Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Clarification and Amendment

Requests for clarification and amendment

Amendment request: Maghreb

Initiated by Skitash at 00:35, 8 November 2026 (UTC)

Case or decision affected
Maghreb arbitration case (t) (ev / t) (w / t) (pd / t)
Clauses to which an amendment is requested
  1. Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Maghreb#Skitash_topic_banned
List of any users involved or directly affected, and confirmation that all are aware of the request
Information about amendment request

Statement by Skitash

Skitash's statement contains 1303 words and exceeds the 700-word limit.
Green tickY Extension granted to 700 words. HouseBlaster (talk • edits • he/they) 18:35, 8 November 2026 (UTC)

Greetings. I am writing to request reconsideration of my topic ban and ask for the opportunity to contribute to the Maghreb region again. It has now been over six months since my topic ban was put in place, and I feel that this time away has given me plenty of opportunity to reflect on my previous conduct and consider how I could have handled things differently.

Looking back, I recognize that I wasn't the easiest person to work with. I was involved in edit warring, wasn't particularly welcoming or patient toward newer editors, and sometimes approached disagreements as arguments I needed to win rather than discussions where I should have been willing to listen and find common ground. I regret handling things this way. I can see that I sometimes became too caught up in particular edits and disagreements, and I didn't always recognize when it was better to step back. I've learned that editing Wikipedia isn't about having things written exactly the way I want them, but about being willing to hear other people's views and work toward an outcome everyone can agree on. I know I could have approached many of my previous disagreements differently.

Over the past six months, I have complied with the topic ban and refrained from editing in the area covered by it. I have instead redirected my attention on other areas of Wikipedia, where I have continued making constructive edits and creating articles, particularly relating to West Asia, soccer, and U.S. politics. I've enjoyed being able to contribute to other areas, and this period has also given me the opportunity to step away from the disagreements that previously occupied much of my attention. I hope my activity during this period demonstrates that I've taken the ban seriously.

I would now very much appreciate the opportunity to return to editing the Maghreb region. It remains an area of considerable interest to me, and I would welcome the chance to contribute constructively to its articles and talk pages. I don't expect disagreements to disappear, nor do I expect to agree with every decision other editors make. However, I want to handle those situations differently than I did before. If my topic ban is lifted, I intend to approach things differently, with a much greater emphasis on collaboration and consensus-building. I will avoid edit warring and refrain from making repeated reverts when disagreements arise, and I shall take content disagreements to the relevant talk pages and try to work things out there. I also intend to be more patient and welcoming toward newer editors, assume good faith, and think more carefully about how I come across to others. Thank you very much for taking the time to consider my request. Skitash (talk) 00:35, 8 November 2026 (UTC)

