will remove the assessment from the GA reassessment page.
  2. The article either meets or does not meet the good article criteria:
    • If the article now meets the criteria, you can keep the article listed as GA. To do this:
      • remove the {{GAR/link}} template from the article talk page
      • remove the {{GAR request}} template from the article talk page, if present
      • add or update the {{Article history}} template on the article talk page (example)
    • If the article still does not meet the criteria, you can delist it. To do this,
      • remove the {{GAR/link}} template from the article talk page
      • remove the {{GAR request}} template from the article talk page, if present
      • add or update the {{Article history}} template on the article talk page, setting currentstatus to DGA (delisted good article). (example)
      • blank the class parameter of the WikiProject templates on talk, or replace it with a new assessment
      • remove the {{good article}} template from the article page (example)
      • remove the article from the relevant list at good articles (example)
  3. Add the GAR to the most recent GAR archive page. (example)

Disputing a reassessment

  1. A GAR closure should only be contested if the closure was obviously against consensus or otherwise procedurally incorrect. A closure should only be disputed within the first seven days following the close.
  2. Before disputing a GAR closure, first discuss your concerns with the closing editor on their talk page.
  3. If discussing does not resolve concerns, editors may post at the GAN discussion page and ask for review from uninvolved editors and the GAR coordinators.

GAR Coordinators

The GAR Coordinators—Lee Vilenski, Chipmunkdavis, and Trainsandotherthings—work to organize GAR efforts, as well as to resolve contentious reviews. To quickly bring issues to their notice, or make a query, use the {{@GAR}} notification template, or make a comment on the GAN discussion page.

Articles needing possible reassessment

Good article reassessment

Talk notices given
  1. The Chariot (band) 2025-02-12
  2. Dragon Quest 2025-03-13
  3. 18th Military Police Brigade (United States) 2025-05-01
Find more: 2023 GA Sweeps Project

The good articles listed below have been flagged for the attention of reviewers for reassessment. If reassessment is appropriate, please open a reassessment and remove the {{GAR request}} template from the article talk page. For cases where no reassessment is needed, remove the template from the article talk page.

The intention is to keep the above list empty most of the time. If an article is currently a featured article candidate, please do not open a reassessment until the FAC has been closed.

Articles listed for reassessment

Siege of Svetigrad

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

There are several "citation needed" tags in the article, including entire sub-sections. The article has a verifiability issue. StephenMacky1 (talk) 20:01, 16 November 2026 (UTC)


Apple Music Live: Mayhem Requiem

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Requesting reassessment because of concerns about likely AI-generated content and inaccurate sourcing. During an earlier spot-check of the article, I encountered passages that had no basis in the cited sources. For example, I removed a claim that the performance of "Disease" "emphasized the concert's darker tone", as nothing of the sort appeared in the cited reference (see my edit and edit summary).

Since then, the article's main contributor CHr0m4tiko0 (approximately 65% of the article's current text is attributed to them according to XTools' authorship analysis), admitted at ANI to using ChatGPT and Gemini for their Wikipedia edits. They also admitted that they had not always checked the added text against the sources and that inaccuracies "may have" entered their contributions. I think a thorough source-to-text review is warranted, and in it's current stage, it should not be a good article. Sricsi (talk) 18:53, 15 November 2026 (UTC)


Cry Baby (Melanie Martinez album)

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Per Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive1234#Consistent fake assumption of using AI without providing valid reasons. RedShellMomentumtalk that talk to me 00:46, 15 November 2026 (UTC)


The Glorification of Sadness

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Per Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard/IncidentArchive1234#Consistent fake assumption of using AI without providing valid reasons. RedShellMomentumtalk that talk to me 00:44, 15 November 2026 (UTC)


House of Lancaster

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

The article's GAN was passed over twelve years ago, but even a brief review suggests that it fails to meet several GA criteria, for the following reasons:

  • In the first section alone, I have found several unverified claims () and at least one highly questionable statement (). Consequently, the article needs a thorough source review for retaining its GA status. Unfortunately, I do not have access to most of the works cited.
  • Near the beginning of the article, I have also found an instance of close paraphrasing (). As the original nominator was later indefinitely blocked following a long history of plagiarism (), the article should be carefully checked for further instances of plagiarism or close paraphrasing before its GA status can be confirmed.
  • The article relies heavily on individual Oxford Dictionary of National Biography (ODNB) entries about members of the two Houses of Lancaster. Although these are reliable sources, using them to build a general account of the two houses raises concerns about original synthesis: our policy states that "Wikipedia articles usually rely on material from reliable secondary sources", recognising only that tertiary sources "can help provide broad summaries of topics that involve many primary and secondary sources and may help evaluate due weight". For example, Alison Weir discusses members of the first House of Lancaster and John of Gaunt, the founder of the second house, among the Plantagenets, and only lists the Lancastrian kings as members of the House of Lancaster. Why does the article's scope differ from her presentation of the House?
  • The article does not cite any academic study specifically about the House(s) of Lancaster. This raises questions about its scope. In particular, what is the scholarly basis for covering the two houses in a single article? Borsoka (talk) 04:27, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
    it was also nom'd by someone now blocked for socking fwiw, Norfolkbigfish (talk · contribs) Kowal2701 (talk, contribs) 13:23, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

Interstate 59 in Alabama

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

While this article is well-researched, it's still has some major issues that should have been addressed during the GA review. First of all, it's still missing some history, such as when sections opened. There is also no mention of the roughly 20-year widening project between Tuscaloosa and I-459. There are also issues with grammar, clutter, excess detail in some places, and flow. For example, I'm not sure we need to mention the cost of individual sections unless they were unusual. I wouldn't quickfail this if it were a GA nomination, but I would still push to address these issues before passing. I'm going to try to fix these issues before delisting, but I'd prefer additional opinions. Bneu2013 (talk) 16:44, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

