This case is now closed and pages relating to it might no longer be watched
|
Case clerks: HouseBlaster (talk) & SilverLocust (talk) • Drafting arbitrators: Aoidh (talk) & HJ Mitchell (talk) & CaptainEek (talk)
| Wikipedia Arbitration |
|---|
| Track related changes |
Case opened on 04:41, 30 November 2024 (UTC)
Case closed on 23:49, 23 January 2025 (UTC)
Case amended by motions on 07:03, 23 January 2026 (UTC)
This case is closed. No edits should be made to this page except by clerks or arbitrators.
|
Preliminary statements given in the case request stage may be found at /Preliminary statements.
| Motion name | Support | Oppose | Abstain | Enacted |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Motion 1: Appeals only to ArbCom | 9 | 0 | 0 | |
| Motion 2a: Word limits | 0 | 6 | 0 | |
| Motion 2b: Word limits | 10 | 0 | 0 | |
| Motion 2c: Word limits | 6 | 3 | 0 | |
| Motion 3: Involved participants | 0 | 8 | 0 | |
| Motion 4: Enforced BRD | 1 | 5 | 3 | |
| Motion 5: PIA5 Case | 6 | 3 | 1 |
Maybe even everyone is limited to 500-1000 words in any ARBPIA discussion.as ScottishFinnishRadish suggests). Best, KevinL (aka L235 · t · c) 18:39, 17 August 2024 (UTC)
A case with a sprawling scope and no clear question that ArbCom can answer is likely to be an enormous time sink and end up producing little long-term benefit. Instead, I think SFR's suggestions have merit for maintaining some semblance of order, even if it means ArbCom playing a more proactive role than it's used to and hearing appeals of CTOP sanctions or acting as AE admins en banc. I would also welcome direct case requests or AE referrals if there are allegations that a particular editor is behaving tendentiously (ie, the sum of their contributions is disruptive even if no one diff in isolation is sanctionable) and AE admins are unable to reach a conclusion. And something that stood out to me from AHJ (and which I've been reminded of, reading some of the comments above about how knowledgeable many Wikipedians are on their chosen subject) was the analysis of sources; I didn't think it was ArbCom's place to be doing that analysis itself, but but it could be valuable to have an agreed baseline of what the academic literature says, which (aside from being useful in itself) would then support (or refute) allegations of source misrepresentation. One final thing we could do is avoid the use of news media and primary reporting in articles on current events (this could potentially be done by consensus, or ArbCom writ, or part of the suite of sanctions administrators have available and applied article by article).
Tl;dr: we need to do something, and we should welcome new ideas but a sprawling ARBPIA5 is unlikely to resolve anything satisfactorily. HJ Mitchell | Penny for your thoughts? 19:29, 1 September 2024 (UTC)
Trying something different to see if we can break the deadlock without spending months on a case. I think we can have concise community feedback on individual motions to help with readability. These are all without prejudice to a case, now or at a later date. I'm also open to other ideas. HJ Mitchell | Penny for your thoughts? 21:20, 15 September 2024 (UTC)
When imposing a contentious topic restriction under the Arab-Israeli conflict contentious topic, an uninvolved administrator may require that appeals be heard only by the Arbitration Committee. In such cases, the committee will hear appeals at ARCA according to the community review standard. A rough consensus of arbitrators will be required to overturn or amend the sanction.
Enacted - HouseBlaster (talk • he/they) 04:17, 15 November 2024 (UTC)
All participants in formal discussions (RfCs, RMs, etc) within the area of conflict are urged to keep their comments concise, and are limited to 500 words per discussion.
Uninvolved administrators may impose word limits on all participants in a discussion, or on individual editors across all discussions, within the area of conflict. These word limits are designated as part of the standard set of restrictions within the Arab-Israeli conflict contentious topic. These restrictions must be logged and may be appealed in the same way as all contentious topic restrictions.
Enacted - HouseBlaster (talk • he/they) 04:17, 15 November 2024 (UTC)
All participants in formal discussions (RfCs, RMs, etc) within the area of conflict are urged to keep their comments concise, and are limited to 1,000 words per discussion. This motion will sunset two years from the date of its passage.
Enacted - HouseBlaster (talk • he/they) 04:17, 15 November 2024 (UTC)
Editors designated "involved" in the area of conflict may not register a bolded vote in formal discussions but may offer opinions and are encouraged to offer sources. Editors may designate themselves involved in the entire topic area or a subset of it, or may be designated by an uninvolved admin. Designations by administrators may be appealed in the same way as sanctions. Designation is not a suggestion that an editor's contributions are problematic.
Where a recent edit within the area of conflict is reverted for a substantive reason, it may not be reinstated by any editor until a discussion on the talk page reaches a consensus. Reverts made solely to enforce the extended-confirmed requirement are excluded from this requirement. This motion will sunset two years from the date of its passage.
Following a request at WP:ARCA, the Arbitration Committee directs its clerks to open a case to examine the interaction of specific editors in the WP:PIA topic area. Subject to amendment by the drafting arbitrators, the following rules will govern the case:
Enacted (case is scheduled to open on November 30) - HouseBlaster (talk • he/they) 04:17, 15 November 2024 (UTC)
to refer the dispute to the full arbitration committee for final decision. I do not believe the other motions will adequately address the reason for the referral and a case would allow for the opportunity to make a more fully informed decision. I don't think a case was ever a foregone conclusion just because the issue was referred to us, but in this circumstance I think it's the better option we have in terms of examining and attempting to address the dispute AE referred to us. - Aoidh (talk) 17:50, 10 October 2024 (UTC)
All tallies are based on the votes at /Proposed decision, where comments and discussion from the voting phase is also available.
1) The purpose of Wikipedia is to create a high-quality, free-content encyclopedia in an atmosphere of camaraderie and mutual respect among contributors. Use of the site for other purposes, such as advocacy or propaganda or furtherance of outside conflicts is prohibited. Contributors whose actions are detrimental to that goal may be asked to refrain from them, even when these actions are undertaken in good faith.
2) The role of the committee is to act as a final binding decision-maker for serious conduct disputes the community has been unable to resolve. Content areas the committee has previously ruled on are sometimes designated as contentious topics or subject to ongoing special restrictions. As necessary, the Committee may revisit previous decisions and associated enforcement systems in order to review their effectiveness or necessity.
3) The Arbitration Committee has jurisdiction over conduct on the English Wikipedia and retains jurisdiction over all matters previously heard, including associated enforcement processes. While the Arbitration Committee may take notice of behavior outside of the English Wikipedia, it cannot restrict behavior which occurs outside of the English Wikipedia.
4) The Committee rules on conduct, not content. It does not dictate the content of any article.
5) Arbitration enforcement (AE) is the noticeboard, set up by the Arbitration Committee and staffed by administrators, for editors to report suspected breaches of arbitration decisions. When enforcing arbitration decisions, administrators act as delegates of the Arbitration Committee: in that role, they review the facts and take action if necessary.
6) In enforcing arbitration decisions, administrators should seek to create an acceptable collaborative editing environment. Administrators are expected to use their experience and judgment to balance (1) the need to assume good faith, to avoid biting genuine newcomers, and to allow responsible contributors maximum editing freedom with (2) the need to keep edit-warring, battleground conduct, and other disruptive behavior to a minimum.
7) Several of Wikipedia's most bitter disputes have revolved around national or ethnic conflicts such as rival national claims to disputed territories or areas. Editors working on articles on these topics may frequently have strong viewpoints, often originating in their own national or other backgrounds. Such editors may be the most knowledgeable people interested in creating Wikipedia content about the area or the dispute, and are permitted and encouraged to contribute if they can do so consistent with Wikipedia's fundamental policies. However, conduct that furthers a preexisting dispute on Wikipedia should receive special attention from the community, up to and including sanctions. It is perfectly possible to present a balanced, accurate, and verifiable encyclopedia article about contentious issues or preexisting disputes.
8) Edit warring is disruptive and tends to inflame content disputes rather than resolve them. Users who engage in multiple reverts of the same content but are careful not to breach the three-revert rule are still edit warring.
9) Users who disrupt the editing of articles by engaging in sustained aggressive point-of-view editing may be banned from editing these articles. In extreme cases, they may be banned from the site.
10) Contentious Topic page protections are put in place to "intervene in topic areas that have proved problematic". Page protections are not typically implemented automatically in a contentious topic area.
11) Wikipedia users are expected to behave reasonably, calmly, and courteously in their interactions with other users. Unseemly conduct, such as personal attacks, incivility, harassment, disruptive point-making, and gaming the system, is prohibited. Additionally, editors should presume that other editors, including those who disagree with them, are acting in good faith toward the betterment of the project, at least until strong evidence emerges to the contrary. Even when an editor becomes convinced that another editor is not acting in good faith, and has a reasonable basis for that belief, the editor should attempt to remedy the problem without resorting to inappropriate conduct of their own.
12) Wikipedia is not a battleground.
13) Wikipedia is not a general discussion forum or a debate club.
14) Violations of Wikipedia's behavioral expectations are not excused on the grounds that the editor who violated those expectations has the correct position on an underlying substantive dispute or the interpretation of policies and guidelines within those disputes. Those expectations apply universally to all editors, and violations of those expectations are harmful to the functioning of the project, irrespective of the merits of an underlying substantive dispute.
15) Editors sanctioned for disruptive behavior are expected to improve their behavior, should they continue to participate in the project. Sanctioned editors should be afforded assistance and reasonable time to improve (especially if they demonstrate the ability to engage positively with the community), but if their conduct does not improve they may be subject to increasingly severe sanctions.
16) Wikipedia articles do not have owners who control edits to them. Instead, they are the property of the community at large and governed by community consensus.
17) In formal discussions, less is usually more. Editors who choose to ignore this advice by replying to a large number of comments can bludgeon the discussion. Bludgeoning exhausts other editors, dissuades further participation, wastes time, and makes discussions less effective. Editors should avoid repeating the same point or making so many comments that they dominate the discussion. Editors should particularly avoid trying to convince specific other people that they are right and the other person is wrong, and should instead focus on presenting their own ideas as clearly and concisely as possible.
18) When the community's extensive and reasonable attempts to control the spread of disruption arising from long-term disputes have failed, the Arbitration Committee may, as a last resort, be compelled to adopt robust measures to prevent further damage to the encyclopedia, disruption to the editing environment and to the community.
1) This case relates to behavioral issues occurring around articles relating to the Israeli–Palestinian conflict. This area has been the subject of four previous arbitration cases, Palestine-Israel articles, West Bank - Judea and Samaria, Palestine-Israel articles 3, and Palestine-Israel articles 4.
2) 1RR restrictions are often an ineffective mechanism for preventing edit wars in the PIA topic area, as multiple editors will each make a single revert on an article, but the combined efforts of multiple editors creates an edit war with multiple reverts per day on a single topic (ScottishFinnishRadish evidence).
3) Edit warring has been used to preserve a perceived "status quo" point of view in articles within the topic area. This creates an incentive to be the first to write an article or to add content, as it often requires an affirmative consensus to change away from its point of view (Aquillion evidence, ScottishFinnishRadish evidence).
4) When the status quo version of an existing article does not match an editor's preferred version or point of view and attempts to change it are reverted, new articles describing the same subject from a different point of view ("POV forks") are often created (ScottishFinnishRadish evidence, Aquillion evidence, Alaexis evidence, Boksi evidence).
5) Requests for Comment and Requested Moves in this topic area are often closed by involved editors (ScottishFinnishRadish evidence).
6) Many editors in the topic area exhibit both battleground behavior (ScottishFinnishRadish evidence) and sealioning (Valereee evidence), inflaming disputes.
7) Sockpuppetry is an ongoing issue in the topic area, causing significant disruption. While roughly the same proportion of editors in PIA are socks as in other topic areas, those socks make a higher proportion of edits compared to other topic areas. In a recent sample of edits in the PIA topic area, roughly 7% of mainspace edits were made by known socks (Sean.hoyland evidence).
8) Sockpuppet investigations in the topic area can draw outsized attention from third parties who either rush to defend or attack the suspected sock (Eladkarmel evidence, Nableezy evidence).
9) Despite widespread extended confirmed (EC) protection on pages, non-EC accounts continue to make a significant number of edits. In a recent sample of edits in the PIA topic area, roughly 13% of mainspace edits were made by non-EC accounts (Sean.hoyland evidence).
10) Outside actors are heavily invested in influencing Wikipedia's coverage of the topic area (Aquillion evidence).
11) Many of the named parties regularly file and participate in discussions at the arbitration enforcement noticeboard (Barkeep49 evidence).
12) The plurality of recent AE reports have been in the PIA topic area. Despite this, PIA threads were resolved no slower than threads from other topic areas, were not longer than other threads, and did not require more admin participation than other threads (Barkeep49 evidence and analysis).
13) AE reports with more than two parties tend to derail or become difficult to solve (Barkeep49 evidence and analysis).
14) BilledMammal (talk · contribs) has engaged in disruptive behavior in the PIA topic area, including edit warring (ScottishFinnishRadish evidence). They have made vexatious reports at AE and misrepresented sources in the topic area (Smallangryplanet evidence). They have weaponized reporting systems against perceived ideological enemies (David A evidence, private evidence).
15) Iskandar323 (talk · contribs) has engaged in disruptive behavior in the PIA topic area, including consistently non-neutral editing (FOARP evidence). A November 2024 AE report filed on them was closed as "No action, broader case currently before Arbcom
" (Barkeep49 evidence).