@Asilvering: Thank you for the questions. Regarding the edits on MAK you've highlighted, I see why they would raise concerns over POV-pushing, and looking back, I can see that my approach to incorporating that material wasn't sufficiently neutral. My intention at the time was to include information from reliable sources that reflected the views and positions of the organization concerned, though obviously, verifiability does not guarantee inclusion nor does it guarantee that the way it is presented is necessarily appropriate. I don't necessarily believe that the underlying material was inherently inappropriate to discuss, but I should have given greater consideration to its due weight and how it was presented. In the future, I would take greater care to consider how material is weighted and presented, and ensure that my contributions maintain a neutral and encyclopedic tone.
As for the binary question issues (to include something or not), I think the correct approach is to work within the available sourcing and established talk page consensus. Where previous RfCs have taken place, I would take their outcomes into account and respect the consensus established. If disagreements persist and discussions reach a deadlock, I would avoid repeatedly reopening the same discussions or attempting to pursue an outcome through reverts, leaving the matter unresolved unless there is a substantive reason to revisit it, such as new sourcing or a meaningful change in circumstances. Ultimately I recognize that there will be occasions when I won't get my preferred outcome, and that's something I understand comes with collaborative editing. Skitash (talk) 20:20, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
@SilverLocust: I did use some assistance to refine the wording and structure of my own original thoughts. The reflections and substance are entirely my own. I'm happy to provide my original draft if necessary. Skitash (talk) 00:46, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
@HouseBlaster: 1. My original draft is as follows: "Greetings, I'd like to request reconsideration of my topic ban and ask for the opportunity to contribute to the Maghreb region again. It has now been just over six months since my topic ban was put in place and I feel that this time off has given me a lot of opportunity to reflect on my past conduct and think about how I could've done things differently. I acknowledge that I wasn't the easiest person to work with. I was involved in edit warring, I wasn't so friendly to new editors, and I sometimes treated content disputes as battles I had to win instead of reaching compromise with the other side. I regret handling things that way and I see where I went wrong. I should've known when to stop edit warring and arguing instead of persistently doing so. I learned that I shouldn't expect things to always go my way and that I need to be more willing to find compromises.
It has been over six months and I fully complied with the topic ban, fully refraining from editing anything covered by it. I instead made constructive edits to other areas and kept creating articles, particularly relating to West Asia, soccer, and U.S. politics. I've been able to contribute constructively to those areas and use this time as an opportunity to steer clear of my past disagreements I was so embroiled in. For this reason I would greatly appreciate the opportunity to return to editing the Maghreb region. It remains an area of great importance to me and I'd greatly appreciate constructively contributing to its articles and talk pages. I don't expect that I won't get into any arguments and I don't expect to agree with every decision other editors make, but I'd like to do things differently this time. If unbanned I want to approach things differently with a much greater emphasis on collaboration and consensus-building. I will avoid edit warring and refrain from repeatedly reverting others during disagreements, and I shall take content disagreements to the relevant talk pages and try to work things out there. I also want to be more welcoming toward newer editors, assuming good faith of them, and and to think more carefully about how I come across to others. Thank you very much for taking the time to consider my request."
2. I had asked for assistance with polishing my argument, improving the wording, making the writing more natural, perfecting the grammar, and develop areas where needed. I reviewed the resulting text and made further adjustments myself before submitting it.
3. I think my actions complied with the exception outlined at WP:LLMTALK which permits the refining of expression of one's own authentic ideas. The reflections and ideas in my appeal were entirely my own and I used assistance to improve how they were articulated. Skitash (talk) 22:56, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
@SilverLocust: I can assure you the original was written by me and was not AI-generated. I seriously question the reliability of AI detectors given how inconsistent their results can be (I've seen different detectors produce substantially different results). I'm also happy to answer Samuelshraga's questions if requested by an arbitrator, as I've gone beyond my word limit. Skitash (talk) 21:05, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by asilvering

I agree this appeal hits many of the right notes. But I'm concerned about the lack of reference to POV-pushing here, and about the lack of specificity overall. I was really quite alarmed by the framing of Movement for the Self-Determination of Kabylie; this version of the article is some of the most obvious biased editing I've seen in any recent Wikipedia article. I should like to nkow how this came about and what the plan for avoiding it in the future is. Was it pov-pushing, which Skitash now acknowledges and renounces? If it was good-faith biased editing, what's to prevent it from happening in the future?

Regarding the edit-warring, I intend to approach things differently, with a much greater emphasis on collaboration and consensus-building. I will avoid edit warring and refrain from making repeated reverts when disagreements arise, and I shall take content disagreements to the relevant talk pages and try to work things out there. is a good plan in general. But many of the issues in this case were about binary questions (eg, "should we add the Tamazigh name to the infobox or not?"), where there is no obvious compromise position. So what is the plan for when the inevitable happens, and the talk page discussion deadlocks as they did before? In solidarity, asilvering (talk) 18:17, 8 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by Samuelshraga

