This is an essay. It contains the advice or opinions of one or more Wikipedia contributors. This page is not an encyclopedia article or a Wikipedia policy, as it has not been reviewed by the community. |
The issue of articles on schools in Wikipedia has long been a controversial one. There are a number of valid points both for and against these articles, and any recent discussion on them has simply boiled down to a reiteration of these points. In the spirit of civility and progress, we should all agree to disagree, and stop arguing the point. A failed attempt at compromise is archived for historical purposes at Wikipedia:Schools (or Wikipedia talk:Schools:archives).
This page is a list of commonly used arguments for or against schools. This is not meant as a debate, but as a convenient place where people can read about and try to understand the opinions on both sides of the issue.
This is not a talk page. Do not sign your contributions. Do not argue with other people. Simply provide what you think is a good reason for keeping or deleting schools, in the appropriate section, and reword and copyedit as necessary if you think something is unclear. Do not push your point; simply agree to disagree. WP:CIV. WP:NPA. Etc.
Taken from Talk:Bishop Blanchet High School.
Q: Encyclopedic? I don't think so — Why is this high school given a Wikipedia entry?
A: Why not?
Actually, I think you're asking two questions:
Encyclopedic has several senses. Let's look at each of them:
Should it be tolerated? — I don't see why not.
In the debate, arguments used by those who oppose keeping or merging school articles include:
Arguments in favour of merging most school articles into the city, town, village, borough, or neighborhood they lie in. If that is impractical it is preferable to merge them with the school district.
Charter, parochial, private nonparochial, and public noncharter schools may be organized so as to have common ownership or shared management.
A group of schools with which individual schools are obviously identified probably should be written up in a single article; whereas a group of schools with which individual schools are only subtly identified could be written up either in a single article or, for each school that is notable, in separate articles. Obvious identification applies where a group of schools in which individual schools have similar names or a common name root, so that probably many or most people can guess or identify the group from the name of an individual school; but subtle identification applies where the school names are very different so that most people cannot guess or identify the group from the name of an individual school.
Within an article on a group, individual schools can be listed, and should be if sourcing provides weighty information about an individual school. Not all individual schools should be listed if they are not separately weighty or controversial, and some editors reportedly believe that individual schools proposed but that are both not yet open and not sourceably controversial should not be listed. Arguably, if a schools group or many of its schools are controversial, newly proposed individual schools should also be listed, even if not yet open and not controversial at the time, but then if a newly proposed school is not open or controverted even after a month it should be deleted from the article. Even for an individual school not listed but which is likely accepting applications for teachers and students, a community to be served by such a school arguably should be listed. In any case, if some individual schools are not listed in the article and if the group's official website, a government website, or another reliable website lists individual schools, that website should be listed in the External Links section.
Redirects can be added from the name of each individual school, allowing categories that are limited to schools to be assigned to the redirects, while categories appropriate to the schools group as a whole would be assigned to the article about the group.
Grouping by ownership or management avoids the problem of associating schools with political jurisdictions such as cities when the schools may serve multiple jurisdictions or with districts when charter, special, or private schools may occupy their own districts regardless of their geographical preference areas for students.
Charter schools are the subject of one article, it has been suggested that articles be created on charter schools in each U.S. state (e.g., charter schools (New York)), and these articles can list schools and school groups. This concept can be extended to other nations and other school types. If a list grows to be too long to keep within such an article, lists can be separated onto their own pages and linked to from articles on types.
Arguments against mergers: