Wikipedia:Neutral point of view/Noticeboard

Welcome — ask about adherence to the neutral point of view in context!
Before posting here, consult the neutral point of view policy page and the FAQ explainer. Also, make sure to discuss the disagreement at the article's talk page.

Fringe theories often involve questions about neutral point of view. These should be discussed at the dedicated noticeboard.

You must notify any editor who is the subject of a discussion. You may use {{subst:NPOVN-notice}} to do so.

Additional notes:
Start a new discussion

We live in a constitutional republic

We live in a constitutional republic. Calling something "nonsensical", e.g. "absurd", in wikivoice, is a blatant violation of WP:OPINION, WP:NPOV's requirement to not say opinions / value judgements as fact. No matter how well cited something is we cannot put value judgements like good or bad or stupid or weird, no matter how common that opinion is. Plenty of sources call Hitler evil but we cannot say [x] is evil or [x] is good in Wikivoice. Bringing this here for more eyes. This article as a whole seems to have a very non-neutral tone and WP:SYNTH issues. PARAKANYAA (talk) 00:07, 17 October 2026 (UTC)

I agree, just the lead itself is unencyclopedic and nonneutral Katzrockso (talk) 00:41, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
Ditto. Pinging @Chetsford as they’re the primary author of the article. Some1 (talk) 00:50, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
It would have been simpler and more logical to leave "nonsensical" out of the first sentence and then add a second sentence saying "These statements have been described as ... by ...". The sources are already there. Black Kite (talk) 13:25, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
Yes, it should not be in our voice. Slatersteven (talk) 13:27, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
I think Hemiauchenia's rewrite is fine. I also think the original was fine (I think it's within the bounds of WP:EDITDISC to substitute seven words that are synonymous or closely similar used by RS with a single encapsulating word to promote readability). Either way, since there seems to be no objection and no question from anyone, this could probably have just been handled at the Talk page or by WP:BOLD. Chetsford (talk) 15:55, 26 October 2026 (UTC)
Also, to clarify, I don't believe the term "absurd" was ever used, which is likely a violation of NPOV outside of limited uses related to absurdism. "Nonsensical" (the term actually used) is qualitatively different and simply indicates something lacking coherence or being without an intelligible meaning (e.g. "we live in a constitutional republic" or "the sky is made of red"), which is the essence of the consensus RS cited. Chetsford (talk) 19:33, 26 October 2026 (UTC)
Nonsensical and absurd are synonyms. PARAKANYAA (talk) 23:24, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
They're not in conceptual understanding (see ). They're near-synonyms and popular dictionaries like Merriam-Webster may list them as synonyms, but one indicates a thing without meaning, while the other indicates ridiculous unreasonableness. That, however, is beside the point that no one used the word "absurd" in the article. Chetsford (talk) 01:44, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
The US is a Federation comprised of federated states, territories, and the District of Columbia. Each one of theses states has their own system of laws and government. The federal government is organized as a Republic and employs a form of Representative democracy. Democracy and republic are ambiguous terms, so it is important to clarify the exact definition. They are not mutually exclusive though. Ideas like Democracy, Republic, Rechtsstaat and Rule of Law trace back centuries, cross cultures, and have a lot of overlap. Saying "We live in a constitutional republic" is pretty benign (given the US is a republic and does have both federal and state constitutions establishing the framework for laws), however, "the U.S. is a republic, not a democracy" is nonsense. If we can attribute experts calling it nonsense, then we should, but also there isn't a reason to avoid calling a spade a spade. GeogSage (⚔Chat?⚔) 21:40, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
because its still a subjective assessment, and wikivoice should never be ysed to state a subjective conclusion as objective fact. Instead, we can add a few extra words (like "Some political analysts say...") to still include it but framed outside wikivoice. The "calling a spade a spade" is really a bad approach that harms WP. Masem (t) 21:50, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
If we can attribute it, then we should. However, we should not shy away from pointing out something is illogical. Honestly, can't think of a way to explain the logic of "Republic not a democracy" unless it is to mean "We are a representative republic, not a direct democracy." I should point out, representative republic redirects to Representative democracy. GeogSage (⚔Chat?⚔) 22:40, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
We do not say value judgements in wikivoice. PARAKANYAA (talk) 23:25, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
I understand, which is why attribution would be the best way forward. That said, trying to explain the meaning behind "Republic not a democracy" is pretty difficult to do without pointing out that the meaning is fairly unclear. Essentially, trying to explain Doublespeak. I'm sure sources exist we can attribute to say it is nonsense, maybe one tries to explain the phrase in a way that doesn't dismiss it, and we could cite that, but I'd question the neutrality of such a source. GeogSage (⚔Chat?⚔) 23:41, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
As described in the long-referenced essay WP:SPADE "POV pushers often like to create obfuscated prose which disguises the majority view... When it is clear that the consensus among reliable sources is that Flat Earth is not a real thing, the article should state it in wikivoice, with a supporting reliable source." In this case we have six RS that state it's nonsensical using various polyonyms like fallacious, dichotomous, etc., and none that counter those presentations. Chetsford (talk) 01:44, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
Nonsensical is a value judgement. No matter how well sourced a value judgement is it cannot be in Wikivoice. PARAKANYAA (talk) 17:07, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Agree with every word, it's discouraging sometimes how longtime prolific contributors are unable to differentiate between a fact and an opinion. Samuelshraga (talk) 12:29, 6 November 2026 (UTC)

POV-stacking and missing defense context in 1993 Michael Jackson allegations (Strip search section)

Hello, I'm requesting a brief review of the "Strip search" section, which currently suffers from a severe imbalance. The text repeats versions of the words "corroborated", "matched" and "confirmed" five times over two paragraphs to hammer a law enforcement theory, using flat declaration verbs ("said", "stated") instead of the 2005 original journalistic framing ("prosecutors contend"). Meanwhile, the text completely censors the official 2005 court motions where the defense challenged the scientific basis of these claims, as well as Judge Melville's exact ruling quote: "I find the prejudicial effect would far outweigh the probabitve value." I welcome guidance to restore a neutral, encyclopedic balance by including the defense's legal counter-arguments and the Judge's full language. Thank you. Vanauleyley (talk) 19:54, 17 October 2026 (UTC)

Please note that per Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Michael Jackson, the Michael Jackson sexual abuse topic area has been the subject of extensive off-wiki coordinated editing/meatpuppetry. Vanauleyley is a SPA dedicated to this topic who has become active after the case was closed. Hemiauchenia (talk) 19:59, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
Thank you @Hemiauchenia for your input. Most of the article had been indeed written by people who have been recently banned. After a long time, I've resumed editing it using only WP:RS, with claims directly verifiable according to WP:V, presented proportionally with respect to WP:DUE/WP:WEIGHT, and in a chronological order. Recently, the user has been insisting that the section "Strip search" is not neutral and there was no equal weight. They even added a POV tag above the section, which I find unnecessary, especially after I have provided a comparison between the old version and the current one, with the list of WP policies involved.
The user insists that
  • too much space is given to claims made by the prosecution
  • we need to directly mention the content of court documents, despite being WP:PRIMARY and potentially WP:BLPPRIMARY
  • the choice of words is not neutral ("said", for example)
  • the chronological order is not neutral
  • and, I quote, This all creates a textbook narrative bias
According to their requests, the following information has already been added:
  • Jackson's claim that he had discussed his skin condition in February 1993
  • Claims made by Jackson's attorney Johnnie Cochran Jr. (x2)
  • Jackson's claim during the 1995 ABC interview with Diane Sawyer
My understanding is that
  • per WP:WEIGHT and WP:BALANCE, the space given in an article/section is proportional to the relevance given in WP:RS. In this case, the defense of Jackson has never released any official statement about the match/mismatch of the description made by the first accuser; there's literally just an interview with Jackson and an unidentified source "close to Jackson": both have been included in the section per WP:DUE. The investigators involved, on the other side, have released several statements over the years (the last ones in 2026). To avoid bloating the article and in accordance with a comment made by another user, only those directly involved with the strip search and/or the description made by the boy have been quoted (Smith, Weis, Sicard, Dworin). The user feels it is unbalanced, while I believe they're WP:DUE.
  • per WP:ONUS and WP:SUMMARYSTYLE, an article about the 1993 allegations doesn't need a detailed description of all the motions happened in 2003-2005. Currently, the section only states that in 2005 the DA wanted to introduce the photos of Jackson and the drawing/description made by Jordan Chandler but the request was refused, because Chandler wasn't willing to testify. The user feels it is necessary to cite the multiple motions that led to the final decision, but in my opinion so much detail would only be WP:DUE for the article about the 2005 trial.
  • per WP:ATTRIBUTEPOV e MOS:SAID, words like "said" and "stated" are neutral when reporting a declaration or statement made by someone, contrary to "alleged", "suggested", "meant" etc.
Despite the final claim in the section Because the photographs and Chandler's original drawing remain unavailable for public comparison, the conflicting claims cannot be independently verified., the user insists that it's the prosecution's narrative on entertainment TV trying to push back against official court.
If any of you could provide a feedback and some directions, I'd be grateful. DanieleJava (talk) 21:08, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
This is pretty obviously AI slop. Hemiauchenia (talk) 21:12, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
Hi,
no, it isn't. I actually write like this. You can see my texts from 2010 that are basically the same. DanieleJava (talk) 22:09, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
Your earliest Wikipedia edit dates to 2023, well after ChatGPT was launched. I don't really care about whether your writing is AI or not, other users can decide that for themselves. You are in any case an obsessive WP:SPA, rather a serious Wikipedia contributor. Hemiauchenia (talk) 22:20, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
First of all, WP:AGF should help you there. I don't use AI for my edits, apart from Deepl, that I use to translate from my native language and I'm not even sure it counts as AI.
There aren't just many topics where I can help with my knowledge. I have recently translated an article from Japanese and I'm working on another article about a book by Robert Epstein. My field of knowledge is connected with youth rights, so the Jackson case is obviously something connected to it, just like that movie and the book.
You're free to believe whatever you want, but please, keep it to yourself. DanieleJava (talk) 22:42, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
You are right though that Talk:1993 Michael Jackson sexual abuse allegations is a complete dumpster fire. Almost all of the recent discussion on that page other than you comes from two different users: Vanauleyley (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log), another highly suspicious SPA only active since September this year, and Elfast (talk · contribs · deleted contribs · logs · filter log · block user · block log) who also looks quite sus even though they have a considerable number of historic non-Jackson related contributions. There's clearly a need for some kind of enhanced protection in the Michael Jackson topic area to keep SPAs out. Hemiauchenia (talk) 23:07, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
Or just tban the spas User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 23:52, 17 October 2026 (UTC)
You need to a clear justification beyond just "they're SPAs" though. Also, if they're banned they can just keep creating new sock accounts. I wouldn't be surprised if Vanauleyley in particular is a sock of someone blocked in the MJ arbcom case (or at the very least was canvassed by one of the participants), but I am not familiar enough with the case to say who they might be. Hemiauchenia (talk) 00:00, 18 October 2026 (UTC)
@DanieleJava
DeepL now uses AI. Katzrockso (talk) 01:14, 18 October 2026 (UTC)
What I mean is that I sometimes use the translation tool. I'm not using LLMs to generate my texts, contrary to what Hemiauchenia implies. I'm a polyglot and I occasionally use DeepL to check how to express something naturally in English when I'm not sure about a particular phrasing. There is literally a function where you click on the translation and you can see different possibilities to rephrase the same concept.
I teach English, so I don't really need it, but sometimes I get a lapsus and I prefer to check twice. If there are people who speak multiple languages here, they might confirm this is an actual issue and it occurs even with one's native language.
But just like I've demonstrated with texts written 16 years ago, I tend to write a lot and I tend to use bullet points and so on. It's not AI slop, I'm just autistic. DanieleJava (talk) 07:24, 18 October 2026 (UTC)
I'm also not a native speaker and sometimes use AI to try and figure out phrasing that I'm struggling with. And I also tend to write a lot and I tend to use bullet points and so on, and I definitely have thoughts about the next part of what you wrote... Not that I think I'll ever get a diagnosis, but whatever.
@Hemiauchenia I haven't dealt much with issues of LLM use and socking, but I'm pretty sure that just like other matters of conduct, making such accusations and implications is inappropriate in this forum and without substantial evidence. You're a far more experienced editor than me, but I find that sometimes people need a reminder for these simple rules that are meant to keep us all a bit more sane and orderly. If there is indeed socking happening here that is a huge issue and an SPI should be filed.
With regards to both the questions of content and conduct, I do not have further opinions here, and do not currently intend to delve into it.
Thanks and good tidings, غوّاص العلم (Ghawwas) (talk) 07:42, 19 October 2026 (UTC)
ERR "I'm also not a native speaker and sometimes use AI to try and figure out phrasing that I'm struggling with", so accusing you of using AI is not unsubstantiated; you admit you use it. Slatersteven (talk) 10:06, 19 October 2026 (UTC)
Are you speaking to me? No one accused me of using AI. I suspect that you might have lost the plot on characters in this discussion. I took issue with the comment "This is pretty obviously AI slop", which I find inappropriate. Either way, I have no issue "admitting" how I use AI, as I have before:
  1. I use it to look for sources (alongside google, databases, etc.), both for and against positions that seem to me like the correct ones, and in reading through those sources I develop my opinions on the matter at hand, and improve articles and/or participate in discussions.
  2. When I can't think of a word, or a phrasing I come up with feels awkward to me, I sometimes ask an LLM, either in Arabic or in English, how I could phrase my meaning better in English. It's quite helpful both for writing better in the moment, and for improving my English over time.
Is either of those use cases at all problematic? غوّاص العلم (Ghawwas) (talk) 14:12, 19 October 2026 (UTC)
I think @Simonm223: is referring to the banned users, he seems not to know they're banned (although one user was only warned, and one seem to have re-appear (or is he a socketpuppet of the warned user ?) ; and although Vanauleyley has the same purpose as them, but he's a newcomer (but he's not a socketpuppet, I've explained everything to Hemiauchenia, as he was mentioning me, in his talk page, in case you want to take a look...)). Elfast (talk) 18:12, 19 October 2026 (UTC)
I've just read it, thanks for the kind words <3 DanieleJava (talk) 21:21, 19 October 2026 (UTC)
Thanks for your detailed summary Daniele. Indeed, here is what currently appears at the ending of the strip search section:
- 1994 MATCH DISPUTED
- 1995 NO MATCH
- 2004 MATCH
- 2005 MATCH
- 2026 MATCH
- 2026 MATCH, MATCH
- The 1993 photos have never been made public
My original request hasn't been addressed yet. Any input on this from neutral editors would be greatly appreciated. Thanks. Vanauleyley (talk) 21:02, 23 October 2026 (UTC)
I had missed your reply. The section is as balanced as it can be based on the WP:RS that are available as for November 2026.
Also, in the end, the claims are a total of 2 "NO MATCH" and 3 "MATCH".
  • 1994 - Reuters quotes a source close to Michael Jackson, citing a NO MATCH