Leaving aside the merits of this appeal, even to my eyes something about it came across as artificial. Pangram and GPTZero showed it as 100% AI. I'm not sure how to share a link to the results I got but I just copied and pasted the text of the appeal (minus the signatures and timestamps), so you can do the same and verify the results. Samuelshraga (talk) 11:22, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Well... Pangram thinks with high confidence that the entirety of Skitash's "original" appeal is AI-generated, mostly with high confidence although a few words with lower. I wondered if Skitash's writing style engenders false positives, so I took a couple of other samples (from a regular talk page and from the Maghreb case) which both came up as 100% human written. I suppose a false positive is still possible, but my quick google search tells me that Pangram is reasonably accurate. I also don't think that Skitash has provided the prompts as requested by HouseBlaster in the second part of their answer. Samuelshraga (talk) 09:06, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Assuming that the AI issue is not material though, there are some things that Skitash's appeals cover either vaguely or not at all. The FOFs relating to Skitash included:
  • Repeatedly misusing WP:3O to help allies win disputes
  • Behaving aggressively towards new editors
  • Voting on a purely partisan basis without reference to sources and policy
  • Edit warring to restore and preserve poorly sourced material
So now I think it would be best if you clarify:
  • Were you ever in touch with M.Bitton or any other editors off wiki? Are there any current editors in the topic area you might feel prejudiced to support in content disputes?
  • Do you feel that you sufficiently understand the line between anti-vandalism work and biting newcomers, even ones causing disruption in good faith.
  • Your editing has dramatically slowed since WP:ARBMAG. Fewer than 500 edits since the close of the case, compared to over 2000 in the first 4 months of 2026. Is this a considered part of how you've changed your editing since the case, and do you plan to continue at this pace or return to the previous one?
  • The FoF referred "poorly sourced material". Do you understand why? Apart from avoiding edit wars, what are you going to do differently in regard to material and sourcing in future?
Samuelshraga (talk) 09:22, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by The Bushranger

I don't think it's necessarily disqualifying but I'm very dissapointed the original post was AI "polished". There was nothing wrong with your original draft. We want to hear from you and you alone, not what a chatbot suggests you say. - The Bushranger One ping only 01:42, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Given the evidence presented by Samuelshraga above, and having looked over the "original draft" with a possibly slighly more gimlet eye, I have to strike parts of my comment above - this is almost certainly AI generated as well and I urge the Committee to disqualify the request as such. Even leaving aside the lack of post-tban editing as mentioned by CaptainEek, the fact this is clearly a chatbot given a prompt of "get me unbanned" instead of a genuine appeal from the user on the user's merits is unfortunate. - The Bushranger One ping only 20:19, 18 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by {other-editor}

Other editors are free to make relevant comments on this request as necessary. Comments here should address why the Committee should or should not accept the amendment request or provide additional information.

Maghreb: Clerk notes

This area is used for notes by the clerks (including clerk recusals).
  • @Skitash: can you please respond to asilvering's questions? I've given you an extra 200 words. Best, HouseBlaster (talk • edits • he/they) 18:35, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
    Skitash, I give you an extension covering (1) the full text of the pre-AI version, (2) all prompts you gave the LLM, and (3) your concise answer to my question about whether your actions complied with AITALK. Best, HouseBlaster (talk • edits • he/they) 03:29, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Maghreb: Arbitrator views and discussion

Motion: Skitash topic ban rescinded

For this motion there are 13 active arbitrators, not counting 1 recused. With no arbitrators abstaining, 7 support or oppose votes are a majority.
Support
Per above. ~ Jenson (SilverLocust 💬) 14:10, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
  1. Izno (talk) 15:22, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
    I am unconvinced that the original is AI generated. Izno (talk) 23:06, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
  2. With a good deal of apprehension, but I ultimately come down on the side of WP:ROPE. It will be a while before I feel comfortable lifting the pseudo–contentious topic designation for Skitash. I urge Skitash to be extremely careful in the topic area, to seek outside support when necessary, and to treat newcomers with all of the courtesy and tact that you brought to this very appeal. If you don't, I am certain that an admin will quickly reimpose the restriction, and I promise that I will be first in line to do so; getting out of a second topic ban is much more difficult than your first. Best, HouseBlaster (talk • edits • he/they) 22:34, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
    I am indenting this vote for the time being (though I agree with everything I wrote in my vote). @Skitash: I need to see the pre-AI appeal and the prompts you gave to the LLM. Do you believe your actions complied with WP:AITALK? Best, HouseBlaster (talk • edits • he/they) 03:29, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
    Reinstating my vote. Thank you for your comments, Skitash. Best, HouseBlaster (talk • edits • he/they) 03:49, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
  3. Echoing House's remarks. It would be unwise to lapse back into previous conduct. I would also encourage Skitash to continue working on other topics alongside this one so as to maintain perspective (and to have something to fall back on if Maghreb-related editing becomes frustrating). HJ Mitchell | Penny for your thoughts? 20:24, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
  4. Daniel (talk) 10:18, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
  5. Aoidh (talk) 03:45, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Oppose
  1. the sustained pov pushing needs more than a year in the penalty box --Guerillero Parlez Moi 08:54, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
  2. We're not even 500 edits past the topic ban. While there is mention of what Skitash has been up to since, I'm not seeing citation to discussions that went well. For an editor that we tbanned because of some serious problems getting along with others, I'd like to see that occur more in practice first. CaptainEek Edits Ho Cap'n!⚓ 09:21, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
  3. I have changed my mind on this AI appeal given that the provided original draft is also very likely to be AI-generated, and per Eek. ~ Jenson (SilverLocust 💬) 20:43, 18 November 2026 (UTC)
Abstain
Arbitrator discussion