My Newspapers.com subscription expired in October of last year and I forgot to renew. I'll see if I can find reports of that 20-year project from other sources. In the meantime I'll fix grammar issues and do some copyediting. NoobThreePointOh (talk) 16:53, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm currently researching this myself, and have already clipped some articles. I'll see what else I can find. I've also found two Tuscaloosa News articles that are still live. Bneu2013 (talk) 17:33, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I wasn't aware of the widening project when I did the review and thought that the prose was just fine at the time (maybe not to FA level but still good). I also am not sure what is "excess detail" with regards to highway articles since this is otherwise a pretty short article. I didn't really notice "clutter" either though that could have been a consequence of how wide my screen is. -- Reconrabbit (talk) 17:03, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I'm not so sure about the "clutter" part as the page seems to read just fine on the mobile version of the site, including my phone and tablet. Maybe it has something to do with the site scrolling too far to the right on the desktop site, which I can fix. NoobThreePointOh (talk) 17:11, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
This primarily relates to grammatical issues and image spacing. I don't know of any issues on the mobile version. However, it still needs a good copyedit for grammatical issues. An example of this is The first section of I-59 became under construction in 1959. There are also some confusing and ambiguous sentences. For example: On June 7, 1970, a segment of I-59 in Birmingham received grading, draining, paving, and new bridges, while a segment of it in Tuscaloosa between the US 82 bypass and Bessemer also went into effect. What does "received grading" mean? Was a contract awarded? It most certainly wasn't all done in a single day. What does "went into effect" mean here?
With regards to excess detail, I'm not sure we really need to mention the costs of each section, unless the costs were unusually high or low or went significantly over budget; this seems to be the standard followed for most highway GAs and FAs. However, I'm kind of neutral here, and I am not going to push for removal, but I'd like to get other road editor opinions on this. There are also some other examples of minor excess detail. For example: first stages of construction on the roadbed for four lanes. This isn't really necessary, since all Interstates are a minimum of four lanes. I would only mention unusual lane configurations; for example, Interstate 40 in Tennessee (an FA) mentions a rural section that was initially constructed with six lanes, which was unusual at the time. Bneu2013 (talk) 17:46, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
I have cut out all of the contractor names and some of the prices as they're unnecessary and don't add anything to the article other than just being there. However, I believe that the Assistant Division Engineer Randolph Rowe announced that the project, which was estimated to cost over $5 million part can be left in as he stated it was the largest contract to date in Jefferson County, so there is some significance in it. If you want me to remove the other prices (there are still some in the article other than this one that I pasted above), I can do that. Newspapers.com also states this in my clipping for the US 82 bypass segment back in 1970: miscellaneous items to complete Interstate 59 between the US 82 bypass at Tuscaloosa to near Bessemer, which I'm not sure how to word properly in that sentence I wrote for the article. NoobThreePointOh (talk) 18:13, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Okay, update on the US 82 part: I've reworded it to while work continued on completing I-59 between the US 82 bypass in Tuscaloosa and near Bessemer, which sounds much better and more natural. NoobThreePointOh (talk) 18:23, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Keep the Rowe part. Other articles will likely reveal the specifics of the latter. Bneu2013 (talk) 20:28, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

There are also some potential factual accuracy issues that need to be addressed. For instance, the article states that in 1967 Despite having the fewest completed miles among Alabama's Interstate highways at the time, I-59 was projected to be completed by 1971. The preceding sentence says this segment was 94 miles long. I-10 is only 66 miles long in Alabama, and I-85 is 80 miles. These roads also weren't complete at this time. All auxiliary Interstate Highways in Alabama, some of which had been approved by this time, are also shorter than this. I also fixed an error that erroneously claimed that I-59 was planned to continue to Nashville from Birmingham. This could imply that I-65 was planned to be numbered I-59, but I haven't found any evidence of this. In 1939, a freeway that roughly follow's I-59's present alignment was planned in the Toll Roads and Free Roads plan to run between roughly Meridian, MS, and Birmingham, which was reaffirmed in the 1944 Interregional Highways plan. The 1947 report is the first plan that shows a freeway in the present-day footprint of I-59 through all of Alabama. Bneu2013 (talk) 21:06, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

Yup. I ended up fixing that 1967 sentence, which I did not read the clipping I made properly. It was the segment between Meridian and Birmingham that had the fewest completed miles of the Interstate overall. I removed that because it felt like it would contradict I-59 being the longest completed highway at the time. NoobThreePointOh (talk) 21:24, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
This was likely the longest continuous completed segment in Alabama at the time, although the segment of I-65 between Mobile and Montgomery may have been longer. On a related note, the Birmingham to Georgia leg of I-59 may have been the first major Interstate Highway leg in Alabama to be finished. Bneu2013 (talk) 00:22, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
@Bneu2013, unfortunately I did not get the time to add any more info to the article due to classes and work, so I guess the GA status may have to be removed from the article. Apologies for the late notice, and I'll try again when I have fixed everything in the near future, so thank you for the reassessment. I'll let you know when the info has been added, which will happen sometime next month. NoobThreePointOh (talk) 16:42, 19 November 2026 (UTC)
I'll see if I can add some stuff before closing. Hopefully we can still save it. Bneu2013 (talk) 20:37, 19 November 2026 (UTC)

The Dead Dance

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Requesting a reassessment because of concerns about likely AI-generated content and inaccurate sourcing. IMO, the Music video section, particularly its Reception subsection, contains passages that appear to be AI-written. CHr0m4tiko0, the main contributor to the article, admitted at ANI to using ChatGPT and Gemini, adding that inaccuracies "may have" entered their contributions. Sricsi (talk) 12:02, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

ErnestKrause

Hi Sricsi and The Bushranger; Responding to ping for reassessment of article as original GAN reviewer. The nominator has recently been blocked by The Bushranger for AI-related flags raised by other editors concerning his conduct issues. From the review earlier this year, as I recall it, I put the nominator through 2 rounds of Q&A, and I was not aware that anything looked like it was AI-tainted. My own concern was that the Tim Burton material and contributions be given full credit in the article which appeared to be the case, with no tainted AI edits as far as I could see. Possibly the nominator switched to AI usage after this GAN went through early this year, since I was not seeing tainted AI edits in the version which I reviewed. Its been over half a year ago, and I'll offer to do update and clean-up edits to the article if that's useful, though my sense is that the article itself when originally submitted, was not AI-tainted. The article also has over 200 cites which seems to show due diligence taken by the original editors when it was submitted originally to GAN. This article was submitted for reassessment at the same time along with 3-4 other Wikipedia articles done by the blocked editor, though I'm inclining to think that this one is ok; I'm not able to comment on his other 3-4 articles with which I don't remember be involved with. Let me know if there is more to be done for this article. ErnestKrause (talk) 12:58, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

Thanks for your response, ErnestKrause. However, I still have concerns about the article, particularly the music video's Reception subsection. To me, the text looks visibly AI-generated, with variations of the word "highlight" appearing six times within just a few paragraphs. This kind of repetitive, formulaic wording is very common in AI-generated text.
More importantly, CHr0m4tiko0 admitted at ANI that, because of difficulties with English, they relied on AI tools such as ChatGPT and Gemini, sometimes also asking ChatGPT to rephrase sentences. They also acknowledged that they had not always checked the resulting text against the original sources. Sricsi (talk) 13:16, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
Hi Another Believer; The article which you've previously edited has been submitted for reassessment; I've made some updates to the lede and some copy edits to the Music video reception section. Does it look better or can you make some further improvements? ErnestKrause (talk) 01:39, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
As much I would like to see GA status kept here, I am working on other article projects and have stepped back from editing Gaga-related entries for a while. --Another Believer (Talk) 01:42, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I think the concerns are not only about the wording itself. The repetitive phrasing that I pointed out is just one visible example. CHr0m4tiko0 said they relied on AI because of difficulties with English. I believe their ≈125 edits in this article should be checked against the cited sources, not just copyedited. CHr0m4tiko0 acknowledged that they had not always checked the resulting text against the sources while using Chatgpt/Gemini. @MarioSoulTruthFan: may be able to comment, since similar issues were found in "Die with a Smile", where some passages did not accurately reflect the cited sources. @Gnomingstuff: encountered several instances of AI use in articles edited by CHr0m4tiko0.
One thing that can be helpful in the cleanup is the Who Wrote That? tool, which can highlight which passages CHr0m4tiko0 contributed. Sricsi (talk) 07:39, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I will give my two cents from my experience. So I had to check every source regarding claims he made since some were just created by LLM, mainly when stuff got a bit more complicated to understand. Simple sentences such as "The song was nominated at X awards", straight to the point no problems at all. MarioSoulTruthFan (talk) 20:29, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
That sounds like you did a successful crosscheck of every source, and that the direct factual statements made in the article have been verified. ErnestKrause (talk) 22:37, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Zombieboy

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Requesting a reassessment because of concerns about most likely AI-generated content and inaccurate sourcing. In the article's talk page discussion, St0407 identified entirely nonexistent song lyrics accompanied by apparently AI-generated analysis. CHr0m4tiko0, the article's principal contributor, later admitted at ANI to using ChatGPT and Gemini, acknowledging that inaccuracies "may have" entered their contributions. Sricsi (talk) Sricsi (talk) 11:56, 12 November 2026 (UTC)


Cambodian Civil War

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • GAN review not found
Result pending

A concerning number of citation needed tags. Have raised it on the talk page but no one has commented. ZKang123 (talk · contribs) 04:23, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

  • Delist. Lots of unsourced sentences. Provisionally (talk) 15:49, 12 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Comment While perhaps not enough to delist on its own, this has a bloated infobox that tries to capture too much detail and nuance and (per MOS:INFOBOXPURPOSE) fails to achieve its purpose. Cinderella157 (talk) 01:43, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Delist if no one comes forward in the allowed time to provide the missing citations. I checked quite a few of the contributors to this article and almost all are no longer active, probably accounting at least in part for the lack of talk page comment. While I would not be surprised if no one tries to fix the problems within the usual time period, or even states that they will try and in fact works on it within that time, I would not favor a delisting before that time has run. Donner60 (talk) 08:50, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Nikola Tesla

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

The article has a whopping 43 instances of [citation needed] tags being used in lieu of adequate sourcing. § Consulting on Niagara has 6 [citation needed]'s and only one citation. According to WP:GAFAIL, having "large numbers" of such tags would immediately put an article being a GA out of the question.

There are, in addition, two [page needed] tags, totalling 45 tags which, according to WP:GAFAIL, en masse, would disallow the article from being accepted into GA-class.


Flag of Gdańsk

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Article cites WP:FOTW sources. Additionally, I cannot find a way to access the first (currently dead) source that mentions the flag in anyway. On the internet archive, it shows the front page for "Akademia Rzygacy" but no flag subpage. Going to the archive of the site from when this GA passed, it redirects to a 404 page on a seemingly unrelated site Froglord (Finnfrog99) (talk) 19:37, 10 November 2026 (UTC)


Flag of Barbados

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

7 of the citations are WP:FOTW, 10 are flagmakers (a flag shop), and 5 are barbadospocketguide, which is owned by a hotel company Froglord (Finnfrog99) (talk) 19:27, 10 November 2026 (UTC)


Abracadabra (Lady Gaga song)

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Requesting another reassessment because of concerns about most likely AI-generated content and inaccurate sourcing. In the article's talk page discussion, Gnomingstuff encountered several instances of unsupported claims and problematic paraphrasing through a spot-check of the sources. CHr0m4tiko0 explicitly denied using AI in the article, but later admitted at ANI to using ChatGPT and Gemini, acknowledging that inaccuracies "may have" entered their contributions.

Furthermore, the article was promoted to GA status following a review by Camilasdandelions, who was later indefinitely blocked from mainspace over concerns involving AI-generated content and copyright violations. As I previously wrote at Wikipedia:Administrators' noticeboard#Concerns about Good Article reviews conducted by Camilasdandelions, this also raises questions about the reliability of the original GA review.