    an unidentified source close to Jackson said the photographs did not tally with Chandler's description

  • 2005 - Zonen's request, despite his position in the trial, is NEUTRAL

    Ron Zonen argued that the evidence was relevant

That said, I support the request of some kind of clear outcome.
Maybe @Bluethricecreamman @Hemiauchenia @Katzrockso @Simonm223 @Slatersteven and @غوّاص العلم can help, since they were part of the debate. DanieleJava (talk) 15:52, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
I am seeing no major issue, as all claims are attributed. Slatersteven (talk) 16:01, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
Same. Just drop the issue already. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 16:02, 2 November 2026 (UTC)
+1Simonm223 (talk) 16:29, 2 November 2026 (UTC)

Bosch

I am concerned about temporary accounts adding an undue amount of information to Bosch about the holocaust that lacks a neutral point of view and whereby the extent of it is undue. Specifically from this account and this account. I tried to start a discussion about this, with no response. I feel a check user may be necessary to see if there have been problems with the underlying IP. I am also concerned because each time this edit is reinstated, I am experiencing off-Wiki harassment. As such, I would like someone else to sense check if they feel I have done the right thing and to also consider the check user option. Someone seems very keen to include a lot of content regarding WWII (which is already discussed in the history part) and within the context of the company's overall history it seems undue and lacking in a NPOV, particularly given things like this, this, this and this. Thank you. LateFatherKarma (talk) 13:15, 27 October 2026 (UTC)

These are very serious allegations. If you're experiencing off-Wiki harassment, then you should either contact an oversighter or report it to ANI(I'm not sure which one, it's best to ask someone more experienced than me about that). ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե (Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 22:55, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
Thanks I will consider that, off-Wiki issues aside, if anyone here has a view on the NPOV issue, specifically how I've dealt with it (content removal, discussion, leaving messages on the TAs) and whether other people agree with my rationale or not etc please let me know. LateFatherKarma (talk) 23:25, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
I've left my thoughts on the talkpage. ғѳmɑɭʱɑυե (Any pronouns)ᵀᵃˡᵏ 23:26, 27 October 2026 (UTC)
I took a look at the current version that you've incorporated into the history section but with a separate subsection for during the Nazi regime. Per WP:BALASP that's an appropriate step and yes separate controversy/criticism sections are better avoided. I suggest renaming "Effect of Nazi regime" to "During the Nazi regime" since we are giving a time-based overview. Swirlymarigold (talk) 05:19, 29 October 2026 (UTC)
Done. I think this is largely resolved now the controversy part is incorporated and their resistance activities are discussed in the article too. Feels more balanced and neutral now. Thanks for the help with this. LateFatherKarma (talk) 07:56, 29 October 2026 (UTC)

Concerns and controversies at the 46th Chess Olympiad

Is this article, currently running at DYK, an example of the type of stuff listed at WP:CONTROVERSYSECTION? Nighfidelity (talk) 18:42, 29 October 2026 (UTC)

Giving due weight vs original research

I need guidance in understanding how WP:DUE and WP:OR interact. Even after reading WP:RSUW, it is not clear how to evaluate whether a view is the majority, minority, or tiny minority without crossing into original research territory.