Arbitration enforcement request referral: Zalaraz

Initiated by Newslinger at 00:33, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

Case or decision affected
Indian military history arbitration case (t) (ev / t) (w / t) (pd / t)
Arbitration enforcement thread
Zalaraz
Reason for referral
The arbitration enforcement noticeboard has been unable to resolve this enforcement request, which was filed on 27 July 2026. The Committee is asked to examine the request.

List of any users involved or directly affected, and confirmation that all are aware of the request:

Confirmation that all parties are aware of the request

Statement by Newslinger

On 27 July 2026, Longewal filed an enforcement request alleging improper coordination (including tag teaming) involving Zalaraz and Orientls within WP:CT/SA. Orientls responded with a statement alleging that Longewal and UnpetitproleX have been following each other. Over three months after filing, the request remains unresolved because reviewing administrators are unable to definitively conclude that tag teaming has occurred, and also hesitant to close the request without action in the face of the presented evidence.

Most of the core involved parties have exhausted their AE word limits, and the amount of evidence needed for a finding of tag teaming is likely more than can be suitably presented at AE. While the request was open, another administrator suggested WP:SPI as an alternative venue. Subsequently, an account filed an LLM-generated SPI case against three users including Zalaraz and Orientls, which was deleted, rephrased and refiled, then closed without action, after which I blocked the filer per WP:NOTHERE.

Longewal, Zalaraz, Orientls, and UnpetitproleX have been involved in three prior AE requests in the past year:

Three administrators (Vanamonde93 – who did not post in the uninvolved section, voorts, and myself) supported referring the filing to ARCA for examination by the Committee. Four editors who participated in the request (Longewal, Zalaraz, UnpetitproleX, and Kautilya3) stated they have prepared statements for the Committee. We are now awaiting these statements. — Newslinger talk 00:33, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

@Ivanvector: Because this is an AE referral, I listed every editor who posted a statement in the AE request and every reviewing administrator who supported the referral to allow everyone a chance to post a statement here. If a case is opened, the list of involved parties should be different from the list of users here. — Newslinger talk 21:16, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
@Kautilya3: If a case is opened, my understanding is that the Committee would take the above list of editors and all of the statements in this discussion (including yours) into consideration when creating the initial list of involved parties, but the above list is not definitive and includes editors who I believe should not be in the initial list of parties. You may want to notify the newly named editors in your comment of this discussion with {{Arbitration CA notice}} on their talk pages. — Newslinger talk 16:41, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by Longewal

To give some background, I had originally filed the 27 July AE request on Black Kite's suggestion to open a separate report. I want to clarify that I am not claiming Zalaraz and Orientls are indulging in socketpuppetry, and accept Izno's technical finding. It is acting in tandem on each other's behalf that crosses into WP:MEAT-style coordination, which includes arriving a minute apart on unrelated pages, reverting to each other's version to circumvent revert restrictions in CT/SA, and backing each other at noticeboards:

Sharing CT/SA watchlists or reaching the same view in RfCs with independent policy- and source-based arguments (which Orientls cites against UnpetitproleX, Kautilya3, and me) is normal editing, and not tag-teaming as alleged.

I have had no off-wiki contact with any editor including UnpetitproleX. If one runs the the interaction tool, it's not just with UnpetitproleX but across my ~890 edits since September 2025, overlap on major CT/SA talk pages with Zalaraz and Orientls too.