I think a thorough source-to-text review is warranted and that the article, in its current state, should be delisted as a good article. Sricsi (talk) 08:29, 8 November 2026 (UTC)

Delist. Provisionally (talk) 04:10, 12 November 2026 (UTC)

Mayhem (Lady Gaga album)

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Requesting a reassessment because of concerns about most likely AI-generated content and inaccurate sourcing. At Wikipedia:AI noticeboard/CHr0m4tiko0, Gnomingstuff identified nonexistent quotation in this article. CHr0m4tiko0 later admitted at ANI to using ChatGPT and Gemini for his contributions on Wikipedia. I think a thorough source-to-text review is warranted to determine whether the article actually meets the GA criteria. In its current state, I believe it definitely does not. Sricsi (talk) 08:13, 8 November 2026 (UTC)


Owodo

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Per Wikipedia:AI noticeboard/Vanderwaalforces, this article appears to have been LLM-generated and as such, should not retain its GA status. Bgsu98 (Talk) 15:13, 5 November 2026 (UTC)

Given the outcome of the discussion, obviously yes this should not retain GA status. Catjacket (talk) 16:19, 5 November 2026 (UTC)

Samuel Conway

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

This article passed GA back in April 2009 over 17 years ago, but I don’t think this article would pass GA review today. The sourcing (2b) and coverage (3a) are particularly bad. For example, the Media Dealings section has nothing about Fursonas, the 2016 documentary that focused on how he dealt with the press. Sourcing is also often incorrect, and the page has had an excessive primary sources tag since April 2025. I believe this article should be demoted from GA status. Provisionally (talk) 04:19, 5 November 2026 (UTC)


National Sporting Club

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Per this thread, this GA is suspected of having been generated by a LLM. Bgsu98 (Talk) 20:07, 21 August 2026 (UTC)

@Bgsu98: I've re-written the article section by section and rechecked all sources and citations. I've also asked at the AI noticeboard where to get an independent cleanup review. I'm sorry for the extra work I've caused other editors
I suggest delisting it unless an editor is willing to keep this reassessment open and review the revised article once the AI concerns have been resolved and the tag removed. If it's delisted, I'll nominate it again at a later date, once the article has been cleared. Metalicat (talk) 16:58, 31 October 2026 (UTC)

Bonded by Blood (band)

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Issues involving well-writtenness (awkwardly worded sentences, puffery) and questionable sources (WP:ALLMUSIC's artist bio, WP:DOTDASHMEREDITH, some sources I believe to be self-published)

Note: This became a GA in 2010 and seems to have improved little since then Goobab (talk) 14:03, 31 October 2026 (UTC)


Milan Heimerl

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Per this thread, this GA review is suspected of having been entirely generated by a LLM. Unless an editor undertakes a proper GA review of this article, this article should be delisted. Note: I am in no way impugning the quality of this article. Bgsu98 (Talk) 20:10, 21 August 2026 (UTC)

@Tomobe03: ? Vacant0 (talk • contribs) 15:51, 29 October 2026 (UTC)
So far, I have seen no remarks regarding GA criteria (non-)compliance. I'd be happy to address them if any are brought up. Tomobe03 (talk) 16:59, 29 October 2026 (UTC)
To clarify: I believe all articles I submit as GANs, including this one, meet GA criteria. Whenever a defect is pointed out I'd try to address it, but as things stand right now, I believe it is up to a reviewer to reassess compliance and point out defects if any. Tomobe03 (talk) 17:13, 29 October 2026 (UTC)

FutureSex/LoveSounds

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • GAN review not found
Result pending

As much as I don't want to do this, I have to. The problem with this article is that there are numerous unsourced statements throughout, along with numerous {{page needed}} templates for the Rolling Stone source. With these problems, I don't think FS/LS can retain its good article status (which sucks cuz JT is one of my favorite musicians and this is my favorite album by him). RedShellMomentum mobile (talk) 04:55, 27 October 2026 (UTC)

Someone I know has a Rolling Stone subscription so I can try to get access to that source. Give me a week or so and I'll see what I can do. NRP (talk) 00:33, 30 October 2026 (UTC)
@NRP: Sorry for not clarifying earlier but an archive exists here. RedShellMomentumtalk that talk to me 02:56, 6 November 2026 (UTC)
Oops sorry, I forgot about this. I'm gonna try to find pages for that this weekend NRP (talk) 02:59, 6 November 2026 (UTC)
@NRP: Any updates? RedShellMomentumtalk that talk to me 02:02, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Shoot, sorry. I got really busy. I'll look at it tomorrow and try to find pages. NRP (talk) 02:06, 10 November 2026 (UTC)
Okay, I've added some. I'll work on adding the rest in a little. NRP (talk) 01:43, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
@NRP: Just a reminder that the missing page numbers aren't the only issue (this isn't to rush you btw). RedShellMomentumtalk that talk to me 08:39, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
I know, I'm gonna work on removing unsourced stuff too. NRP (talk) 20:00, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

1971 Iraq poison grain disaster

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

This article fails GA criterion 3a (broadness of coverage). It never explains the basic agricultural rationale behind the events it describes, leaving readers unable to follow the causal logic.

  • Purpose of mercury seed treatment is unexplained.

The Context section states only that "Mercury was found to be an effective fungicide in the early 1900s." It does not explain that this treatment was applied specifically to seed grain to protect it from fungal spoilage during shipping/storage prior to planting — not to the crop that would eventually be harvested. Without this, readers cannot understand why seed grain in particular was treated with a toxin, or why such a practice existed.

  • Fate of mercury after planting is unaddressed.

The article never states whether wheat/barley grown from properly planted treated seed would itself have been safe to eat. This is the central premise that makes the disaster comprehensible: the poisoning occurred specifically because farmers consumed the raw seed grain rather than planting it and eating the resulting harvest. Without addressing what would have happened under intended use, the article leaves this foundational question open.