Context

On the talk page for Superpower, there is a discussion on the propriety of the framing that "possible extant superpowers, or entities having the potential to become one in the near future—supported in varying degrees by academics, include the United States, China, the European Union, India, and Russia". In various places in the article, all five entities are presented in a flat, single-level list. Two camps of thought disagree on this presentation.

Perspective A (No False Balance)

Presenting all 5 entities in a single flat list creates a wp:false balance. There are far more sources supporting the US as a superpower than those supporting India. Referring to them both identically as "possible extant superpowers, or entities having the potential to become one in the near future" is inappropriate.

Perspective B (No Original Research)

Within the literature, there exist sources arguing for and against each entity as a superpower. While the sources we collected on each claim is uneven, we don't have a source that quantifies how prominent each contradictory claim is. There very likely is an unknown number of reliable sources for each. On Wikipedia, editors assessing viewpoint prominence constitutes a literature review, which is prohibited wp:original research.

Questions

  1. Does editor evaluation of the preponderance of reliable sources violate WP:OR?
  2. When sources disagree, and the disagreement is asymmetric, how to discern appropriately where the majority lies? How should we present it in the lead and visuals?

Redwolf Milkshake Fox 🦊 02:47, 31 October 2026 (UTC)

sidebar, Portions of this do read like AI, though there are signs that read more like human. Apologies, but this type of framing with headers looks very AI like. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 03:17, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
100% human written. Including the formatting. I thought this will make a post more readable. Redwolf Milkshake Fox 🦊 03:23, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
Also WP:OR is entirely forbidden in article space only. One can do as much OR as theyd like in talk page and in fact such OR is very much required to assess dueness. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 03:19, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
The problem is there are many sources making many claims. There are many sources that state there are many claims. There are not (as far as I can tell) sources for which claims are most prominent. One source sums up the problem pretty well:

While American scholars claim that the US is still the sole superpower, Chinese ones argue China is already a superpower. Also, Europeans fit the superpower title to the European Union (EU). In addition, Russia and India are seen as candidates for superpowerhood. Moreover, some scholars like Etzioni (2013: 13) underlines the importance of regional powers.

The debates about the polar system are not without biases and prejudices since people are polarized like states, too. It is not a coincidence that American pundits claim the indispensability of their countries while anti-American, anti-Western and anti-Capitalist people declare the demise of the American era. Therefore, it is difficult to find neutral comments about the polarity, American superpower, or China’s rise. In fact, when only numbers are considered, everyone can prove his/her claims.

The number of sources for various POV makes me believe anything short of a systematic review article will just be based on vibes and editor worldviews. GeogSage (⚔Chat?⚔) 03:44, 31 October 2026 (UTC)
Ideally we'd find some kinds of review article that do the synthesis for us, and thus give us a better idea of how to weigh the various sources because we could cite them. The alternative is to simply explain what the various scholars wrote without introducing our own subjective weighing. In the context of "superpower", there's going to be subjectivity, so it's important to keep that part in mind. — Red-tailed hawk (nest) 04:37, 1 November 2026 (UTC)
I've been looking for such a review article for a while (I might end up publishing one at this point given all the research I've done on the topic). The article currently does emphasize explaining what scholars wrote about particular entities without attaching out own weighing, the issue is that various editors want to attach weight to the various POV. Most articles with a literature review discuss what various people say, but don't do the work of attaching weight to the claims in literature they are reviewing. Most of these are in the context of an author taking a position through a metric they are proposing, not a pure systematic review. Even if we found one, it is likely that weights would be dependent on the authors bias, and different mythologies will produce different weights. For example, limiting to only peer-reviewed sources, only English language sources, or only sources published within a specific timeframe will produce different results then opening up to all sources considered reliable on Wikipedia. There are several scholars that have published opinions in magazines or newspapers for example (such as Jennifer Welsh writing in The Globe and Mail), and those might not get caught in a dragnet systematic review article. If you look at talk page archives, this issue has been going on for at least 18 years. While it does shift depending on editors involved, there is a consistent effort to gatekeep what countries get discussed, and the scope of the article, by dismissing reliable sources. GeogSage (⚔Chat?⚔) 02:43, 2 November 2026 (UTC)

Discussion around Talk:Do you condemn Hamas?#Lead

@Mangroves has been disputing if the question is a binary question, and if it's been done in response to criticism of Israel.

I've added thes additional citations 1 and 2, but Mangroves asserts that it does not specify that these sources cover all scenarios. Additional eyes could be helpful here. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 21:13, 1 November 2026 (UTC)

Conflict around phrasing of “Providing material support to hamas” Talk:Zohran_Mamdani#Holy_Land_Five_song

Additional eyes appreciated here User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 23:42, 1 November 2026 (UTC)

Mohamed Al-Fayed

Hello. The article could use more eyes. Editor Ghiniw unilaterally removed sexual assault allegations despite the significant coverage in reliable sources. The editor argued that the inclusion of allegations violates NPOV. StephenMacky1 (talk) 13:01, 9 November 2026 (UTC)

I support removing this extensive section in its current form. The fact that allegations have received media coverage does not automatically justify dedicating a separate, lengthy section to them in a biographical article.
Wikipedia is not a platform for compiling every allegation or reproducing extensive accounts of controversies, particularly when the claims have not been established through criminal proceedings. Reliable sourcing establishes that allegations were reported; it does not establish their factual validity or justify giving them disproportionate prominence.
Under Wikipedia's Neutral Point of View policy, content must reflect the weight given to the subject by reliable sources as a whole. The current section risks giving excessive prominence to allegations while turning the biography into an extensive account of controversy rather than a balanced presentation of the subject's life and career.
I therefore believe the section should be removed in its current form rather than retained simply because the allegations have been reported. If any information is considered essential, it should be addressed briefly and proportionately elsewhere in the article, with clear attribution and without presenting allegations as established facts. Ghiniw (talk) 13:12, 9 November 2026 (UTC)
The fact that allegations have received media coverage does not automatically justify dedicating a separate, lengthy section to them in a biographical article.
WP:SIGCOV states that "a topic is presumed to be suitable for a stand-alone article when it has received significant coverage in reliable sources that are independent of the subject." As long as the allegations against the subject of the article meet this standard, they merit inclusion - and in fact, omitting them would probably go against WP:NPOV. 11achitturi (talk) 04:03, 10 November 2026 (UTC)

RFC on Xinjiang camps

There is currently an RFC going at Talk:Xinjiang re-education camps#RfC: Describing the Xinjiang camps

It is in regard to the naming of the Xinjiang camps on Wikipedia and there is a strong NPOV concern here.

