Wikipedia:Requests for comment/All

The following discussions are requested to have community-wide attention: You can sign up to receive a user talk page invitation to participate in discussions of interest to you, see Wikipedia:Feedback request service

Biographies

Talk:Jim Jordan

Talk:Tony Dalton

Talk:Zohran Mamdani

Talk:Kahlil Seren

Wikipedia talk:Naming conventions (royalty and nobility)

Economy, trade, and companies

History and geography

Talk:Kungssången

Wikipedia talk:WikiProject UK geography

Language and linguistics

Talk:Urdu

Maths, science, and technology

Talk:COVID-19 lab leak theory

Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Astronomy

Talk:Artemis program

Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Apple Inc.

Talk:Dog

Art, architecture, literature, and media

Talk:Kungssången

Talk:Rule 34

Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard

Talk:Grace Reiter

Talk:Stranger Than Heaven

Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Middle-earth

Wikipedia:Village pump (proposals)

Politics, government, and law

Talk:Xinjiang re-education camps

Template talk:Gaza genocide sidebar

Talk:Zohran Mamdani

Talk:Kahlil Seren

Wikipedia talk:Naming conventions (royalty and nobility)

Talk:Artemis program

Religion and philosophy

Talk:Infinite regress

Society, sports, and culture

Talk:Kungssången

Talk:Kurds

Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard

Wikipedia talk:WikiProject National Football League

Talk:Childhood nudity

Talk:Skydance

Talk:Stranger Than Heaven

Wikipedia:Village pump (proposals)

Wikipedia style and naming

Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Astronomy

Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Apple Inc.

Wikipedia policies and guidelines

Wikipedia:Village pump (policy)

Talk:Rule 34

Wikipedia:Reliable sources/Noticeboard

Wikipedia talk:Disambiguation

Wikipedia:Village pump (policy)/Promote WP:LLM from guideline to policy

Wikipedia talk:No original research

Wikipedia:Village pump (policy)/ITN reform/RFC phase

Wikipedia:Village pump (proposals)

WikiProjects and collaborations

Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Apple Inc.

Wikipedia technical issues and templates

Template talk:Db-meta

Wikipedia:Village pump (proposals)

Wikipedia proposals

File talk:Question book-new.svg

Wikipedia:Village pump (proposals)

Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Articles for creation

Wikipedia:Village pump (policy)/ITN reform/RFC phase

Unsorted

User names

This page is for bringing attention to usernames which may be in violation of Wikipedia's username policy. Before listing a username here, consider if it should be more appropriately reported elsewhere, or if it needs to be reported at all:

Do NOT post here if:

Before adding a name here you MUST ensure that the user in question:

If, after having followed all the steps above, you still believe the username violates Wikipedia's username policy, you may list it here with an explanation of which part of the username policy you think has been violated. After posting, please alert the user of the discussion (with e.g. {{subst:UsernameDiscussion}}). You may also invite others who have expressed concern about the username to comment on the discussion by use of this template.

Add new requests below, using the syntax {{subst:rfcn1|username|2=reason ~~~~}}.

Tools: Special:ListUsers, Special:BlockList


Reports

Please remember that this is not a vote, rather, it is a place where editors can come when they are unsure what to do with a username, and to get outside opinions (hence it's named "requests for comment"). There are no set time limits to the period of discussion.

Place your report below this line. Please put new reports on the top of the list.

EditWarCriminal

EditWarCriminal (talk · contribs)

Aside from not being a fan of characterising Wikipedia into a battleground, I think this one, identifying the user as an apparent "war criminal", runs afoul of WP:ATTACKNAME at worst and at best identifies the user as being involved in edit warring. I went to raise this with this editor but saw that another user left a template about this and the editor did not respond, continuing to edit, so I'm taking this here. ser! (chat to me - see my edits) 20:25, 20 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Allow. The editor is not identifying themselves as a war criminal or even characterizing Wikipedia as a battleground, it is a play on the term edit war. 331dot (talk) 20:40, 20 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Allow per 331dot. * Pppery * it has begun... 20:43, 20 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Allow - I don't see how this violates any of the WP:ATTACKNAME criteria. As 331dot says, this is just word play and doesn't identify the user as a war criminal or characterize Wikipedia as a battleground. - ZLEA TǀC 01:40, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
Disallow - I didn't see the userpage. I have no problem with dark humor on a userpage, but it's probably not appropriate for a username to reflect it. - ZLEA TǀC 21:19, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Comment - I feel like I'm not getting my point across here at all. Obviously it's a play on words, specifically edit warring, as is expressly mentioned in the nomination. Whether war crimes are something we're cool with joking about is another matter, but even aside from that, I just don't see how having a username that can be seen as a marker of being involved in edit warring doesn't "make harmonious editing difficult" per WP:ATTACKNAME. If consensus runs the other way I'll withdraw this, but that's my 2c. ser! (chat to me - see my edits) 08:01, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
    I understand exactly what your point is. There are no warnings for edit warring on their user talk page; they have 2500 edits, with what seems to be few problems. If you believe this user edit warred under a different account, open an SPI.
    I understand how you're reading the username, but they're not joking about war crimes. You're seeing "edit (war criminal)" and we're seeing "(edit war) criminal". 331dot (talk) 09:22, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Disallow. I wouldn't really care if it were EditWarParticipant or EditWarPerpetrator or whatever, but it's obviously not an accident that "war" and "criminal" are being used in conjunction with one another, as the userpage (with its jokes about "Unethical Biological Experimentation", "Unethical Prisoner of Edit War Treatment", etc.) makes fairly clear. I know it's all meant in good fun, but if I were a new editor getting rollbacked by someone calling themselves "EditWarCriminal" who wants me to "prepare to face the full wrath of all the horrors that are barely within human comprehension", I don't think I'd want to stick around for very long. Extraordinary Writ (talk) 09:50, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Disallow I get that this is "(edit war) criminal" but I also feel that since edit warring is generally seen as antisocial in Wikiland, this username does "imply an intent to personally attack, harass, or threaten other Wikipedia editors." even if the people who they are implying they will harass are edit warrers. I don't have strong feelings in this direction but I do think you can read WP:ATTACKNAME to cover this use case. Jessamyn (my talk page) 17:35, 21 November 2026 (UTC)
  • Disallow. Apparently I have this page on my watchlist, and the first thing I saw in the edit summary was "war criminal", not "edit war". The user page doesn't really help my view. LittlePuppers (talk) 17:44, 21 November 2026 (UTC)