These are coverage gaps, not merely prose-clarity issues, and I believe they warrant reassessment.流山隆一 (talk) 01:30, 9 August 2026 (UTC)

This page was first transcluded at WP:GAR 19 August due to a now fixed bug. PrimeHunter (talk) 12:28, 19 August 2026 (UTC)
How odd, I looked at GAR on 9 August and bookmarked it then, so it was certainly visible to ordinary editors. Chiswick Chap (talk) 12:32, 19 August 2026 (UTC)
Maybe you actually saw Talk:1971 Iraq poison grain disaster in Category:Good article reassessment nominees and followed the link here. PrimeHunter (talk) 22:33, 19 August 2026 (UTC)
I did not. Chiswick Chap (talk) 03:38, 20 August 2026 (UTC)
The transclusion was so I don't know how you found the page to make an edit 9 August but never mind. PrimeHunter (talk) 22:44, 20 August 2026 (UTC)
KEEP: The Context already states that (methyl)mercury fungicides are toxic; I have added a cited statement that mercury was used in seed dressings as you suggest. Your objection is in a way too strong for its own good: it would apply to all pesticides used on any crop at any stage, as it is always the case that the harvested parts are claimed to be safe to eat after any properly-conducted pesticide treatment. I have all the same added a direct cited statement that seed dressings are supposed not to leave harmful residues in harvested cereal crops. I believe that resolves this matter, which really should not have required a GAR. Chiswick Chap (talk) 06:34, 19 August 2026 (UTC)

User:流山隆一, has your concern been addressed? Chiswick Chap (talk) 08:18, 26 October 2026 (UTC)


Preston railway station, Melbourne

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

GA criterion 2.c states that good article "contains no original research". Per WP:PSTS, Wikipedia articles should be based on reliable, published secondary sources, and to a lesser extent, on tertiary sources and primary sources. Secondary or tertiary sources are needed to establish the topic's notability and avoid novel interpretations of primary sources. All analyses and interpretive or synthetic claims about primary sources must be referenced to a secondary or tertiary source and must not be an original analysis of the primary-source material by Wikipedia editors.
Notably this article has more primary sources than secondary sources. This issue was raised at Talk:Preston railway station, Melbourne#Excessive reliance on primary sources over a year ago and the issue has not been sufficiently addressed in that time.
Additionally this article contains references sourced to the Herald Sun or Seven News. These sources have are listred at either WP:RSP or WP:NPPSG as being less than WP:GREL, notably Herald Sun is listed as being WP:GUNREL. TarnishedPathtalk 13:16, 23 October 2026 (UTC)

Comment: when I was conducting the review, I was still a newbie at GAN reviewing. Now that I have more experience, I think the concerns on the talk page (overreliance on primary sources and PUFFERY arising from them) are valid. However, I will say that rail stations (especially modern ones) can rely on non-independent/primary sources for uncontroversial stuff like what landmarks the station serves and where the station is located... they can, in fact, be the most reliable source for that type of stuff. Subjective statements like "the station creates 'newer and safer connections'" should be cited to parties that are independent of the station's owner, like a newspaper columnist or a public transport designer, not to the owner itself.
I also wasn't aware of the NPP sources list and Seven News's unreliability (I thought of the contrary while reviewin the article, actually). I'm not sure why I didn't properly assess the reliability of the sources back when I was doing this review... Anyways, the two sources should be removed and replaced with more reliable sources. If both issues are resolved, then I move to keep the article. Icepinner (Come to Hakurei Shrine!) 13:52, 23 October 2026 (UTC)
I think it needs a bit more than the two sources replaced, there needs to at minimum be more reliable secondary sources than primary sources. TarnishedPathtalk 14:00, 23 October 2026 (UTC)
Agree. Icepinner (Come to Hakurei Shrine!) Icepinner (Come to Hakurei Shrine!) 15:12, 23 October 2026 (UTC)
@Icepinner: Don't worry, the Herald Sun and Seven News are reliable for non-political or controversial topics such as this. Steelkamp (talk) 07:30, 24 October 2026 (UTC)
I would only use the Herald Sun for any WP:ABOUTSELF content. Seven is not as bad. Preferably both sources ought to be replaced. TarnishedPathtalk 08:51, 24 October 2026 (UTC)
I think the context of what the source is used for needs to be taken into account. Those sources shouldn't be used for anything related to climate change, but for a week long station closure, i think its fine. Steelkamp (talk) 11:32, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
I'm less concerned about the Herald Sun and Seven News being used as sources, and more concerned that this article is not broad in its covereage. There's so little pre-LXRP history there. And for the LXRP, what package of works was this part of? What contractor? What budget? What planning was done? Is there any information at all on the 1889 structures? The passenger counts are not up to date or mentioned in prose. Steelkamp (talk) 07:27, 24 October 2026 (UTC)
You're correct there. I overlooked that when I was looking at the talk page and the reference list. I imagine there could be stories to be found in Trove on the 1889 structures. TarnishedPathtalk 08:53, 24 October 2026 (UTC)
Original GA Nominee here
Back when I expanded the article and made the Preston railway station, Melbourne article to meet GA status back in November/December 2024 to June 2025, it was incredibly difficult to find reliable and secondary sources even after doing deep research about Preston railway station. The Herald Sun and Channel 7 News Australia were the only secondary sources that I could find at the time to add it in to existing paragraphs of the article. Now, I did go have a look once again today to find a reliable, secondary sources, but still couldn't find much about this station.
I used primary government sources, such as Victoria's Big Build when getting this article to GA status because they were really easy to find through research, but I do really wish that there were more secondary, reliable sources, but there is nothing we can do about it.
I've also since learnt that The Herald Sun is more right-wing leaning in politics and may do controversial topics, but from that Herald Sun news article from memory, I didn't see any political or controversial topics in there.
I don't really mind if the Preston railway station, Melbourne article is taken off the GA status article lists, considering it had less secondary, reliable sources and I still couldn't find them.
Thanks. PEPSI697 (💬) (📝) 09:40, 24 October 2026 (UTC)
@PEPSI697, considering @Steelkamp's comment above, have you looked for material about the 1889 structures? Trove or Newspapers.com might be places to find material. If there was content added about that it could potentially make a difference in regards to the proportion of primary sources. TarnishedPathtalk 10:10, 24 October 2026 (UTC)
Trove is likely to contain good info. I'm also wondering whether any local history books mention the station. Steelkamp (talk) 10:20, 24 October 2026 (UTC)
No, I haven't looked for secondary sources regarding the 1889 structures, good point.
I've looked through Trove for the 1889 Preston railway station, Melbourne structures and unfortunately couldn't find anything about those structure despite doing deep research today. Is there anything else I could look up for newspaper archives through Trove related to Preston railway station, Melbourne?
For newspaper.com, the search for newspaper archives was unfortunately behind a paywall and didn't bother deciding to pay for it considering that I wouldn't use this website as much.
Again, I don't mind at all if this article gets taken off the GA status list.
Also apologies for me taking 3 days to respond, I was busy in the last few days.
Thanks. PEPSI697 (💬) (📝) 09:32, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
@PEPSI697: you should be able to access Newspapers.com via WP:TWL, but you'll need to apply for it. If I remember correctly, the Wikipedia side of things should be quick, but I never got my subscription to Newspapers.com to work properly, so I can't say how long it will take for you to get access to Newspapers.com. Icepinner (Come to Hakurei Shrine!) 10:45, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Trove would have anything from before 1955 due to copyright. What useful newspapers would Newspapers.com even have? Does it have The Age? There might be other ways to access The Age through a library in Victoria, for example. Steelkamp (talk) 11:10, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
In this situation Newspapers.com wouldn't be any better than Trove, given the subject matter is Australian. TarnishedPathtalk 11:12, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
I've got a subscription through WP:TWL, which has come in handy for my work reviewing nominations at WP:DYK. The licenses are limited, so if they are all allocated at any given time, anyone applying for access has to wait until someone else loses or gives up their access. TarnishedPathtalk 11:11, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Today I learned! Icepinner (Come to Hakurei Shrine!) 14:30, 27 October 2026 (UTC)