Please participate  // Timothy :: talk  00:49, 11 November 2026 (UTC)

Material omissions creating a misleading impression

The odd statement in question is from Danny Schechter who claimed that unnamed practitioners told him that -

"[Li Hongzhi] has (always) discouraged theories predicting dooms-day scenarios of the kind found in many religious communities.

And that's basically it with no further context or clarification.

I have concerns that this statement would strongly violate NPOV policy on the basis that it is an absolute statement with a severe lie of omission.

The issue is I expect most people who read it would reasonably get the misleading impression that Li opposes any teachings about judgement day or he will never make claims that our civilization will face a major apocalypse that ends society.

But that is just not true as Li himself teaches exactly that. There's a substantial body of reliable scholarly sources that highlighted such teachings. Examples below;

Helen Farley -

Falun Gong’s founder is convinced that the moral decadence of these times will inevitably lead to an apoca-lypse. He refers often to the “Dharma-ending period” of “the apocalypse,” the “great havoc,” and the “end times.” He insists that moral values are dete-riorating daily and that civilization will be annihilated because human beings are no longer “up to standard”; but fortunately, Falun Gong will pro-vide salvation for humankind (Chang 2004: 91).

David Palmer -

But while qigong foresaw a blissful future for humanity in this world, Li Hongzhi predicted the apocalyptic end of the universe and situated salvation in another dimension.

And here's Li's lecture about how the coming apocalypse (jienan) will be a mass annihilation of humanity or the culling of those deemed not redeemable like homosexual and atheists who trust science over Falun Dafa etc.

Everything that Dafa disciples do at the present is resisting the persecution of Dafa and its disciples. In the future, several billion people are to obtain the Fa, and if people's minds contain thoughts that resist Dafa, once this evil drama is over a large-scale elimination of humankind will commence. You cannot skip Fa study. This is what can best ensure your reaching consummation.

So numerous RS + primary confirms Li teaches others of an upcoming judgement day. This btw is deemed a higher teaching where Kavan have noted that Li instructs his followers to avoid letting the general public know these things.

Journalists also get their stories from interviewing participants. However, Li forbids practitioners from talking about what he calls “high level things” to ordinary people, and instructs them to lie to those uninterested in spiritual matters (“tell them that we’re just doing exercises” [Li, 2002, p. 21]). Therefore spokespeople tend to be evasive about their beliefs.

JaredMcKenzie (talk) 16:46, 11 November 2026 (UTC)

No, I read it as opposition publicly stating them, as they never pan out, so it just makes you look silly. Slatersteven (talk) 16:49, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
I don't know what you are saying. Can you clarify what you mean by "making you look silly?"
Are you saying I look silly or that Danny is silly for claiming that? JaredMcKenzie (talk) 16:52, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
No I am saying that I read it as Li Hongzhi does not want to look silly. Slatersteven (talk) 16:54, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
@Slatersteven Yeh I get that. If he predicts too early and firmly, yes, his followers will surely test his theory then abandon him when they realize he is full of it. But it appears he predicts it will happen in our future, and least near enough to be experienced/relevant in many people's lifetime to be taken fairly seriously. Enough for FG reared children to be taught that their entire life is dedicated to saving people from a coming apocalypse.

For Shen Yun dancers, that belief shapes their role. “Our entire existence was dedicated to this mission – saving sentient beings,” Li Zhuxing said. “The message for us as children was that the apocalypse was coming.”

Some interviewed followers in 2008 estimate it to be expected within 25 years. (Before 2033)

As the Chinese members I met had no exposure to other spiritual paths, they believed the peace they experienced in meditation is only available through Falun Gong. Moreover, if they are left behind in the apocalypse they will suffer horribly (Li, 2000a). (The date of this event is uncertain because Li can use his mystical powers to delay it, but participants were expecting it within the next 25 years.)