On my own record, Zalaraz and Orientls filed the only two AEs ever raised against me: Zalaraz's November 2025 AE closed without action (a bit overzealous, per voorts), Orientls's June 2026 AE recycled 2025 AI claims from Zalaraz's dismissed report and closed with warnings to both of us (mine, and Orientls's for representing evidence in a misleading way to get ideological opponents sanctioned), and Rosguill blocked me in August for breaching BRD on 2025 Pahalgam attack. I accepted the warning and the block and have had zero blocks, warnings, or revert breaches since August. Whether the Committee decides to open a case or pass Newslinger's 30 October motion, I accept its decision. — Longewal (talk) 09:32, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by Zalaraz

I made my statement in the report and completely refuted the misleading presentation of diffs that were used for accusing me of off-wiki coordination. Another admin had already rejected such assertions earlier.

The report has wasted nearly 4 months of Wikipedia. This is when the report was filed by an editor who had logged warning just days before this report and even got an AE block during the report.

I request Arbcom to prevent any further waste of time over this report and recommend involved users to use proper WP:DR for their disagreement over content issues. Zalaraz (talk) 01:49, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by Orientls

UnpetitproleX and Longewal share 923 edits on over 20 uncommon pages under the span of 9 days. Thats higher than even the whole edit count of Longewal which is only 892. They are currently tag teaming at Talk:Exodus of Kashmiri Hindus for months.

When I filed a report against Longewal, user Gotitbro started accusing me and Zalaraz of off wiki canvassing. After that, Longewal (registered September 2025) went to file an AE report with fabricated evidence to accuse Zalaraz and me of off-wiki canvassing while having never filed a single SPI ever before. Gotitbro was blocked for off-wiki canvassing by Arbitration Committee on 3 October. The AE report itself was largely dominated by UnpetitproleX who is tag teaming with Longewal since the time that account registered, and tag teamed even in the report. When Red-tailed hawk said SPI is the right place for this report, Kautilya3 (not a party) jumps to comment on the report. Earlier, UnpetitproleX and Kautilya3 worked hard to defend Longewal when he was reported. It is extremely suspicious these how 3 editors (Kautilya3, UnpetitproleX, Gotitbro) jumped to report to defend an about to be topic banned editor. Kautilya3 has a long history of confessing his engagement in off-Wiki collusion.

During this time, at least 3 ban evaders went to accuse Zalaraz of meatpuppetry involving some different users.

It seems that off-wiki canvassing is happening but it is happening against Zalaraz. I would recommend declining the request as it will only empower forumshopping for removing editorial opponents anyhow. Orientls (talk) 07:50, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by UnpetitproleX

The disruption is in WP:MEAT and WP:TAGTEAM territory, several editors are involved in this including Zalaraz and Orientls. They edit-war in tandem, frequently participate in RFCs, AFDs, RMs, and other discussions to always uncritically support each other—even contrary to P&Gs. Evidence for Zalaraz and Orientls:
Collaborative edit-warring

All are their first (and many only) edits to these articles.

!Voting exactly same way in
—Every RFC and RM both have participated in:

In each, except RFC4, final consensus was contrary to their !votes.

—Every AFD both participated in (asterisk* denotes AFDs Zalaraz started):

Mostly reworded copies of each other's !votes.

There is also evidence of them supporting each other in seemingly every discussion both participate in (including instances where Orientls responds when Zalaraz is pinged: ,). Similar evidence/pattern of MEATing with other editors (Segaton, Wareon, ZDRX, Accesscrawl, Chronos.Zx) was also presented at AE. UnpetitproleX (talk) 03:27, 14 November 2026 (UTC)

Orientls's statement is deceptive. That's not how interaction analyser works: 186 of those '923' are my edits on just Talk:Kashmiri-Hindu-Exodus since 2022—half made before Longewal even showed up. We've routinely disagreed there (, ) and elsewhere (+), not tag-teaming. UnpetitproleX (talk) 12:10, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
@Sean.hoyland and Asilvering: I understand. I was trying to not exhaust my word limit right off the bat. More detailed explanations showing co-ordination with references to timing and content of edits can be found here, here and here. UnpetitproleX (talk) 14:19, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by Kautilya3

The topic area of this complaint is Hindu nationalism in India, often extending to Hindus/Hinduism in general (e.g., Diet in Hinduism) and India in general (e.g., Morarji Desai, a former prime minister). A team of editors has developed over the years, contributing critical content on the topic, which is often low quality and POV-ridden, but the editors working as a team have attempted to ward off all challenges to this content. The editors team up in edit-warring cycles, talk page discussions, and RfCs in an effort to silence all opposition ("tag teaming").

Having flown below the radar for a few years, the team burst into open with the page Dhurandhar: The Revenge (film), insisting on calling it a "propaganda film" in the lead sentence in wikivoice. The labelling caused ripples in Indian media (including an academic commentary), a fraught RfC in which Jimmy Wales had to chip in, and an admin intervention to remove the problematic content. Next, the team launched an attack on an Indian news website called Firstpost, and initiated an RfC to declare it an unreliable source. The full membership of the team, visible through these projects, and it is by no means limited to the two editors named here. More than a dozen editors participate in this activity (editor interaction); at least the following editors appear to be key members:

I give a sample of tag-teaming edits, which illustrate the range and persistence of these editors:

Editors that opposed their editing have been taken to WP:AE, including UnpetitproleX, Longewal, Gotitbro (, , ), TryKid () and me ().

Given the extent of the problem, I would urge the ARBCOM to open a full case to conduct a thorough investigation. I am also requesting Newslinger to add the above named editors as parties to the case. -- Kautilya3 (talk) 15:43, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by Srimant ROSHAN

Statement by Vanamonde93

Statement by Ivanvector

I am not a party to this filing, and do not know why I am listed as one. I will not be providing a statement, and will not be participating in any action that follows. Ivanvector (Talk/Edits) 21:11, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

@Newslinger: thank you for clarifying. Ivanvector (Talk/Edits) 21:23, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by Ar1201u1

Hello,

I would like to note that I was involved here as one of the victims of this tag-team on the Economic history of India page. While the temp p-block on me for that page might be justified, there is a much deeper problem here involving several accounts which are not included here. I cannot say for sure how many accounts are involved, but I would request the arbitrators to look into other editors as well, particularly user:ZDRX and user:Chronos.Zx along with others mentioned by user:UnpetitproleX. Ar1201u1 (talk) 12:44, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by Sean.hoyland

Quick comment as a completely uninvolved observer. The case appears to include arguments that combine intersection and inference. This always makes me a bit queasy. For example, a different way of writing UnpetitproleX's statement 'Every AFD both participated in...' is something like 'Zalaraz has participated in 190 AfDs. Orientls has participated in 285 AfDs. They both participated in 12 out of their combined total of 463 AfDs.' I think this is a safer way to present intersection related information when it is used with inference. Figure and ground, not just figure. Sean.hoyland (talk) 16:16, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by {other-editor}

Other editors are free to make relevant comments on this request as necessary. Comments here should opine whether and how the Committee should clarify or amend the decision or provide additional information.

Zalaraz (AE referral): Clerk notes

This area is used for notes by the clerks (including clerk recusals).