Missouri River

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

The aritcle is quite long, at almost 11,000 words. This is about 1,000 words longer than the version listed in 2011, and over the 8,000 that WP:SS recommends considering spinning out. I think there are some sections, like "Watershed", "Early European explorers", "American frontier", "Dam-building era", and "Tourism and recreation" that could be spun out, summarised more effectively, or have additional headings to help with navigation. There are also a couple of uncited statements, which I can tag with "citation needed" templates if pinged. Z1720 (talk) 03:42, 4 September 2026 (UTC)

I tend to think all of the human history stuff could be spun out, but the "Dam-building era" section should remain (possibly with some cleanup or being broken down by decades or significant periods of construction). The damming of the Missouri is pretty significant and properly belongs with an article about the river, although perhaps it should be merged with the "Human impacts" section under Ecology, since dams are certainly a human impact. Parts of it are indeed poorly-written, but that's an easy fix. Spinning off the history stuff should reduce the article size, but the "Tourism and recreation" section is sufficiently small I think it can stay where it is. Intothatdarkness 12:38, 4 September 2026 (UTC)
I haven't been on Wikipedia for a while but I think I can tackle this over a few months or so. I can do some heavy copy-editing and condensing in the longer sections. Shannon [ Talk ] 03:07, 20 October 2026 (UTC)

Hans Otto Roth

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Otto Roth/1&action=watch Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

I am nominating this article because I believe it fails criterion 3(a), which is essentially impossible to fulfill by practically failing to cite Romanian-language sources about a man who spent his entire political career in Romania.

The four sources that are cited are hardly up to standard. One is a speech made in 2003 on the floor of the Romanian parliament. I need hardly say that this cannot be considered a reliable source about anything. Another, while a slight improvement, is essentially hagiography, relying on interviews with his aged daughter. A third, while quoting a bona fide expert, is rather superficial. Source four duplicates #3 and can be eliminated on that basis.

As noted, Roth spent over three decades at the highest levels of the Romanian state. He was written about extensively by his fellow citizens: in newspapers, in magazines, in diaries and essays. Similarly, Romanian historians have been writing about him for at least three decades, if not significantly longer. The fact that none of this material has made its way into the article raises serious questions about its comprehensiveness. — Biruitorul Talk 23:17, 25 August 2026 (UTC)

Pinging author, reviewer and recent commenter: @Apollo468: @Thebiguglyalien: @Dahn: — Biruitorul Talk 23:19, 25 August 2026 (UTC)

