| Request name | Motions | Initiated | Votes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Polyphenols COI | 10 November 2026 | 0/6/0 |
No cases have recently been closed (view all closed cases).
| Request name | Motions | Case | Posted |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amendment request: Maghreb | Motion | (orig. case) | 8 November 2026 |
| Arbitration enforcement request referral: Zalaraz | none | (orig. case) | 14 November 2026 |
| Amendment request: SchroCat | none | (orig. case) | 15 November 2026 |
No arbitrator motions are currently open.
Submitting a request
{{subst:Arbitration CA notice|SECTIONTITLE}} to do this.Users who have been blocked or banned sitewide can appeal by emailing the Arbitration Committee (arbcom-en
wikimedia.org).
Guidance on participation and word limits
Initiated by Skitash at 00:35, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
Greetings. I am writing to request reconsideration of my topic ban and ask for the opportunity to contribute to the Maghreb region again. It has now been over six months since my topic ban was put in place, and I feel that this time away has given me plenty of opportunity to reflect on my previous conduct and consider how I could have handled things differently.
Looking back, I recognize that I wasn't the easiest person to work with. I was involved in edit warring, wasn't particularly welcoming or patient toward newer editors, and sometimes approached disagreements as arguments I needed to win rather than discussions where I should have been willing to listen and find common ground. I regret handling things this way. I can see that I sometimes became too caught up in particular edits and disagreements, and I didn't always recognize when it was better to step back. I've learned that editing Wikipedia isn't about having things written exactly the way I want them, but about being willing to hear other people's views and work toward an outcome everyone can agree on. I know I could have approached many of my previous disagreements differently.
Over the past six months, I have complied with the topic ban and refrained from editing in the area covered by it. I have instead redirected my attention on other areas of Wikipedia, where I have continued making constructive edits and creating articles, particularly relating to West Asia, soccer, and U.S. politics. I've enjoyed being able to contribute to other areas, and this period has also given me the opportunity to step away from the disagreements that previously occupied much of my attention. I hope my activity during this period demonstrates that I've taken the ban seriously.
I would now very much appreciate the opportunity to return to editing the Maghreb region. It remains an area of considerable interest to me, and I would welcome the chance to contribute constructively to its articles and talk pages. I don't expect disagreements to disappear, nor do I expect to agree with every decision other editors make. However, I want to handle those situations differently than I did before. If my topic ban is lifted, I intend to approach things differently, with a much greater emphasis on collaboration and consensus-building. I will avoid edit warring and refrain from making repeated reverts when disagreements arise, and I shall take content disagreements to the relevant talk pages and try to work things out there. I also intend to be more patient and welcoming toward newer editors, assume good faith, and think more carefully about how I come across to others. Thank you very much for taking the time to consider my request. Skitash (talk) 00:35, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
I agree this appeal hits many of the right notes. But I'm concerned about the lack of reference to POV-pushing here, and about the lack of specificity overall. I was really quite alarmed by the framing of Movement for the Self-Determination of Kabylie; this version of the article is some of the most obvious biased editing I've seen in any recent Wikipedia article. I should like to nkow how this came about and what the plan for avoiding it in the future is. Was it pov-pushing, which Skitash now acknowledges and renounces? If it was good-faith biased editing, what's to prevent it from happening in the future?
Regarding the edit-warring, I intend to approach things differently, with a much greater emphasis on collaboration and consensus-building. I will avoid edit warring and refrain from making repeated reverts when disagreements arise, and I shall take content disagreements to the relevant talk pages and try to work things out there.
is a good plan in general. But many of the issues in this case were about binary questions (eg, "should we add the Tamazigh name to the infobox or not?"), where there is no obvious compromise position. So what is the plan for when the inevitable happens, and the talk page discussion deadlocks as they did before? In solidarity, asilvering (talk) 18:17, 8 November 2026 (UTC)
Other editors are free to make relevant comments on this request as necessary. Comments here should address why the Committee should or should not accept the amendment request or provide additional information.
Remedy 5a (Skitash topic banned) of Maghreb is rescinded.
Initiated by Newslinger at 00:33, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
List of any users involved or directly affected, and confirmation that all are aware of the request:
Confirmation that all parties are aware of the request
On 27 July 2026, Longewal filed an enforcement request alleging improper coordination (including tag teaming) involving Zalaraz and Orientls within WP:CT/SA. Orientls responded with a statement alleging that Longewal and UnpetitproleX have been following each other. Over three months after filing, the request remains unresolved because reviewing administrators are unable to definitively conclude that tag teaming has occurred, and also hesitant to close the request without action in the face of the presented evidence.
Most of the core involved parties have exhausted their AE word limits, and the amount of evidence needed for a finding of tag teaming is likely more than can be suitably presented at AE. While the request was open, another administrator suggested WP:SPI as an alternative venue. Subsequently, an account filed an LLM-generated SPI case against three users including Zalaraz and Orientls, which was deleted, rephrased and refiled, then closed without action, after which I blocked the filer per WP:NOTHERE.
Longewal, Zalaraz, Orientls, and UnpetitproleX have been involved in three prior AE requests in the past year:
Three administrators (Vanamonde93 – who did not post in the uninvolved section, voorts, and myself) supported referring the filing to ARCA for examination by the Committee. Four editors who participated in the request (Longewal, Zalaraz, UnpetitproleX, and Kautilya3) stated they have prepared statements for the Committee. We are now awaiting these statements. — Newslinger talk 00:33, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
I made my statement in the report and completely refuted the misleading presentation of diffs that were used for accusing me of off-wiki coordination. Another admin had already rejected such assertions earlier.
The report has wasted nearly 4 months of Wikipedia. This is when the report was filed by an editor who had logged warning just days before this report and even got an AE block during the report.
I request Arbcom to prevent any further waste of time over this report and recommend involved users to use proper WP:DR for their disagreement over content issues. Zalaraz (talk) 01:49, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
UnpetitproleX and Longewal share 923 edits on over 20 uncommon pages under the span of 9 days. Thats higher than even the whole edit count of Longewal which is only 892. They are currently tag teaming at Talk:Exodus of Kashmiri Hindus for months.
When I filed a report against Longewal, user Gotitbro started accusing me and Zalaraz of off wiki canvassing. After that, Longewal (registered September 2025) went to file an AE report with fabricated evidence to accuse Zalaraz and me of off-wiki canvassing while having never filed a single SPI ever before. Gotitbro was blocked for off-wiki canvassing by Arbitration Committee on 3 October. The AE report itself was largely dominated by UnpetitproleX who is tag teaming with Longewal since the time that account registered, and tag teamed even in the report. When Red-tailed hawk said SPI is the right place for this report, Kautilya3 (not a party) jumps to comment on the report. Earlier, UnpetitproleX and Kautilya3 worked hard to defend Longewal when he was reported. It is extremely suspicious these how 3 editors (Kautilya3, UnpetitproleX, Gotitbro) jumped to report to defend an about to be topic banned editor. Kautilya3 has a long history of confessing his engagement in off-Wiki collusion.
During this time, at least 3 ban evaders went to accuse Zalaraz of meatpuppetry involving some different users.
It seems that off-wiki canvassing is happening but it is happening against Zalaraz. I would recommend declining the request as it will only empower forumshopping for removing editorial opponents anyhow. Orientls (talk) 07:50, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
The disruption is in WP:MEAT and WP:TAGTEAM territory, several editors are involved in this including Zalaraz and Orientls. They edit-war in tandem, frequently participate in RFCs, AFDs, RMs, and other discussions to always uncritically support each other—even contrary to P&Gs.