Zalaraz (AE referral): Arbitrator views and discussion

  • Awaiting statements, as Newslinger said. Remember not to use up your 500 words all at once, in case you will want to make additional comments later on. ~ Jenson (SilverLocust 💬) 01:02, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Also awaiting statements. I have one preliminary thought: I'm glad this issue was referred to ArbCom—that's what we are here for. Best, HouseBlaster (talk • edits • he/they) 03:38, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Accept the AE thread is from 4 months ago and is unsolved. --Guerillero Parlez Moi 08:45, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Given the rhetoric we're already seeing, it's clear that some kind of action needs to be taken, and if AE doesn't have the capacity, it's our job. I'll hold off on a formal support until we get some more statements. In solidarity, asilvering (talk) 08:55, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
    Yes, @Sean.hoyland, that's some of what I meant by "the rhetoric we're already seeing". At this point, we have enough votes to open the case, but if anyone would like to continue adding statements, by all means. In solidarity, asilvering (talk) 18:40, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Accept, AE admins asked and the statements already show there's something to look at. ScottishFinnishRadish (talk) 13:03, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Accept per SFR. Daniel (talk) 23:31, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Accept - Per SFR and Asilvering. - Aoidh (talk) 08:49, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Not really certain why y'all are writing accept, this isn't WP:ARC where the presumption is an open or declined case at the end of the day. Izno (talk) 19:55, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
    @Izno, do you think it is resolvable by motion? In solidarity, asilvering (talk) 19:58, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
    That's a bit immaterial to the point. If we want to open a case we can, but you're going to have to propose the motion and get 8 or move this request to WP:ARC to get this on 4 (but in neither world are arbitrary bold accepts how we do business at ARCA). Paperwork is greater in one of those cases but easier to pass from a votes perspective. (And where these are done is important so long as we separate the forums. [Increasingly I think we could just toss both ARCA and ARM.]) Izno (talk) 20:03, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Amendment request: SchroCat

Initiated by Ssilvers at 21:25, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Case or decision affected
SchroCat arbitration case (t) (ev / t) (w / t) (pd / t)
Clauses to which an amendment is requested
  1. Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/SchroCat#Ssilvers anti-coordination restriction with SchroCat (alt)
List of any users involved or directly affected, and confirmation that all are aware of the request
Confirmation that all parties are aware of the request
Information about amendment request

Statement by Ssilvers

I request reconsideration of my topic ban restriction with SchroCat. It has been more than six months since the restriction was put in place. During that time, I have complied with the restriction, refraining from commenting on any article or talk page where SchroCat has disagreed with anyone and avoided editing articles where SchroCat has commented or has been editing.

In the ArbCom case, people noted that I had "personalized" several content disputes where SchroCat or another involved editor had disputed content. Reviewing these instances, I see that it is true that I negatively commented on another editor's contributions to the Talk page, and in a few instances, my comments were impolite, impatient or dismissive, or expressed that I did not like the comments that the other editor made. I should have handled these instances by being more patient and kind, and by focusing on the content. I know that it is not important whether I like the other editor’s attitude or conduct. I commit, in future interactions, to be more patient and kind, to assume good faith, and to focus on the content rather than the other editor’s attitude in the dispute. Another matter raised in the ArbCom case was that during some discussions I had "piled on" to dismiss other editors' arguments or concerns. I commit to carefully consider the comments of others in any Talk page disagreement that I participate in to try to find common ground, and to make sure that my contribution is not made to dismiss another editor’s concerns or reasoning. I also commit to avoid stoking edit wars and, instead, work harder to achieve WP:CONSENSUS.

I often edit in the areas of musical theatre, the Victorian and Edwardian eras and related people and places, as does SchroCat, so our paths often cross. I hope that you give me the opportunity to return to working on these articles without the concern that I might be editing or commenting on an article where SchroCat has or had a disagreement with another editor.

Per User:HouseBlaster below, I gladly commit that if I am brought to a conduct noticeboard concerning any of my contributions related to SchroCat's editing or conduct, or more broadly, if I become aware that SchroCat has been brought to a noticeboard where I have knowledge of the facts, I will avoid the first course of action outlined by HouseBlaster and adhere to the last. That is, first I will check my own conduct, and second, if I can provide any useful counsel, I will quietly urge Schrocat, in the spirit of User:Barkeep49/Friends don't let friends get sanctioned, to take a break, examine their conduct, and/or rethink the issue at hand in a cooler light. I will further keep Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/SchroCat § Focusing on content isn't enough in mind and work to patiently and kindly explain why I believe that someone's edits were harmful or unconstructive, and I will seek to be collaborative and helpful. -- Ssilvers (talk) 23:24, 15 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by SchroCat

As a reminder, the full restriction is "Ssilvers and SchroCat are topic banned from article disputes or user disputes involving each other. This restriction may be appealed by either party six months after the enactment of this remedy, and every six months thereafter."

I have not been involved in any discussions where Ssilvers has been a party since my return and he has not (to the best of my knowledge) been involved in heated discussions on any matters on the talk pages of articles on my watchlist (ie. pages of interest to me) for the six months he has remained active since the case. This includes not commenting in any residual matters where discussions had not reached closure by the time of the case.