I believe that this is holding the article to a standard above the bare-minimum requirements of the GA criteria and these are issues that would be raised if it were being compared to the more stringent FA criteria. But I'm just the guy who checked the boxes, so do what you will with it. Thebiguglyalien (talk) 23:45, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
  • The whitewashing of Roth's Nazism is a troublesome concern: the article manages to mention that he opposed the Romanian Nazi Party from within without ever bothering to even mention what he was doing therein in the first place -- are we to believe that he was kidnapped by the Nazis and forced to wear the uniform? I want to emphasize the level of bad writing that went into this: it's not just that his Nazi affiliation is mentioned only to be immediately qualified as irrelevant; it is also that the reader is not given a basic fact (which would have incidentally been available in local sources) about when he joined a political party, in fact even that he joined that party. Imagine an article about Trump switching directly from when he owned casinos to when he was president -- "and that, boys and girls, is the whole story".
Now I'm not saying that Roth was literally Hitler -- it is quite evident that he came to oppose Nazim (very lightly so, and at very little personal risk, and after having joined with it knowing full well what it stood for). Though even on that note, the article manages to be infuriatingly lopsided: it coaches us on how Roth supposedly once told Hitler to, as it were, cool it with the antisemitism, but we are spared having think about how he only did so after having himself joined a movement and a party that he knew to be antisemitic!
But true enough: he wasn't Hitler, and even Schindler was a Nazi before he was anything else. But it is still poor form, and it should have struck the reviewers as poor form, that this aspect, of his voluntary political commitments in that controversial era, is only lightly touched, in what is a text that manages to dwell mostly on his martyrdom and the many services he did to the world by always being in power. This is the sort of article that you get when you only mix in encomiums, and the exact part of the sources you use that reassure the reader "all is okay", instead of doing proper, dispassionate, research into what the sources actually say. It also strikes me as odd that the editors were apparently aware of the abundance of Romanian (and Hungarian, and local Saxon) sources, but made a conscious editorial decision not to use them -- see the mention of Arcanum hits on the talk page. ("I can see through Arcanum that there were a lot of attacks at the time by doing date range from multiple newspapers" -- you see, the editor saw that there were articles critical of Roth, but gleefully concluded that we should ignore their content. The editor didn't even search for a monograph that would synthesize what those articles said, and if they were at any point correct. The editor just made a conscious choice to ignore them, as we, the idiot readers, and Roth's wonderful legacy as well, need to be protected from a grown-up discussion about Roth and the Völkisch movement. Let's take a moment to put these two things together: the article uses interviews with Roth's daughter, but consciously glosses over articles mentioning his dealings with the far-right. What sort of article do you imagine emerges from that mix, if not puffery and defense of the great man? Is there even a single source used that outright criticizes Roth for anything?)
This is a study-case in how not to write an article, and it should be removed from the GA list pronto, pending massive improvements.
(The structure of the article is incidentally incoherent, at various points driven by the editor's personal musings into how each new thought should be a section -- why is there, as a random example, a two-line separate section for "Roles in Transylvanian Saxon institutions"? how can this be methodologically different from what is in the rest of the article? Just who thought this was a way to write an article, let alone an example of what constitutes good writing on wikipedia?) Dahn (talk) 04:54, 26 August 2026 (UTC)
  • The question about primary sources, of political speeches, used as RSes is not, btw, "above the bare-minimum requirements". Such sourcing is prevented by the bare-minimum criteria for writing an article, let alone a GA. Dahn (talk) 04:59, 26 August 2026 (UTC)
  • It also does not work that an article barely checks the GA criteria but then "something happens" and a myriad of sources get added to where it is good for the FA. Nah. What we get in that promotional line-up is a fruit of the poisonous tree -- a half-assed, encomiastic article gets plastered with two or three more sources, all of the same nature, all used in the same unilateral think-happy-thoughts manner, and the half-assed GA becomes a half-assed FA. And from then on it becomes cited as a model for how to write other articles -- someone recently mentioned the FA on W. B. Yeats which is less detailed than the preface in a paperback Yeats I used to own, incidentally by, among many other things, also having very little and timidly worded material on his Blueshirts involvement (imagine the chutzpah it took to say that the article on that monument of Anglo-Irish culture and European poetry was "complete" in that form). Dahn (talk) 06:03, 26 August 2026 (UTC)
  • Erm, what exactly is the status of this reassessment? Is it just being ignored at the moment? Dahn (talk) 04:20, 17 October 2026 (UTC)

Natalie Harp

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Look at the original GA review. That was not a review. That GA should never have been allowed. This article has never had a proper GA review. Bgsu98 (Talk) 03:56, 5 October 2026 (UTC)

You haven't checked if this article meets the GA criteria, so this reassessment is also not proper. A review with no comments is itself not a reason to open a GAR. elijahpepe@wikipedia (he/him) 04:01, 5 October 2026 (UTC)
I don't see how the article does not meet the GA criteria. Some comments from the reviewer–@Thepharoah17–would have been nice (WP:GANI#R3) but with 22 reviews and 16 GAs, it's clear that they are familiar with the review process. aesurias (she/her) (talk) 04:30, 5 October 2026 (UTC)
At the time of the GA pass, May 10, it appears that there was no citation for her birth year, and the WP text of the name of her title did not match the name of her title as reported in RS. Different reviewers I’m sure have different priorities in BLPs that they spot check for verifiability, but it does seem to me that birth year and job title should be very high on anyone’s list. If we had some comment we could point to as evidence that any amount of fact-checking occurred in this review, it might be easier to overlook the miss on the birth year and job title.
Either way, the article has expanded significantly since May 10. I would think a case could be made that the article is over-focused on the more lurid details (therefore not broad in its coverage) and someone might reasonably be able to articulate that our presentation of the more lurid stuff is not neutral.
My understanding is GA Reassessment is not meant to assess new material added after the GA pass. Mikewem (talk) 15:34, 5 October 2026 (UTC)
GA Reassessment examines the article in its current form. Bgsu98 (Talk) 15:38, 5 October 2026 (UTC)
Bgsu98 is correct, but I'm not seeing a compelling reason to reassess the article. In a strange sense, more attention dedicated to this article has meant that uncited statements are being noticed. I agree that "the article is over-focused on the more lurid details", but that does not mean that it is not broad in its coverage. Broad coverage is the floor, not the ceiling. It seems to me that editors have come here instead to try to paint a particular view of Harp that is hasty. I'm not seeing any problematic sources on a brief glance, it might be correct, and it probably doesn't warrant a GAR yet. I would want to see a rewrite done before a GAR, which strikes me as an article for which a rewrite is beyond the realm of possibility. elijahpepe@wikipedia (he/him) 17:05, 5 October 2026 (UTC)
The problem is this article never had a proper review in the first place. Thepharoah17 received a notice on their talk page about sparse GA reviews around the time this supposed GA was completed. It should have been vacated and sent back to the queue at that time. Bgsu98 (Talk) 17:35, 5 October 2026 (UTC)
GAR does not appear to be the avenue for that. The review was already completed. The point of this process is to assess whether the article meets the GA criteria at the current moment, regardless of how detailed the review might have been at the time. If you are not able to explain why this article does not meet the criteria, then this needs to be closed. elijahpepe@wikipedia (he/him) 21:04, 5 October 2026 (UTC)
As one of the editors who was part of the more attention, I’m very sympathetic to the argument that the increased attention was good for filling in citations.
But the increased attention did result in the addition of a lot of potentially non-neutral material.
I think a good solution for right now is for interested editors to take a critical look at the Relationship with Donald Trump section for neutrality, with an eye towards volume of material we cover in the section. Even the name of the section might conceivably attract criticism. The word Relationship possibly implying a “relationship”. Mikewem (talk) 17:51, 5 October 2026 (UTC)

1976 San Diego Chargers season

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Per this thread, this GA review is suspected of having been entirely generated by a LLM. Unless an editor undertakes a proper GA review of this article, this article should be delisted. Note: I am in no way impugning the quality of this article. Bgsu98 (Talk) 20:13, 21 August 2026 (UTC)


J. Wray & Nephew Ltd.

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch • Watch article reassessment page • Most recent review
Result pending

Bringing this here after discussion at DYKT. I believe the review did not properly assess the sourcing under GACR 2(a) and 2(b). It uses self-published sources extensively when reliable sources are required per 2(a), and it uses primary sources extensively, when 2(b) requires no original research.