Evidence for Zalaraz and Orientls:
Collaborative edit-warring
!Voting exactly same way in
—Every RFC and RM both have participated in:
—Every AFD both participated in (asterisk* denotes AFDs Zalaraz started):
|
|
There is also evidence of them supporting each other in seemingly every discussion both participate in (including instances where Orientls responds when Zalaraz is pinged: ,). Similar evidence/pattern of MEATing with other editors (Segaton, Wareon, ZDRX, Accesscrawl, Chronos.Zx) was also presented at AE. UnpetitproleX (talk) 03:27, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Quick comment as a completely uninvolved observer. The case appears to include arguments that combine intersection and inference. This always makes me a bit queasy. For example, a different way of writing UnpetitproleX's statement 'Every AFD both participated in...' is something like 'Zalaraz has participated in 190 AfDs. Orientls has participated in 285 AfDs. They both participated in 12 out of their combined total of 463 AfDs.' I think this is a safer way to present intersection related information when it is used with inference. Figure and ground, not just figure. Sean.hoyland (talk) 16:16, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
Other editors are free to make relevant comments on this request as necessary. Comments here should opine whether and how the Committee should clarify or amend the decision or provide additional information.
Initiated by Ssilvers at 21:25, 15 November 2026 (UTC)
I request reconsideration of my topic ban restriction with SchroCat. It has been more than six months since the restriction was put in place. During that time, I have complied with the restriction, refraining from commenting on any article or talk page where SchroCat has disagreed with anyone and avoided editing articles where SchroCat has commented or has been editing.
In the ArbCom case, people noted that I had "personalized" several content disputes where SchroCat or another involved editor had disputed content. Reviewing these instances, I see that it is true that I negatively commented on another editor's contributions to the Talk page, and in a few instances, my comments were impolite, impatient or dismissive, or expressed that I did not like the comments that the other editor made. I should have handled these instances by being more patient and kind, and by focusing on the content. I know that it is not important whether I like the other editor’s attitude or conduct. I commit, in future interactions, to be more patient and kind, to assume good faith, and to focus on the content rather than the other editor’s attitude in the dispute. Another matter raised in the ArbCom case was that during some discussions I had "piled on" to dismiss other editors' arguments or concerns. I commit to carefully consider the comments of others in any Talk page disagreement that I participate in to try to find common ground, and to make sure that my contribution is not made to dismiss another editor’s concerns or reasoning. I also commit to avoid stoking edit wars and, instead, work harder to achieve WP:CONSENSUS.
I often edit in the areas of musical theatre, the Victorian and Edwardian eras and related people and places, as does SchroCat, so our paths often cross. I hope that you give me the opportunity to return to working on these articles without the concern that I might be editing or commenting on an article where SchroCat has or had a disagreement with another editor.
Other editors are free to make relevant comments on this request as necessary. Comments here should address why the Committee should or should not accept the amendment request or provide additional information.
Ssilvers's conduct was the least concerning of the parties who were subject to remedies. Indeed, reviewing the PD, I see I felt similarly six months ago. I have two lingering concerns. The first is that this restriction equally applies to SchroCat, so I want to hear from them. The second is about what will happen if you or SchroCat are brought to a conduct noticeboard. There are two main approaches to defending your friends when brought to a noticeboard and some uninvolved editors see a problem. The first is that you deny your friend has done anything wrong and vocally opposing any action (except, of course, for a WP:BOOMERANG). The second is having a quiet word with your friend, in the spirit of User:Barkeep49/Friends don't let friends get sanctioned. Ssilvers and SchroCat, can you commit to taking the second approach?
Finally, about focusing on content, keep Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/SchroCat § Focusing on content isn't enough in mind. When someone unintentionally degrades the quality of a featured article, editors should patiently and kindly explain why their edits were harmful. It's a great opportunity to teach them to be a better writer, which will greatly improve Wikipedia in the long run. Best, HouseBlaster (talk • edits • he/they) 22:34, 15 November 2026 (UTC)