So he is still predicting that it will come. And that people must now listen to him if they want to be saved by him.
If Danny's statement was not vague but clear and had said that Li avoids giving a specific date then that will at least be defensible. But he didn't specify that. And instead one can still predict a doomsday scenario will come without giving a precise date.
My question is given what I said, does the (statement in question) fail NPOV and is potentially misleading as it largely omits that Li teaches it will come in our future? That's all I really came here to ask. JaredMcKenzie (talk) 17:50, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
Which article is this? User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 17:51, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
It's been added to several articles but the main one is Falun Gong under the Dharma-ending period chapter. JaredMcKenzie (talk) 18:08, 11 November 2026 (UTC)
This was recently discussed on Wikipedia:Reliable_sources/Noticeboard/Archive_527#Danny_Schechter.
In religious contexts, apocalypse doesn't necessarily mean the end of the world or doomsday. As the wikipedia article Apocalypse explains: "In popular use apocalypse often means such a catastrophic end-times event, but in scholarly use the term is restricted to the visionary or revelatory event." So there is no contradiction for a religion to have both apocalyptic teachings but not predict the end of the world.
Li's lecture excerpts, such as this one and this one , confirm that he predicted something would happen, such as a powerful disease, but that it wouldn't be the end of the world.
I think these sources are consistent that this NRM believes there will be an apocalyptic event, but it won't be the end of the world. It is just that some sources emphasize the apocalyptic aspect, while Danny Schechter emphasizes the no end of the world aspect. Journalist Ian Johnson also said Falun Gong adherents do not believe the world's end is imminent. I don't see a contradiction.
Including Schechter's quote together with other sources gives readers the full picture. Leaving it out would rather violate WP:NPOV. MrGerLib (talk) 00:38, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
The modern dictionary defines doomsday as "a day of final judgment"; "a time of catastrophic destruction and death". And that's exactly what Li is predicting.
And in the past, I disagreed with you because it has misleading implications. You also previously implied Li doesn't predict the destruction of our world ever. That is simply not true.
Many RS sources - Helen Farley, David Palmer, David Ownby, Benjamin Penny, and others - explicitly characterize Li's teachings as containing apocalyptic/millenarian elements that includes the "destruction" or "annihilation" of the current human civilization due to moral degeneration.
Also most native English speakers know doomsday as near-synonymous to apoclaltpse or an event that destroys civilization. Trying to work a semantic angle by saying doomsday somehow doesn't mean catastrophic destruction/ annihilation of civilization or judgement day - but is something different is disingenuous. If the end result is that defending this absolute statement leads to people to believe that Li never predicted the end of our civilization in a religious reckoning way, despite multiple academic specialists document precisely the opposite pattern - it is misleading and fails NPOV. JaredMcKenzie (talk) 01:45, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
If we are at the point where we are trying to argue that apocalypse isnt the end of the world, i think there needs to be clear evidence that the word is being used as something than what it means.
So there is no contradiction for a religion to have both apocalyptic teachings but not predict the end of the world. yeah no unless the source using the word apocalyptic isnt qualifying it as some revelatory event we can probably assume the word means what it means. User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 03:05, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
@Bluethricecreamman If I understood you correctly - the burden should be then on those to prove that "apocalyptic" is being used in a specialised, non-catastrophic sense by sources.
Ordinary English readers generally understand this word to mean a catastrophic event involving destruction or a radical annihilation of the current civilization.
Many scholarly sources (Farley, Palmer, Lewis etc) describe Li teaching a great havoc or destruction/annihilation of civilization, affecting all who cannot be saved (in religious manner). None of them limit the term to only mean visionary or revelatory experience and nothing more.
Danny Schechter's phrasing — that (Li always discourage predicting dooms-day scenarios of the kind found in many religious communities") - likewise uses everyday colloquial language that invokes the common catastrophic understanding. An absolute statement framed that way is misleading when expert literature documents the opposite pattern in his teachings. JaredMcKenzie (talk) 03:58, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
I mean yeah. If there is some specialized meaning involved with the word apocalyptic i could believe it but it has to be clear, not handwaving to other literature User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 04:01, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Thank you for that clarification.
Since we agree that any non-catastrophic meaning needs to be explicitly shown in sources, and I am aware there are too many scholarly sources discussing Li's Apocalyptic teachings, describe it in terms of annihilation of the current civilization, (rather than limiting the term to some narrow non-catastrophic/purely visionary sense), then Schechter's absolute phrasing remains problematic.
Ordinary readers will understand Schechter's statement as referring to predictions of a catastrophic judgement day or large-scale destruction. As it currently stands, such a statement (based on anecdotal statements relayed by one journalist and using absolute language) - only creates a very misleading impression that conflicts with the higher-weight scholarly sources. I therefore propose it should be removed.JaredMcKenzie (talk) 04:56, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
Various scholarly sources, including some you cited above, described FG as having millenarian elements. According to wikipedia page of Millenarianism, it is "the belief held by a religious, social, or political group or movement in a coming fundamental transformation of society, after which "all things will be changed" So, millenarianism does not necessarily imply the end of the world.
Sources describing FG having apocalyptic elements, such as David Ownby and Benjamin Penny, also said that FG's cyclic worldview was adopted from Buddhism and each destruction/decline is followed by renewal (which you omitted).
The NY Times article you cited on RSN said:

Mr. Li has said that people who believe in the goodness of Falun Gong, and reject the Chinese Communist Party, will be saved from a coming apocalypse and enter a new universe.

The audio in the Australian ABC source you listed above is not playable to me. I did a search and found a couple of Li's quotes resembling what you cited from that source:

"This is the grandest mercy, because in the future billions of people are to obtain the Fa, and if people’s minds contain thoughts that resist Dafa, once this evil drama is over a large number of people will begin to be weeded out,..."

"There are billions of people in this world waiting to obtain the Fa after this evil drama is completely wiped out as the Fa rectifies the human world."

If Li expected billions of people to survive the apocalypse and obtain the Fa, that wouldn't be the end of the world. MrGerLib (talk) 20:24, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
large number of people will begin to be weeded out…
yeah thats pretty text book apocalypse end time talk User:Bluethricecreamman (Talk·Contribs) 22:01, 13 November 2026 (UTC)
The ABC audio is broken but the "transcript" is still readable. It writes "large-scale elimination of humankind will commence". Li may have an inflated view and thinks his followers can grow to a billion. It doesn't change the fact that he predicts a final judgement and massive elimination of what he considers undesirables. His followers may interpret this differently, but wouldn't a prophecy predicting a day of reckoning that will eliminate large numbers of people reasonably fit the common understanding of a doomsday scenario? Danny's statement fails to make that distinction and instead gives readers the impression that Li teaches nothing of the kind. As written, isn't it misleading by omission? JaredMcKenzie (talk) 02:31, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Again, that relies on an artificially narrow definition of "doomsday" while treating it as the only legitimate one. Standard dictionaries defines doomsday as "a day of final judgment"; "a time of catastrophic destruction and death". Ordinary English reader understand it in either sense.
The point is whether Danny's statement is misleading under the world's common understanding. And it is. Li teaches a day of a day-of-reckoning / large-scale purge of undesirables (morally unfit and non-practitioners). A prophecy of judgement and widespread destruction of the unworthy - basically shares the central features of doomsday/judgment scenarios found across many religious communities.
Danny makes an unqualified statement that fails to communicate that distinction. His sloppy statement leaves readers the impression that nothing of that kind above is taught by Li. Even if you want to emphasize that a new world will arise right after the mass destruction and day of reckoning - Danny's statement fails to communicate that. Who can possibly understand that from his statement? He is simply misleading where he completely denies that FG teachings have anything in common with doomsday/judgement day theories in other religious communities - which is wrong.JaredMcKenzie (talk) 01:39, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
@JaredMcKenzie raised this same topic multiple times on talk pages and on RSN. After being unsuccessful in those fora, he has brought the same argument here.
Danny Schechter is a reliable source. His book was published by a reputable publisher based on extensive and well documented research he conducted within the Falun Gong community. He raises valid points to be included on this topic. It is attributed appropriately on the pages and is given less weight than the other sources cited here.
As to this specific quote, @JaredMcKenzie states “And that's basically it with no further context or clarification.” But Schechter does give context. Here is the context that they say does not exist. The following two paragraphs are from Schechter's book:
The Chinese government tried to mock Li Hongzhi by claiming that he had warned practitioners that the end of the world was at hand. He denies making any such apocalyptic predictions and, at a talk he gave in New York, he said: "I can proclaim here to everyone in all earnestness that all of those so-called catastrophes of the earth or of the universe and things of this kind in the year 1999 simply do not exist." Practitioners say that he has always discouraged theories forecasting the end of the world or doomsday scenarios common in many religious circles.
China has not paid any attention to his denials, as Stephen D. O'Leary explained in a piece about Falun Gong and the Internet in June 2000. "If Li is the archetypal doomsday cult leader, and his followers are deluded, superstitious victims of sophisticated psychological coercion, then any measures taken by the government would seem to be justifiable," he noted. "These allusions to the Western ideas of a doomsday cult figure are clearly an attempt by the Chinese government to seek sympathy and empathy from Western countries, particularly from America, where Li now resides"
O’Leary’s quote applies particularly well to this conversation.
@JaredMcKenzie presents selective sources as if there is academic consensus on this subject when there is not. Schechter’s comments provide valuable nuance to a discussion of esoteric beliefs that are not easily understood by English-speaking audiences who (as this conversation shows) have their own interpretations of the topics discussed by Li Hongzhi in his native Chinese language in the context of spiritual teachings that differ from the beliefs and religious traditions of most editors and readers.
It is not cut and dry, which is why a variety of perspectives from reliable sources is important. —Zujine|talk 16:24, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
I don't want to fight with you here so if you want to accuse me of misconduct, then do it in another thread on Ani. I will only address content here.
The only issue is Danny's overstatement is a demonstrable falsehood when claiming explicitly Falun Gong people don't learn of a coming apocalypse. This is not a statement I make lightly nor use selective sources. Pretty much the bulk of respectable scholars on FG are talking about Li teaching apocalypse - Benjamin Penny, Andrew Junker, David Palmer, David Ownby, Helen Farley, Stefano Bigliardi, Manova, Heather Kavan and also many large media outlets report this too like NBC, NYT, RFI, and ABC news (in transcripts) quoting Li teaching a mass annihilation of mankind will commence. Meanwhile, you can only find a couple of journalists like (Danny) claiming the opposite and that's it. You can't find much else in because Danny is a fringe source that is being contradicted by the major researchers. My sources far outnumber what you have in spades.
Your quote provides useful context where it appears Li was responding to the public pressure from the Chinese gov accusing him of teaching apocalyptic theories. However, his denial of the apocalypse is only limited for the year 1999. It doesn't establish that he never taught an apocalypse.
And if Li stated that he "denies making any such apocalyptic predictions". Then we can attribute that he said that. It doesn't prove he didn't teach an apocalypse, it just proves that in the context of China gov accusing him of teaching such things - he is a liar with that PR statement to deny, as many reliable sources confirms he indeed teaches an apocalypse.
There is concrete evidence that Li teaches an apocalypse so Danny claiming that he never did (contradicted by vast numbers of media and top scholars with hard evidence of his lectures), shows his statement needs to be treated cautiously. JaredMcKenzie (talk) 17:24, 14 November 2026 (UTC)
Sorry, I didn't realize the ABC source had a transcript. Now I see it says, "large-scale elimination of humankind will commence." The primary source that I cited above says, "once this evil drama is over a large number of people will begin to be weeded out." The difference might be due to a translation issue.
This 2001 lecture by Li seems to be consistent with the following 1994 lecture excerpt that Thomas Meng posted on the Teachings of Falun Gong talk page. I understand the teachings shifted toward a more millenarian interpretation after Chinese gov's suppression in 1999. But the nature of what Li predicted would happen seems to be consistent.

If there really is a catastrophe it’s sure that good people will remain afterwards. Catastrophes weed out bad people. So, since you are a cultivator and you’re improving yourself, why worry about that? Whatever catastrophe there is, so what—it has nothing to do with you. That’s if there really is a catastrophe. But today I can tell you this clearly: the catastrophe no longer exists. People have talked about things like Earth exploding, satellites colliding, a big flood… You know, catastrophes were arranged in the past to unfold one after another. The catastrophes arranged at different levels have all passed. The comet hit Jupiter instead of Earth. The flood has passed—last year flooding was very severe and it was worldwide. Now it’s very weak, weak to the point that it’s passed. Many things have passed, meaning, that kind of catastrophe no longer exists. The only thing that exists is—we don’t have anything to hide—the only thing that exists is that in the future a large number of people may be weeded out. People who are very bad might be weeded out by a powerful disease—this is possible. That’s why we say that even though some people always talk about these things, you shouldn’t worry about them. That kind of catastrophe no longer exists. What’s key is how you cultivate yourselves and how you improve yourselves.

Seeing the exact quote from Danny's book and the context above, it seems that what both Danny and Li were addressing (or denying) was the end-of-world type of apocalypse. If Danny's statement doesn't give the full picture, what about the other sources that only say Li predicted an apocalypse without mentioning he also said billions of people (the NYT quote above suggests that it is beyond FG followers) would be spared from it. Would those sources create a misleading impression too? I think the best route is to include both types of sources to comply with WP:NPOV. MrGerLib (talk) 00:56, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Apology accepted but please do not conflate as if they are both misleading. Other sources like NYT don't need to further explain that an "apocalypse" involves large numbers of people being killed, with only the believers and "righteous" largely spared. (As that is typical of any religious Apocalyptic theories). They are not misleading anyone. Danny is different where he is saying Li doesn't predict doomsday scenario while omitting the essential qualification that Li continued to predict the elimination of large numbers of people. He gives readers the misleading impression that Li never predicted anything of that sort.
As @Binksternet pointed out on Ani, there is a tight group of these editors that often work like a team in these articles and I genuinely cannot reason with them when you all rehash the same fallcious reasoning. That's why I did not continue to talk to you guys further on article talk but reached out to RS noticeboard (so we can finally have someone who isn't part of the pro Falun Gong group to weigh in).
Below 👇 is why I see your group constantly gives the same fallcious reasoning for this issue (which you are again repeating above now);
Examples of fallcious replies - I told your rotating group that heaps of major academic researchers of Falun Gong agree that Li predicted our civilization will be destroyed due to moral degeneration and so it is wrong to still allow an absolute statement that say he ALWAYS denied making such theories. Yet the pro FG group collectively reply by giving me this same selective isolated quotes from Li dated in 1994 or 1998 despite these do not even dispove the fact li predicted judgement day is coming. None of their quotes say Li claim it will never happen.
Also regardless, anything that Li says one time in 1994 would not erase the fact that Li had stated numerous times particularly in year 2000 and 2001 (Penny page 156) about a coming time of reckoning that will destroy our civilization.
To be completely honest, I just don't see your group giving a valid rebuttal but are merely giving the impression you gave valid rebuttals with fallcious reasoning. I think I understand now what @PARAKANYAA meant by these articles bringing out the worst in us. I see a group constantly arguing on allowing shoddy disinfo on the article, and it's not easy to accept that.
The only relevant question is whether Li ever predicted an apocalypse or doomsday scenario for the future? If he did, then Danny's blanket denial, without the necessary qualifications, that Li ALWAYS discourage predicting doomsday scenarios of the kind found in many religious communities - is misleading. JaredMcKenzie (talk) 01:32, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
The issue is not as simple as you present. For instance, Li Hongzhi often speaks about how the catastrophes of the world have been prevented or averted. In addition to the quote cited by Schechter, here is another quote along those same lines:
"Master has spread Dafa for ten years. Even in the human world, predestinations have been greatly changed. The comet catastrophe predestined in history is no more, the third world war has been averted, and the peril in 1999 from the cycle of formation-stasis-degeneration-destruction of Heaven and Earth will never recur."
And most of Li's teachings take a very positive tone. It is not fear-based like many apocalyptic predictions. Here is a poem about the positiveness of the changes in "Fa-rectification", and it doesn't just apply to his disciples but to "sentient beings" writ large.
"Only after the immense force of Fa-rectification sweeps through, / Are the boundless wonders known. / Falun Dafa is great, / Gradually enters the human realm. / The sentient beings need not worry, / Gods and Buddhas are smiling."
A lot of researchers never addressed the issue of apocalyptic teachings in Falun Gong because from their perspective they may not have seen it as important enough to be included in their analysis. Based on Ownby and others, it isn't considered by everyone to be a central part of their beliefs.
My point is that on wikipedia, we are presenting the teachings and beliefs of Falun Gong, not just the criticism of those beliefs. The critiques and concerns raised by editors and the sources cited are valid, but so are other viewpoints. Schechter presents the viewpoints of Falun Gong practitioners who he interviewed and a statement by Li Hongzhi, who he interviewed. You can say that his statement to Schechter contradicts what you or others have found in his writings, but that is up for interpretation, which is why multiple viewpoints are important to include. —Zujine|talk 21:45, 16 November 2026 (UTC)
Even for that speech you quote where he plays a Messiah, you do realize it reads like a doomsday pamphlet where he is literally taking credit for stopping the comet catastrophe and that his religion literally prevented WW3. He is talking about doomsday scenarios there.
So yeah he likes to take credit for stopping specific apocalypse like the specific year 1999. REGARDLESS - It doesn't change the fact he does predict a judgement day for the future where a mass elimination of humanity will occur and for his people to be ready.

once this evil drama is over a large number of people will begin to be weeded out.

However he reassures his followers that as long as they follow him, they be fine. It's negative for all those who don't follow him and will be wiped out.
Other scholars (available and already provided) are much more straightforward and explained it better without misleading. Proper sources like Penny and Palmer explain Li doesn't set a specific date for judgement day but just say it's coming in our times. And that this apoclaltpic event will mass destroy those who aren't believers and then the world will start a new civilization from scratch. That is an honest full description.
Danny's statement looks absurd in comparison and a whitewash by giving the reverse impression that Li never predicted a future event of catastrophic destruction.
As I said before, the modern dictionary defines doomsday as "a day of final judgment"; "a time of catastrophic destruction and death". And the ordinary English reader would also understand the word to mean that too.. We both know that Li teaches we are living in the last havoc where the "a day of final judgment" or "a time of catastrophic destruction and death" will arrive and why it is very likely readers will be mislead by Danny's statement as if he doesn't teach exactly that. JaredMcKenzie (talk) 04:57, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Polygny article biased

Need overview on the article, especially Findings section. Check talk page. It's alot of POV stacking and unweighted critiques

QuantumTraveller (talk) 09:54, 13 November 2026 (UTC)

Please dont use Ai on talk pages MacTheOp (talk) 16:42, 16 November 2026 (UTC)

Xinjiang_re-education_camps has an RfC

Xinjiang_re-education_camps has an RfC for possible consensus. A discussion is taking place. If you would like to participate in the discussion, you are invited to add your comments on the discussion page. Thank you. Maayaaaaa (talk) 00:31, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Weaponization of antisemitism

This contentious topic article has two heated but low participation discussion on its talk page that would benefit from extra eyes. BobFromBrockley (talk) 02:23, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

Atrocity Denialism as enforced but unestablished consensus, and WP:SYNTH and WP:V POV pushing in the lead on the Sexual and gender-based violence in the October 7 attacks article

Can a few take a look at this? There has been several attempted discussions and fixes but they all have led nowhere.

Talk:Sexual and gender-based violence in the October 7 attacks#Atrocity Denialism as enforced but unestablished consensus, and WP:SYNTH and WP:V POV pushing in the lead. Bobbobet (talk) 04:41, 17 November 2026 (UTC)

"Civil disorder" article RM to "Civil unrest"

(Involved) At Talk:Civil disorder#Requested move 27 October 2026, I argue the "civil disorder" framing is an NPOV violation. Feel free to stop by and contribute ~ Alexandraaaacs1989 (talk) 20:57, 17 November 2026 (UTC)