When I returned I removed over fifty per cent of the articles on my watchlist. These were where I know both Tim riley and Ssilvers were also active and comprised articles I had previously worked on or commented on. I have avoided looking at the talk pages of any articles in the musical theatre area (which is where Ssilvers does most of his editing) and this has helped greatly in avoiding any possible overlap. I intend not to re-add any of the pages onto my watchlist and to avoid the musical theatre area of the project going forward.

If I am made aware of Ssilvers being brought to a conduct noticeboard I will not comment (except if my name is mentioned or it is necessary for me to do so, such as is the case here). Instead I will counsel him to correct his course towards any community norms he is accused of breaking, if he has indeed breached such norms. In other words, Houseblaster, yes, I'll have a quiet word with Ssilvers - preferably before any issues, although as our orbits no longer overlap, that is now less likely.

I know I have not been back for six months, but Ssilvers has been active throughout, and he's kept to the letter and spirit of the restriction for the six month restriction. If he has to wait another three months, surely that's just a backdoor extension of his term to nine months, rather than the agreed six? As above, he has not commented in any residual discussions that were still active, so has more than satisfied the six month period. I am happy to continue to live under the same restrictions (ie not commenting on any discussion where Ssilvers is in disagreement with someone) for a longer period, but extending the restriction on him seems odd. – SchroCat (talk) 08:57, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by GreenLipstickLesbian

In terms of how managaing a heated dispute is currently working, I'd point the arbitrators to Special:History/Mean Girls (musical). There's been an on and off again edit war from the past month -- with both parties telling each other off for edit warring as recently as last week. GreenLipstickLesbian💌🧸 01:07, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Statement by {other-editor}

Other editors are free to make relevant comments on this request as necessary. Comments here should address why the Committee should or should not accept the amendment request or provide additional information.

SchroCat: Clerk notes

This area is used for notes by the clerks (including clerk recusals).

SchroCat: Arbitrator views and discussion

  • Recuse. Izno (talk) 21:38, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
  • I'd rather see this run for a full six months after SchroCat's return before lifting it. ScottishFinnishRadish (talk) 22:21, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Ssilvers's conduct was the least concerning of the parties who were subject to remedies. Indeed, reviewing the PD, I see I felt similarly six months ago. I have two lingering concerns. The first is that this restriction equally applies to SchroCat, so I want to hear from them. The second is about what will happen if you or SchroCat are brought to a conduct noticeboard. There are two main approaches to defending your friends when brought to a noticeboard and some uninvolved editors see a problem. The first is that you deny your friend has done anything wrong and vocally opposing any action (except, of course, for a WP:BOOMERANG). The second is having a quiet word with your friend, in the spirit of User:Barkeep49/Friends don't let friends get sanctioned. Ssilvers and SchroCat, can you commit to taking the second approach?

    Finally, about focusing on content, keep Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/SchroCat § Focusing on content isn't enough in mind. When someone unintentionally degrades the quality of a featured article, editors should patiently and kindly explain why their edits were harmful. It's a great opportunity to teach them to be a better writer, which will greatly improve Wikipedia in the long run. Best, HouseBlaster (talk • edits • he/they) 22:34, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
    I am bitterly disappointed about the behavior shown by GreenLipstickLesbian. Just as a general rule, reverting someone with the edit summary "don't edit war" is one of the surest signs you are, in fact, edit warring. Per Aoidh, I cannot vote to modify the restriction. HouseBlaster (talk • edits • he/they) 03:29, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
  • I have no issue with hearing this apeal at this time, but the issue GLL has linked to gives me pause. In solidarity, asilvering (talk) 16:00, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Recuse. HJ Mitchell | Penny for your thoughts? 20:29, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
  • The dispute that GLL mentions is concerning. Telling someone to stop edit warring in an edit summary made while engaging in that exact same edit warring undermines the commit to avoid stoking edit wars statement. - Aoidh (talk) 03:13, 17 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Oppose, recent edit warring is a bad sign, especially so close to the original sanction. CaptainEek Edits Ho Cap'n!⚓ 09:09, 18 November 2026 (UTC)