16) Ïvana (talk · contribs) was banned from editing the English Wikipedia by the Arbitration Committee on 9 December 2024 for off-wiki misconduct relating to the PIA topic area.
17) Levivich (talk · contribs) has engaged in disruptive behavior in the PIA topic area, including consistently non-neutral editing (AndreJustAndre evidence), inconsistent standards of behavioral expectations (Crossroads evidence), and incivility (Crossroads evidence, Tryptofish evidence). Levivich was warned for "removing an RM when involved and inappropriate communication
" in an October 2024 AE thread (Barkeep49 evidence).
18) Nableezy (talk · contribs) has engaged in disruptive behavior in the PIA topic area, including consistently non-neutral editing (FOARP evidence), incivility (Eladkarmel evidence), and aspersions (AndreJustAndre evidence). A 90-day PIA topic ban enacted by ScottishFinnishRadish was reduced upon an appeal from Nableezy at AE. Two further AE reports filed in 2024 were referred to the Arbitration Committee, while a fourth filed by ScottishFinnishRadish was withdrawn (Barkeep49 evidence).
19) Selfstudier (talk · contribs) has engaged in disruptive behavior in the PIA topic area, including consistently non-neutral editing (FOARP evidence) and edit warring (ScottishFinnishRadish evidence). Selfstudier was warned for "removing an RM when involved
" as a result of an October 2024 AE report (Barkeep49 evidence).
20) האופה (talk · contribs) was blocked during this case as a sockpuppet of Galamore.
21) AndreJustAndre (talk · contribs) has engaged in disruptive behavior in the PIA topic area (Zero0000 evidence, Nableezy evidence). This comes after they were unblocked by the Arbitration Committee in September 2024, following a January 2024 ArbCom block. In 2018 they resigned their administrative and bureaucratic permissions after ArbCom accepted a case focusing on their conduct.
22) Zero0000 (talk · contribs) has engaged in disruptive behavior in the PIA topic area, including incivility (ScottishFinnishRadish evidence, AndreJustAndre evidence).
23) Makeandtoss (talk · contribs) has engaged in disruptive behavior in the PIA topic area, including non-neutral editing (FOARP evidence) and stonewalling discussions (ScottishFinnishRadish evidence). Makeandtoss was warned "...to avoid (slow-motion) edit warring in the area of the Arab-Israeli conflict [and] warned to adhere to the area's topic-wide one revert restriction
", as a result of a January 2024 AE report, and was given "a final warning for behavior that falls below the required level required when editing in contentious topics
" in a June 2024 AE report (Barkeep49 evidence).
24) Nishidani (talk · contribs) has engaged in disruptive behavior in the PIA topic area, including an ongoing pattern of incivility (Tryptofish evidence). As a result of a February 2024 AE report, Nishidani was "warned against using unconstructive or unnecessarily inflammatory language in [PIA] the topic area
" (Barkeep49 evidence). The Committee topic banned them in the original PIA case in 2009; the ban was lifted in 2011. They were most recently topic banned from PIA for three weeks, starting on October 24, 2024 (Special:Diff/1253179153).
Note: All remedies that refer to a period of time, for example to a ban of X months or a revert parole of Y months, are to run concurrently unless otherwise stated.
1) All articles whose topic is strictly within the Arab-Israeli conflict topic area shall be extended confirmed protected by default, without requiring prior disruption on the article.
2) BilledMammal is indefinitely topic banned from the Palestine-Israel conflict, broadly construed. This restriction may be appealed twelve months after the enactment of this remedy, and every twelve months thereafter.
3) Iskandar323 is indefinitely topic banned from the Palestine-Israel conflict, broadly construed. This restriction may be appealed twelve months after the enactment of this remedy, and every twelve months thereafter.
4) Levivich is indefinitely topic banned from the Palestine-Israel conflict, broadly construed. This restriction may be appealed twelve months after the enactment of this remedy, and every twelve months thereafter.
5) Nableezy is indefinitely topic banned from the Palestine-Israel conflict, broadly construed. This restriction may be appealed twelve months after the enactment of this remedy, and every twelve months thereafter.
6) Selfstudier is indefinitely topic banned from the Palestine-Israel conflict, broadly construed. This restriction may be appealed twelve months after the enactment of this remedy, and every twelve months thereafter.
7) Zero0000 is warned for their behavior in the Palestine-Israel topic area, which falls short of the conduct expected of an administrator.
8) Makeandtoss is indefinitely topic banned from the Palestine-Israel conflict, broadly construed. This restriction may be appealed twelve months after the enactment of this remedy, and every twelve months thereafter.
9) Nishidani is indefinitely topic banned from the Palestine-Israel conflict, broadly construed. This restriction may be appealed twelve months after the enactment of this remedy, and every twelve months thereafter.
10) WP:Contentious topics/Arab–Israeli conflict#Word limits (discretionary) and WP:Contentious topics/Arab–Israeli conflict#Word limits (1,000 words) are both modified to add as a new second sentence to each: Citations and quotations (whether from sources, Wikipedia articles, Wikipedia discussions, or elsewhere) do not count toward the word limit.
11) Any AE report is limited to a max of two parties: the party being reported, and the filer. If additional editors are to be reported, separate AE reports must be opened for each. AE admins may waive this rule if the particular issue warrants doing so.
12) The community is encouraged to run a Request for Comment aimed at better addressing or preventing POV forks, after appropriate workshopping.
13) The Committee recognizes that working at AE can be a thankless and demanding task, especially in the busy PIA topic area. We thus extend our appreciation to the many administrators who have volunteered their time to help out at AE.
16) Editors are reminded that outside actors have a vested interest in this topic area, and might engage in behaviors such as doxxing in an attempt to influence content and editors. The digital security resources page contains information that may help.
17) Within this topic area, the balanced editing restriction is added as one of the sanctions that may be imposed by an individual administrator or rough consensus of admins at AE.
19.1) AndreJustAndre is indefinitely topic banned from the Palestine-Israel conflict, broadly construed. This restriction may be appealed twelve months after the enactment of this remedy, and every twelve months thereafter.
19.2) Should the Arbitration Committee receive a complaint at WP:ARCA about AndreJustAndre, within 12 months of the conclusion of this case, AndreJustAndre may be banned from the English Wikipedia by motion.
22) If a sockpuppet investigations clerk or member of the CheckUser team feels that third-party input is not helpful at an investigation, they are encouraged to use their existing authority to ask users to stop posting to that investigation or to SPI as a whole.
In addition to clerks and members of the CheckUser team, patrolling administrators may remove or collapse contributions that impede the efficient resolution of investigations without warning.
0) Unless otherwise specified by the Arbitration Committee, should any user violate a restriction imposed directly by the Committee, that user may be blocked as an arbitration enforcement action. Such blocks must be logged in the arbitration enforcement log.
0) Appeals and modifications |
|---|
|
This procedure applies to appeals related to, and modifications of, actions taken by administrators to enforce the Committee's remedies. It does not apply to appeals related to the remedies directly enacted by the Committee. All active arbitration enforcement actions may be appealed. Only active restrictions may be appealed, and all labelled enforcement actions (including ones alleged to be against policy) must be successfully appealed under the applicable arbitration enforcement appeals procedure before they can be modified. Unless otherwise specified by the Arbitration Committee, the following procedure governs arbitration enforcement appeals. An editor may:
Appeals submitted at AE or AN must be submitted using the applicable template. Only the restricted editor may appeal an editor restriction. Any editor may appeal a page restriction. A rough consensus of administrators at AE or editors at AN may specify a period of up to one year during which no appeals (other than an appeal to ARCA) may be submitted. While asking the enforcing administrator and seeking reviews at AN or AE are not mandatory prior to seeking a decision from the Committee, once the Committee has reviewed a request, further substantive review at any forum is barred. The sole exception is editors under an active sanction, who may still request an easing or removal of the sanction on the grounds that said sanction is no longer needed, but such requests may only be made once every six months, or whatever other period the Committee may specify. Changing or revoking an enforcement actionAn administrator may only modify or revoke an enforcement action if a formal appeal is successful or if one of the following exceptions applies:
A formal appeal is successful only if one of the following agrees with revoking or changing the enforcement action:
Any administrator who revokes or changes an enforcement action out of process (i.e. without the above conditions being met) may, at the discretion of the Arbitration Committee, be desysopped. Standard of review On community reviewUninvolved administrators at the arbitration enforcement noticeboard ("AE") and uninvolved editors at the administrators' noticeboard ("AN") should revoke or modify an arbitration enforcement action on appeal if:
Arbitrators hearing an appeal at a request for amendment ("ARCA") will generally overturn an arbitration enforcement action only if:
References
|
Based on an explicit finding that a topic ban from the Arab-Israeli conflict has been insufficient to prevent disruption, a rough consensus of administrators at the arbitration enforcement noticeboard may extend an existing topic ban to include other topics related to Israel, Israelis, Jews, Judaism, Palestine, Palestinians, Islam, and/or Arabs. They should cite at least one diff pertinent to each area into which the ban is extended.
Any block, restriction, ban, or sanction performed under the authorisation of a remedy for this case must be logged at Wikipedia:Arbitration enforcement log, not here.