  • 9 claims are sourced to Petr Hlousek's self-published rum label archive. Even if this were to be considered an appropriate source somehow, the rum labels would still be primary sources.
  • A Medium post by Javaun Francis. The nominator said in the review Javaun Francis is a rum educator with a Youtube channel where he does in-depth videos about rum, and owns a company, Louisiana Cane Spirits, and a website, booksrumandthensome.com. Again, I normally avoid Medium for that exact reason, but Javaun Francis is genuinely an expert in the field and his credibility should carry over. I'm sorry, but there is no evidence provided that Francis meets the requirements of WP:SPSEXPERT, and his other website named is a personal Substack.
  • 39 claims are attributed to two videos featuring interviews with J. Wray personnel published by J. Wray & Nephew's trade association. These are primary and non-independent sources, and while such sources can be used sparingly, here they are used extensively and not just for straightforward, non-contentious claims. Here, for instance, one of these videos is used as a source for a negative claim about a competitor: Unlike some other distilleries, such as Hampden Estate, which re-use dunder during fermentation to increase the concentration of esters, producing higher-ester "funky" rums, J. Wray & Nephew does not re-use it and treats dunder purely as waste. Or for promotional/exceptional claims, such as Their more premium line of rums is Appleton Estate or Park Avenue, a liquor store in Manhattan, at one point was the exclusive distributor of a 20-year-old column still Appleton rum. Two additional claims are sourced to the company's own website
  • 23 claims are sourced to Matt Pietrek's blogs Cocktail Wonk and RumWonk. There was some discussion as to whether Pietrek's blogs would count as WP:SPSEXPERT since he has published a few articles in otherwise reliable sources, but this RSN discussion indicates some skepticism about it.
  • 8 claims are attributed to a Wordpress blog by a "Michael Mosley". The nominator says but the author, Michael Mosley, is a BBC journalist, so I think his credibility on reporting should carry over to his wordpress. But the Michael Mosley who was a BBC journalist died in 2024 and was married to Clare Bailey, while the Michael Mosley of the Wordpress blog does not claim to be a BBC journalist and is married to Bonita. Any claim of WP:SPSEXPERT falls apart.
  • Other problematic sources: sponsored content from the company, a self-published family genealogy site, more primary sources.

All told, dozens of claims (a significant majority of this article) are based on primary, non-independent, and/or self-published sources. This should never have been passed at GAN and should be delisted. Dclemens1971 (talk) 13:56, 25 August 2026 (UTC)

Would like to apologize for any shortcomings I have not looked up on, but will try to rectify the issues. Thanks. brachy08 (chat here lol) 23:57, 25 August 2026 (UTC)
@Dclemens1971 I will try my best to improve the article on 10art's behalf and have removed as many dubious sources as I can. https://singlecaskrum.com/countries/jamaica/appleton-estate-new-yarmouth/ seems promising, but I'm not sure. brachy08 (chat here lol) 12:49, 30 August 2026 (UTC)
I have canned an entire section about New Yarmouth, and until I can resolve the claims myself, I'll have to support demoting this article. brachy08 (chat here lol) 12:51, 30 August 2026 (UTC)
I appreciate the effort you put into this.
I'm not going to lie, I have not been active lately, since I submitted this article for GA just to see if I have been doing a good job editing wikipedia, and to hear that I have been doing it all wrong, and the person I rely on for probably over a quarter of my citations across all articles is not reliable at all, just made me want to step away from editing wikipedia. 𝟏𝟎𝐚𝐫𝐭𝟏 talk 19:32, 2 September 2026 (UTC)
You have been doing a good job, but we do make mistakes sometimes.
If you want to take a break, be my guest, but you're not doing it all wrong and he's just not reliable enough. You've done a lot of research on the subject, so you're on the right track. Please don't get disheartened over one failure. brachy08 (chat here lol) 01:38, 7 September 2026 (UTC)
Alright, I'll take a break and consider things.
Pietrek also wrote for Bevvy by the way, he has a column there called "Ruminations" https://bevvy.co/articles/author/matt-pietrek 𝟏𝟎𝐚𝐫𝐭𝟏 talk 16:19, 7 September 2026 (UTC)
Understood. Sorry for the late reply, but given a quick glance at Bevvy, I believe they're kinda reliable, not experienced with reliability but I think it counts as SPSEXPERT brachy08 (chat here lol) 07:11, 21 September 2026 (UTC)
I agree (uninvolved editor here) - i think Pietrek is fine. I'm more worried of the other ones. Jishara (please ping upon response) (talk) 16:18, 1 October 2026 (UTC)
So Hlousek, I agree is a weak source, and it looks like he mostly copied the info from https://old.jamaica-gleaner.com/pages/history/story0030.html, so I replaced his citations with the gleaner one where appropriate, and the rest I could find in some other sources, so there's no more Hlousek citations.
Likewise, it looks like Javaun Francis just took his historic information from A Jamaican Plantation: The History of Worthy Park 1670-1970 so I'm going to cite the book for that one claim. 𝟏𝟎𝐚𝐫𝐭𝟏 talk 02:11, 5 October 2026 (UTC)

Subpages • Category:Good article reassessment nominees • Good article cleanup listing